Thursday, April 12, 2012

Trayvon Martin, cont.

George Zimmerman was arrested last night.  Prosecutors charged him with second degree murder. Evaluating the facts listed in previous posts by existing Florida law it is my personal, legal opinion that Zimmerman should have been charged with either manslaughter or second degree murder.

Wednesday, April 11, 2012

China.

Look at these pictures!  I am utterly shocked. Dr. Weimen Mo forwarded these to me from China Digital Times. These are street scenes in Chongqing.



Tuesday, April 10, 2012

China.

Murder?

Bo Xilai's wife...Mrs. Bo, was "held," I guess arrested, by the gendarme today in what the gendarme are saying is a murder investigation in the death of Neil Heywood, a British national.  Mr. Bo was stripped of all party posts today, too.

Sheesh.
Robert Ballard, in conjunction with National Titanic magazine, found the wreck of the Titanic what seems like 100 years ago too. Ballard took lots of photos of the Titanic, showing it a rusting, crumbling hulk in two pieces. Ballard found no survivors. 
There was a tremendous loss of life. The Titanic hit an iceberg and sank very quickly.  A lot of passengers lost their lives.  It was a tremendous tragedy.
Continuing our wall-to-wall coverage of the Titanic we can report that 100 years ago today the ship left Southampton, England. It sunk.  Five days later it sunk.  

Omg, even the New York Times.  Three articles yesterday.  That goddamned ship won't stay sunk.

Monday, April 09, 2012

Americans, question to you:

Q: As Commander-in-Chief, has President Obama had to send a message to the troops because of Mitt Romney like Paramount Leader Hu Jintao sent to the PLA because of Bo Xilai?

A: Nooooo.
God, I'm funny.

China.


American politics is bipolar.  So, is Chinese politics Bo-polar?



China.

A few months ago a friend in Beijing asked me to check on how Fang Lizhi was doing, if there was any new news on him. I checked and there wasn't much and I sent my friend what there was.

When Fang died over the weekend I sent him the following email:

"Hi Chang,

Fang Lizhi died yesterday, as I am sure you know.

-Ben"

I was sure he knew. I felt a little sheepish sending the email.  His response:

"No, Ben, there is no news and I understand why---the so-callled "people's servants" here fear and hate such a brave, good man, and they also fear their "master"!!! 
If you have more news about his passing away and the comment on/feedback to that event in Western society, please send it to me. Thanks!"
  
They don't know.  The Chinese people don't know that Fang Lizhi died.

Sunday, April 08, 2012

China.


"Excuse me soldier, heard any good coup rumors lately?"

Is there something more than the usual paranoid nonsense going on behind the "Gate of New China?"  There appears at least to be a shortage of Imodium.

网站正在维护中……

"This website is under maintenance..."             





That was the message we neo-Maoists started to get yesterday when we tried to access our favorite website (other than www.hotchinesefemalesoldiers.com), the neo-Maoist “Utopia,” http://www.wyzxsx.com/.

The Center has turned its censorious eye from pro-liberalization websites to neo-Maoist websites. It has shut down 17 of them recently. But isn’t China, like, Maoist?  Isn’t that, like, Mao’s mausoleum in the middle of Tiananmen Square?  What’s the prob?

“Utopia” was one of the favorite haunts of supporters of Bo Xilai who was purged a few weeks ago; Bo was popular among the people of Chongqing, where he was Party Secretary, for fighting corruption there; the Chongqingers sang the old Cultural Revolution songs of which Bo was so fond; China is in the middle of a “transition” of power this year (How is that going?); transition by “consensus” (of the ruling elite) is the Chinese Way; popularity is not an approved method of transition.

The initial run on Imodium was caused by Bo’s taste in music.  The Cultural Revolution scares the shit out of the Center.  So, they purged him, he’s outta there, what-is-the-problem?  China-watchers are not sure.  Indeed there were coup rumors on the Chinese internet the last two weeks. But that’s the internet, you can find anything on the internet, except Utopia right now.  To this amateur China-watcher the most significant indication that something more than the usual paranoid nonsense might be going on is the Center’s directive to the military yesterday in the “Liberation Army Daily:” 

"[R]esolutely resist the incursion of all kinds of erroneous ideas, not be disturbed by noise, not be affected by rumours, and not be drawn by undercurrents, and ensure that at all times and under all circumstances the military absolutely obeys the command of the Party central leadership, the Central Military Commission and Chairman Hu."

