Monday, May 24, 2004

there some pertty, pertty pitchers in this month's vogue.

nicole kidman by irving penn is stupendo. the cover photo is stunning, some of those inside, even more so.

on the cover and on page 263 kidman is wearing this christian lecroix oyster satin gown that is called a "sheath." whatever it's called it's sensational fashion.

the lighting in both photographs is a dramatic background that fades from light-brown/gray to black from right to left.

each of the photos discretely focus on one fashion segment--hair, front of sheath, back of sheath--and the lighting really enhances what's being focused on. in the cover photo it is the incredible huge, jewel-brooched black bow that is the coup de grace of the back of the gown.

the photo on page 262 focuses on the upper back and kidman's hair-do. her back is so strong in that soft, feminine way and her stawberry hair is in a bun that is itself a fashion segment. it looks like a strawberry colored bird's nest. maybe that doesn't sound so beautiful but it really is. great job by the stylist

that same photo also has this cool little hidden gem in it. kidman's face is in barely 1/4 profile from the rear. you see her fine chin but most strikingly, you see on close inspection that her right eyelashes show that she is looking down in demure femininity. wonder if penn told her to look down or it just turned out that way?

you can best see how special the lecroix gown is in the photo on page 263. it is cut so perfectly that it drapes like the fabric is made to look in those ancient greek statues. it seems more substantial than mere fabric, like it was sculpted.

satin also does such wonderful things with light. the folds look buttery or like a waterfall. a sculpted buttery waterfall. or something like that.

on page 260 is a black and white photo with lighting similar to that in the colors and kidman is in a karl lagerfeld outfit consisting of a mannish coat and a flapper-style skirt.

the focus in this photo though is this incredible hat she's wearing. it's by leah c. couture millinery and is bowler-like with feathers drooping over the face. it has a little of the effect of a veil. kidman's eyes look to her right, adding mystery-by-indirection to the mini-veiled effect.

i bet also this is kidman's favorite photo because the black and white and the lighting softly but clearly define the planes and angles of her face so that that face could not look more beautiful.


finally the photograph on p. 259, with the same background lighting in the others, shows the face direct and head-on. you see her stunning blue eyes for the first time and her hair is all teased out so that it looks like flames. what amazing hair. and then her whole head, the eyes, the hair, the face is dramatically framed by a massive, velvety black collar that is part of a valentino cape. jeezus crimminy.

best pitchers in vogue in a long, long time. i bet this issue is gonna be saved by fashion-photog types.


-benjamin harris

Sunday, May 23, 2004

Books: War & Peace

Books: War & Peace

the most meaningful description of the death experience that i have ever read i have read just now in WAR AND PEACE of the death of prince andrei.

it is the leave-taking of the soul from the body and the manifestations of that leave-taking on the physical and on those of the loved ones, here, natasha, prince andrei's lover and princess marya, his sister.

tolstoy's description begins with natasha explaining to marya the course of prince andrie's condition and its ups and downs:

"'but two days ago...THIS suddenly happened.
i don't know why but you will see what i
mean.'" (original emphasis)

it was not a new physical ailment like pneuonia or gangrene that had set in, it was the physical manifestation of the soul's leave-taking.

this is how it looked to princess marya:

"when natasha opened the door...and let
princess marya enter the room...[marya]
understood what natasha meant by the words:
'two days ago THIS suddenly happened.' she
took it to mean that he had suddenly softened
and that this softness and susceptibility were
signs of approaching death."

"'how are you, marie? how did you manage to
get here?' he said in a voice as even and
aloof as his gaze."

"if he had uttered a desperate shriek, that
cry would have been less horrifying to
princess marya than the tone of his voice."

"'and have you nikolushka [his son]'? he
asked in the same deliberate, even tone
and with an obvious effort to remember."

"'how are you now?'" asked princess marya.."

"'that, my dear, you must ask the doctor,"
he replied, and with a manifest effort to
be gracious, and speaking with his lips
only (his mind was clearly not on what he
was saying)..."

"she understood the change that had come
over him two days ago. in his words,
his tone, and above all in his almost
hostile look, could be felt that alienation
from all things earthly that is so terrible
to one who is alive. evidently it was difficult
for him to understand anything living; YET IT
SEEMED THAT HE FAILED TO UNDERSTAND NOT BECAUSE
HE HAD LOST THE POWER TO DO SO, BUT BECAUSE HE
UNDERSTOOD SOMETHING ELSE--SOMETHING THE LIVING
DID NOT AND COULD NOT UNDERSTAND AND WHICH
WHOLLY ABSORBED HIM." [emphasis added]

when my mother was dying there was a similar affect. i would say something to her or ask her something and she would say "what?" in an almost annoyed way.

at first i thought she was not hearing. but after awhile i realized that she was not all there, not in the sense that the drugs had made her goofy but in the way tolstoy describes it, that her soul was leaving and she was absorbed in other thoughts.

tolstoy continues on this point:

"...he was indifferent to everything,
indifferent because something of
far greater importance had been
revealed to him."

"the conversation was cold, desultory,
and continually broken off."

"'andrei, would you like...would you like
to see nikolushka? [marya asked]."

"for the first time there was a barely
perceptible smile on prince andrei's face,
but princess marya, who knew his face so
well, saw with horror that it was not
a smile of pleasure or of affection for his
son, but of gentle irony at his sister's
using what she believed to be the ultimate
means of awakening his feelings."

after seeing nikolushka briefly marya began crying in andrei's presence. now tolstoy describes what andrei is thinking and experiencing:

"when princess marya began to cry he
understood that she was crying at
the thought of nikolushka being left
without a father. he made a great effort
to come back to life and see things from
their point of view."

"'yes, to them it must seem sad,'" he thought.
'"but how simple it is!'"

..."'they don't understand that all these feelings
they set such store by--all our feelings,
all those ideas that seem so important to us
DO NOT MATTER. we cannot understand one
another,'" [emphasis in original]

tolstoy continues the description from andrei's perspective:

"[he]...knew...that he was already half
dead. he was conscious of an alienation
from everything earthly, and of a strange
and joyous lightness of being."

"during the hours of solitude, suffering,
and partial delirium that he spent after
he was wounded, the more deeply he reflected
on the principle of eternal love that had
been newly revealed to him, the more he
unconsciously renounced earthly life. to
love everyone and everything, always to
sacrifice oneself for love, meant not to
love any one person, and not to live this
earthly life."

before my mother died she had a presentiment of her death. for many years she had had a recurring dream in which she was standing on the edge of a field and on the opposite end was her father, long dead.

in her dream, her father smiled at her and said "come on, honey; come on, dear." and mum had not gone. she said "daddy, i'm not ready." she told meher father "had put his head down and turned away with the saddest look on his face."

mum always said that she knew that if she had gone to her dad that she would have died. "so you see benjamin, i know that when it's my time, my dad will come for me."

a week before her death, after a couple of days of noticably declining health she had the dream again. she awoke that morning and told my brother, "tim, my dad was here last night." tim asked what she meant and she said "my dad was here, he was in the bed with me all night."

tolstoy describes prince andrei's epiphany:

"...what natasha referred to when she
said: "THIS suddenly happened" had
occurred two days before princess
marya's arrival. it was the final
spiritual struggle between life and
death..."

"it happened in the evening." he fell asleep:

"he dreamed he was lying in the room
he actually was in but that he had not
been wounded and was well. a great many
people...appear before him. he talks to
them...they are preparing to go away...
gradually,imperceptibly, all these persons
begin to disappear, and are supplanted by
a single problem: the closed door."

"he gets up and goes to the door to bolt
and lock it, EVERYTHING depends on whether
he succeeds in locking it in time."

"he starts toward it... but his legs will
not move...IT stands behind the door....
that ominous something is alreay pressing
against it and forcing its way in. something
inhuman--death--is breaking in and must be
stopped..."

"his efforts are feeble and ineffectual...
once more IT pushed from outside...IT
entered, and it was DEATH. and prince
andrei died."

as with my mother's epiphany though, that was just THE SIGN. neither my mother nor tolstoy's character actually physically died at that moment although both were aware that IT was now irrevocable:

"but at the very moment he died,
prince andrei remembered that he
was asleep, and at that very moment,
having exerted himself, awoke."

"'yes, that was death. i died--and i awoke.
yes, death is an awakening!"

"and his soul was suddenly sufused with
light..and from then on that strange
lightness did not leave him again."

"this is what happened to him two days
before princess marya's arrival."

"with his awakening from sleep that day,
there began for prince andrei an awakening
FROM life." [emphasis added]

my mother went quietly at about 6 am on april 5, which had been my father's birthday. lucy, our hospice nurse, called tim and told him she thought he should come over because mum had stopped breathing.

tolstoy:

"when he was in the last throes and the
spirit left the body, princess marya and
natasha were present."

"'is it over?'" asked princess marya after
the body had lain motionless for some moments,
growing cold before their eyes."

