
Saturday, December 08, 2007
China's Great Wall of Silence: The Struggle for History. Photo #1

Sunday, December 02, 2007
Sports
"To encourage knowledge of affairs at home and abroad; to cure the spirit of lying which prevails
amongst us; to record memorable providences."-Statement of purpose, Public Occurrences, September 25, 1690
The college football regular season in the U.S.A. ended last night. It has been the most unpredictable season in history. Seven different teams who were ranked #2 in the country have lost during the course of the season, five of them to completely un-ranked teams. Last night both the number-one and number-two teams
played their season-ending games. Had they won they would have played against each other after the new year for the national championship.
Both lost.
Missouri, the number-one team, lost to Oklahoma, a highly-ranked team in its own right. Number-two West
Virginia however lost to the University of Pittsburgh, an un-ranked team with a losing record, over whom
West Virginia was a twenty eight and one-half point favorite. To make the result even more surprising the
game was played on West Virginia's campus. "Home" teams in American college football have a decided
advantage. Most surprising is that Pittsburgh is West Virginia's most- despised rival, thus seeming to negate
the common concern that a superior team might overlook an inferior opponent. Finally, this was exactly the 100th game between the two schools.
None of this mattered. Pittsburgh won the game 13-9.
The game has been described in historic terms by American sports writers. To lose to one's bitterest rival, at home, in the final game of the season, when playing for a chance at a national championship, while being favored by twenty eight and one-half points is indeed historic.
At its best sports presents the human condition in the starkest of terms. West Virginia's coach sorrowfully described the game as a "nightmare." We have all had those. We are all West Virginians. But for Pittsburgh's fans, and for underdog fans everywhere, the result was a miraculous joy. We are all Pittsburghers.
We have not had occasion to document memorable providences in the five-plus years that we have been publishing this electronic continuation of Public Occurrences but Pittsburgh's victory was not just historic, it was providential, that is miraculous, and so, true to our ancient mission we hereby record it. This is Public Occurrences.
Thursday, November 22, 2007
The IQ war: Here we go again
If that is true, there is no "and therefore..." to that result. That is, governments are not going to revive anti-
miscegenation laws or the like. There is no public policy consequence to that finding, if it is true. There is also no "private policy" consequence. Individuals should not be presumed to share their groups racial average.
The reason why there is no "and therefore..." is that intelligence does not equal goodness, nor even wisdom,
and both of those traits are far more important to the human condition than intelligence and there are no genetic tests for them. This is Public Occurrences.
Feel free to email us at Publocc@gmail.com
This is Public Occurrences
date in our history, the memories of which some of us still
have.
Tuesday, November 20, 2007
Stem Cell Breakthrough
resolved an ethical dilemma that had threatened the use of
stem cells to solve a host of medical conditions.
Published in Cell and Science, two of the most prestigious
journals in the world, the scientists reported that they had
been able to change common skin cells into embryonic stem
cells by adding four genes, thus avoiding the ethical dilemma
of having to destroy human embryos to harvest the stem cells.
Immediate reaction has been uniformly positive across the
political spectrum. "Everyone was waiting for this day to
come" was the reaction of Rev. Tadeusz Pacholczyk of the
National Catholic Bioethics Center, courtesy of the
Associated Press from The New York Times. "It really is
amazing," and "ethically uncomplicated" were the reactions
of two leading medical authorities at Harvard, according to
AP and NYT.
So, on this eve of Thanksgiving Eve, let us give thanks. This is
Public Occurrences.
Monday, November 12, 2007
This is Public Occurrences
almost constantly at work on China so I was able to work as
hard today as I ever have.
..............................
Before going to bed, very early, last night I resolved to rise
early and go right into work. I wrote "work" on four business
cards. I put one in my cell phone so that when I opened it I
would see the note. I put one on top of the computer keyboard,
one in the bathroom sink, one in the doorjamb. I wanted to
give myself no room for getting into a non-work frame of mind.
I arose and didn't want to go into work. Not dread, just no fire.
But the alternative would be like yesterday, a lot of reading, not
the energy to write, then boredom and at five o'clock drink. I
didn't want that again.
When I turned on the computer I had an email from a person
in China who had sent me some useful information. It gave me
the fire and adderral-fired too, I worked on China for about
forty-five minutes. Then I got tired and had to rest. I read for
two hours, after taking another half of an adderral.
For twenty-two years I had a fire in me that allowed me to
work prodigiously. Then, after a trial, my recovery time was
longer than I was used to and I went to my G.P. and the result
was the Zodiac.