Was that really necessary?  China watchers don’t know. Bo knows.

Happy Easter.  Christeean gentleman above.  Of the Rooski persuasion.

The name of the divine is Patriarch Kirill I.  Head of the Russian Orthodox Church.  On his left wrist in the photograph at left is a divine Breguet watch, or "timepiece" as it's probably called.  That particular timepiece set God back $30,000. Our brother Alexsei Navalny and others went nuts at the Church's excess.

We Americans know what Patriarch Kirill I should have done.  Pat should have called Mitt Romney who would have told him that Navalny, et al were just jealous losers attacking success. But this church is Russian so they didn't do that. They airbrushed the $30,000 Breguet out of the photo (at right).  Who would notice?

Now this is the detail that makes this so quintessentially Russian:  When the Church was caught airbrushing, their explanation was that indeed airbrushing had occurred; some unbeliever had airbrushed the $30,000 Breguet onto Pat's wrist.  The Church, the Church said, hadn't airbrushed it off Pat's wrist; someone else, a Jew?!, had airbrushed it onto Pat's wrist.

We here at Public Occurrences do not know how the Russian Orthodox Church differs from other Christeean churches but we assume that they recognize the Ten Commandments, number nine of which is "Thou shalt not lie."

Saturday, April 07, 2012

Fang Lizhi, In Memoriam.


Fang Lizhi, the great Chinese patriot and human rights activist, inspiration to the June 4 martyrs, died today in Tucson Arizona.  Mr. Fang immigrated to the U.S. after seeking refuge in the U.S. Embassy in Beijing on June 5, 1989. He was granted asylum but remained in the embassy for over a year until the Chinese government let him leave for America.

The Soul of China.


Hmm.  A yellowed photograph lying in a lifeless bare left hand with a (bullet? nail?) hole in the palm, and an elegantly-gloved right hand grasping a better preserved photo. 

The Soul of China.


The Soul of China.


The Soul of China


Soul as screw:

"A man's usefulness to the revolutionary cause is like a screw in a machine. It is only by the many, many interconnected and fixed screws that the machine can move freely, increasing its enormous work power."
                         -The Diary of Lei Feng.

Contemporary art is an effective medium for alternative visions and criticism of the established order.  It works that way in China. Oblique messages are more likely to be missed by the censors than direct, written dissent on websites and blogs. There's also a double message in contemporary Chinese art that throws the censors off. 

In general of course Chinese art is something the Center wishes to promote. The powerful frequently want to be surrounded by art.  The rich want it on their walls at home; banks want it in their lobbies--even if they don't "get it."  Art tends to confer--and confirm--elite status. Hu Jie's film Red Art was able to escape the censors initially because it conveyed one message on the surface, that Cultural Revolution "art" was worthy. To further this surface message Hu interviewed that art's "creators" and supporters, who spoke at length in the film.  But nested in the film, in comments made by Hu during interviews, in brief flashes of imagery,  was the second, "real" message of critical irony. The powerful, whether rich Westerners and bankers or red censors, are more likely to miss irony. 

Maleonn's photographs convey this same double message: they are "indigenous" art; they are ascetically pleasing to view; they contain photographs from the Cultural Revolution with no surface criticism. They are art "of the people, by the people, for the people" and the People's Republic likes that. The sub-surface messages though are (1) individual expression (2) of themes: memory of suffering, and of a painful period, that the Center doesn't want expressed.

The Soul of China


The individual is blotted out in the Center's conception of the soul.  Below, the soul as nail, hammered relentlessly. What a vision!


"How can nails, nail up a perfect board which has no holes? Because we exert pressure on the nails, so they can squeeze into the board, from this point, the nail has two strong points, one is squeezing and the other is drilling. After examination we should promote the nails spirit and learn from it."
                                                                                                  -The Diary of Lei Feng.

Every March 5 is celebrated in China as "Learn from Lei Feng Day."

