Saturday, February 08, 2014
Dylan Farrow Rejoins.
The prosecutrix always gets the last word. From the Hollywood Reporter. I think that's where Kristof is going to be working next:
"Once again, Woody Allen is attacking me and my family in an effort to discredit and silence me--but nothing he says or writes can change the truth. For 20 years, I have never wavered in describing what he did to me. I will carry the memories of surviving these experiences for the rest of my life. His op-ed is the latest rehash of the same legalese, distortions, and outright lies he has leveled at me for the past 20 years. He insists my mother brought criminal charges--in fact, it was a pediatrician who reported the incident to the police based on my firsthand account. He suggests that no one complained of his misconduct prior to his assault on me--court documents show that he was in treatment for what his own therapist described as 'inappropriate' behavior with me from as early as 1991. He offers a carefully worded claim that he passed a lie detector test--in fact, he refused to take the test administered by the state police (he hired someone to administer his own test, which authorities refused to accept as evidence). These and other misrepresentations have been rebutted in more detail by independent, highly respected journalists, including this most recent article here: http://www.vanityfair.com/online/daily/2014/02/woody-allen-sex-abuse-10-facts.
With all the attempts to misrepresent the facts, it is important to be reminded of the truth contained in court documents from the only final ruling in this case, by the New York Supreme Court in 1992. In denying my father all access to me, that court:
-Debunked the 'experts' my father claims exonerated him, calling them 'colored by their loyalty to Mr. Allen', criticizing the author of their report (who never met me) for destroying all supporting documentation, and calling their conclusions 'sanitized and therefore less credible'.
-Included testimony from babysitters who witnessed inappropriate sexual behavior by my father toward me.
-Found that 'there is no credible evidence to support Mr. Allen's contention that Ms. Farrow coached Dylan or that Ms. Farrow acted upon a desire for revenge against him for seducing Soon-Yi. Mr. Allen's resort to the stereotypical 'woman scorned' defense is an injudicious attempt to divert attention from his failure to act as a responsible parent and adult.'
-Concluded that the evidence '...proves that Mr. Allen's behavior toward Dylan was grossly inappropriate and that measures must be taken to protect her.'
Finally, the Connecticut State prosecutor found 'probable cause' to prosecute, but made the decision not to in an effort to protect 'the child victim', given my fragile state.
From the bottom of my heart, I will be forever grateful for the outpouring of support I have received from survivors and countless others. If speaking out about my experience can help others stand up to their tormentors, it will be worth the pain and suffering my father continues to inflict on my. Woody Allen has an arsenal of lawyers and publicists but the one thing he does not have on his side is the truth. I hope this is the end of his vicious attacks and of the media campaign by his lawyers and publicists, as he's promised. I won't let the truth be buried and I won't be silenced."
"Once again, Woody Allen is attacking me and my family in an effort to discredit and silence me--but nothing he says or writes can change the truth. For 20 years, I have never wavered in describing what he did to me. I will carry the memories of surviving these experiences for the rest of my life. His op-ed is the latest rehash of the same legalese, distortions, and outright lies he has leveled at me for the past 20 years. He insists my mother brought criminal charges--in fact, it was a pediatrician who reported the incident to the police based on my firsthand account. He suggests that no one complained of his misconduct prior to his assault on me--court documents show that he was in treatment for what his own therapist described as 'inappropriate' behavior with me from as early as 1991. He offers a carefully worded claim that he passed a lie detector test--in fact, he refused to take the test administered by the state police (he hired someone to administer his own test, which authorities refused to accept as evidence). These and other misrepresentations have been rebutted in more detail by independent, highly respected journalists, including this most recent article here: http://www.vanityfair.com/online/daily/2014/02/woody-allen-sex-abuse-10-facts.
With all the attempts to misrepresent the facts, it is important to be reminded of the truth contained in court documents from the only final ruling in this case, by the New York Supreme Court in 1992. In denying my father all access to me, that court:
-Debunked the 'experts' my father claims exonerated him, calling them 'colored by their loyalty to Mr. Allen', criticizing the author of their report (who never met me) for destroying all supporting documentation, and calling their conclusions 'sanitized and therefore less credible'.
-Included testimony from babysitters who witnessed inappropriate sexual behavior by my father toward me.
-Found that 'there is no credible evidence to support Mr. Allen's contention that Ms. Farrow coached Dylan or that Ms. Farrow acted upon a desire for revenge against him for seducing Soon-Yi. Mr. Allen's resort to the stereotypical 'woman scorned' defense is an injudicious attempt to divert attention from his failure to act as a responsible parent and adult.'
-Concluded that the evidence '...proves that Mr. Allen's behavior toward Dylan was grossly inappropriate and that measures must be taken to protect her.'
Finally, the Connecticut State prosecutor found 'probable cause' to prosecute, but made the decision not to in an effort to protect 'the child victim', given my fragile state.
From the bottom of my heart, I will be forever grateful for the outpouring of support I have received from survivors and countless others. If speaking out about my experience can help others stand up to their tormentors, it will be worth the pain and suffering my father continues to inflict on my. Woody Allen has an arsenal of lawyers and publicists but the one thing he does not have on his side is the truth. I hope this is the end of his vicious attacks and of the media campaign by his lawyers and publicists, as he's promised. I won't let the truth be buried and I won't be silenced."
Woody Allen Responds.
As I pulled a muscle climbing up that light pole and a ladder rescue truck had to get me down...PDA Saturday is over. From the New York Times:
TWENTY-ONE years ago, when I first heard Mia Farrow had accused me of child molestation, I found the idea so ludicrous I didn’t give it a second thought. We were involved in a terribly acrimonious breakup, with great enmity between us and a custody battle slowly gathering energy. The self-serving transparency of her malevolence seemed so obvious I didn’t even hire a lawyer to defend myself. It was my show business attorney who told me she was bringing the accusation to the police and I would need a criminal lawyer.
I naïvely thought the accusation would be dismissed out of hand because of course, I hadn’t molested Dylan and any rational person would see the ploy for what it was. Common sense would prevail. After all, I was a 56-year-old man who had never before (or after) been accused of child molestation. I had been going out with Mia for 12 years and never in that time did she ever suggest to me anything resembling misconduct. Now, suddenly, when I had driven up to her house in Connecticut one afternoon to visit the kids for a few hours, when I would be on my raging adversary’s home turf, with half a dozen people present, when I was in the blissful early stages of a happy new relationship with the woman I’d go on to marry — that I would pick this moment in time to embark on a career as a child molester should seem to the most skeptical mind highly unlikely. The sheer illogic of such a crazy scenario seemed to me dispositive.
Notwithstanding, Mia insisted that I had abused Dylan and took her immediately to a doctor to be examined. Dylan told the doctor she had not been molested. Mia then took Dylan out for ice cream, and when she came back with her the child had changed her story. The police began their investigation; a possible indictment hung in the balance. I very willingly took a lie-detector test and of course passed because I had nothing to hide. I asked Mia to take one and she wouldn’t. Last week a woman named Stacey Nelkin, whom I had dated many years ago, came forward to the press to tell them that when Mia and I first had our custody battle 21 years ago, Mia had wanted her to testify that she had been underage when I was dating her, despite the fact this was untrue. Stacey refused. I include this anecdote so we all know what kind of character we are dealing with here. One can imagine in learning this why she wouldn’t take a lie-detector test.
Meanwhile the Connecticut police turned for help to a special investigative unit they relied on in such cases, the Child Sexual Abuse Clinic of the Yale-New Haven Hospital. This group of impartial, experienced men and women whom the district attorney looked to for guidance as to whether to prosecute, spent months doing a meticulous investigation, interviewing everyone concerned, and checking every piece of evidence. Finally they wrote their conclusion which I quote here: “It is our expert opinion that Dylan was not sexually abused by Mr. Allen. Further, we believe that Dylan’s statements on videotape and her statements to us during our evaluation do not refer to actual events that occurred to her on August 4th, 1992... In developing our opinion we considered three hypotheses to explain Dylan’s statements. First, that Dylan’s statements were true and that Mr. Allen had sexually abused her; second, that Dylan’s statements were not true but were made up by an emotionally vulnerable child who was caught up in a disturbed family and who was responding to the stresses in the family; and third, that Dylan was coached or influenced by her mother, Ms. Farrow. While we can conclude that Dylan was not sexually abused, we can not be definite about whether the second formulation by itself or the third formulation by itself is true. We believe that it is more likely that a combination of these two formulations best explains Dylan’s allegations of sexual abuse.”
Could it be any clearer? Mr. Allen did not abuse Dylan; most likely a vulnerable, stressed-out 7-year-old was coached by Mia Farrow. This conclusion disappointed a number of people. The district attorney was champing at the bit to prosecute a celebrity case, and Justice Elliott Wilk, the custody judge, wrote a very irresponsible opinion saying when it came to the molestation, “we will probably never know what occurred.”
But we did know because it had been determined and there was no equivocation about the fact that no abuse had taken place. Justice Wilk was quite rough on me and never approved of my relationship with Soon-Yi, Mia’s adopted daughter, who was then in her early 20s. He thought of me as an older man exploiting a much younger woman, which outraged Mia as improper despite the fact she had dated a much older Frank Sinatra when she was 19. In fairness to Justice Wilk, the public felt the same dismay over Soon-Yi and myself, but despite what it looked like our feelings were authentic and we’ve been happily married for 16 years with two great kids, both adopted. (Incidentally, coming on the heels of the media circus and false accusations, Soon-Yi and I were extra carefully scrutinized by both the adoption agency and adoption courts, and everyone blessed our adoptions.)
Mia took custody of the children and we went our separate ways.
I was heartbroken. Moses was angry with me. Ronan I didn’t know well because Mia would never let me get close to him from the moment he was born and Dylan, whom I adored and was very close to and about whom Mia called my sister in a rage and said, “He took my daughter, now I’ll take his.” I never saw her again nor was I able to speak with her no matter how hard I tried. I still loved her deeply, and felt guilty that by falling in love with Soon-Yi I had put her in the position of being used as a pawn for revenge. Soon-Yi and I made countless attempts to see Dylan but Mia blocked them all, spitefully knowing how much we both loved her but totally indifferent to the pain and damage she was causing the little girl merely to appease her own vindictiveness.