"natasha went up to it, looked into the dead
man's eyes and quickly closed them."

i was not present when my mother died but i had been present for the events after THE SIGN, had flown back home and then came back up the day she died.

i got to her house a little before dusk. i entered the house, empty except for her cocker spaniel.

buddy greeted me in his usual friendly way. i went through the kitchen and stood at the entrance to the hallway that led down to mum's bedroom.

buddy had scampered ahead of me and was standing at the entrance to the bedroom, looking into the room where mum had so recently lain, and then looking at me,looking into the empty room and then back at me.

i wept as i walked down the hallway and when i entered the bedroom and saw her hospice bed gone but the imprints on the carpet that the legs of the bed had left were still there.

i smelled her smell still in the room and saw her clothes. i wept when i went into her bathroom and saw everything just as it had been a few days before and yet with everything irrevocably different now.

mum was 85, had survived skin cancer, two episodes of breast cancer, bladder cancer and had finally succumbed to liver cancer.

i wept of course because she was my mother and because i missed her and felt the loss so much. but i also wept because of the strange, awesome death process that i had witnessed. it was like as tolstoy describes the feelings of natasha and princess marya:

"[they]also wept now, but not because
of their personal grief; they wept
out of a reverent emotion that filled
their souls before the solemn mystery
of a death that had been consummated
in their presence."


-benjamin harris

"What a Wonderful World" Department

"What a Wonderful World" Department

Dave johnson's horse racing calls. I was coming home from work last Saturday, turned on sportsradio and it happened just about to be post-time at the preakness.

The start was delayed and then delayed again and again. Then they had trouble getting some horse in the gate. I was already home by now but just drove around the block in circles so I wouldn't miss Johnson's call.

Finally the race started. Johnson not only has a signature phrase but he also calls a very good race. You can see the race through your radio. Very articulate too. No stumbles, no mispronunciations. And then,

"DOWN THE STRETCH THEY COME!...."

Gave me a tingle down my spine. Always does.


-Benjamin Harris

Friday, May 21, 2004

was just spending my 15 minutes a day channel surfing and reminding myself how exasperating tv is when i happened onto clinton's speech at the university of kansas today on c-span.

what an amazing, amazing man he is. his ability to communicate and connect is just incredible.

he thinks "big thoughts," like at his renaissance weekends, and even though his communication skills were, of course, evident during his presidency, you don't often have the luxury of giving big thought speeches when you have to deal with mundane matters like the budget and getting your ass impeached.

today at ku, with no portfolio, with no election to think about, with none of the minutia of the capitol to occupy his time, he just talked, it appeared without notes.

i just saw the last maybe 15 minutes of his speech but the general topic was apparently how he thought we could best deal with terrorism. i'm sure he touched all the common military issues but his larger point was that we had to change the way we think.

as he said, "this is going to sound a little flaky, but i believe it." he recounted a white house evening with bennet cerf and some harvard biologist/geneticist. what a pairing, and he said that of all the interesting things that were said that night, the most striking for him was that the biologist said that all human beings are 99.99% genetically identical.

ok, it is a little twee and his point is obvious. we have to come up with ways to identify with others based on that 99.99% commonality and not let the .01% blind us. "the next time you want to demonize somebody, think of that," he said.

i don't know, maybe it's just because i'm so sick of hearing bush and the contrast in intellectual depth was so stark, (and maybe because i was on adderal) but the esp-like connection he always made with people just came right through the tv screen. for the people watching and hearing him in person, it was always said he was even more "connective."

such a complex man psychologically. the inclusiveness theme obvious to a first year psych student as the product of trying to keep a family with an alcoholic, abusive father together. the bizarre, near death-wish risk taking that he engaged in.

but man, how gifted and how brilliant. he was an incredible politician and a great president. i miss him.


-benjamin harris

Wednesday, May 19, 2004

why does the new york times continue to give a forum to william safire?

his hiring was widely believed to be the result of an affirmative action program for conservatives, to put a voice from the right on the op-ed page to counter right-wing charges of liberal bias.

even at the time i thought the choice an odd one. safire was a political hack, a nixon lackey, the author of spiro agnew's rants against the "nattering nabobs of negativism," and such like. there was really noone better?

alliterative political red-meat is not the same thing as astute commentary or good writing and safire has little in the way of either of those.

above all, he is a writer who lacks intellectual honesty. he is incapable of admitting that he is, or ever has been, wrong.

he defends to this day nixon and his association with him, agnew and his association with him.

after 9/11 he was nattering nabob number one in publicizing a czech intelligence report that one of the 9/11 operatives, i believe mohammad atta, had met with an iraqi diplomat in prague.

the reported meeting did, as it should have, generate much follow-up investigation by czech and u.s. intel officials.

when these investigations began to raise doubts that the meeting occurred, safire continued to make the assertion and started hinting at a coverup and conspiracy.

when the story was finally discredited safire persisted, raising the volume of his voice to compensate for its lack of substance and now bitterly complained of a coverup (and HE should know cover-up).

the safire m.o. is to build an argument on sketchy facts or half-truths and then to respond with attacks of incompetence or duplicity on anyone who disagrees with the argument or who questions the underlying facts.

today he's at it again, this time on the news that an artillery shell found in iraq may contain the nerve agent sarin. this column is safire at his shrill, conspiratorial, insinuating, ad hominem, denying, worst.

knowing the factual insufficiency of his argument he starts with the attack:

"you probably missed the news because it
didn't get much play..."

so right off the bat we're conditioned that something fishy is going on here. there is "news" and "it didn't get much play." the implication is that a REVELATION is forthcoming and that others in the media didn't give it the attention it deserved because of incompetency or worse.

in the same sentence he then begins to lay out his "case":

"...a small, crude weapon of mass destruction
may have been used by saddam's terrorists
in iraq this week."

well the FACT (which you may have missed because he doesn't give it much play) is that an artillery shell was ACCIDENTALLY DETONATED by AMERICAN SOLDIERS and that the powder inside was a BINARY compound that included small amounts of sarin.

lest the evil be missed the next paragraph makes it with the subtlety of a sledgehammer: sarin was first developed by the nazis and was used by japanese terrorists in the subway attack of a few years ago.


to label this ONE shell as a "weapon of mass destruction" is irresponsible and typical of safire's method. take a small fact and exaggerate it into a larger evil.

and those who point this out, those who say "one or two poison-gas bombs USED SO FAR does not a 'stockpile' make"? they are "our lionized apostles of defeat."

that is just outrageous. first, the ONE found so far was not "USED." WE, U.S. soldiers ACCIDENTALLY DETONATED IT!. and second those who disagree are subjected to an ad hominem attack.

"you never saw such a rush to dismiss this
as not news," noting that usatoday saw fit to bury the story on page ten as a "brushoff."

he then writes:

"u.n. weapons inspectors whose reputations
rest on denial of saddam's wmb pooh-poohed
the report. 'it doesn't strike me as a big
deal,' said david kay."

so anyone who disagrees that this is big news is dismissed as trying to save his reputation.

but there may be something more malicious in that paragraph. wasn't david kay the U.S. weapons inspector? wasn't he OUR, the U.S.'s, the bush administration's, weapons inspector?

if i'm wrong, if kay was a u.n. guy, then safire is still attacking those who disagree with him for being more concerned with their careers than the truth but if kay was, as i remember, a U.S. inspector then that entire sentence is so malicious and so misleading that it should never have made it past the editors of any respectable newspaper, much less those of the new york times.

more attacks: "even the defense department," "on the defensive, STRAINED not to appear alarmist, saying confirmation was needed for the field tests." so waiting until confirmatory tests are done before telling the world that a WEAPON OF MASS DESTRUCTION has been found is "straining," it's the result of a defenive, timid dod. rummy has been accused of a lot of things, timidity has never been one of them.

he then lists "the Four noes" of "the defeatists' platform, the first one of which is that no wmd were found in iraq. to that he says bizarrely that even at this late date it is a rush to judgement if "the absence of evidence is taken to be evidence of absense," and that "when the pendulum has swung" and today's "cut-and-runners" are shown to be wrong there will be books written about this and "these MAY WELL reveal the successful concealment of wmd, as well as prewar shipments...to syria..."

further, "in a sovereign and free iraq, when...scientists are fearful of being tried as prewar criminals their impetus will be to sing--and point to caches of anthrax and other mass killers."

what can you say about that? the guy is in denial, he is intellectually dishonest, his argument is now being based, not even on half-truths, but on speculation into the future. opinionist or not, he should have no right to write such rubbish in a respectable newspaper.

maybe the times is getting tired of his irrational act. in an unusual move, it issued an editorial to accompany safire's irresponsible screed. after giving a fairer treatment of the facts it refers to "the dwindling band of die-hards who remain convinced that mr. hussein squirreled away stockpiles of illicit weapons..."

members of that irresponsible, dwindling band should not be given a forum in the "gray lady."