The Soul of China


"During my 11 years of art education, there was never a lesson on soul, inner thoughts, emotion or love," he said. "How can an artist not talk about these things?"
                                                                     -Maleonn, BBC interview.

The Soul of China.


Survival as soul is bleak, it is the minimum that human beings can be. But the soul is mutable.

Great artists create, they do not imitate.  The great contemporary artists of China are creating conceptions of the soul that compete with the Center's soul as survival.

This image and those to follow are by Maleonn (Ma Liang) in a series called "White on White."  Old photographs, and the memories they recall, fade to white over time. The Center wants memories of the Cultural Revolution to fade away.  Maleonn's parents were artists during the C.R. and suffered.  He has taken still-vivid photographs from the Cultural Revolution period and placed them against all-white backgrounds. Maleonn wants China's history to be remembered, against the Center's intent to white-wash it.

The Soul of China



"It's more than a power struggle.  It's a corresponding interest to maintain the legitimacy of the Communist Party-to survive."
                                    -Cheng Li, Brookings Institution on Bo Xilai, New York Times, April 7.


Image: Painting by Maleonn for "China's Soul" exhibition, Shanghai, 2010.

Friday, April 06, 2012

Spot the Difference in the Two Pictures.



It is Good Friday and Christeeans worldwide,and those of us raised as Christeeans, celebrate the day.  I didn't do too good in Sunday School so as I sit here now decades later I misremember why we Christeeans celebrate the day that Christ was crucified.  This was the day, right?  Easter, I can understand. Christ rose from the dead, that's never happened before--or since.  Maybe it would be more accurate to say that we "observe" today but when I googled "Good Friday" images and procured the Signorelli at top Google prompted me with the suggested search "Happy Good Friday."  Maybe it would be more accurate to say that Jews "celebrate" today and Christeeans "observe" it but that always infuriates Jews and makes them paranoid and makes them go hide under the bed so we won't say that.

However all that may be it is not a good Friday for Americans, especially American Democrats whether Christeean or Jew.  Since it is the first Friday of the month this is also the day that the Labor Department releases it's monthly jobs report. They did that at 8:30 today and told us that 120,000 jobs were added in March. Consistent with our monthly practice, 120,000 is the size of the city of Charleston, South Carolina, Charleston take a bow,


thank you, and that SUCKS!  Charleston won't cut it, they're still in the horse-and-buggy era as we can all see. No, 120,000 is too little, we need at least Chula Vista or at the very, very least Garland, to be able to say that the recovery is really continuing, and we ended up with dang Charleston. We economics scholars were predicting Chula Vista or Garland also and so there's the additional, dreaded "adverse psychological effect" attendant to unmet predictions confidently made.

What really sucks is that, according to the New York Times, the Federal Reserve Bank (the "Fed," to us insiders) believes that even a Chula Vista per month is too anemic for a "recovery" after 2 years of stimulus. Interest rates are about as low as they can go, have been about as low as they can go for some time, that's been the Fed's strategy to stimulate the economy, and so when the Feds met this week, before the Charleston disaster,  they asked themselves the question, "What do we do if we don't start seeing Chula Vista+ numbers?"  According to the Times the Feds were going to consider redefining what "full employment" meant and raise interest rates. ? It seems to us here at Public Occurrences that the Feds need to have another meeting.

On the other hand Mitt Romney had an orgasm today.

Thursday, April 05, 2012

American Presidential Politics.


American politics is "polarized."  That's the conventional wisdom;  wise normal people think that, Chinese think that, idiot bloggers think that. It's true. America has always been bipolar...maybe in both the political and psychological meanings. In politics we have two parties.  That's "bi," duh.  That's not what people mean though. They mean when they say American politics is polarized today that there is an unusual breadth and depth of hatred among partisans of one candidate towards the other. I think there is hatred in American politics today. I think some people really hate President Obama. A lot of people really hated President George W. Bush.  A lot hated Bill Clinton. I don't understand the hatred but I agree it's there.  Is this hatred unusual in American politics though?  Some people hated Richard Nixon, some hated FDR.  And then there are these.  These are actual campaign slogans of actual candidates for the actual presidency:

"Blaine, Blaine, James G. Blaine, The Continental Liar from the State of Maine," Grover Cleveland-AND-"Ma, Ma, Where's My Pa, Gone to the White House, Ha, Ha, Ha," James G. Blaine (1884). Editorial note: Cleveland fathered a child out of wedlock. Can these ever be topped?  No.