Here I quote Moses Farrow, 14 at the time: “My mother drummed it into me to hate my father for tearing apart the family and sexually molesting my sister.” Moses is now 36 years old and a family therapist by profession. “Of course Woody did not molest my sister,” he said. “She loved him and looked forward to seeing him when he would visit. She never hid from him until our mother succeeded in creating the atmosphere of fear and hate towards him.” Dylan was 7, Ronan 4, and this was, according to Moses, the steady narrative year after year.
I pause here for a quick word on the Ronan situation. Is he my son or, as Mia suggests, Frank Sinatra’s? Granted, he looks a lot like Frank with the blue eyes and facial features, but if so what does this say? That all during the custody hearing Mia lied under oath and falsely represented Ronan as our son? Even if he is not Frank’s, the possibility she raises that he could be, indicates she was secretly intimate with him during our years. Not to mention all the money I paid for child support. Was I supporting Frank’s son? Again, I want to call attention to the integrity and honesty of a person who conducts her life like that.
NOW it’s 21 years later and Dylan has come forward with the accusations that the Yale experts investigated and found false. Plus a few little added creative flourishes that seem to have magically appeared during our 21-year estrangement.
Not that I doubt Dylan hasn’t come to believe she’s been molested, but if from the age of 7 a vulnerable child is taught by a strong mother to hate her father because he is a monster who abused her, is it so inconceivable that after many years of this indoctrination the image of me Mia wanted to establish had taken root? Is it any wonder the experts at Yale had picked up the maternal coaching aspect 21 years ago? Even the venue where the fabricated molestation was supposed to have taken place was poorly chosen but interesting. Mia chose the attic of her country house, a place she should have realized I’d never go to because it is a tiny, cramped, enclosed spot where one can hardly stand up and I’m a major claustrophobe. The one or two times she asked me to come in there to look at something, I did, but quickly had to run out. Undoubtedly the attic idea came to her from the Dory Previn song, “With My Daddy in the Attic.” It was on the same record as the song Dory Previn had written about Mia’s betraying their friendship by insidiously stealing her husband, André, “Beware of Young Girls.” One must ask, did Dylan even write the letter or was it at least guided by her mother? Does the letter really benefit Dylan or does it simply advance her mother’s shabby agenda? That is to hurt me with a smear. There is even a lame attempt to do professional damage by trying to involve movie stars, which smells a lot more like Mia than Dylan.
After all, if speaking out was really a necessity for Dylan, she had already spoken out months earlier in Vanity Fair. Here I quote Moses Farrow again: “Knowing that my mother often used us as pawns, I cannot trust anything that is said or written from anyone in the family.” Finally, does Mia herself really even believe I molested her daughter? Common sense must ask: Would a mother who thought her 7-year-old daughter was sexually abused by a molester (a pretty horrific crime), give consent for a film clip of her to be used to honor the molester at the Golden Globes?
Of course, I did not molest Dylan. I loved her and hope one day she will grasp how she has been cheated out of having a loving father and exploited by a mother more interested in her own festering anger than her daughter’s well-being. Being taught to hate your father and made to believe he molested you has already taken a psychological toll on this lovely young woman, and Soon-Yi and I are both hoping that one day she will understand who has really made her a victim and reconnect with us, as Moses has, in a loving, productive way. No one wants to discourage abuse victims from speaking out, but one must bear in mind that sometimes there are people who are falsely accused and that is also a terribly destructive thing. (This piece will be my final word on this entire matter and no one will be responding on my behalf to any further comments on it by any party. Enough people have been hurt.)
TWENTY-ONE years ago, when I first heard Mia Farrow had accused me of child molestation, I found the idea so ludicrous I didn’t give it a second thought. We were involved in a terribly acrimonious breakup, with great enmity between us and a custody battle slowly gathering energy. The self-serving transparency of her malevolence seemed so obvious I didn’t even hire a lawyer to defend myself. It was my show business attorney who told me she was bringing the accusation to the police and I would need a criminal lawyer.
I naïvely thought the accusation would be dismissed out of hand because of course, I hadn’t molested Dylan and any rational person would see the ploy for what it was. Common sense would prevail. After all, I was a 56-year-old man who had never before (or after) been accused of child molestation. I had been going out with Mia for 12 years and never in that time did she ever suggest to me anything resembling misconduct. Now, suddenly, when I had driven up to her house in Connecticut one afternoon to visit the kids for a few hours, when I would be on my raging adversary’s home turf, with half a dozen people present, when I was in the blissful early stages of a happy new relationship with the woman I’d go on to marry — that I would pick this moment in time to embark on a career as a child molester should seem to the most skeptical mind highly unlikely. The sheer illogic of such a crazy scenario seemed to me dispositive.
Notwithstanding, Mia insisted that I had abused Dylan and took her immediately to a doctor to be examined. Dylan told the doctor she had not been molested. Mia then took Dylan out for ice cream, and when she came back with her the child had changed her story. The police began their investigation; a possible indictment hung in the balance. I very willingly took a lie-detector test and of course passed because I had nothing to hide. I asked Mia to take one and she wouldn’t. Last week a woman named Stacey Nelkin, whom I had dated many years ago, came forward to the press to tell them that when Mia and I first had our custody battle 21 years ago, Mia had wanted her to testify that she had been underage when I was dating her, despite the fact this was untrue. Stacey refused. I include this anecdote so we all know what kind of character we are dealing with here. One can imagine in learning this why she wouldn’t take a lie-detector test.
Meanwhile the Connecticut police turned for help to a special investigative unit they relied on in such cases, the Child Sexual Abuse Clinic of the Yale-New Haven Hospital. This group of impartial, experienced men and women whom the district attorney looked to for guidance as to whether to prosecute, spent months doing a meticulous investigation, interviewing everyone concerned, and checking every piece of evidence. Finally they wrote their conclusion which I quote here: “It is our expert opinion that Dylan was not sexually abused by Mr. Allen. Further, we believe that Dylan’s statements on videotape and her statements to us during our evaluation do not refer to actual events that occurred to her on August 4th, 1992... In developing our opinion we considered three hypotheses to explain Dylan’s statements. First, that Dylan’s statements were true and that Mr. Allen had sexually abused her; second, that Dylan’s statements were not true but were made up by an emotionally vulnerable child who was caught up in a disturbed family and who was responding to the stresses in the family; and third, that Dylan was coached or influenced by her mother, Ms. Farrow. While we can conclude that Dylan was not sexually abused, we can not be definite about whether the second formulation by itself or the third formulation by itself is true. We believe that it is more likely that a combination of these two formulations best explains Dylan’s allegations of sexual abuse.”
Could it be any clearer? Mr. Allen did not abuse Dylan; most likely a vulnerable, stressed-out 7-year-old was coached by Mia Farrow. This conclusion disappointed a number of people. The district attorney was champing at the bit to prosecute a celebrity case, and Justice Elliott Wilk, the custody judge, wrote a very irresponsible opinion saying when it came to the molestation, “we will probably never know what occurred.”
But we did know because it had been determined and there was no equivocation about the fact that no abuse had taken place. Justice Wilk was quite rough on me and never approved of my relationship with Soon-Yi, Mia’s adopted daughter, who was then in her early 20s. He thought of me as an older man exploiting a much younger woman, which outraged Mia as improper despite the fact she had dated a much older Frank Sinatra when she was 19. In fairness to Justice Wilk, the public felt the same dismay over Soon-Yi and myself, but despite what it looked like our feelings were authentic and we’ve been happily married for 16 years with two great kids, both adopted. (Incidentally, coming on the heels of the media circus and false accusations, Soon-Yi and I were extra carefully scrutinized by both the adoption agency and adoption courts, and everyone blessed our adoptions.)
Mia took custody of the children and we went our separate ways.
I was heartbroken. Moses was angry with me. Ronan I didn’t know well because Mia would never let me get close to him from the moment he was born and Dylan, whom I adored and was very close to and about whom Mia called my sister in a rage and said, “He took my daughter, now I’ll take his.” I never saw her again nor was I able to speak with her no matter how hard I tried. I still loved her deeply, and felt guilty that by falling in love with Soon-Yi I had put her in the position of being used as a pawn for revenge. Soon-Yi and I made countless attempts to see Dylan but Mia blocked them all, spitefully knowing how much we both loved her but totally indifferent to the pain and damage she was causing the little girl merely to appease her own vindictiveness.
Here I quote Moses Farrow, 14 at the time: “My mother drummed it into me to hate my father for tearing apart the family and sexually molesting my sister.” Moses is now 36 years old and a family therapist by profession. “Of course Woody did not molest my sister,” he said. “She loved him and looked forward to seeing him when he would visit. She never hid from him until our mother succeeded in creating the atmosphere of fear and hate towards him.” Dylan was 7, Ronan 4, and this was, according to Moses, the steady narrative year after year.
I pause here for a quick word on the Ronan situation. Is he my son or, as Mia suggests, Frank Sinatra’s? Granted, he looks a lot like Frank with the blue eyes and facial features, but if so what does this say? That all during the custody hearing Mia lied under oath and falsely represented Ronan as our son? Even if he is not Frank’s, the possibility she raises that he could be, indicates she was secretly intimate with him during our years. Not to mention all the money I paid for child support. Was I supporting Frank’s son? Again, I want to call attention to the integrity and honesty of a person who conducts her life like that.
NOW it’s 21 years later and Dylan has come forward with the accusations that the Yale experts investigated and found false. Plus a few little added creative flourishes that seem to have magically appeared during our 21-year estrangement.
