There is so much fog surrounding the English Premier League's case against City that one would think we were still in the Court of Chancery days. Only the broadest generalities can be sketched. But there are internal emails and documents common to both cases, and a failure to cooperate with the investigation in both cases, which convince me, a City fan of over twenty years that my beloved City are guilty of substantial, deliberate circumvention of Financial Fair Play, the near equivalent of the NBA's salary cap conventions. There are significant, specific differences, for example the offset rules in the EPL for community investment, the allegedly inflated endorsement agreement with Etihad Airways which has stood the test of time. However, I see, albeit with my 20/400 vision through the London fog, guilt by City, specifically on failure to cooperate, a serious offense on both sides of the Atlantic and across the two different sports. And I see the credibility of the EPL at stake even more so than the NBA's credibility was at stake in the Kawhi Leonard fraud.
I believe, I hope, and I expect in the name of "fair play" and the integrity of the Premier League, even though potentially devastating to my beloved City, that the rules are enforced equitably on this richest of league owners and the team which I love so dearly, and that the punishment fits the crime(s), plural. I expect the punishment to be severe and historic, as was the NBA's of the Los Angeles "Clippers". The harm to my City may likely, and perhaps deservedly, be apocalyptic, a severe deduction of points amounting to relegation, vacating of titles won, perhaps expulsion form the Premier League and the Football Association.
Manchester City is forever for me and wherever they end up I will never give up my loyalty to them. Sheikh Mansour is the greatest owner of any club in any sport in sports history. But I am pretty well convinced that our trophy cabinet constitutes in some significant measure ill-gotten gains.
The NBA has set down a marker for the EPL. I want justice done. I want City to remain an EPL power and for the EPL to remain a credible, respected fixture on the short-pants worldscape. Those may be incommensurate desiderata. Very well. I accept whatever outcome.
City Forever!