"Cox and Cocktails," Warren G. Harding (1920).Ed. note: James M. Cox, the Democrat, was a "Wet," i.e. against Prohibition, i.e. for drinking. If I had been alive in 1920 Cox would have gotten my vote.

"In Your Heart, You Know He's Right,"  Barry Goldwater-AND-"In Your Heart, You Know He Might" (over a picture of a nuclear mushroom cloud), Lyndon Baines Johnson (1964).

Dishonorable mention:

"Reannexation of Texas and Reoccupation of Oregon," James K. Polk-AND-"Who is James K. Polk?," Henry Clay (1844).

Monday, April 02, 2012

China.

China holds my interest. Those closest to me say I'm obsessed.

The New York Times prominently reports today And they don't mean that as a compliment on a new Brookings Institute study, "Addressing U.S.-China Strategic Distrust."  The study gets prominent reporting because a co-author is Wang Jisi, an adviser to the Center, and thus reveals what PRC officials really think.  Although I have downloaded the study this post is based on the Times article summarized below because I am impatient as well as...interested.

1. China is more assertive in the world. 
2. That's because the Center is more confident of China's capabilities based on post-Deng economic growth.
3. The Center is not impressed with the U.S. as a model for China.
     A. The U.S. is in decline economically and in world influence.
     B. Internal U.S. politics is increasingly polarized.
4. Americans are nosey people with a bone in their brain and should not be raising human and political rights issues with China.
5. The Center has no intent to liberalize human and political rights. 
6. Sino-American economic and world influence competition is zero-sum.
7. China will win the sum and the U.S. will win the zero.
8. Sino-American competition is likely to develop into hostility, maybe into military conflict but not necessarily.

The entire outlook is of course plausible, Mr. Wang and co-author Kenneth Lieberthal are rational, informed analysts. Numbers 1 and 5 are factually true and obvious. 

Number 3 is also true as far as it goes. That is, China does not see the U.S. as a model. 3A and 3B are undoubtedly the reasons China does not see the U.S. as a model.  3A is not true in my opinion and 3B, while true, is not relevant if one believes that America is not in decline. 3B is relevant to those who are paranoid and see a one-party state as the best way forward.

I don’t find the analysis in number 3 particularly cogent. This strikes me as boilerplate. It was said America was in decline in the 1960’s and ‘70’s during and after Vietnam. Henry Kissinger believed America-as-Athens might succumb to Russia-as-Sparta. In the, what was it, the ‘80’s, there was a book by some guy—Paul Kennedy?-- that was all the rage.  The cover imagery was the thesis: it showed a platform with three steps, like in the Olympics. John Bull was stepping off the platform entirely; Uncle Sam was stepping off the “gold medal” top step, and a figure carrying a Japanese flag was ascending to the top step.  And I bought a lot of stock in a mutual fund called the “Japan Fund” and lost a lot of money.  But “past success is no guarantee of future success.”  Nothing lasts forever and China is a plausible candidate to be next up on the winner’s step. But I don’t think so.  And that’s because of number 2.

Number 2 surprises me: “confident,” the Center is confident.  I don’t see “confidence” in China’s soul.  China was dysfunctional for 3,000 years; they have been functional for 30 and Chinese are a very history-conscious people. As the People’s Republic, China was as dysfunctional, incompetent, and murderous as any regime in human history from 1949-1976.  Now they’ve had economic success for 30 years and they’re confident?  No.  Or at least not the people; the Center may be confident but not the people. Historically they have never competed. Chinese have a slavish mentality. They obey. When the Center tells the people to go do something they do it. This works particularly well in the catch-up phase of economic development, which is the phase China is in.  "See that stuff over there?  Go make stuff like that."  They will do it. Look at the Beijing Olympics. They figured out what Hollywood did and out-did Hollywood.  They're great at working off blueprints; blueprints are orders and they obey orders. Here's what pains me:  it's imitation and imitation is fake. This is why I say China today is not real.  China is not real.   Imitation is not creation.  To move to the next phase of economic development, Chinese have to create. A modern post-industrial economy must continually create: new products, new ideas to stimulate demand for new products.  Chinese have the ability to do this by virtue of being human just like Americans.  Historically they haven't done it and the slavish mentality is one key reason.  But history need not be destiny.