Not that I doubt Dylan hasn’t come to believe she’s been molested, but if from the age of 7 a vulnerable child is taught by a strong mother to hate her father because he is a monster who abused her, is it so inconceivable that after many years of this indoctrination the image of me Mia wanted to establish had taken root? Is it any wonder the experts at Yale had picked up the maternal coaching aspect 21 years ago? Even the venue where the fabricated molestation was supposed to have taken place was poorly chosen but interesting. Mia chose the attic of her country house, a place she should have realized I’d never go to because it is a tiny, cramped, enclosed spot where one can hardly stand up and I’m a major claustrophobe. The one or two times she asked me to come in there to look at something, I did, but quickly had to run out. Undoubtedly the attic idea came to her from the Dory Previn song, “With My Daddy in the Attic.” It was on the same record as the song Dory Previn had written about Mia’s betraying their friendship by insidiously stealing her husband, André, “Beware of Young Girls.” One must ask, did Dylan even write the letter or was it at least guided by her mother? Does the letter really benefit Dylan or does it simply advance her mother’s shabby agenda? That is to hurt me with a smear. There is even a lame attempt to do professional damage by trying to involve movie stars, which smells a lot more like Mia than Dylan.
After all, if speaking out was really a necessity for Dylan, she had already spoken out months earlier in Vanity Fair. Here I quote Moses Farrow again: “Knowing that my mother often used us as pawns, I cannot trust anything that is said or written from anyone in the family.” Finally, does Mia herself really even believe I molested her daughter? Common sense must ask: Would a mother who thought her 7-year-old daughter was sexually abused by a molester (a pretty horrific crime), give consent for a film clip of her to be used to honor the molester at the Golden Globes?
Of course, I did not molest Dylan. I loved her and hope one day she will grasp how she has been cheated out of having a loving father and exploited by a mother more interested in her own festering anger than her daughter’s well-being. Being taught to hate your father and made to believe he molested you has already taken a psychological toll on this lovely young woman, and Soon-Yi and I are both hoping that one day she will understand who has really made her a victim and reconnect with us, as Moses has, in a loving, productive way. No one wants to discourage abuse victims from speaking out, but one must bear in mind that sometimes there are people who are falsely accused and that is also a terribly destructive thing. (This piece will be my final word on this entire matter and no one will be responding on my behalf to any further comments on it by any party. Enough people have been hurt.)
Friday, February 07, 2014
"Fuck the E.U.."-Victoria Nuland, U.S. Permanent Representative to NATO.
I could be a diplomat, I talk like that too! I will talk like that. Fuck Victoria Nuland, author of the Benghazi coverup talking points and fuck the U.S.!
Thursday, February 06, 2014
On Kris Dylwood and Song Binbin (really).
Hey didja hear? The New York Times may publish a rebuttal by Wood, according to "Questions" Sullivan.
I suggest an alternative to the dueling op-ed's: a truth and reconciliation (or non) proceeding at New York University. Yes! exactly as I suggested in Songie's case. No, I have not had "positive confirmation" that my idea that the Chinese people confront and question Binbin at Peking University has actually been, like, "adopted" or anything. That's okay. A "moot court" proceeding really would work in l'affaire Dylwood. No, it will never happen. That's okay.
Are Kris Dylwood Chinese? Are they unfamiliar with the concept of an "interview," of questions AND answers? Or do they just do statements, like Song. Dyl called me--all of us--out in her letter for paying to see Wood's movies and I am goddamn well going to continue answering her. She called out actors and actresses by name--Cate Blanchett, WD-40, Alec Baldwin. Dyl took a shot (with Kris' weapon); is that it? It shouldn't be. She has the obligation to answer questions, too. She said in her letter she is now strong enough to go public with her accusations against Wood and against all of us. Is she strong enough to answer questions? Maybe Wood will ask her some questions. Will you take questions from anybody, Dyl? Agree to be interviewed, say, on 60 Minutes? Best of all, would you appear at an NYU moot court? Or, are you only strong enough to fire shots while hiding behind Kris? Huh? I'm asking you.
I suggest an alternative to the dueling op-ed's: a truth and reconciliation (or non) proceeding at New York University. Yes! exactly as I suggested in Songie's case. No, I have not had "positive confirmation" that my idea that the Chinese people confront and question Binbin at Peking University has actually been, like, "adopted" or anything. That's okay. A "moot court" proceeding really would work in l'affaire Dylwood. No, it will never happen. That's okay.
Are Kris Dylwood Chinese? Are they unfamiliar with the concept of an "interview," of questions AND answers? Or do they just do statements, like Song. Dyl called me--all of us--out in her letter for paying to see Wood's movies and I am goddamn well going to continue answering her. She called out actors and actresses by name--Cate Blanchett, WD-40, Alec Baldwin. Dyl took a shot (with Kris' weapon); is that it? It shouldn't be. She has the obligation to answer questions, too. She said in her letter she is now strong enough to go public with her accusations against Wood and against all of us. Is she strong enough to answer questions? Maybe Wood will ask her some questions. Will you take questions from anybody, Dyl? Agree to be interviewed, say, on 60 Minutes? Best of all, would you appear at an NYU moot court? Or, are you only strong enough to fire shots while hiding behind Kris? Huh? I'm asking you.
Wednesday, February 05, 2014
On Kris Dylwood.
The topic here is standards. What standard do others apply in deciding whom to honor? The case of Jameis Winston immediately came to mind, a case well-known to many readers of the American persuasion. Nicholas D. Kristoff's characterization of Woody Allen as an "artistic giant" would reasonably be applied to Winston, whose art was practiced in the field, and on the field, in that branch of the entertainment industry known as "college tackle football." Like Allen, Winston was accused of a serious sex crime, rape. Winston's victim was young but not that young, not seven years old. She was college student age. As in Allen's case the District Attorney declined to prosecute. The D.A.'s decision in both cases freed the suspects to continue their artistic endeavors. And, like in Woody Allen's case, the "industry" had an honor to bestow on Winston. Which it did.
In the case of Jameis Winston there are two bodies whose standards we may compare and contrast with Kristof's and Hollywood's in the Allen case, first, Winston's university's standard, and second the standard of the honor-bestowing body. Florida State University's standard was no arrest, no prob, Winston could continue representing the university as their star player in the most visible and most lucrative college sport there is. The undersigned believes but does not know "for sure," that this standard was applied consistently by the university, i.e. to other athletes, male and female, football and field hockey, cash cow, and money-losing dreg. As with the standards used by Kristof and Hollywood, there are no "should's" here. Florida State was within its right to employ that standard. Is it a reasonable standard. In my opinion it is. Might we reasonably criticize it? We may. It does seem a little low; this is a publicly funded university. That is as far as the "character" issue extends at a public university? It is. Might there not be more character expected of a student on a free tuition ride at a public university in such a high-profile role as star of the tackle football team than not to get arrested for rape. For Godssake? Yep. But, that's the standard and they're stickin' to it. One more thing: Florida State's standard is to adopt someone else's standard, namely the standard of the police. Might we reasonably criticize a public university for not independently determining this matter rather than to punt ( pun intended, of course) that decision to the cops and breathlessly await the D.A.'s press conference? Yes. But...standard...stickin' to it.
What is the police standard to make an arrest? "Probable cause," more probable than not that the accused committed the crime. Now I must say, that is the goddamndest most reasonable standard I've heard yet. If it is probable that the accused committed the crime, he was OUTTA THERE! Winston would have had to pursue alternative artistic endeavors, perhaps in the field of medicine or nuclear physics, or pizza delivery, wherever his talents took him. So, thank you Florida State, thank you cops. You have shined light in the dark forest of Nicholas D. Kristof's cranium.
In the case of Jameis Winston there are two bodies whose standards we may compare and contrast with Kristof's and Hollywood's in the Allen case, first, Winston's university's standard, and second the standard of the honor-bestowing body. Florida State University's standard was no arrest, no prob, Winston could continue representing the university as their star player in the most visible and most lucrative college sport there is. The undersigned believes but does not know "for sure," that this standard was applied consistently by the university, i.e. to other athletes, male and female, football and field hockey, cash cow, and money-losing dreg. As with the standards used by Kristof and Hollywood, there are no "should's" here. Florida State was within its right to employ that standard. Is it a reasonable standard. In my opinion it is. Might we reasonably criticize it? We may. It does seem a little low; this is a publicly funded university. That is as far as the "character" issue extends at a public university? It is. Might there not be more character expected of a student on a free tuition ride at a public university in such a high-profile role as star of the tackle football team than not to get arrested for rape. For Godssake? Yep. But, that's the standard and they're stickin' to it. One more thing: Florida State's standard is to adopt someone else's standard, namely the standard of the police. Might we reasonably criticize a public university for not independently determining this matter rather than to punt ( pun intended, of course) that decision to the cops and breathlessly await the D.A.'s press conference? Yes. But...standard...stickin' to it.
What is the police standard to make an arrest? "Probable cause," more probable than not that the accused committed the crime. Now I must say, that is the goddamndest most reasonable standard I've heard yet. If it is probable that the accused committed the crime, he was OUTTA THERE! Winston would have had to pursue alternative artistic endeavors, perhaps in the field of medicine or nuclear physics, or pizza delivery, wherever his talents took him. So, thank you Florida State, thank you cops. You have shined light in the dark forest of Nicholas D. Kristof's cranium.
Tuesday, February 04, 2014
On Kris Dylwood.
Boy. Folks, I don't know what is wrong with me. I have not been thinking well on this subject. Taking posts down, putting them back up. I've concentrated on this sentence by Mr. Kristof in 2-3 posts now and I missed the most important part:
"When evidence is ambiguous, do we really need to leap to our feet and lionize an alleged molester."
The most important part of that sentence is "when evidence is ambiguous." Think of what that means for Kristof's "standard." If even when evidence is ambiguous, friendship or honors are withheld or the accused is boycotted or shunned, all things I dealt with in previous posts, then an impossible, an utterly impossible, standard is set for "unimpeachable honor." The evidence of dishonor should be unambiguous and unimpeachable. Kristof has taken leave of his senses. That is outrageous. It is an outrageous statement to make. There is something going on here with Kristof. He is too close to this--somehow, for some reason--to be writing crap like this. He has no perspective, he's writing claptrap.