-benjamin harris



Friday, May 14, 2004

those most basic principles show iraq, and brooks' commentary on iraq in a new light. the muddled thinking and writing on iraq are part of a larger muddle on foreign policy doctrine.

in 1989 the cold war ended but america's thinkers did not replace george kennan's cold war doctrine of containment with a new doctrine to meet the new world. we responded reactively and tentatively, sometimes with trial ballons of a new world order, but mostly with keeping on keeping on. bob dole said after the implosion of the soviet union, "this is no time to be cutting military spending." oh,why not? we never had a debate on that.

we maintained, and still maintain, cold war structures and alliances fifteen years after their raison d'etre ended. nato has been expanded rather than disbanded. we have kept our treaty obligations to defend taiwan and south korea even though an attack on either, horrendous though it would be, certainly does not have the meaning that would have had during the cold war.

we went along piecemeal in our responses to world crises. we intervened in bosnia and in haiti, two ultimately bloodless forays but without any overarching answer to the question "why?"

9/11 came along and showed that that question and its answer were not just academic. we had/we have, no doctrine for understanding and framing a response to 9/11.

president bush said immediately thereafter that our war was not with islam. why not? we never had a debate on that either.

so we hit afghanistan, a no-brainer as the home of the taliban which housed al qaeda. but from the beginning the president defined the war broader, as a war on terrorism and rumsfeld immediately wanted to strike somewhere else. why? the only reason was that he didn't want all of our eggs to be in one basket, he didn't want the success of our initial response to be defined by what we did in a place where the word "quagmire" had been accurately used to describe the soviet's venture.

so he asked if 9/11 hadn't given us the "opportunity" to hit iraq. that was the extent of the thinking that went into it. we needed to diversify our portfolio. let's take a swing at hussein. we've been there and done that, we can do it again.

i do not fault the administration for invading iraq. i supported the war and i believe that we are marginally better off today than we were with hussein in power but the lack of doctrine has led to confused thinking about how success of that mission should be defined, of why we really did it, of what we really accomplished, and what we should do next.

bush has, justifiably taken hits for basing the war on hussein's non-existent possession of weapons of mass destruction.

other conservative thinkers wanted to ground the war in a higher moral purpose, the liberation of iraq, on establishing a "shining city on the hill" as a model for arab democracy.

the president took up the cudgel. when baghdad fell his father called him to congratulate. "it's a great day for america," said bush41. "it's a great day for the people of iraq," said bush43.

the raison d'etre for the war had shifted or had been augmented by liberation thinking, which is exactly the kind of "nation-building" that bush and the conservatives had dismissed liberals as proposing.

without wmd though they were left with a pale horse indeed to ride strategically and so reacted ad hoc, as american foreign policy had been doing since 1989.

so you have the startling situation of neocons like brooks and protocons like william safire both proclaiming that success in iraq will be defined by the establishment of a democracy there.

where did the conserative focus on national security at all costs--of real politik, of the difference between authoritarin regimes and totalitarian regimes, of the difference between "our" dictators and "their" dictators--where did all of that go?

it went out the window in 1989 and wasn't replaced by any new doctrine.
david brooks is "crushingly depressed" over the events of the last few weeks and of the situation in post-war iraq generally.

william safire attempts to lift the spirits of hawks like him and brooks, "those...who believe in the nobility of exporting freedom," under the headline "hold fast, idealists."

maureen dowd unloads on "the administration's demented quest to conquer arab hearts and minds," with their fixation on "making the middle east look more like america..."

it is disturbing to read brooks writing squishy things like "we were blinded by idealism," "we can't do good without losing our innocence," and there's still a chance, if elections are held that "we will have succeeded in doing what we set out to do."

it is shocking to read an old manicheanistic hardliner like safire buy into these terms of debate by chasting brooks and his old weekly standard crowd by reassuring them that "hope for iraqi freedom is in the wings. wait and see."

it is crushingly depressing to be in agreement with maureen dowd (whose email address, b.t.w., is "liberties@nytimes.com").

let's be clear about what should be and then proceed from there.

america should not involve itself militarily in another country, much less wage war, unless its national security is threatened. period.

america won the war in iraq. our military goal was to affect regime change and to capture or kill saddam hussein. we accomplished that.

that should have been the definition of success that all hawks should have accepted.

however, there is no post-9/11 conservative foreign policy doctrine any more than there is a liberal doctrine.

that is what has changed most alarmingly since sept. 11. before that, or i would argue, before 1989, the conservatives had a foreign policy doctrine, a resolute containment of communism first articulated by george kennan.

through the pressures of the sixties and seventies they persevered while the democrats floundered about, lurching from neo-isolationism to nation-building as a justification for military intervention.

since 1989 however, conservatives have kept working within the cold war structures, as by say, expanding nato when the entire justification for the alliance ceased to exist, without changing doctrine to fit a new world and by acting, and reacting, after 9/11 without any doctrinal superstructure.

the point is not just an intellectual one any more than capitalism was just an economic theory or das kapital just a political science book. doctrine dictates policy which dictates strategy which dictates tactics.





Sunday, May 09, 2004

The Night Vigil, Shen Zhou

The Night Vigil, Shen Zhou

"On a cold night sleep is very sweet. I woke in the middle of the night, my mind clear and untroubled, and as I was unable to go to sleep again, I put on my clothes and sat facing my flickering lamp. On the table were a few folders of books. I chose a volume at random and began to read, but tiring I put down the book and sat calmly doing nothing. A long rain had newly cleared, and a pale moon was shining through the window. All around was silence."

"Then after a long time absorbing the fresh brightness, I gradually became aware of sounds. Listening to the rustling of the wind stirring the bamboo gave one the feeling of going bravely and unwaveringly onward. Hearing the harsh snarling of dogs gave feelings of barring out evil, of opposing marauders. Hearing the sound of drums, large and small--the small ones thin, and the far ones clear and deep and uninterrupted--stirred restless thoughts that were lonely and sad. The official drum was very close, from three beats, to four and then five, gradually faster, hastening the dawn. Suddenly in the northeast the sound of a bell, a bell pure and clean through rain-cleared air, and hearing it, came thoughts of waiting for the dawn, rising and doing. It was inevitable."

"My nature is such as to enjoy sitting in the night. So I often spread a book under the lamp going back and forth over it, usually stopping at the second watch. Man's clamor is not at rest, and yet the mind is bent on learning. Seldom does he find the outside calm and the inner world at peace."

"Now tonight all sounds and shapes bring this stability and calm. Thus can one purify the mind and spirit and realize one's will. But one should remember that it is not that at other times these sounds and shapes do not exist like this, nor that they do not reach the eye and ear of man, but that appearance is the servant of a thing, and yet hastens to follow it."

"True perception through hearing lies concealed in sound like that of a drum and bell, whereas perception through seeing is hidden in any pattern. Thus things usually harm rather help men. Often is it like tonight's sounds and shapes, for they are really no different from other times, and yet striking the ear and eye they become so firmly and wonderfully a part of me. And so this existence of sounds and patterns is not what prevents me from gaining wisdom; for things are not enough to enslave men."

"When sound is broken and shape shattered and the will rises free, what is this will? Is it within? Or is it without? Or is it in a thing? Or does it cause the thing to be? Is there not a way of defining the difference? Most certainly, and I perceive the difference."

"How great is the strength to be gained sitting in the night. Thus, cleansing the mind, waiting alone through the long watches by the light of the candle becomes the basis of an inner peace and of an understanding of things. This, surely, I will attain."

-Shen Zhou, the calligraphy he put on his painting "The Night Vigil" (1492; in The Three Perfections by Michael Sullivan.