I see pain, so much pain, in China’s soul, so much sorrow. I look in those eyes and I see it; I hear it in their voices. The Chinese population is still half rural. All of those huge cities and half the people still live in the countryside*  The West, and I certainly, know virtually nothing about rural Chinese. For three millennia the peasants of China have survived, little more. In my oft-stated view Chinese are survivors, not achievers, not competitors. For these reasons I do not believe Number 7.  I don’t believe number 8 on this ground either and because China historically has not been nearly as imperial as many other nations, nor as aggressive. Nor even interested.  China did not explore. If the authors are correct that China and America are locked in competition and that competition may turn “antagonistic,” I am confident as China’s American competitor and antagonist. I am more confident that my antagonist is confident. 

Number 6 puzzles me. Economic competition is hardly ever zero-sum. That was at the root of Harry Truman’s desire for a “one-handed” economic advisor.  There’s almost always an “on the other hand.”  Even with the enormous trade deficit the U.S. runs currently with China, there’s some benefit to the U.S., more supply, cheaper goods (but see below). Maybe it’s because the Center fundamentally doesn’t understand economics. Wouldn’t be the first time. There is something though about this view that I’ve read somewhere, maybe in Kissinger’s book.  If survival is at your soul, do you not see more than one winner possible?

Number 4 causes schizoid thinking in Americans, from bloggers to policy makers, even in Henry Kissinger, the champion of realpolitik in Sino-American relations.  Last year (I think it was) when Hu Jintao visited Washington I wrote here that the Administration should not talk human rights with Hu, that America had made the decision to play with China and should accept the repression as something we can and should do nothing about.  Except decide not to play with them. The latter no one seriously advocates.  I wonder.

Human rights are important values to Americans.  That’s why they’re part of our foreign policy sometimes.  We really believe in them and we really don’t like to see people slaughtered or repressed, even in far-away China.  And when we “play” with another country, we feel guilty if that other country slaughters or represses its people because then we have “enabled” that slaughter and repression to some degree.  All for money (trade, “play”).

What if we think of it this way:  how much money has America made from playing with China, and is that enough to offset our guilty feelings (everything has a price; guilty feelings are a thing).  At the macro-economic level, we’ve lost money. Our trade deficit with China last year was $295 billion. So we’ve paid the Center $295 billion (last year) for them to repress their people.  I think it is factual that if the U.S. decided, “You know what, you disgust us, we’re not going to trade with you anymore,” China would be hurt economically more than the U.S. would.  Actually, it’s factual, it is undeniable.  That would throw off Lieberthal’s and Wang’s predictions. I have thought about this.  I have thought about this as seriously as an idiot blogger can. After I read Kissinger’s On China, I re-read parts of Margaret Macmillan’s Nixon and Mao. Macmillan asks the question whether Nixon, Kissinger, and America gave up too much in 1972 and thereafter.  My recollection is she didn't answer the question.  She was troubled by it.

I’m troubled by it. I have found myself turn away in disgust at times. China’s assertiveness in the last few years has annoyed me. I have found myself sometimes wistful for those pre-1972 days when China was closed. Maybe it is always thus with obsessions.

*Changed April 7, 2012 from "The Chinese population is--60%? 70%?, some astonishing figure—rural. All those huge cities and China is still largely a rural nation," based on the CIA estimate of 53% in 2010  https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ch.html, and Wikipedia's estimate of 48.7% at the end of 2011.

Saturday, March 31, 2012

American Health Care Law.


"...it would be folly to predict what the court will conclude..."
                                                        -New York Times, March 31.

Welcome to Supreme Court follies.

It is Saturday morning which means that the members of the court met yesterday to take a "preliminary vote" on the constitutionality of Obamacare and (prediction) voted it down, probably 5-4. 