And so am I. How did I miss that? I don't know, I don't know. Readers of this page can expect corrections in previous posts, maybe entire re-writes, I don't know. I'll read them all over tomorrow and see what else I've fucked up. And an apology now. I have thought hard and spent a lot of time writing on this subject and I've botched it. I apologize. I will report for a struggle session tomorrow.
"When evidence is ambiguous, do we really need to leap to our feet and lionize an alleged molester."
The most important part of that sentence is "when evidence is ambiguous." Think of what that means for Kristof's "standard." If even when evidence is ambiguous, friendship or honors are withheld or the accused is boycotted or shunned, all things I dealt with in previous posts, then an impossible, an utterly impossible, standard is set for "unimpeachable honor." The evidence of dishonor should be unambiguous and unimpeachable. Kristof has taken leave of his senses. That is outrageous. It is an outrageous statement to make. There is something going on here with Kristof. He is too close to this--somehow, for some reason--to be writing crap like this. He has no perspective, he's writing claptrap.
And so am I. How did I miss that? I don't know, I don't know. Readers of this page can expect corrections in previous posts, maybe entire re-writes, I don't know. I'll read them all over tomorrow and see what else I've fucked up. And an apology now. I have thought hard and spent a lot of time writing on this subject and I've botched it. I apologize. I will report for a struggle session tomorrow.
On Kris Dylwood.
This is a partial re-write of the original post.-Feb. 5, 10:13 pm.
I was in the middle of writing a post and googled "nicholas kristof dylan farrow" to get Kristof's column again when I saw and read Margaret Sullivan's article. This was the post.
"When evidence is ambiguous, do we really need to leap to our feet and lionize an alleged molester?"
What a question, what a standard! After 20 years, when evidence is ambiguous, Hollywood still should not have honored Woody Allen.
What other questions does Kris ask:
"Look, none of us can be certain what happened. The standard to send someone to prison is guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, but shouldn’t the standard to honor someone be that they are unimpeachably, well, honorable?"
I was in the middle of writing a post and googled "nicholas kristof dylan farrow" to get Kristof's column again when I saw and read Margaret Sullivan's article. This was the post.
"When evidence is ambiguous, do we really need to leap to our feet and lionize an alleged molester?"
What a question, what a standard! After 20 years, when evidence is ambiguous, Hollywood still should not have honored Woody Allen.
What other questions does Kris ask:
"Look, none of us can be certain what happened. The standard to send someone to prison is guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, but shouldn’t the standard to honor someone be that they are unimpeachably, well, honorable?"
That is a GREAT question. It is THE question (to me). We are at liberty to honor, merely to associate with, whomever we please. And whom not to. I, as a private employer, can hire or fire you for any reason or a good reason, just not a bad reason (race, etc.). I like your hair color, I can hire you for that reason. I don't like your hair color, I can fire you for that reason. I can befriend, or not; honor, or not, whomever I please. I can think of fewer better reasons not to hire, befriend, or honor a person than that he is a frigging child molester!
By what standard?
By what standard should...there are no "should's" here; I may decide not to honor you based on no evidence whatsoever that you are a child molester. I may look at you, conclude in my mind that you are a child molester, and decide not to honor you. By what standard do people decide to honor and not honor. Mr. Kristof's standard is that the evidence must be unambiguous that the person is "unimpeachably honorable." Indeed, with the understanding that there are no should's here we may say...I will say (I have said) that Kristof's standard for is unreasonable. But, if Kris is consistent in applying that standard across the board in his personal judgment-making there is nothing to fault him with. He would not have honored Woody Allen. Allen clearly does not meet the standard of being unimpeachably honorable, I mean, my God, forget the child molestation charge, it is unimpeachably true that Woody Allen took nude photos of, and had an affair with, Mia Farrow's daughter Soon-Yi Previn while he was in a long-term relationship with Ms. Farrow! Ooooh doggie. But, Kristof goes farther than this in his statement above. Kristof thinks Hollywood, or "we," should have employed Kristof's standard and not honored Allen.
Hollywood evidently had a different standard since they honored Allen. What was Hollywood's standard? Don't know except that it had a lot to do with Allen's talent, his accomplishments as a movie director. Those trumped any concerns they may have had with how honorable a man Allen was. It seems reasonable to me that the entertainment industry would give primacy to Allen the movie director over Allen the honorable man. Kristof himself characterizes Allen as an "artistic giant." This was not the Presidential Medal of Freedom after all, not the Nobel Peace Prize, not Humanitarian of the Year, not even Good Housekeeping's seal of approval. May we reasonably criticize Kristof's standard as applied to an honor within the field where he admits the candidate is a "giant?" It seems to me we may, and I do. May we reasonably criticize Hollywood for employing a standard by which artistic achievement so trumps "character" issues? I am not at this point... My God, man, are there not some moral standards for a Hollywood award?...Yes. It seems to me, understanding that there are no "should's," that we may criticize Hollywood if there is no, or unreasonably little, consideration given to character. How little? Let's start to answer that by looking at the standards used by some other people. I had one instantly come to mind, a case also in the entertainment industry. It is the case of Jameis Winston.
By what standard?
By what standard should...there are no "should's" here; I may decide not to honor you based on no evidence whatsoever that you are a child molester. I may look at you, conclude in my mind that you are a child molester, and decide not to honor you. By what standard do people decide to honor and not honor. Mr. Kristof's standard is that the evidence must be unambiguous that the person is "unimpeachably honorable." Indeed, with the understanding that there are no should's here we may say...I will say (I have said) that Kristof's standard for is unreasonable. But, if Kris is consistent in applying that standard across the board in his personal judgment-making there is nothing to fault him with. He would not have honored Woody Allen. Allen clearly does not meet the standard of being unimpeachably honorable, I mean, my God, forget the child molestation charge, it is unimpeachably true that Woody Allen took nude photos of, and had an affair with, Mia Farrow's daughter Soon-Yi Previn while he was in a long-term relationship with Ms. Farrow! Ooooh doggie. But, Kristof goes farther than this in his statement above. Kristof thinks Hollywood, or "we," should have employed Kristof's standard and not honored Allen.
Hollywood evidently had a different standard since they honored Allen. What was Hollywood's standard? Don't know except that it had a lot to do with Allen's talent, his accomplishments as a movie director. Those trumped any concerns they may have had with how honorable a man Allen was. It seems reasonable to me that the entertainment industry would give primacy to Allen the movie director over Allen the honorable man. Kristof himself characterizes Allen as an "artistic giant." This was not the Presidential Medal of Freedom after all, not the Nobel Peace Prize, not Humanitarian of the Year, not even Good Housekeeping's seal of approval. May we reasonably criticize Kristof's standard as applied to an honor within the field where he admits the candidate is a "giant?" It seems to me we may, and I do. May we reasonably criticize Hollywood for employing a standard by which artistic achievement so trumps "character" issues? I am not at this point... My God, man, are there not some moral standards for a Hollywood award?...Yes. It seems to me, understanding that there are no "should's," that we may criticize Hollywood if there is no, or unreasonably little, consideration given to character. How little? Let's start to answer that by looking at the standards used by some other people. I had one instantly come to mind, a case also in the entertainment industry. It is the case of Jameis Winston.
On Nicholas D. Kristof.
This is from Margaret Sullivan, the New York Times "Public Editor," sort of the paper's ombudsman, on Kristof's posting of Dylan Farrow's letter on his Times blog. I do wish people who wrote for the New York Times and even to the New York Times did more than pose questions. I wish they'd try answering, at least the questions they themselves pose. In the end, this is very disappointing, especially from Ms. Sullivan. What Kristof did seemed to me to be wrong but in a vague way that I still cannot quite put my finger on. Professor Rasmussen raises a number of concerns and all Ms. Sullivan, the ombudsman, can say is that she is "troubled by the same questions?" C'mon, man, that's a cop-out, what is the answer? Did Kristof do wrong and if so, how exactly? Sullivan does the same thing Kristof did. He just threw Dylan Farrow's letter out there, ostensibly for us to "reflect on." She just throws Rasmussen's email on Kristof's ethics out there. In both cases, the implication is clear: Woody Allen molested Dylan Farrow and Nicholas D. Kristof committed an ethical transgression. But neither Kristof nor Sullivan say so directly. God damn it, I hate when people do this stuff:
As I’ve been thinking about Nicholas Kristof’s Sunday column and the related blog post that have caused so much discussion and disagreement, a number of thoughtful emails from readers have arrived.
One, from Chris Rasmussen, an associate professor at Fairleigh Dickinson University, is particularly reasonable, intelligent and thought-provoking. He writes:
I have long been an admirer of Nicholas Kristof’s columns. I cannot say that I object to his column on Dylan Farrow and Woody Allen. But I write to ask about the propriety of publishing largely one-sided columns assailing a lone individual. The writers who are permitted to “columnize” for The Times have a tremendously influential platform, and I wonder whether they should use that platform to advocate on behalf of personal friends, as Mr. Kristof did yesterday. If Dylan Farrow wishes to publish an open letter about her allegations, there are ample forums in this internet age. Should The Times and Mr. Kristof lend their credibility to her argument against Woody Allen?I cannot possibly know what actually transpired between Woody Allen and Dylan Farrow — no one can. Initially, I was strongly inclined to accept her account of being sexually abused. But Robert B. Weide’s recent column in “The Daily Beast” raises significant questions about the veracity of her childhood testimony and the acrimonious falling out between Woody Allen and Mia Farrow.I am not a journalist. I do sometimes teach courses on ethics. I know that public figures are fair game. So I write simply to ask about the wisdom and propriety of these ad hominem columns, which assail particular individuals and champion others. A couple weeks ago, Bill Keller published a controversial column about cancer and dying. Personally, I agreed with his larger point about how to die a good death. But his criticisms of cancer patient Lisa Bonchek Adams and his paean to his own father in-law seemed ad hominem.I do not have answers. Only questions.