I have never been able to get the fire back continuously since
that trial. In my mind I had not been able to get it back because
of the treatment but the doctors told me repeatedly that it was
not the treatment. So then it was the onset of the Zodiac that I
blamed. The doctors said it couldn't be that either.
My girlfriend told me that she did not see the absence of the
fire except on those occasions when I would have to sleep all
day. Upon thinking about it she opined that the cause was my
dusky mutt brought home by my son. I completely discounted
that. Then relations with my son improved and he was happier
and I was happier and the dog went away. But I have still not
gotten the fire back completely. My girlfriend says I have but I
don't feel it.
It's probably age plus the drink plus the sleeping pills plus no
physical activity plus work plus China. I cut out drink for a
month but felt no increase in fire. A couple of weekends ago I
read all day both days and on Monday morning was too tired to
go to work. So I've tried to cut down on the reading and have
not written anything serious for awhile. Writing has always
been taxing, as taxing as work.
If I had my old fire I could work and read with no problem and
even write a little. A friend of mine is a scholar and I am
impressed and envious when I get an email that he's sent at
midnight or one a.m. I am Benjamin Harris
Sunday, November 04, 2007
China's Great Wall of Silence: Song Binbin Returns to the Scene of the Crime

Anyone with information on the identities of those involved in the beating of Bian Zhongyun on June 23, 1966, August 4,1966 or August 5, 1966 please email Benjamin Harris, J.D. at PUBLOCC@gmail.com
Friday, November 02, 2007
This is Public Occurrences
that thy right worship is defiance."
Herman Melville, Moby Dick.
Sunday, October 28, 2007
YEAH!
make a very good living. Her mother and I are about in
the lowest 1% income of families with children attending
the school.
Today Dianna went Yachting with her school friend
Natalie and Natalie's folks.
I know yachts. I've seen them. At the boat show once I was
even on one briefly.
Natalie also invited Dianna to go skiing with her family at
Vail over the Christmas break.
They own a house there.
Dianna's mom called the Stuarts and profusely thanked
them and, of course, offered to pay for Dianna's air fair.
I mean, come on, that's just courtesy.
Mr. Stuart is completely unaffected by his wealth. With
no condescension he informed Dianna's mom that that
would be unnecessary seeing that he had a private jet.
When Dianna came back from Yachting her mom said to
her, "Dianna, they take you Yachting, then they offer to
take you to Vail ON A PRIVATE JET?!" "Yeah mom, and
I told them that my dad, after he charges a lot on his credit
card, gets a FREE TICKET ON SOUTHWEST AIRLINES!"
Friday, October 26, 2007
On the Genarlow Wilson case
immediate release of Genarlow Wilson from state prison,
holding that Wilson's ten year mandatory sentence
violated the U.S. constitution's bar on "cruel and unusual
punishment."
Wilson was convicted of an underage sex crime, having oral
sex with a 15 year old girl. Wilson was 17 at the time. The sex
act was consensual. Wilson spend two years in prison for this.
The Georgia Supreme Court was right. What is wrong is laws
like this. Georgia's legislature has since changed its law (but
did not make it retroactive) but there are other similar laws
on the books in many states, and not just in "backward" or
southern states. In a case in Miami a 14 year old girl was
dating and having sex with her 17 year old boyfriend. The
girl's parents found out about it and forbade her from
seeing the boy again. They grounded her and wouldn't let
her leave her room. The girl crawled out the window one
night to be with and have sex with her boyfriend. The boy
was arrested for a felony. That law is still on Florida's
books.
Besides changes in the law (Georgia reduced the crime
from a felony to a misdemeanor) what is needed at least
as much is greater discretion and common sense on the
part of police officers and prosecutors. Each has discretion
in enforcing the law. The police do not have to arrest some-
one even when a crime has been committed and many,
many times don't. More importantly, prosecutors do not
have to file cases, and many, many, many times don't. The
prosecutor's job, his only job is to seek justice.
Cowed legislators respond to public pressure by enacting
draconian laws, cowed police officers make arrests they'd
probably just as soon not, and cowed prosecutors file cases
with too little concern for justice. What is needed is more
courage and less cowing. This is Public Occurrences.
Saturday, October 20, 2007
On Dr. James Watson
There are so many issues raised by Dr. James Watson's recent
(and more recently retracted) remarks that people of African
descent are genetically less intelligent than others. In rough
order of importance:
(1) The pain and humiliation that the remarks caused to black
people. If it were true that black people were genetically less
intelligent than others no public policy would be changed as a
result. For example, governments would not forbid racial
intermarriage to reduce the number of intellectually-
challenged children, employers would not stop hiring
black people, etc. Nothing would change. So the only result of
proof that black people were genetically less intelligent would
be the pain and humiliation that it causes black people. That is
bad.