There was, and is, a great debate in America over the wisdom of Obamacare.  That, in a democracy, is as it should be. It is a peculiarity of the American democracy that the members of the third co-equal federal branch of government do not assume, or "ascend" to, as it is sometimes put, their positions via democratic vote.  They are not elected but appointed.  For life. The American way thus seeks to insulate Supreme Court justices from the vicissitudes of politics. 

Oh, there is some tinny sound to this, certainly.  Most Americans, and I, hear it too. Laws, plural, are made by politicians; they are the product of overtly, unabashedly, often messy-looking political work and judges, who are registered voting Republicans or Democrats and sometimes were elected politicians before their "ascent," are in some meaningful way not political?  Oh yes, we hear it too. That discordant noise is merely a part of the larger symphony from above.  On the whole, we like the sound.

We like the sound of “all are equal under the law” and “the law is above all.” Those familiar maxims of verticality put the law, singular, "up" and politics "down." Judges "up," politicians "down."  The Constitution is the uppidiest "up" there is.  All are under that Law. We want the Constitution protected, we don’t want it pulled down from on high, and we will swallow our democratic principles to do it. We want Supreme Court justices to protect the Constitution and we will protect the justices to accomplish that. And so lifetime appointments. We will protect Supreme Court justices from us.

Just do not act politically on the bench.

In return for this protection from us political animals we ask Supreme Court justices to refrain from politics.  Obviously no campaigning or endorsing; aside from voting we ask Supreme Court justices to keep their political opinions to themselves. We agree not to ask, they agree not to tell.  That’s easy.  We also ask them to keep their political views out of their decisions: “apply the Law” is another American bromide.  “Apply the Law,” do not change it.  That’s hard sometimes.

It is impossible sometimes. When we political animals enact “a” law that conflicts with “the” law, the Constitution, we charge Supreme Court justices to smite it, and us, down.  We hope that doesn’t happen often since he who is smitten sometimes wants to smite back and we agree to protect Supreme Court justices, not smite them. So we ask Supreme Court justices not to do that very often. And they don’t.  They are above us in this elevated position because we put them there. They're vulnerable to a long, hard fall.

Supreme Court justices understand that it is a long, hard fall and so they have, enacted, of their own, certain limitations on their own behavior.  Like this:

''It is but a decent respect to the wisdom, integrity, and patriotism of the legislative body, by which any law is passed to presume in favor of its validity, until its violation of the Constitution is proved beyond a reasonable doubt.''*

And this:

“The Court developed, for its own governance in the cases within its jurisdiction, a series of rules under which it has avoided passing upon a large part of all the constitutional questions pressed upon it for decision. They are:

1. The Court will not pass upon the constitutionality of legislation in a friendly, non-adversary, proceeding, declining because to decide such questions is legitimate only in the last resort, and as a necessity in the determination of real, earnest, and vital controversy between individuals. It never was the thought that, by means of a friendly suit, a party beaten in the legislature could transfer to the courts an inquiry as to the constitutionality of the legislative act.

2. The Court will not anticipate a question of constitutional law in advance of the necessity of deciding it. It is not the habit of the court to decide questions of a constitutional nature unless absolutely necessary to a decision of the case.

3. The Court will not formulate a rule of constitutional law broader than required by the precise facts it applies to.

4. The Court will not pass upon a constitutional question although properly presented by the record, if there is also present some other ground upon which the case may be disposed of… If a case can be decided on either of two grounds, one involving a constitutional question, the other a question of statutory construction or general law, the Court will decide only the latter.

5. The Court will not pass upon the validity of a statute upon complaint of one who fails to show that he is injured by its operation.

6. The Court will not pass upon the constitutionality of a statute at the instance of one who has availed himself of its benefits.

7. When the validity of an act of the Congress is drawn in question, and even if a serious doubt of constitutionality is raised, it is a cardinal principle that this Court will first ascertain whether a construction of the statute is fairly possible by which the question may be avoided.” **

Now I ask you, are these not wise rules to distance the Court from politics and vice versa?  Are these not sentiments of comity between co-equal branches of government? They are.