Tuesday, May 04, 2004

manchester city should fire manager kevin keegan.

this will be considered sacrilege because city has just clinched a third straight season in the premiership but this "underachieving, sorry" team, in the words of espn's soccernet, should never have been in the position of having to fight for survival, perhaps literally, down to the 36th game of the season.

this is "king kev's" third year at the helm of the blues and he has two years left on his contract. immediately after being promoted from the nationwide league two years ago, city was thought to be so talented and so well-coached that some predicted qualifying for the champion's league. they finished 9th last year--and that only after a late season flourish--and 17th this year.

this despite the proverbial carte blanche that was given keegan to get the talent he desired, and the fact that city moved into a brand new facility this year, guaranteeing a substantial increase in revenue. keegan spent widely and often, buying steve mcmanaman, david seamen, claudia reyna, paulo wanchope, and most notoriously robbie fowler. stealing from some wag, the city board gave keegan an unlimited budget and he exceeded it. if city had been relegated this year it might well have meant the bankruptcy of the team, so great were its wage debts, combined with its mortgage payments. as my criminal law professor used to say, "i could have lost that case for a lot less money."

keegan made his reputation as a master motivator at newcastle united where he took the magpies to second place in the premiership. he then was honored with the coaching position of england's national team but that foray ended with the infamous, ignoble 1-0 defeat to germany.

if motivation is keegan's coin of the realm that currency has been seriously devalued by his performance at city. there is far too much talent on this team for them to have finished 9th last year, much less 17th this year. the team has been maddeningly inconsistent, winning the manchester derby last year, drawing this year, but inexcusably losing at home to vastly inferior squads both years. the low point was its 3-1 debacle against southhamptom at eastlands late this season, a match of supreme importance to the blues. the supreme motivator's team looked scared and tentative, not only in that match but for much of the season. as of this writing, city has as many wins at eastlands as on the road. inexcusable.

the turning point was his signing of robbie fowler from cash-strapped leeds late last season. fowler played for keegan's english national team and at one time was a superstar in the making, a dangerous and prolific goal scorer. city won a big match right before the signing, in fact when it looked like the deal would fall through, but right after getting fowler, city began its late season swoon and the underachievement and inconsistency just continued this season.

keegan has always put a premium on scoring--which was the reason for the fowler signing--to the detriment of defense and that deficiency has shown itself this year especially. at times city has been a sieve. and fowler has not near made up for the defensive deficiencies by goal scoring. he has been near invisible and has been benched both seasons. his signing has been an unmitigated failure and keegan, naturally, has stood by his man, reluctant to admit failure.

fowler was also subtraction by addition because it resulted in the replacement and eventual release of city legend shaun goater, who was the hero of last season's victory over manchester united.

the city board should step in now, for the immediate and long-term survival of the club in the premiership. selling off fowler and wanthrope and replacing them with hungry "muckers" as they would be called in hockey not only makes financial but football sense. that will not happen however as long as "the boss" is in charge, which means king kev should be the first one to get the axe.

seventeenth place? i could have coached them to that, and for a lot less money


-benjamin harris

Wednesday, April 28, 2004

reading woodward's plan of attack. fascinating account of decision-making in a bureaucracy. the life-changing course i took in grad school was on the study of bureaucracy. it was a boring-sounding fill-in for my semester's caseload.

woodward certainly doesn't have the whole story behind what led up to the decision to go after iraq, he acknowledges that. we probably won't until people write their memoirs and documents are declassified. but at this point, given woodward's track record, it's as good as we're going to get for a long time.

fascinating and shocking. shocking because the whole lead up to the decision to attack seems to occupy only the first 40 pages of the book. i haven't read the whole book yet but long before page 100 we're already past the decision-making phase and into the planning stage.

this is it from the book with page references:

-at clinton's urging, congress passed a law in 1998 calling for regime change in iraq. (10) THIS WAS THE PRECEDENT THE BUSHIES INHERITED. IT SHOULDN'T AMOUNT TO MUCH, IF ANYTHING, BUT IN BUREAUCRACIES ENTROPY IS ALL.

-cheney came to the vice-presidency with a sense of "unfinished business" re iraq (9). THIS WAS A KEY FACTOR.

-bush relied on cheney heavily because of his experience and lack of ambition for presidency.

-rumsfeld worked hard on bush's campaign and had a talk with bush before he was even selected as defsec where he characterized the clinton approach to being attacked as "reflexive pullback" and he thought bush's should be "forward-leaning." bush like this more aggressive approach. (19) BUSH ALREADY LEANING TOWARD BEING MORE AGGRESSIVE GENERALLY.

-in jan. '01 before cohen briefs bush, cheney tells cohen he wants him to make iraq "topic a." THIS IS ASTONISHING. ASTONISHING THAT IN JAN. '01 CHENEY WOULD STACK A BRIEFING OF A TOTALLY GREEN PRESIDENT WITH IRAQ.cohen thinks, and thinks the bushies will eventually conclude that hussein was effectively de-fanged and contained and that military removal was more trouble than it was worth. bush says he thought so too, pre-9/11. IT IS NOT CLEAR BUT CERTAINLY IMPLIED THAT COHEN DID IN FACT MAKE IRAQ TOPIC A.

-two days after the cohen briefing, tenet briefs bush. the main world threats to the u.s. were 1-obl, 2-wmd, 3-china (long term and because of its size,economically). iraq "barely mentioned." (12) I WAS VERY SURPRISED TO SEE CHINA ON THIS LIST. I
HAVE LONG HAD A STRONG SENSE OF FOREBODING ABOUT CHINA AND THE "CHALLENGES" IT WILL POSE TO US IN THE FUTURE. THIS CONCERN COMES
INFREQUENTLY BECAUSE OF MORE IMMEDIATE PROBLEMS BUT IT'S FASCINATING THAT
IT WOULD BE #3 ON THE CIA'S LIST AT THIS TIME. I'D LOVE TO KNOW THE DETAILS OF
WHAT THE CIA THOUGHT.

-feb. 5, '01: "principals meeting" (bush not present) to discuss how to increase intel on iraq and wmd. discussed: 1-hussein winning p.r. war that sanctions were hurting people, powell wanted to tighten sanctions on certain more dangerous material. 2-u.n. had discovered and dismantled s.h.'s bio-chem wmd capability and found a "surprisingly advanced nuclear program." 3-even then, there had been "suspicious accounting for materials" and then s.h. kicked inspectors out in '98 (13)

-bush wanted more "robust" response to violations of no-fly zone than under clinton. (14) bush worried about what response would be if a pilot was shot down. THOUSANDS OF SORTIES HAD BEEN FLOWN AND NOT ONE PLANE HAD BEEN SHOT DOWN. bush wanted to know if there was a "big bang" scenario in place if that happened. (16)THIS IS IMPORTANT ONLY AS BUSH'S "I LIKE THAT" WAS TO RUMSFELD'S SUGGESTION THAT THE NEW ADMINISTRATION SHOULD BE "FORWARD LEANING" RATHER THAN "REFLEXIVE PULLBACK." IN THE CONTEXT OF EVENTS TO COME IT SHOWS A PLIANT PSYCHOLOGY IN PLACE.

-feb. 16, '01: major u.s./u.k. bombing raid because s.h. close to patching together a hard-to-hit fiber optics network (14)

-march 1: principals meeting chaired by powell who wanted to focus u.n. sanctions on weapons control, which is what he brought up in feb. 5 meeting. rumsfeld concerned about "dual use items." powell thought rumsfeld was loony in his concern. heated fight between powell and rumsfeld (15).

-timeframe unclear but woodward says that at the same time that this rift between the sec's was going on there was a similar one at the next level down. wolfowitz and armitage disagree about how much to trust chalabi and how and to what extent to help any opposition inside iraq. (20)

-between may 31 and july 26: four dep. sec. meetings re iraq. they recommend heavy reliance on iraqi opposition to pressure s.h. no recommendation for direct u.s. military involvement (21).

-woodwar says, apparently in this time frame, wolfie was "fierce advocate" for toppling s.h. because (these are my quotes of woodward, not his of wolfie), "it was necessary and it would be relatively easy" (21). wolfie believes u.s. could easily overrun southern iraq and seize oil fields and that would ignite opposition forces who would overthrow s.h. (22). powell thinks wolfie's nuts. CAN'T BLAME POWELL HERE. THIS IS BAY OF PIGS REDUX THINKING AND FROM A GUY WHO WAS A POLI. SCI. PROF. WOODWARD SAYS POWELL ROLLED HIS EYES AT HUGH SHELTON AND LATER ASKED HIM IF THERE WASN'T SOMETHING HE COULD DO "TO GET THESE GUYS BACK IN THE BOX."

BUT WASN'T WOLFIE MORE RIGHT THAN SAY, COHEN, WAS? TRUE WE GOT NO MILITARY HELP FROM THE OPPOSITION BUT WE DID END UP TAKING THE SOUTH AND THE OIL WELLS ALMOST UNMOLESTED. AND REGIME CHANGE WAS AFFECTED VERY QUICKLY. IF THAT'S ALL WOLFIE, AND ULTIMATELY THE ADMINISTRATION, WERE FOCUSING ON, IF THAT WAS THEIR DEFINITION OF SUCCESS THEN IT WAS EASY. I DON'T KNOW HOW MUCH THEY THOUGHT ABOUT POST-HUSSEIN-OUSTER IRAQ OR HOW MUCH THEY SHOULD HAVE.

THIS IS THE DIVIDE EVEN AMONG SOME CONSERVATIVES LIKE DAVID BROOKS, WHO NEVER EXPECTED A STUBBORN AND INCREASING AMOUNT OF GUERILLA ACTIVITY POST-REGIME CHANGE. NOBODY WANTS IT, I DIDN'T EXPECT IT EITHER, BUT WHAT DOES IT REALLY MATTER? THAT DEPENDS ON WHAT YOUR DEFINITION OF "MISSION ACCOMPLISHED" WAS. IF IT WAS REGIME CHANGE PERIOD, THEN YOU CAN PRETTY MUCH DECLARE VICTORY AND COME HOME, WHICH IS WHAT BUSH IS APPARENTLY GOING TO DO.