I, too, have long found much to admire in Mr. Kristof’s work. And I was glad to see that he had asked Mr. Allen for comment and had disclosed his relationship with the Farrows. But, while acknowledging that Times columnists appropriately have very free rein in choosing subject matter and commenting on it as they see fit, I am troubled by the same questions raised here by Dr. Rasmussen.
And I urge those who who have not yet done so to read Mr. Weide’s illuminating article. It provides essential context.
Dylan Farrow's Sex Abuse Letter Against Woody Allen.
Since I am conversating on this, I done put it back up again.
What’s your favorite Woody Allen movie? Before you answer, you should know: when I was seven years old, Woody Allen took me by the hand and led me into a dim, closet-like attic on the second floor of our house. He told me to lay on my stomach and play with my brother’s electric train set. Then he sexually assaulted me. He talked to me while he did it, whispering that I was a good girl, that this was our secret, promising that we’d go to Paris and I’d be a star in his movies. I remember staring at that toy train, focusing on it as it traveled in its circle around the attic. To this day, I find it difficult to look at toy trains.
What’s your favorite Woody Allen movie? Before you answer, you should know: when I was seven years old, Woody Allen took me by the hand and led me into a dim, closet-like attic on the second floor of our house. He told me to lay on my stomach and play with my brother’s electric train set. Then he sexually assaulted me. He talked to me while he did it, whispering that I was a good girl, that this was our secret, promising that we’d go to Paris and I’d be a star in his movies. I remember staring at that toy train, focusing on it as it traveled in its circle around the attic. To this day, I find it difficult to look at toy trains.
For as long as I could remember, my father had been doing things to me that I didn’t like. I didn’t like how often he would take me away from my mom, siblings and friends to be alone with him. I didn’t like it when he would stick his thumb in my mouth. I didn’t like it when I had to get in bed with him under the sheets when he was in his underwear. I didn’t like it when he would place his head in my naked lap and breathe in and breathe out. I would hide under beds or lock myself in the bathroom to avoid these encounters, but he always found me. These things happened so often, so routinely, so skillfully hidden from a mother that would have protected me had she known, that I thought it was normal. I thought this was how fathers doted on their daughters. But what he did to me in the attic felt different. I couldn’t keep the secret anymore.
When I asked my mother if her dad did to her what Woody Allen did to me, I honestly did not know the answer. I also didn’t know the firestorm it would trigger. I didn’t know that my father would use his sexual relationship with my sister to cover up the abuse he inflicted on me. I didn’t know that he would accuse my mother of planting the abuse in my head and call her a liar for defending me. I didn’t know that I would be made to recount my story over and over again, to doctor after doctor, pushed to see if I’d admit I was lying as part of a legal battle I couldn’t possibly understand. At one point, my mother sat me down and told me that I wouldn’t be in trouble if I was lying – that I could take it all back. I couldn’t. It was all true. But sexual abuse claims against the powerful stall more easily. There were experts willing to attack my credibility. There were doctors willing to gaslight an abused child.
When I asked my mother if her dad did to her what Woody Allen did to me, I honestly did not know the answer. I also didn’t know the firestorm it would trigger. I didn’t know that my father would use his sexual relationship with my sister to cover up the abuse he inflicted on me. I didn’t know that he would accuse my mother of planting the abuse in my head and call her a liar for defending me. I didn’t know that I would be made to recount my story over and over again, to doctor after doctor, pushed to see if I’d admit I was lying as part of a legal battle I couldn’t possibly understand. At one point, my mother sat me down and told me that I wouldn’t be in trouble if I was lying – that I could take it all back. I couldn’t. It was all true. But sexual abuse claims against the powerful stall more easily. There were experts willing to attack my credibility. There were doctors willing to gaslight an abused child.
After a custody hearing denied my father visitation rights, my mother declined to pursue criminal charges, despite findings of probable cause by the State of Connecticut – due to, in the words of the prosecutor, the fragility of the “child victim.” Woody Allen was never convicted of any crime. That he got away with what he did to me haunted me as I grew up. I was stricken with guilt that I had allowed him to be near other little girls. I was terrified of being touched by men. I developed an eating disorder. I began cutting myself. That torment was made worse by Hollywood. All but a precious few (my heroes) turned a blind eye. Most found it easier to accept the ambiguity, to say, “who can say what happened,” to pretend that nothing was wrong. Actors praised him at awards shows. Networks put him on TV. Critics put him in magazines. Each time I saw my abuser’s face – on a poster, on a t-shirt, on television – I could only hide my panic until I found a place to be alone and fall apart.
Last week, Woody Allen was nominated for his latest Oscar. But this time, I refuse to fall apart. For so long, Woody Allen’s acceptance silenced me. It felt like a personal rebuke, like the awards and accolades were a way to tell me to shut up and go away. But the survivors of sexual abuse who have reached out to me – to support me and to share their fears of coming forward, of being called a liar, of being told their memories aren’t their memories – have given me a reason to not be silent, if only so others know that they don’t have to be silent either.
Today, I consider myself lucky. I am happily married. I have the support of my amazing brothers and sisters. I have a mother who found within herself a well of fortitude that saved us from the chaos a predator brought into our home.
But others are still scared, vulnerable, and struggling for the courage to tell the truth. The message that Hollywood sends matters for them.
What if it had been your child, Cate Blanchett? Louis CK? Alec Baldwin? What if it had been you, Emma Stone? Or you, Scarlett Johansson? You knew me when I was a little girl, Diane Keaton. Have you forgotten me?
Woody Allen is a living testament to the way our society fails the survivors of sexual assault and abuse.
So imagine your seven-year-old daughter being led into an attic by Woody Allen. Imagine she spends a lifetime stricken with nausea at the mention of his name. Imagine a world that celebrates her tormenter.
Are you imagining that? Now, what’s your favorite Woody Allen movie?
When Evidence is Ambiguous.
This is a complete re-write of the post that appeared here earlier (Feb. 5, 10:58 pm)
Finish the sentence. "When evidence is ambiguous...," what? "You can't decide," that would be one reasonable way of finishing the sentence. "Get more evidence." Also reasonable, but also a dodge, maybe a misunderstanding: Assume "evidence" means "all the evidence." All the evidence is ambiguous. I think most people would answer "You can't decide."
I will ask now a leading question: What does it mean for a criminal defendant in an American court of law when evidence is ambiguous? (S)he's not guilty. The prosecution has the "burden of proof;" the allegation must be proven "beyond a reasonable doubt."
This is how Nicholas D. Kristof finished the sentence, which is, like, his sentence, in his column on Dylan Farrow;
"When evidence is ambiguous, do we really need to leap to our feet and lionize an alleged molester?"
Mr. Kristof is not in a court of law, he need not employ the legal standard for a conviction, none of us employ the legal standard for a conviction in making daily decisions. He employs a standard that would be the opposite for a criminal defendant in an American courtroom. The accused, in this case Woody Allen, does not get the benefit of the doubt. When the evidence is ambiguous, Hollywood should not honor him.
That is unreasonable. That standard is just not reasonable and Mr. Kristof goes beyond employing it himself by suggesting that it be used by others.
On display here also is Kristof's use of the Socratic method of law school professors, asking questions, not directly answering one's own questions. And another method, a forensic tool, exaggerating one's opponent's position to make it look more unreasonable. Did Hollywood leap to its feet literally at the award ceremony? I don't know because I didn't see it. Neither did Allen since he wasn't there either. Did Hollywood figuratively leap to its feet? Like a spontaneous, spur-of-the-moment act? This was a lifetime achievement award and Woody Allen, at 78 years old, is near the end of that lifetime. Kristof characterizes him as an "artistic giant." It does not seem like a figurative leap. It seems like just a forensic tool Kristof used to score points in a contest in which he is personally involved.
Finish the sentence. "When evidence is ambiguous...," what? "You can't decide," that would be one reasonable way of finishing the sentence. "Get more evidence." Also reasonable, but also a dodge, maybe a misunderstanding: Assume "evidence" means "all the evidence." All the evidence is ambiguous. I think most people would answer "You can't decide."
I will ask now a leading question: What does it mean for a criminal defendant in an American court of law when evidence is ambiguous? (S)he's not guilty. The prosecution has the "burden of proof;" the allegation must be proven "beyond a reasonable doubt."
This is how Nicholas D. Kristof finished the sentence, which is, like, his sentence, in his column on Dylan Farrow;
"When evidence is ambiguous, do we really need to leap to our feet and lionize an alleged molester?"
Mr. Kristof is not in a court of law, he need not employ the legal standard for a conviction, none of us employ the legal standard for a conviction in making daily decisions. He employs a standard that would be the opposite for a criminal defendant in an American courtroom. The accused, in this case Woody Allen, does not get the benefit of the doubt. When the evidence is ambiguous, Hollywood should not honor him.
That is unreasonable. That standard is just not reasonable and Mr. Kristof goes beyond employing it himself by suggesting that it be used by others.
On display here also is Kristof's use of the Socratic method of law school professors, asking questions, not directly answering one's own questions. And another method, a forensic tool, exaggerating one's opponent's position to make it look more unreasonable. Did Hollywood leap to its feet literally at the award ceremony? I don't know because I didn't see it. Neither did Allen since he wasn't there either. Did Hollywood figuratively leap to its feet? Like a spontaneous, spur-of-the-moment act? This was a lifetime achievement award and Woody Allen, at 78 years old, is near the end of that lifetime. Kristof characterizes him as an "artistic giant." It does not seem like a figurative leap. It seems like just a forensic tool Kristof used to score points in a contest in which he is personally involved.
Monday, February 03, 2014
On Dylan Farrow, Woody Allen, Nicholas D. Kristof, Song Binbin (Heh-heh-heh-heh-heh, just kidding on that last one).
Of the 3,600 posts on this blog I can count on one hand (maybe two) the number of posts I have taken down.
This subject, these subjects, have gotten under my skin in ways I can barely explain. One of those ways became a little clearer to me today. And away we go.