Is this?:


     "Mr. Clement, I didn't take the time to figure this out, but maybe you did. Is
     there any chance at all that 26 States opposing it have Republican 
    governors and all of the states supporting it have Democratic governors? Is that 
                         possible?"



*Ogden v. Saunders, 25 U.S. 213, 270 (1827).
**Ashwander v. Tennessee Valley Authority 297 U.S. 288, 346-9 (1936) (Brandeis concurring) (citing cases). 

Friday, March 30, 2012

Friday.  No court.  Friday morning. Run errands. File pleadings in courthouse. Few people. Little interaction. Good. Conserve energy.Auto-pilot. Own world. Oblivious.

Go visit clients in jail. Depressing.

Enter jail. Buzzed in to sign-in space. Small. Three-four person capacity tops. Metal detector. Present id, signing in, back turned. Auto-pilot. Own world.

"Good morning, sir."

Turn around. Young, fresh-scrubbed. Blue uniform. "Good morning, ma'am."

"Good morning, sir."

Turn around. Young, fresh-scrubbed. Blue uniform. "Good morning, sir."

"Good morning, sir."

Turn around. A battalion. A tour. Leaving as I'm entering. One after the other. All young, fresh-scrubbed, blue uniform.

All polite.

TRAPPED.

"GoodmorningsirGoodmorningsirGoodmorningsirGoodmorningsirGoodmorningsirGoodmorningsir." 

Thursday, March 29, 2012

Trayvon Martin, cont.

10.  http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/28/trayvon-martin-police-video_n_1386764.html?ncid=wsc-huffpost-cards-image

There is no injury to George Zimmerman apparent on these police videos.  This conflicts with #4 and casts doubt on #9.  It focuses attention on the underlined portion of the "stand your ground" law below:

"If George Zimmerman was not engaged in an unlawful activity and was attacked in any place where he had a right to be, he had no duty to retreat and had the right to stand his ground and meet force with force, including deadly force, if he reasonably believed that it was necessary to do so to prevent death or great bodily harm to himself or to prevent the commission of a forcible felony."


Was it "necessary" for George Zimmerman to shoot Trayvon Martin?

Wednesday, March 28, 2012

American Health Care Law.

Today was the last of three days of oral argument before the United States Supreme Court. Case number 11-393, National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius and 11-400, Florida v. Health and Human Services Department, tests the constitutionality of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act passed by the United States Congress and signed into effect by President Obama on December 24, 2009. The law, popularly (or unpopularly) known as "Obamacare," so identified is it with the president, was lauded here, as was the president, upon enactment.  It is the most significant piece of social legislation in fifty years.

The law has not been lauded in oral argument before the Supreme Court.  Based on their judicial histories and questioning of the lawyers the nine justices seem split on party affiliation of the president who appointed them. Those who were appointed by Republican presidents seem inclined to strike down the law, those appointed by Democrats to uphold it. This has surprised many close observers of the Court who had predicted approval by a decisive majority.

Yesterday's arguments revealed deep reservations by half of the court on whether the federal government had the power under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution to enact legislation mandating, as Obamacare does, individuals to pay for insurance or pay a penalty. The concerns about this Commerce Clause power are captured by a question asked by Justice Anthony Kennedy:  "Can you create commerce in order to regulate it?"  Solicitor General Donald B.Verrilli, speaking for the government, answered, "That's not what's going on here, Justice Kennedy." Nor does it seem to this legal non-scholar and non-close, non-observer of the Court to be what is going on here but it seemed that way to Justice Kennedy--and Justice Scalia and Justice Alito and Chief Justice Roberts (Justice Thomas didn't ask any questions, seldom does, so predictably conservative is he.).  That's a 5-4 majority against the law right there.

Today's arguments reinforced the impression from yesterday that the law was in trouble: they focused on whether the law could be saved if the "individual mandate" (to buy or be fined) was struck down.  Justice Scalia, who thinks as a hatchet cuts, said, "My approach would be to say that if you take the heart out of this statute, the statute's gone."  That would be unfortunate for the American people in the opinion here.

It would also be unfortunate for President Obama.  It is called "Obamacare" after all and this is an election year. If this signature piece of legislation from the president's first term is deemed unconstitutional it hurts his chances for a second term.