EVERYONE, BROOKS, LUGAR, MCCAIN, BELIEVE THE SITUATION IS TOO UNSTABLE FOR US TO JUST PULL OUT NOW BUT I THINK THEY WOULD BE SATISFIED IF THE "REBELLION" WERE SIMPLY QUASHED, THAT IS, IF WE JUST KILL A FEW MORE PEOPLE.

THAT WOULD BE MY VIEW. WE HAVE SOME RECALCITRANTS IN FALUJAH AND SOME OTHER PLACES. WE NEED TO WIPE THEM OUT AND MAKE SURE WE GET OTHERS ELSEWHERE SO THAT WHEN WE LEAVE WE DON'T GET A RADICALIZED ISLAMIC STATE BUT BEYOND THAT I DON'T THINK, AND I DON'T THINK THE HAWKS ABOVE THINK, THAT WE SHOULD "NATION BUILD." THE FUTURE OF IRAQ IS FOR THE IRAQIS TO DECIDE, WITHIN THE LIMITS OF OUR SAFETY CONCERNS.

THE ONE CONTRADICTION TO MY VIEW HERE OF WHAT BUSH AND THE HAWKS THINK IS WOLFIE'S "SHINING CITY ON A HILL" VISION FOR IRAQ.

-wolfie is relentless in pushing his view and powell is worried about the momentum he is creating. powell speaks to bush personally about not getting pushed into anything. bush says "i get it" (22). later on, woodward writes what everyone by now knows, that bush and powell never had a personal relationship, certainly not like bush and cheney had or even bush and rumsfeld had. OBVIOUSLY, THIS WOULD PLAY A SIGNIFICANT ROLE AS BUSH DECIDED WHOSE JUDGMENT TO RELY ON. woodward says there was always a little bit of competition with, and resentment of, powell that bush felt.

I REMEMBER READING SOMEWHERE THAT BUSH WOULD SOMETIMES MALICIOUSLY SAY TO POWELL SOMETHING LIKE, "WELL, IF IT'S NOT THE WORLD'S GREATEST HERO." BUSH IS SUCH A SMALL, INSECURE, LITTLE ASSHOLE.

-aug. '01: work on iraq stops because bush goes on vacation. deep divisions exist between state and defense (23)

-9/11: bush says it is the "pearl harbor of the 21st century." (24). in interviews with woodward two years after, bush explains thinking that after 9/11 s.h.'s capacity for harm became to him much more menacing, and containing him much less feasible (27). woodward writes, "worse for bush, tenet had explicitly warned him about the immediacy and seriousness of obl threat. focusing on domestic issues and a giant tax cut, bush had largely ignored the terrorism problem." "i didn't feel that sense off urgency...my blood was not nearly as boiling," woodward quotes bush as later describing how he felt. IT SEEMS CLEAR TO ME ALSO THAT BUSH'S SENSE OF BEING A FUCK-UP IN LIFE KICKED IN HERE. BUT HOW MUCH WOULD THIS SENSE OF HAVING SCREWED UP HAVE EFFECTED SOMEONE ELSE, SAY CLINTON, OR EVEN POWELL IF EITHER HAD BEEN PRESIDENT? AFGHANISTAN WOULD CERTAINLY HAVE BEEN ATTACKED BY ANYONE. WOULD IRAQ? I DON'T THINK SO UNDER CLINTON OR POWELL, BUT OWING MUCH LESS, I.M.O., TO BUSH'S SENSE OF HAVING FAILED AND HAVING TO PROVE HIMSELF, THAN TO THE EFFECT THAT CHENEY, AND TO A LESSER EXTENT, RUMSFELD, HAD ON HIM. IT SEEMS TO ME CHENEY'S INFLUENCE ALONE WOULD ULTIMATELY HAVE BEEN DECISIVE. AND RUMSFELD'S ADDED TO THE WEIGHT.

-on 9/11 itself, rumself raises the possibility of going after iraq in response. THIS IS CRITICAL. "hit s.h. at same time--not only ubl," are an aide's notes of rumsfeld's suggestion. rumsfeld asks "pentagon lawyer" to talk to wolfie about iraq "connection withe obl." (25) THE WHEELS ARE IN MOTION BIG-TIME NOW.

-sept. 12: at war cabinet meeting rumsfeld asks if 9/11 didn't present an "opportunity" to hit iraq (25)

***to be continued***


-benjamin harris


Thursday, April 22, 2004

a friend has just nominated me for people magazine's list of the "twenty most eligible bachelors who are prosecutors."

PROFILE

name: benjamin harris

personal:

-forty-nine year old
-twice divorce (but one annuled so it doesn't count)
-father of two
-murder cases only, especially cold cases.

interests:

-women's fashion
-wild boar hunting
-art
-starting civilizational war.

accomplishments:

-made legal history by getting reversed for racial discrimination in jury selection.
-stopped by ski patrol for skiing too fast.
-kicked out of personal therapy for being "too difficult."

goals:

-flying a plane into that big square thing in mecca.

quotes:

-"blowjobs are like croissants, i'm not sure i've ever had a good one." (made to ex-wife numero dos)
-"if you were my wife i'd want one too," in replay to therapist's statement, "if i were your wife, i'd want a seperation."

Sunday, April 18, 2004

can i write in ariel sharon for president of the u.s.? a most contradictory man, he has nonetheless done exactly the right things to move the israeli-palestinian conflict off stalemate. i'm referring to the security wall in the west bank, his announced intention to pull out of gaza and to remove 7,500 jewish settlers but most of all his courage and strength to do what has been necessary all along: assasinate palestinian terrorist leaders.

last month it was the founder and philosophical--"spiritual" is an inapposite term for such a minister of hate--leader of hamas, sheik ahmed yassin. yesterday the exhilirating news that israeli helicopters had fired hellfire missiles at the vehicle carrying yassin's successor, dr. abdel aziz rantisi and ended the non-practicising pediatrician's days of delivering jewish babies to their graves.

yassir arafat must have a tick about now and some hamas advisor suggested it might be appropriate under these circumstances to keep secret whomever hamas chooses as it's next leader.

i picture a hamas council meeting solemnly conveyed to choose a new leader, and worthy after worthy declining the position with shermanesque finality. what if they held an election and noone ran?


-benjamin harris

Saturday, April 17, 2004

Mum and Dad: Part One

Mum and Dad: PART ONE

as dad told it, he first realized that mum was the one for him when, as part of a church or school group, he was invited to her 6 year birthday party.

because of the number of kids there and time constraints he had to leave without getting the chance to give mum her present in person.

he recalled telling a friend disconsonately "tell joan it's from michael."

mum first realized dad was for her when, in their late teens, they ran into each other at "twilight", one of the huge dance halls that dotted rural america in the 30's and 40's and which brought big-time entertainers like benny goodman and a young frank sinatra to the hinterland.

as mum told it, when dad walked in, with his full head of pomaded black hair and dressed in an all-white suit, that was it. years later they could laugh at that all-white suit but magic occurs in strange forms and that night it wore vestments of white.

mum kept the suit preserved until the day she died, which occurred on my father's birthday.

as far as we could tell, it wasn't long after "twilight" that that they eloped to laurel maryland and were married.

i say "as far as we could tell" because we never knew their anniversary date. it wasn't talked about and wasn't celebrated as a family event. we always suspected that that was because if you "did the math," mike III's birth would fall damningly short of the 9-month mark.

mum had strong opinions and didn't recoil from rendering judgments but one subject that she was noticeably soft-hearted on was grils who had "premature" births.

mum had her contentious moments with all of us, and especially with mikeIII and mary jane but of all the harsh words she ever spoke to and about them, not a discouraging one was heard about mike having gotten mary jane pregnant out of wedlock.

"only the good girls get pregnant," she used to say, "the bad ones know to use protection." that was a little too facile, too pat, for mum's personality.

mum was a voracious reader. the quintessential image i have is of her sitting in a chair reading. she only had a high school education--and a one-room-schoolhouse-in-rural-pennsylvania one at that--but she had a very good vocabulary as a consequence of her reading and thus a medium for expressing her thoughts, which were those of an agile mind. it was at times a combustible combination.

i always thought that the abrupt, sometimes inexplicable losses of temper and of downright meanness that she exhibited were in significant measure due to that combustible combination, and the container--that of housewife from the 1930's-1980's in small town america--that it was forced to exist in, and occasionally to resist. i don't think mum was in any significant regard aware of this. her upsets seemed to puzzle her as much as they did the rest of us.

then too, she was smarter than dad so you had a confluence of conditions that led to frustration, questioning, uncertainty, fear, guilt, denial, anger, more guilt and sorrow. i think the wonder is not that she had the upsets that she did but that she didn't have more of them.

mum and i talked a lot. i don't know exactly to what extent she talked to me more, if at all, than with my brothers--i never really asked them about it--, but i honestly believe she opened up a little more with me than with the others, or even with dad on some subjects. at least she told me she did and on more than one occasion while i was a teenager, dad would tell me in exasperation "go talk to your mother," or "ben, you can talk to your mother, go talk to her." the subject matter of these i don't remember.

nowhere were mum's existential difficulties greater exhbited than in her relationship with her own mother, who we boys referred to as "gram."