Dylan Farrow's letter and Nicholas D. Kristof's column were directed at me, and you, and you and you and you. It is directed at all of us. This is how it begins and ends:
"What's your favorite Woody Allen movie?"
See?
That gets under my skin because I had no thought I had ever wronged Dylan Farrow. But after I read her letter the first time I thought. "I may never watch a Woody Allen movie again." She made me feel I had wronged her because I had paid to see his movies. Oh Ben, don't be ridiculous, you're too sensitive, you didn't do anything wrong in going to see his movies. Hold on there, hoss. Didn't I though? Then why was my first reaction that I wouldn't see any more of his movies, huh? That is the reaction Farrow aimed at.
Nearly everyone...a lot of people reading this have refused to patronize a business on principal. Am I right? That's what boycotts are about. You believe in a principal--South African apartheid was wrong--a country or a corporation or a merchant violates your principal, and you don't give it your business. I bought tickets to Carnegie Hall once, bought them blind, didn't know what was on the program, turned out it was a performance of Wagner and was prepared to eat the cost and not go until my Jewish girlfriend talked me out of it. Wrote about that, too.
This is the bitch of the Farrow-Allen-Kristof thing: Farrow and Kristof are requiring me (us) to decide if Allen molested Farrow 20 years ago. Because if he did then that would kick in my principal that I will not pay to see movies made by a child molester. And if he didn't then, you know, reverse things.
I don't want to make that decision.
I don't think any of us want to make that decision and I may not make that decision but, it does follow on principal. It also follows because that is what Farrow told us we must do or we've wronged her! And Hollywood, too. Particularly Hollywood:
"Last week Woody Allen was nominated for his latest Oscar...It felt like a personal rebuke..."
See?
"Like the award and the accolades were a way to tell me to shut up and go away."
SEE!
"What if it had been your child, Cate Blanchett? Louis CK (Don't even know who "Louis CK" is (See, Dylan!))? Alec Baldwin? What if it had been you, Emma Stone?...Scarlett Johansson? You knew me when I was a little girl, Diane Keaton, have you forgotten me?"
She feels all of these people have wronged her by working with him.
Now, as I write this, and quote her words, I feel myself getting all...a little riled up. Defensive mechanism. Nicholas D. Kristof personalized this by publishing Farrow's letter on his New York Times blog. Kristof wrote a column on this in his New York Times column space too, you know. Kristof riles me up differently (and it's not a defensive mechanism) because he believes Allen molested Farrow...Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait and because he won't say directly, "ALLEN MOLESTED FARROW." He doesn't want to make that decision. So, Kristof just throws Farrow's letter out there "for all of us...to reflect on." :) (Kristof really gets under my skin.). Kristof employs the Socratic method of law school professors. He asks questions (of us) and never deigns a direct answer his own self:
"When evidence is ambiguous, do we really need to leap to our feet and lionize an alleged molester?"
He's asking us. What's our answer?
This subject, these subjects, have gotten under my skin in ways I can barely explain. One of those ways became a little clearer to me today. And away we go.
Dylan Farrow's letter and Nicholas D. Kristof's column were directed at me, and you, and you and you and you. It is directed at all of us. This is how it begins and ends:
"What's your favorite Woody Allen movie?"
See?
That gets under my skin because I had no thought I had ever wronged Dylan Farrow. But after I read her letter the first time I thought. "I may never watch a Woody Allen movie again." She made me feel I had wronged her because I had paid to see his movies. Oh Ben, don't be ridiculous, you're too sensitive, you didn't do anything wrong in going to see his movies. Hold on there, hoss. Didn't I though? Then why was my first reaction that I wouldn't see any more of his movies, huh? That is the reaction Farrow aimed at.
Nearly everyone...a lot of people reading this have refused to patronize a business on principal. Am I right? That's what boycotts are about. You believe in a principal--South African apartheid was wrong--a country or a corporation or a merchant violates your principal, and you don't give it your business. I bought tickets to Carnegie Hall once, bought them blind, didn't know what was on the program, turned out it was a performance of Wagner and was prepared to eat the cost and not go until my Jewish girlfriend talked me out of it. Wrote about that, too.
This is the bitch of the Farrow-Allen-Kristof thing: Farrow and Kristof are requiring me (us) to decide if Allen molested Farrow 20 years ago. Because if he did then that would kick in my principal that I will not pay to see movies made by a child molester. And if he didn't then, you know, reverse things.
I don't want to make that decision.
I don't think any of us want to make that decision and I may not make that decision but, it does follow on principal. It also follows because that is what Farrow told us we must do or we've wronged her! And Hollywood, too. Particularly Hollywood:
"Last week Woody Allen was nominated for his latest Oscar...It felt like a personal rebuke..."
See?
"Like the award and the accolades were a way to tell me to shut up and go away."
SEE!
"What if it had been your child, Cate Blanchett? Louis CK (Don't even know who "Louis CK" is (See, Dylan!))? Alec Baldwin? What if it had been you, Emma Stone?...Scarlett Johansson? You knew me when I was a little girl, Diane Keaton, have you forgotten me?"
She feels all of these people have wronged her by working with him.
Now, as I write this, and quote her words, I feel myself getting all...a little riled up. Defensive mechanism. Nicholas D. Kristof personalized this by publishing Farrow's letter on his New York Times blog. Kristof wrote a column on this in his New York Times column space too, you know. Kristof riles me up differently (and it's not a defensive mechanism) because he believes Allen molested Farrow...Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait and because he won't say directly, "ALLEN MOLESTED FARROW." He doesn't want to make that decision. So, Kristof just throws Farrow's letter out there "for all of us...to reflect on." :) (Kristof really gets under my skin.). Kristof employs the Socratic method of law school professors. He asks questions (of us) and never deigns a direct answer his own self:
"When evidence is ambiguous, do we really need to leap to our feet and lionize an alleged molester?"
He's asking us. What's our answer?
On an average day the most-read post, whatever it may be, gets about 4-8 hits. Seldom gets in double-digits for the day. Today the most-read post, "Red Legacy in China," March 30, 2010 http://publicoccurrenc.blogspot.com/2010/03/red-legacy-in-china_30.html has gotten 30, and not one of those from China. All from the U.S. No, doesn't float your boat? Apologize for any inconvenience.
Sunday, February 02, 2014
Boy. Should Nicholas D. Kristof have done this? Let Dylan Farrow use his New York Times blog to publish her letter? All day, until just a few minutes ago, I've been thinking, "Did Woody Allen molest Dylan?" I researched it online a little; there's nothing that helps me, at least, decide. I thought, "If he did, the statute of limitations has probably run," and then the Connecticut prosecutor who investigated it back in 1993 confirmed. I guess it was that that switched topics for me. Since criminal charges are not possible, why did Kristof publish Dylan's letter? I'm thinking this through as I write. What bothers me about this? That something can't be done. Since something can't be done, why publish it? If Dylan wanted to tell her story, she could have gone to blogspot.com, created a blog and published it herself. Why did Kristof do that? I have read that this was Kristof's personal blog. It's not his NYT column but the link I clicked on when I first read the story took me to the Times website. Kristof permitted Dylan to use his and the Times' imprimatur to make this letter public. That bothers me...Why? I guess because nothing can be done and it just looks like a shot. I thought earlier, "Where does this go from here?" A civil suit by Dylan? Since the statute has run on a criminal prosecution it has certainly run on a civil action. I thought, "What does Woody Allen do?" This is a shot. What does he do? The only way I can think he can effectively respond is to sue himself, for libel. The statute of limitations dates from the incident, in a libel action the incident date would be yesterday. Is Allen going to do that? He could not win. He would have to prove the allegation was made by Dylan with knowledge that it was false. He can't prove that. Dylan clearly believes it is true, i.e. she believes herself. There is nothing Woody Allen can do. I guess that is what bothers me. An allegation of a horrible crime has been made and the alleged victim can't get justice, and the alleged perpetrator can't defend himself. What about Dylan calling out the actors and actresses who've worked with Allen? What the hell are they supposed to do? I'm not even clear on what Dylan is calling them out over, but it's bad! It's just a shot. I don't think Kristof should have published it.
Saturday, February 01, 2014
"Happiness and Its Discontents."- Mari Ruti
Professor Ruti distinguishes between "persona" and "character" which, "captures something about the wholly idiosyncratic and potentially rebellious energies that, every so often, break the facade of that persona."
When our character asserts itself, "what is fierce and unapologetic about us undermines our attempts to lead a 'reasonable' life."
"Unfortunately, we live in a culture that finds such insurrections threatening, not least because they make us less predictable and therefore harder to control. [Hmm, maybe...Yeah, I think that's more right than wrong.] This is one reason we're constantly reminded of the importance of leading a happy, balanced life..." [Keep 'em happy~control, yeah, okay.]
"One could even say that, in our era, the idea that we should lead happy, balanced lives carries the force of an obligation.." [Yeah, I think that's right.]
"...[W]e are getting a general education in emotional numbness; essentially, we are taught to fear aliveness in all of its manifestations." [Hmm...yeah. Okay.]
She cites to Adorno: reminders to be happy which saturate our culture.
"...nothing makes us more docile than the societal 'happiness scripts'...
"...our fixation on the ideal of happiness diverts our attention from collective social ills..." [Maybe]
"Worst of all, we become callous to the lot of others, assuming that if they aren't...perfectly happy [it's their fault.]" [WHOOP! WHOOP! WHOOP! Wrong, that's a ringer. No. Americans are not a less empathetic people for their birth right/obligation to pursue happiness.]
"...cultural injunction to be happy..."
"...consider this basic psychoanalytic insight: Human beings may not be designed for happy, balanced lives." [I have wondered if that were so. She does not cite to any, like, psychoanalysts as authority for that basic insight. The one psychoanalyst she does cite to, earlier in the article, is Freud, which if you're going to cite to one, that would be the one! She cites Freud for the following proposition: People "want to become happy and to remain so," precisely the opposite basic psychoanalytic insight she avers here.]