(2) It is particularly bad that these statements were made by a
Nobel laureate. If I made them or some other non-scientist had
made them they would be dismissed as unimportant racist
ramblings. When a Nobel laureate, and one who won the prize
in the relevant field of biology, makes them, they are
devastating because they assume the imprimatur of expertise.
(3) Intelligence, either in individuals or in races, is not the most
important quality in human beings. Goodness is. No one argues
that one race is superior or inferior to the others in morality.
My race and Dr. Watson's race, Caucasians, have produced in
just the last century the most murderous behavior that the
world with all of its races, has ever known. This was at a time
when the fruits of our supposedly superior intellect--science
and technology--was at its most advanced. I get angry and
defensive when I read others, such as Jared Diamond, claim
that Caucasians are less intelligent than other races. As I have
written here before I am proud to be white, male, living in the
northern and western hemispheres, and American. But I am
not proud of what my race did in the 20th century.
(4) Although I know not what public policy it informs, research
into and discussion of inherent racial differences should not be
suppressed. As a non-scientist I don't know if Dr. Watson's
initial claims are true. I read and I've never read of any
credible scientific reports that substantiate his initial claims.
If I'm wrong I would like to see the studies widely published
and discussed by the experts. If I'm right, and as Dr. Watson
has said in subsequent comments, that there is no such
evidence then his initial statements are both mean-spirited
as well as unintelligent. And I would like to see research into
racial differences in goodness as well. I don't know why
intelligence get so much attention.
(5) I do share Dr. Watson's bleak view of Africa. As has been
written here before, "It is hard to stay positive" when a head
of state believes he can cure AIDS by reading the Koran,
sprinkling magic water and chanting over victims. That was
just one example recently in the news. High officials in or
formerly a part of the government of South Africa have made
similar, floridly ignorant comments about AIDS. And then
there's Robert Mugabe. However, I don't think it's Robert
Mugabe's race that has made him such a tyrant any more than
I think it's race that made Hitler, Stalin and Mao such tyrants.
(6) I mean this sincerely and not meanly, does Dr. Watson
suffer from any mental problem, such as Alzheimer's? He is
aged and his initial statements seem to me so ridiculous and
his retraction so immediate and categorical that I wondered
if he didn't suffer from some mental impairment, although I
have read that he has made similar statements in the past.
Perhaps he's just a mean man.
I am Benjamin Harris
Sunday, October 14, 2007
China's Great Wall of Silence: A Letter to Congressman David Wu
As the first and only Chinese-American in Congress, and as a lawyer, you are uniquely positioned to be receptive to this request for assistance in the investigation into the murder of Bian Zhongyun.
Bian was beaten to death on August 5, 1966 by her Red Guard students at the privileged Girls School Attached to Beijing Normal University. She was the first educator to be murdered by students in the Cultural Revolution. All of her attackers were girls.
The historical significance of Bian's murder was made complete on August 18, 1966 when Song Binbin, the leader of the Red Guards at Bian's school, was given the honor of pinning a Red Guard armband onto Mao Zedong. The photograph of that moment is one of the most famous of the twentieth century. The occasion was the first rally of Red Guards in Tianenmen Square. Over a million were in attendance.
Bian's murder has ever since been a subject of interest to many. Two films, Though I am Gone, by Hu Jie, and the pseudo-documentary Morning Sun, by Red Guard sympathizer Carma Hinton, have been produced in the last few years. The latter was partially funded by your and my tax dollars through the National Endowment for the Humanities.
Although some courageous people, such as Hu Jie and Dr. Youqin Wang of the University of Chicago, have kept the memory of Bian's murder alive, only one of the perpetrators has been named, Liu Tingting, daughter of the then President of China, Liu Shaoqi. Ms. Liu was one of those who beat Bian on August 5 but there were others, three or four, who committed most of the violence and they have never been named.
It's not for lack of witnesses that those responsible have not been identified. The beating was a public spectacle carried out in front of the student body in broad daylight. The beating lasted for hours. In similar public circumstances Bian was also beaten on June 23 and August 4. After the former beating Bian made a futile written appeal to the Beijing municipal authorities.
Liu Tingting, Song Binbin and a host of other former Red Guards subsequently immigrated to the United States and started new lives. Liu Tingting is now a wealthy, jet-setting business consultant with a residence on Central Park. Song, the most infamous of the Red Guards, changed her name to Yan Song once in the U.S., got her PhD from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, worked for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and had homes in Lexington and Concord, the birthplaces of the American Revolution. Others, such as Weili Ye, are comfortably ensconsed in academia. None have even been questioned about their actions during the murderous period of the Cultural Revolution that resulted in an estimated 3,000,000 killed.