-benjamin harris

Monday, April 12, 2004

i'm starting a new fashion trend--skinny ties, like in the '50's and 60's. not being able to buy any anywhere, even vintage stores, i'm taking the ties i have in to be tailored and narrowed.

-benjamin harris

Monday, April 05, 2004

Mum's Death

tim just called. mum died at about 6:30 today. today was also dad's birthday.

Monday, March 22, 2004

Mum Dying

the human death experience is so mystical.

my brother called this morning to tell me that mum had been going downhill noticeably in the last few days, very weak and complaining of pain underneath her rib cage. tim said he had had her taken by ambulance to the hospital.

my mother always talked with me about things, like her own doubts about god for example, not a popular opinion in the family. her own mother was very strict religiously. mum was closer to her father.

when i went up for her bladder cancer surgery last year i was sitting by her bed in the hospital. it was just the two of us and she told me that for many years she had had a dream where she was on the edge of a field waist-high in weeds, and her father, who died in 1959 was at the far end of the same field. she told me that in her dream her dad said, "c'mon, honey. c'mon, dear," and beckoned with his hands. she was frightened in her dream and said "no, daddy i can't." she said her father turned away "with the saddest look on his face." she told me she knew that if she had made contact with her father that she would die; he would have taken her with him. "so i know when it's my time, my dad will come for me, benjamin."

tim just called me again. they took an x-ray or ultrasound or something and mum's cancer has spread to her liver and it won't be long. we talked for awhile and at one point he said, "ben, you know what mum said to me this morning when she woke up? she said 'tim, you know my dad was here last night." tim asked what she meant and mum said "he came last night and was in the bed beside me."



-benjamin harris

Wednesday, March 03, 2004

"because it's there," said george mallory, explaining why he wanted to climb everest. never a completely satisfying answer for me. i would gladly risk (or would like to THINK i would gladly risk) my life to save another, kill another, find intelligent life on mars or television, for some "higher" purpose in other words. but "because it's there?" that's it?

just read an article on climbing k2 which is the world's most difficult and deadliest mountain. as the subtitle of the article put it, "(everest is for sissies)."

"[members of an unsuccessful 1939 group] were the first...to die on k2. jordan [one of the author's fellow mountaineers] found some of wolfe's equipment--including a mitten with his name on it--plus 30 of his ribs and vertebrae."

upon finding a piece of purple cloth, jordan wondered who would wear such a thing, "a woman, it must be a piece of cloting worn by alison hargreaves," a gifted 33-year old brit who "was blown right off the summit ridge."

"we resumed walking passing sundry bits of gear...until we reached the arm of a wool shirt. the skin was like burned leather, dark brown, but not black. he hadn't been in the ice for long, because he still had his hands and his feet. well...a foot."

O-KAYYY..."because it's there," huh? have these people nothing better to do? i've always been struck by how these "brave exemplars of the human quest are the idle rich, like hillary and the "gifted" hargreaves.

i actually know someone who has climbed "sissie" everest. i remember him telling how it would take them an hour to transverse two vertical feet, at the end of which time he would be soaked through his clothing with perspiration.

claude fit the mold, an andover grad and schemer from rhode island who fled a bankrupt bentley dealership but not before creatively hiding a stash of loot and high-tailing it to florida and its generous homestead exemption, which has for seventy years attracted such as al capone and o.j. simpson and other judgment-proof a-type personalities. i doubt that any youngstown steelworker has ever climbed everest or k2.

effort is all to me. among other things, it's what makes me loathe the republican "work ethic" of being born on third base and holding yourself out as someone who has just hit a triple. i, and all democrats, are philosophical heirs of ben franklin who actually coined the phrase, "no gains without pain."

and we endure pain for the flimmsiest of gains. al of us who lift weights do so for no other reason than vanity. any other reason is pure pap. if you plopped old ben down in a modern american city, perhaps the most flummoxing sight--more so than cars and jets and cell phones--would be a gold's gym.

all of that i admit. but this extreme mountaineering stuff just seems to me the ultimate indulgence of a civilization, or the upper crust of such, whose raison d'etre is perverse.

i can't help but think that there's something a little similar between these westerners who have nothing to do and too much time to do it in and who choose to endanger their lives, and those mutant young saudi men, whose only way of gaining fulfillment was to fly a plane into a building, immolating themselves and others. it's the nihilist's disregard for human life.


-benjamin harris

Thursday, February 19, 2004

One of the Greatest Human Beings Who Ever Lived


"Anybody here seen my old friend Martin..." God bless you Dr. King

Sunday, February 15, 2004

TRUE CRIME STORIES: Pepe

True Crime Stories: Pepe

former judge "pepe" rivera comes to my office to review my file on a murder case he's just been retained on.

i give him copies of the police reports, the witness statements, the autopsy protocol.

"jeezus, i hope i don't ever die in dade county," he mutters, skimming over the protocol.

"why, pepe?"

"because i don't want to be described in an autopsy report as an overweight, middle-aged hispanic male with unremarkable genitalia."


-benjamin harris

Sunday, February 01, 2004

True Crime Stories: Lester

TRUE CRIME STORIES: Lester

when i was in organized crime/public corruption i inherited an investigation of the head of one of the rehabilitation programs who we had gotten intel on was using program credit cards for expenditures--such as vacations and jewelry--that did not, on their face, appear to be directly connected to the aims of reducing recidivism.

every probe by law enforcement, no matter how preliminary and exploratory, was magnified in effect on the fragile constitution of the program head as a whisper is transformed into a shout by one of those science funhouse contraptions.

blithely ignorant of all this i immediately issued a subpoena for some documents on lester himself. the subpoena was served on a sunday morning just as lester was greeting the new day.

monday morning i got a call from his attorney, former judge tom johnson.

"ben, lester called me on sunday, said you served a subpoena on him."

"yeah tom, i did."

"jeezus ben, lester's shittin' so much he can't touch his asshole with a powder puff."

(over my laughter) "there's a knock on his door on a nice sunday morning, he answers the door in his bathrobe and some guy serves him with a subpoena. i think he spent the rest of the day in the bathroom."


-benjamin harris

Tuesday, January 20, 2004

MORE IOWA

what is the saying, "it's always darkest before the dawn?" at near dawn today, i got awake and turned on the radio and did a fist pump at the result. dean even finished a DISTANT third. he got killed! you know, the polls definitely were on the scent of a "sea change" but they were as wrong as they notoriously have been in iowa. it was nowhere near a 4-2ay tie.

i was talking to my right-wing brother don yesterday and he was beating the "go dean!" drum. he actually said he liked kerry a lot. kerry is a great candidate and i think edwards would be too. how about that as a ticket?

dean is definitely hurt but he's got too much money to be out of it yet. his speech was emotionally weird. i think he'll stay in it to the end no matter what the results and who knows? maybe he'll run as a third-party candidate and immolate the party.


-benjamin harris
IOWA

this could hardly be a better result. dean is seriously wounded. tim russert said his out-of-control post-election speech could be a defining moment, like muskie crying in the snow outside the manchester union-leader's office.


-benjamin harris

Monday, December 29, 2003

TRUE CRIME STORIES: Shit

TRUE CRIME STORIES: Shit

your chances of making an arrest in a new murder case fall off drastically after the first 24 hours.

that's why, in mdpd, when your team's up for the next homicide and one comes in, you work around the clock that first day. there's a frisson to the work with everyone aware that the cosmological clock is ticking on them. breaks in the work are few, fewer for some than others.

the homicide prosecutor's job description at such scenes is to consult and advise the detectives on any legal issues that come up, to take the long view toward trial when they might take the more immediate view.

i was on homicide duty one week and got called out to a scene at some guy's house. i forget the context. the body was in the living room.

i was standing next to the lead detective, a big, intense, florid-faced cop who i'd known for years. he was taking notes feverishly. a few streams of perspiration ran down his cheeks.

the most horrid smell wafted to my nostrils. homicide scenes are not for the easily offended of sights and smells but this was unusual. it wasn't decomposition, it wasn't anything i could associate with the crime.

"what the fuck's that smell?", i said to jim.

"i just took a shit in my pants," he said, not raising his pen or eyes from his notepad.

"are you kidding me?"

now he looked at me. "i had to take a shit but we're busy."