"Might some of us not prefer lives that are heaving with an intensity of feeling and action but that do not last quite as long..." [Me, her, yes. So, "some of us," yes. Most persons? No. Most people would not want their chests heaving from a heart attack due to their lives heaving with intensity of feeling.]
"isn't a degree of tension a precondition of our ability to recognize tranquility..." [Yeah. Like that. Sort of like Beckett.]
"Might not the best lives be ones in which we sometimes allow ourselves to become a little imprudent or even a tad unhinged?" [I do imprudent at times; I do unhinged. Ergo: one of the best lives? No. No, I don't thing I've lived one of the best lives for my unhinged imprudence. I don't think I've lived a good life.]
Artists, eccentric intellectuals. [Starry, starry night. Paint your palette green and gray...]
"ideological nature of our faith in the value of poise and equanimity. [Hmm, don't know.] If we had grown up in a different society, we might celebrate other traits--say, absolute dedication to a cause--instead." [Maoist China!]
"It's also possible that the more we pursue happy, balanced lives, the more bland and boring, the more devoid of character, we become." [Objection! speculation. Dude, everything's possible, that's possible, don't be intellectually lazy. Do you mean to say "It is likely?" "It's reasonable to think?" Then, say that. Don't say "It's also possible." Upon rephrasing, yes...well. One of the things I object to about the American "pursuit of happiness" is it's limitlessness. Just: pursue happiness, no limits on that. Own slaves? Pursue happiness! Impregnate your slave women? Pursue happiness! The contradistinction Dr. Ruti has set up here is between the pursuit of happiness as balanced, bland and boring, and character: imprudent, unhinged. No. That's wrong. The p.o.h. does not necessarily lead to bland, boring lives. Unhinged imprudence, even "sometimes,"...Unhinged imprudence sometimes...the best lives? No. Thomas Jefferson wrote "pursuit of happiness" into the Declaration of Independence and was an Epicurean... and slaveowner who impregnated Sally Hemings. Life of T.J.: not bland and boring.]
"...character includes not only what is pleasing and gracious but also what appears volatile, disorderly, unwieldy, and even a bit tumultuous or derailing. Our character routinely mortifies the more refined parts of us." [I agree with those statements. "Man is the sum of the things that he's done and the choices he's made in his life." Character, in Dr. Ruti's definition, includes all those things, volatile, disorderly, unhinged imprudence. Those things are not "good," not "moral," not "nice." And the alternative is not "bland and boring." That's a false dichotomy she has set up here.]
"Adorno proposes that awkward, embarrassing gestures preserve 'a tract of vanished life,' I understand this to mean...lapses of composure..." [I don't know what that means, or what Adorno meant by that; it doesn't seem reasonable that he meant by that what she understands that to mean.]
Hannah Arendt in turn talks about an ethereal 'aura' that is implicit in our demeanor but cannot be reduced to any of our qualities...This inimitable aura tells others something about the deepest layers of our being..." [...? Don't know what that means.]
"This is why [She's concluding] there is something quite hollow about the ideal of a happy, balanced life [Hollow. Hmm, I don't know. Hollow? I don't know.] It's why I think that underneath our quest for vibrant health lurks a tragic kind of discreet death: the demise of everything that is eccentric and messy about human life." [Maybe. I don't know. It's possible.]
When our character asserts itself, "what is fierce and unapologetic about us undermines our attempts to lead a 'reasonable' life."
"Unfortunately, we live in a culture that finds such insurrections threatening, not least because they make us less predictable and therefore harder to control. [Hmm, maybe...Yeah, I think that's more right than wrong.] This is one reason we're constantly reminded of the importance of leading a happy, balanced life..." [Keep 'em happy~control, yeah, okay.]
"One could even say that, in our era, the idea that we should lead happy, balanced lives carries the force of an obligation.." [Yeah, I think that's right.]
"...[W]e are getting a general education in emotional numbness; essentially, we are taught to fear aliveness in all of its manifestations." [Hmm...yeah. Okay.]
She cites to Adorno: reminders to be happy which saturate our culture.
"...nothing makes us more docile than the societal 'happiness scripts'...
"...our fixation on the ideal of happiness diverts our attention from collective social ills..." [Maybe]
"Worst of all, we become callous to the lot of others, assuming that if they aren't...perfectly happy [it's their fault.]" [WHOOP! WHOOP! WHOOP! Wrong, that's a ringer. No. Americans are not a less empathetic people for their birth right/obligation to pursue happiness.]
"...cultural injunction to be happy..."
"...consider this basic psychoanalytic insight: Human beings may not be designed for happy, balanced lives." [I have wondered if that were so. She does not cite to any, like, psychoanalysts as authority for that basic insight. The one psychoanalyst she does cite to, earlier in the article, is Freud, which if you're going to cite to one, that would be the one! She cites Freud for the following proposition: People "want to become happy and to remain so," precisely the opposite basic psychoanalytic insight she avers here.]
"Might some of us not prefer lives that are heaving with an intensity of feeling and action but that do not last quite as long..." [Me, her, yes. So, "some of us," yes. Most persons? No. Most people would not want their chests heaving from a heart attack due to their lives heaving with intensity of feeling.]
"isn't a degree of tension a precondition of our ability to recognize tranquility..." [Yeah. Like that. Sort of like Beckett.]
"Might not the best lives be ones in which we sometimes allow ourselves to become a little imprudent or even a tad unhinged?" [I do imprudent at times; I do unhinged. Ergo: one of the best lives? No. No, I don't thing I've lived one of the best lives for my unhinged imprudence. I don't think I've lived a good life.]
Artists, eccentric intellectuals. [Starry, starry night. Paint your palette green and gray...]
"ideological nature of our faith in the value of poise and equanimity. [Hmm, don't know.] If we had grown up in a different society, we might celebrate other traits--say, absolute dedication to a cause--instead." [Maoist China!]
"It's also possible that the more we pursue happy, balanced lives, the more bland and boring, the more devoid of character, we become." [Objection! speculation. Dude, everything's possible, that's possible, don't be intellectually lazy. Do you mean to say "It is likely?" "It's reasonable to think?" Then, say that. Don't say "It's also possible." Upon rephrasing, yes...well. One of the things I object to about the American "pursuit of happiness" is it's limitlessness. Just: pursue happiness, no limits on that. Own slaves? Pursue happiness! Impregnate your slave women? Pursue happiness! The contradistinction Dr. Ruti has set up here is between the pursuit of happiness as balanced, bland and boring, and character: imprudent, unhinged. No. That's wrong. The p.o.h. does not necessarily lead to bland, boring lives. Unhinged imprudence, even "sometimes,"...Unhinged imprudence sometimes...the best lives? No. Thomas Jefferson wrote "pursuit of happiness" into the Declaration of Independence and was an Epicurean... and slaveowner who impregnated Sally Hemings. Life of T.J.: not bland and boring.]
"...character includes not only what is pleasing and gracious but also what appears volatile, disorderly, unwieldy, and even a bit tumultuous or derailing. Our character routinely mortifies the more refined parts of us." [I agree with those statements. "Man is the sum of the things that he's done and the choices he's made in his life." Character, in Dr. Ruti's definition, includes all those things, volatile, disorderly, unhinged imprudence. Those things are not "good," not "moral," not "nice." And the alternative is not "bland and boring." That's a false dichotomy she has set up here.]
"Adorno proposes that awkward, embarrassing gestures preserve 'a tract of vanished life,' I understand this to mean...lapses of composure..." [I don't know what that means, or what Adorno meant by that; it doesn't seem reasonable that he meant by that what she understands that to mean.]
Hannah Arendt in turn talks about an ethereal 'aura' that is implicit in our demeanor but cannot be reduced to any of our qualities...This inimitable aura tells others something about the deepest layers of our being..." [...? Don't know what that means.]
"This is why [She's concluding] there is something quite hollow about the ideal of a happy, balanced life [Hollow. Hmm, I don't know. Hollow? I don't know.] It's why I think that underneath our quest for vibrant health lurks a tragic kind of discreet death: the demise of everything that is eccentric and messy about human life." [Maybe. I don't know. It's possible.]
The work of Samuel Beckett is moving, subtle. Negativism, blackness, pessimism, these are frequently used to describe Beckett's writing. But...never narcissism, as with Sartre. Never...Umm,"hostile." Sartre there, too. Here is Karl Ragnar Gierow in his Nobel presentation on Beckett:
"What does the negative offer us, once it has been developed? A positive, a brighter image in which black itself is transformed into brilliance, in which the areas in the deepest shadow are precisely those that reflect the source of light. Its name is compassion."
Compassion.
"For what is without worth can never be debased. Proof of the degradation of man--and we have been its witnesses as perhaps no generation before us has been--does not exist if one denies all value to man. But the more the evidence makes us suffer, the deeper the recognition of man's true worth. This is the source of inner purification, the life-giving strength in spite of everything that springs from Beckett's black pessimism. It embraces a love for mankind the more compassionate because it has known the extremes of revulsion, a despair that must reach the farthest limit of suffering in order to learn that that frontier vanishes when compassion disappears." (emphasis in original)
Can't degrade the worthless. True, that. Subtle.
"What does the negative offer us, once it has been developed? A positive, a brighter image in which black itself is transformed into brilliance, in which the areas in the deepest shadow are precisely those that reflect the source of light. Its name is compassion."
Compassion.
"For what is without worth can never be debased. Proof of the degradation of man--and we have been its witnesses as perhaps no generation before us has been--does not exist if one denies all value to man. But the more the evidence makes us suffer, the deeper the recognition of man's true worth. This is the source of inner purification, the life-giving strength in spite of everything that springs from Beckett's black pessimism. It embraces a love for mankind the more compassionate because it has known the extremes of revulsion, a despair that must reach the farthest limit of suffering in order to learn that that frontier vanishes when compassion disappears." (emphasis in original)
Can't degrade the worthless. True, that. Subtle.
Friday, January 31, 2014
On Song Binbin, and On and On and On.