With the above as background these are the specific issues that I am asking for your assistance on:
(1) How did Song Binbin and Liu Tingting get into this country? I would respectfully request that you provide me with their immigration forms in order to determine if either made any false or misleading statements there on.
(2) How could the National Endowment for the Humanities fund Morning Sun? What vetting of content occurred or didn't occur that led to N.E.H.'s approval for funding? I would respectfully ask that you provide me with Ms. Hinton's application and any internal N.E.H.documents that informed their decision.
Congressman, your website says that you will not respond to email from folks outside of your C.D., that all other correspondence must be in writing, so I will send this to you in letter form.
Finally, I just ask that you not send me a form letter in response. If you do not wish to assist no response is necessary.
Sincerely,
Benjamin Harris, J.D.
Thursday, October 11, 2007
Plato/Aristotle v Homer/Nietzsche
Aristotle in his head."
-Herman Melville, Moby Dick.
Wednesday, October 10, 2007
True Crime Stories

I casually mentioned to the judge that he didn't have a poker
face, that I could usually tell how he was going to rule by his
facial expression. When I first told him about that he was
astonished. I was astonished that he was astonished,
sometimes he'd screw up his face like he was having a
hemorrhoid attack when a lawyer was making an argument.
Then we started getting into it: I'd say, "Judge, I can see by
the expression on your face...," or he'd catch himself and say
"Mr. Harris, what am I thinking now?" One time I was begging
for a trial postponement and he said, "Read my face." I looked
up and he was giving me the finger with both hands.
Sunday, October 07, 2007
China's Great Wall of Silence: Carma Hinton's New Film!

The Shocking story of the REAL Red Guard
Girls.
Murder! Looting! Burning!
Entertainment fun for the whole family.
With the ORIGINAL CAST from the hit farce
Morning Sun.
See Song Binbin as you've never seen her
before, with her face exposed!
Also starring Liu Tinting, Deng Rong and Weili
Ye.
Special appearance by Mao Zedong!
Coming soon to a theater near you.
ISLAM HAS BLOODY BORDERS bumper stickers
bumper stickers, ONLY $1.99 + S&H. Contact us at Publocc@gmail.com
Green and red on white field.
This is the most famous sentence from Samuel
Second, it is thought-stimulating. People
Third, it is a statement of fact. Islam
Fourth, it establishes where you
Display this bumper sticker on your car
WE MUST NEVER HATE!
This is Public Occurrences.
---------------------------------
Bumper Stickers Now Being
Displayed By Opinion-
Leaders in:
-Florida
-Michigan
-Minnesota
-Alberta, Canada
-New York
-Pennsylvania
-New Jersey
-New York
-British Columbia, Canada
-Michigan
-Florida
-Texas
-Virginia
-Illinois
The message is being heard worldwide also.
Often Wrong, Always Certain
Sunday, September 30, 2007
This is Public Occurrences
profound beings, such as Plato, Pyrrho, the Devil, Jupiter,
Dante, and so on, there always goes up a certain semi-visible
steam, while in the act of thinking deep thoughts."
-Herman Melville, Moby Dick.
Friday, September 28, 2007
China's Great Wall of Silence: The Murder of Bian Zhongyun
http://youtube.com/watch?v=aDeUA52hngQ
Link posted at http://ht251.blogspot.com/search?q=song+binbin
Thursday, September 27, 2007
Wednesday, September 26, 2007
Homer yea! Plato and progeny nay!
that way; but now, on the other side, hoist in Kant's and you
come back again; but in very poor plight. Thus, some minds for
ever keep trimming boat. Oh, ye foolish! throw all these
thunder-heads overboard, and then you will float light and
right."
-Herman Melville, Moby Dick.
Plato. Aristotle. Descartes. Locke. Kant. They produced
Rationalism which produced World War I which killed
Rationalism.
Tuesday, September 25, 2007
Cursed Plato
death of an Ohio honey-hunter, who seeking honey in the
crotch of a hollow tree, found such exceeding store of it, that
leaning too far over, it sucked him in, so that he died
embalmed. How many, think ye, have likewise fallen into
Plao's honey head, and sweetly perished there?"
-Herman Melville, Moby Dick
Monday, September 24, 2007
Melville,Kuhn, Kierkegaard, Wittgenstein, Rorty.
...
"Let faith oust fact; let fancy oust memory; I look deep down and do believe."
...
"Science! Curse thee, thou vain toy..."
Sunday, September 02, 2007
This is Public Occurrences
Friday, August 31, 2007
This is Public Occurrences
Flavius Vegetius Renatus, Roman general.