-benjamin harris

Sunday, December 14, 2003

the capture of saddam hussein needn't mean it's over for the democrats. it IS over, because howard dean will be the nominee but imagine if lieberman or edwards or even kerry would be? the democrats would be innoculated against attacks that they are soft on foreign policy and would have been free to hammer bush on economics.

imagine if the nominee were clinton. he would do the next best thing. "the war's over. bush wants to live in the past. don't stop thinkin' about tomorrow. it's the economy stupid."

but no, we get dean. "let's refight the war politically. i was/am/always will be against it. DOES EVERYBODY HEAR ME? I WANT EVERYONE TO HEAR THAT. but i'm in favor of us staying there. to finish the job. getting hussein doesn't mean the job's finished. i don't know what 'the job's finished' means. i'll let you know. what i do know is that bush doesn't understand foreign policy. i do. i had to negotiate sensitive maple syrup tariff issues with the canadians. tough negotiators, those canadians."


-benjamin harris

Saturday, November 29, 2003

Coffin's Corner

COFFIN'S CORNER

william sloane coffin, the great divine of the 1960s, was the subject of a little new yorker article this week.

the occasion was proximity to the divine's 79th birthday and, owing to a bum ticker, his own proximity to the GREAT BEYOND. ominously, coffin spoke, according to the interviewer, "with flies buzzing around him."

the divine's guidance was sought on the war with iraq. he allowed as how he was against it. having dispatched that subject, he expounded on the weltanschauung that informs his opinions.

unlike the floppers who see good and evil in simplistic terms like good and evil, the divine has a more nuanced view owing to the nuance and subtlety of his own mind which is of course the hallmark of end-state intellectual evolution, to wit:

"nothing is more dangerous than misunderstanding evil. evil has an irremediable stubbornness about it. and it must be recognized, it has to be constrained, but it can never be resolved."

"an honorable pacifism recognizes that the mystery of evil is beyond its solution."

this is subtle. this is complex. this is The Great Insight.

the intellectual architechtonus being laid, the divine then concatenated historical events with a manner of creativity hitherto unknown among those who concatenate events for a living:

"poor old woodrow wilson said 'we're ending world war I, we're making the world safe for democracy.' as a result we opened all kinds of doors to every kind of dictator, from ataturk all the way to salazar, and in between franco, mussolini, hitler and stalin."

with this last, the interviewer, ben mcgrath, noted that even the coffins dog, a dalmatian, "sat quietly nearly seeming almost to listen." at such perspicacity even the beasts of the earth are stilled.

black fles buzzing ("it's sunday. i guess i'm getting worked up"), the divine expanded on the theme of american responsibility for "ataturk, salazar, franco, mussolini, hitler and stalin":

"and that's what's so pernicious, so dangerous, about bush [to end the suspense, coffin's for howard dean]. that he just doesn't understand the stubbornness of evil, and he just doesn't understand american complicity."

coffin's own axis of evil, mcgrath recorded for posterity, comprised "environmental degradation, pandemic poverty, and a world awash in weapons."(at this point it was observed that there were two lap dogs in the room, interviewer mcgrath having descended to all four fours, chin resting on the divine's chair seat).

rev. coffin is a quote-monger, a veritable walking bartleby's, who keeps binders full of pith. in the course of this short interview he managed to squeeze in references to wilson, moses, hamlet, oliver wendell holmes, the new testament, and this one from st. augustine: "yea, my pride-swollen face has closed up my eyes."

ungenerous readers of rev. coffin's views, those disrespectful of their elders, those not of as nuanced an intellect may have been reminded of another quote:

"fetch here the stocks, ho!
you stubborn ancient knave, you reverend braggart
we'll teach you."
-lear

-benjamin harris

Sunday, November 23, 2003

the attacks by islam on the west, in iraq continuously and ever bolder, in saudi arabia, spectacularly twice in turkey, are harbingers. whether we "degraded" al qaeda with our post-9/11 riposte or whether they were just lying low and in the r&d phase of the next round, the signs are ominous that a new attack on america, in america, is coming, and it's imminent.

-benjamin harris

Wednesday, November 19, 2003

Freddy Adu to Play for United

FREDDY ADU TO PLAY FOR UNITED

D.C. united, that is, not manchester united. quite a coup for major league soccer. the best young player in the world will make his debut next spring at rfk stadium and will appear on letterman tonight.

mls is unlike the four major team sports leagues. it is a "single entity owner" structure, much more centrally controlled than the franchise structure in the nfl, mlb, nba and nhl. only other league to attempt the single owner concept was abe saperstein's old american basketball league.

the benefits are classical economic economies of scale in purchasing and licensing but also makes the league, theoretically, better able to deal with dislocations and unfairness caused by a george steinbrenner or a donald trump who single-handedly destroyed the united states football league. players sign a contract with the league, not with the individual teams, and are assigned to one of the teams, which also helps competitive balance.

mls has never been able to break through the american sports public's conscious, not even close, not even close to the extent that the old north american soccer league did. adu could change all that. the u.s. is such a personality/celebrity driven culture that a player with real star power could allow the "beautiful game" to poke through. pele did it for nasl. d.c. has always been one of the league's glamour franchises. teaming adu with the incomparable ray hudson is a marketing dream.

the signing gives credibility to mls on two other fronts. first, since its inception, the league has had to loan or sell some of its best players abroad for much needed cash. that made it look like--because it was to some extent--a minor league masquerading as a first-division league. making the financial committment to adu (no details announced), and outbidding man-u and other european teams reverses that image.

second, just keeping home grown talent at home is all soccer will have to do to succeed here. there is a huge soccer public in the u.s. not a potentially huge, an actually huge. manchester united sold out everywhere it played in the u.s. this year. the cosmos drew 77,000 to matches at giants stadium. the tampa bay rowdies and ft. lauderdale strikers drew very well.

what america will not pay to see is second-rate anything. the american world cup team has proven it can compete with the best in the world, and was supported as such. more freddy adus peppered throught the ten mls teams will result in a very attractive product on the field, sorry, pitch.

so congratulations to mls. adu and american soccer could be the start of a beautiful relationship.

-benjamin harris

Saturday, November 15, 2003

the philadelphia inquirer reported on wednesday that a secret cia report has warned that the continued guerrila attacks on coalition forces in iraq are convincing the iraqi populace that america can be defeated there and that more and more iraqis are supporting the insurgents.

after "the end of major combat operations" in may a couple of soldiers per week were being killed; that was inevitable. but over the last few months the attacks have been obviously well-coordinated and more deadly. the attack on the palestine hotel when paul wolfowitz was staying there was a brilliant public relations coup to show the world that hussein loyalists had not been vanquished and in fact were able to attack at will what one would have assumed to have been an impregnable target. the look of anger, fear, and embarrassment on wolfowitz' face at his press conference afterwards was a bit humorous and said it all.

this week 26 italian soldiers were killed in the deadliest single attack yet.

in the face of all this the administration has announced that it is going to accelerate the timetable for turning over control of the country to civilian authorities.

so secretive is this administration, so isolated is this president, so deceiving have they been with what they know and what they're thinking that it amounts to little more than guess work to imagine what they're up to.

the cia report has the ring of truth. psychology is an important weapon in war. it is what kept the north vietnamese and viet cong going against the pounding of the b-52s.

the north koreans were being defeated and were demoralized at their prospects going up against the military that had just won world war II, until the chinese came to their aid. their whole psychology changed and they became a coherent, successful fighting force. you can never let your enemy think that he has a chance of success.

what SHOULD be done in iraq is clear: more troops, many more, should be deployed and there should be massive, ruthless application of force (1) to find and kill saddam hussein and the remaining 15 jokers in the pentagon's deck of cards and (2) to communicate to the islamic masses in the only language they understand that every man, woman and child will be slaughtered by the greatest military force in world history if they violently resist the coalition.

so what is the administration up to? as with any large organization where several major actors are involved in decision-making, there certainly is not any one explanation. there are a number of cross-currents effecting our response to events.

to go back to before the beginning of time, in 1998 i believe it was, paul wolfowitz, donald rumsfeld and others signed a full-page ad in major newspapers calling for the use of military force to oust saddam hussein. at papa bush's urging, that team was installed in the pentagon and that philosophy dominates input from there.

rumsfeld came to the pentagon after one prior stint. in an interview once he said that any new defense secretary is floored by the dog-and-pony show the military can put on for him to demonstrate their extraordinary capability, to engender awe and encourage deference. he related an anecdote from 1975 where the secretary of navy came into his office with a video showing how a u.s. sub had so artfully evaded soviet defenses that it slipped undetected into a russian military harbor and took a video of the port through it's periscope.

rumsfeld said he soon learned not to be cowed by such spectacles and to adopt an independent and appropriately skeptical view of military intelligence.

rumsfeld is the most radical, creative secdef the united states has ever had. he came to his second act with an agenda to transform, modernize and streamline what he saw as a huge, bloated, entropic organization. those efforts have been applauded in this space.

the showpiece for rumsfeld's new military was of course the iraq war. he proved what previously had been thought disproved in vietnam and elsewhere, that a war--or the "major combat operations" portion of it-- could be won with air power and a minimum of ground forces.

