Whale, I'm now on page 260 of the last volume of Catton and he lingered for thirteen pages on Chicamauga with no analytical money shot. "Why so much ink on this?", top 246. I gave him until the end of the sub-chapter and no, nothing. I'm now nine pages into "37,000 Plus One" (the "One" being Grant). I really don't understand what he's doing and why he's doing it.