Wednesday, March 15, 2023

MUCH More Comforting Parallel Than 2008

Most of the finance world is looking to the great financial crisis for parallels to what happened to Silicon Valley Bank, but perhaps a better case study lies back in...the 1980s.

The big picture: The savings and loans crisis. From 1980 to 1994, nearly 1,300 of these smaller, home loan-focused banks failed.

  • And they failed mostly because of at least one issue that plagues us today: high inflation that prompted big rate increases by the Fed.
  • The S&Ls were in the mortgage business, and when they made these loans they held them on their books. As rates rose, those mortgages were worth less and less — a sort of corollary to the mortgage-backed and government securities sitting on SVB's books.

 Also: Decades ago, the Fed's rate hikes...some risky loans concentrated in the oil sector, as Edward Harrison writes in Bloomberg.

 In SVB's case, it was similarly reliant on one sector — tech.

 

Yes, but: There are differences in the details, of course....

  • We've also only seen two banks fail. Not hundreds.
  •  
  •  The bottom line: As the kids like to say, history doesn't repeat, but it does rhyme.