what is hard to understand is the memo he wrote that the war "could" still be won but that we were in for a "long, tough slog." the language and the tone certainly suggest that there is something he's not telling us about the capability of the enemy but even with the increased boldness of the guerrila attacks they are nothing more than pop-gun actions against the 135,000 troops we now have there much less the number we should have there. these attacks, even if they went on ad infinitum, would not defeat the coalition.

perhaps he was talking about the apparent failure of wolfowitz' "shining city on a hill" vision for the arab world but the memo did not seem to be talking about that. it seemed to be a purely military view.

whatever, it says here that the administration will not commit more troops for two reasons. one is rumsfeld's influence. if he had to admit that more ground forces were needed it would look like (although it wouldn't be) a refutation of his high-tech war strategy.

the second reason is purely political. polls show that most americans support the decision to have invaded iraq. they believe that that operation was a success. if significant numbers of new troops were deployed it would put the lie to bush's aircraft carrier pronouncement and open the subject for debate again, thus giving howard dean, bush's probable opponent, more ammunition where at present dean is preaching to a choir that only exists to the left of the pulpit.

besides rumsfeld a second major actor, and as maureen dowd wrote this week, perhaps the most important, is vice president dick cheney. i don't believe that cheney was a signator to that '98 policy statement on iraq but from all reports he has a very dark, that is to say accurate, view of the world america finds itself in and consequently a very hawkish foreign policy view. he meets daily with the president, is considered, because of his age and health, to be an honest broker without any personal agenda and because he is loyal and discreet almost nothing is known of exactly what it is he tells the president in their daily sessions.

what is known from his public statements makes cheney a reinforcer of rumowitz' hawkish views and as seymour hersh has written extensively, both relied heavily on the "intelligence" they were getting from the secret basement-dwelling group of spooks rumsfeld installed in the pentagon to find evidence of iraq's attempts to acquire nuclear weapons even where none existed.

because the president is unabashadly uninformed about what is being reported in the press and because of his previous lack of foreign policy experience, he relies extremely heavily on the information he gets from this remarkably narrow group of advisors. the result, in one instance, was the inclusion of laughably--and as hersh has written, possibly deliberately and mischievously planted as a dark practical joke--wrong information on the nigerian yellow cake matter. this information was fed to bush and he insouciantly included it in his state of the union address.

thus the president exercises no skeptical detachment over the information he is given, as rumsfeld said he learned to do after his first stint at the pentagon.

it could be that the fallout from yellow-cake and the continued irritation of the iraqi guerrila activity is giving the president pause in his reliance on the pentagon. the recent announcement that condelleza rice would be put in charge of the post-iraqi planning group was obviously taken by rumsfeld to be a snub. perhaps this will also bring secretary of state powell into a position of greater influence in the president's policy direction. all of this would mean greater hope for a wrong-headed moderation in u.s. foreign policy and the greater involvement of our western allies and the u.n.

from the time rumsfeld took over as defense secretary, his irascible personality, the hatred of him that exists in and outside the pentagon among career officers, and the president's aversion to conflict among his advisors, led many to believe that he would be the first of bush's cabinet secretaries to go. that talk faded with the adulation he received after the iraqi war was "won" so quickly but now it is back again.

the "other" major actor of course is the president. who knows for sure what effect all of this has had on him, if he has grown disenchanted with rumsfeld, how, if at all, frustrated he is with the iraqi situation. he was a tabula rosa in foreign affairs when he came to office. it was always the suspicion here that he was far more likely to go along with a recommendation to invade iraq because of saddam hussein's attempt to assasinate his father. would we have invaded another deserving islamic nation, like syria?

we know that bush is a man of confidence in his convictions. by all accounts he never wavered on the correctness of the course he set on iraq. he was sure and determined. like many conservatives, he seems to see the world in black and white. he is deeply religious. his attorney general is as manicheanistic a man as has ever held the position. does the president really believe in his heart that "the war is not with islam" as he said after 911? apparently so. after a recent demonstration he was heard to say to an aide "do they really think we think all muslims are bad?"

what about rumowitz, do they see this conflict in civilizational terms? peter boyer's article in this week's new yorker on general wesley clark quotes clark as saying that he was told by a three-star general that after 911 the pentagon's civilian leaders "devised a five-year plan to topple the regimes in iraq, syria, lebanon, libya, somalia, iran, and sudan." best plan i've heard so far but i don't trust clark on this, it seems highly unlikely that such a plan could be hatched without anyone finding out about it besides some disgruntled three-star and where the hell is the evidence for it? this space was all broke out with excitement when it looked like the administration might be rattling their sabres in syria's direction in the spring but that petered out.

could the bushies be biding their time? right now, the president looks to be a good bet to be reelected, the economy seems to be getting on track and criticism of the war doesn't seem to have much traction with joe in peoria. why rock the boat? once a second term is secured might we see an expanded conflict?

predictions are irresistible but there is so much uncertainty here, so much secretiveness. oh well. the guess here is that we will muddle through in iraq in 2004 without committing any more troops, there will be a major push, as appears to have been begun, to get saddam hussein, which will be a major public relations coup and a not insignificant accomplishment, then a similar concerted effort to find osama bin laden. bush will be reelected and we will continue to fight the war on terrorism piecemeal. rumsfeld will be replaced in the second term, maybe by condi rice, and the other terror crescent countries will be safe for "four more years."


-benjamin harris



some wag once said of antonio vivaldi that he did not compose 400 pieces of music, he composed one piece of music 400 times, so distinctive and similar was his repertoire.

the same could be said of frank gehry's late architecture. they're all beginning to look like bilbao and son of bilbao.

there's no gainsaying the significance of the original. it is the first post-modern building, one of the most important in the entire 20th century. and it is dramaticus maximus. when i first saw a--small--picture of it in the new yorker my jaw must have dropped. there had never been a building like it, with it's billowing, windowless titanium skin and it's raucous shapes.

that first picture i saw was a view of the "petals" but i didn't see horticulture. i saw a nuclear explosion captured by a still camera, an unfolding of a violent awe-inspiring drama, and in the metallic color of those atomic bomb detonations captured a split second after detonaton. in that way too it seemed to me the perfect emblem of this particular fin de siecle. gehry conveyed movement, quite a feat in the design of a building.

i bought a couple of coffee table books on gehry after that and was disappointed to see so much of bilbao in places other than bilbao, in toledo (ohio), cleveland (ohio), minneapolis, and dusseldorf. bilbao had not been a creation that sprung full-blown like athena from the head of zeus. this was the culmination of a process. at least it seemed a culmination.

detestable los angeles has finally gotten around to honoring it's native son by scraping together enough jingle to complete the interminably-delayed walt disney concert hall. what a deflating experience.

paul goldberger of the new yorker sniffs at the unimpressed. disney "is more refined that that of the guggenheim, and more sumptious..." "gehry has not repeated himself here so much as he has expanded his architectural vocabulary." those who see disney as epigonic "are missing an architectural experience of immense power and subtlety."

i'm with those unrefined philistines who see a constricted vocabulary and want to shout, "the bilbao mold--lose it!"

-benjamin harris

Wednesday, November 05, 2003

anything that presents an obstacle to howard dean getting the democratic nomination for president is ok with me but the confederate flag flap is a sign of the democratic distemper not of the vermont sap's unelectability.

let's consider the different ways in which this issue does not apply to dean:

-dean believes the union was the right side to be on in the civil war.
-dean does not have a confederate flag sticker on the back of his pick up truck.
-dean does not even have a pick up truck (i'd bet)
-dean is not a racist (except in the sense that all elitists, of which he is one, are racists). all the other candidates who spoke on the issue last night conceded that.
-dean does not support policies that would harm or are insensitive to minority rights.
-dean does not have some "southern strategy" where he is going to subtly appeal to southern racists.

so where's the beef? are you john edwards telling me you didn't have, or would have disavowed if you had, ONE pickup truck driving supporter who had a confederate flag on the back of said truck? in NORTH CAROLINA?

and al sharpton? AL FRIGGIN' SHARPTON. HE is a racist. one of the greatest outrages by a public figure in the last thirty years was his libel, on new york city radio, of a state prosecutor who he accused of being involved in the non-existent rape of tawana brawley.

this is what passes for legitimate discourse in the democratic party these days. a major candidate, the presumptive nominee, gets raked because he recognizes that one of the party's big problems is that it only has 22% of white male voters AND HE WANTS TO APPEAL TO THEM ON ECONOMIC ISSUES! he wants them to get past race and see the democratic party as standing up for his economic interests. and that is topic A on his opponents agenda? pathetic. just pathetic.

howard dean is a symptom of what is wrong with the democratic party, but not on this issue. it is just the reverse. it is the "reverse racism" of those like al sharpton and the pandering to the loony left of john edwards, who this page expected better from, that is the larger problem with the democratic party.

-benjamin harris.