I just saw this article, by Professor Xiao Han, from a few days ago. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/27/opinion/confessions-of-the-cultural-revolution.html. This is pretty close to my own view. When this latest Song apology came up I wrote in an email to Dr. Jennifer Ruth "Chinese do not seem to me a very forgiving people." Of course, we write more unguardedly in emails than we do publicly, even on a blog. I caught myself writing that but let it stand in the email. I've thought about it since. Very general statement, I allow; might be wrong; certainly individual exceptions if generally true, yada yada; that is how it seems to me.When I wrote imagining question-and-answer sessions with Song Binbin at Peking University I had this specific image come to mind:
Actually, that specific image without having been washed in olive oil. That's a peasant denunciation of a landlord. I thought, but did not write, "Would Chinese question Song, or would it degenerate into...that?" Ironically, I had just written ("Oh my God, Weimin Mo") that Chinese do not ask questions well (interview with Ben Kingsley, "Omg, W.M."). They have little experience doing it. There is no civil society in China, which means that there is no forum for, ahem, landlord-tenant disputes and the like and no outlet for grievance. So, the Party wants to bulldoze your apartment building, you stand in front of the bulldozers until the cops make tumbleweed of you.
That's why there are 500 protests a day in China and why I, at least, don't view those 500 protests a day as a "simmering cauldron" of unrest. That's all the Chinese people can do! If they could file for a "temporary injunction" I believe they would do that rather than get their asses beat. I make an assumption there. Anyway, they have experience doing tumbleweed, they do not have experience doing questioning. On their first opportunity to do questioning, of Song Binbin, I could see it ending up in olive oil. They did have one formal trial over the Cultural Revolution, we recall.
Objection! Your Honor...Honors. How many Your Honors did they have there? Didn't go well. That trial did not go over well with us foreigners.
They are also missing what underlays Anglo-American law, the Bible. There is a "cycle of redemption" in Christianity, something like, sin-punishment-forgiveness-redemption. "Christian charity." Chinese are not religious much less Christian; they don't believe in that shit. It was that and my memory of Olive Oyle that "informed" my comment to Jennifer, which I now make to all of you'uns. I entirely agree with Professor Han and my friend Zhou Jineng that it is a good thing that Song and others, including Zhou, are apologizing. The Chinese people are credited with this for it was not the Party. It seems to me, a foreigner, as it does to Professor Han (a non-foreigner) that it is in the Chinese people's interests to encourage more of this. Professor Han says the vitriolic reaction to Song's latest will discourage others. I confess that I have had the same thought but I think the Chinese people (including the confessors (including Song)) have handled this astonishingly well so far. There is nothing in the Bible or Anglo-American law that compels forgiveness or redemption. There is no forgiving some crimes (see People v Charles Manson, Leslie van Houten, Patricial Krenwinkle, Susan Atkins). You can still be damned for eternity after apologizing. Song's case may be one of those and I vehemently disagree with Professor Han that Song Binbin does "not appear to have committed very serious crimes." It appears to me she has committed the most serious crime. However, we will never know if she is cowed into (back into, I should say) silence for there is no formal apparatus compelling her to talk. So, no compulsion to forgive, but Christianity says, if possible, that would be "nice." Do the Chinese people have it in them? They don't seem to me a very forgiving people.
Actually, that specific image without having been washed in olive oil. That's a peasant denunciation of a landlord. I thought, but did not write, "Would Chinese question Song, or would it degenerate into...that?" Ironically, I had just written ("Oh my God, Weimin Mo") that Chinese do not ask questions well (interview with Ben Kingsley, "Omg, W.M."). They have little experience doing it. There is no civil society in China, which means that there is no forum for, ahem, landlord-tenant disputes and the like and no outlet for grievance. So, the Party wants to bulldoze your apartment building, you stand in front of the bulldozers until the cops make tumbleweed of you.
That's why there are 500 protests a day in China and why I, at least, don't view those 500 protests a day as a "simmering cauldron" of unrest. That's all the Chinese people can do! If they could file for a "temporary injunction" I believe they would do that rather than get their asses beat. I make an assumption there. Anyway, they have experience doing tumbleweed, they do not have experience doing questioning. On their first opportunity to do questioning, of Song Binbin, I could see it ending up in olive oil. They did have one formal trial over the Cultural Revolution, we recall.
Objection! Your Honor...Honors. How many Your Honors did they have there? Didn't go well. That trial did not go over well with us foreigners.
They are also missing what underlays Anglo-American law, the Bible. There is a "cycle of redemption" in Christianity, something like, sin-punishment-forgiveness-redemption. "Christian charity." Chinese are not religious much less Christian; they don't believe in that shit. It was that and my memory of Olive Oyle that "informed" my comment to Jennifer, which I now make to all of you'uns. I entirely agree with Professor Han and my friend Zhou Jineng that it is a good thing that Song and others, including Zhou, are apologizing. The Chinese people are credited with this for it was not the Party. It seems to me, a foreigner, as it does to Professor Han (a non-foreigner) that it is in the Chinese people's interests to encourage more of this. Professor Han says the vitriolic reaction to Song's latest will discourage others. I confess that I have had the same thought but I think the Chinese people (including the confessors (including Song)) have handled this astonishingly well so far. There is nothing in the Bible or Anglo-American law that compels forgiveness or redemption. There is no forgiving some crimes (see People v Charles Manson, Leslie van Houten, Patricial Krenwinkle, Susan Atkins). You can still be damned for eternity after apologizing. Song's case may be one of those and I vehemently disagree with Professor Han that Song Binbin does "not appear to have committed very serious crimes." It appears to me she has committed the most serious crime. However, we will never know if she is cowed into (back into, I should say) silence for there is no formal apparatus compelling her to talk. So, no compulsion to forgive, but Christianity says, if possible, that would be "nice." Do the Chinese people have it in them? They don't seem to me a very forgiving people.
On Song Binbin, et al.
My Declaration on the Hypocritical Apology Made by Song Binbin and Liu Jin
By Wang Jingyao
August 5, 1966 afternoon, the Red Guards of the Girls’ School of BNU (Currently renamed BNU Lab School) attackedphysically Comrade Bian Zhongyun in name of “subduing her arrogance”. The Red Guards cruelly beat her up with clubs prickled with nails and brass-buckled belts. The brutality of their torture made onlookers’ hair stand on end!
Around 3 PM in the afternoon that day, Comrade BianZhongyun lay unconsciously on the ground with cuts and wounds all over her body. Her coma had caused fecal leakage and dilated pupils. Evidently she was dying. The Red Guards threw her on top of a tricycle, covered with dirty large-character posters and a canvas raincoat which I have kept to this day. For as long as five hours, the Red Guards of the Girls’ School refused to save her life (the Postal Services Ministry Hospital was just across the street). Not till 8 o’clock in the evening did they begin to move her to the hospital. By then it was impossible to revive her.
On August 18, 1966, thirteen days after the murder of Bian Zhongyun, Mao Zedong received representatives of Red Guards. Song Binbin, one of the leaders of Girls’ School of BNU, went up to the top of Tiananmen Pass. She put a Red Guard armband around Mao’s arm in honor of her school’s Red Guards. The armband was stained with the blood of Comrade Bian Zhongyun. Mao nevertheless told Song Binbin to be “militant”.
Since the day (8/18/1966), there were in Beijing 1,772 morepeople whom Red Guards beat to death, including many school teachers and principals.
48 years have passed since the murder of Bian. However, the culprits and perpetrators are still at large. The truth about “August 5 Incident” has been purposely covered.
On 1/12/2014, Song Binbin and Liu Jin made a hypocritical apology to the school leaders and their families, using as excuses their “inability to stop (beating)”, “inability to protect well (the victims)”, and “lack of knowledge about the Constitution and lack of legal consciousness” to rid themselvesof their responsibility for “August 5 Incident”.
Hereby, as widower, and comrade-in-arms of Comrade BianZhongyun, I solemnly declare:
1.
The Red Guards of Girls’ School of BNU are the perpetrators in murder of Comrade Bian Zhongyun!
2.
The Red Guards of Girls’ School of BNU have never tried to rescue Comrade Bian Zhongyun!
3.
I will never accept any hypocritical apologies made by the Red Guards of Girls’ School till the truth comes out about August 5 Incident!
The declaration is intended to make the point.
Wang Jingyao
1/27/2014
Thursday, January 30, 2014
"Mayor Unapologetic in Eye of Storm That Brought Atlanta to a Halt."-New York Times.
"'Buck Stops' with Deal As Reed Battles Brunt of Blame."-Atlanta Journal Constitution.
A tale of two headlines, a tale of two different politicians. A tale of a politician who is man enough to stand up and take responsibility; A tale of a coward, and a fool.
There you go again, Reed, arrogantly flapping your lips, digging yourself deeper. If two inches of snow can bury your city, maybe it can bury your political future. You show no more skill digging out of a political scandal of your making, which scandal you have the arrogance to defend, then you had skill protecting your city. You're close to the Obama White House? Take Obama with you when you leave. You're incompetent, Reed, two storms in three years, you're ineducable, you're a fool just like your mentor in the White House. Take him with you when you leave. And stop flapping your lips. Just shut the fuck up. Bitch.
A tale of two headlines, a tale of two different politicians. A tale of a politician who is man enough to stand up and take responsibility; A tale of a coward, and a fool.
There you go again, Reed, arrogantly flapping your lips, digging yourself deeper. If two inches of snow can bury your city, maybe it can bury your political future. You show no more skill digging out of a political scandal of your making, which scandal you have the arrogance to defend, then you had skill protecting your city. You're close to the Obama White House? Take Obama with you when you leave. You're incompetent, Reed, two storms in three years, you're ineducable, you're a fool just like your mentor in the White House. Take him with you when you leave. And stop flapping your lips. Just shut the fuck up. Bitch.
Wednesday, January 29, 2014
Does America Still Work?
Above is the city of Atlanta, Georgia, paralyzed by less than three inches of snow. Kids had to spend the night in schools. People were stranded on the highways. One lady gave birth in her car. Three inches! The governor of the state of Georgia is "Nathan Deal." Nathan, take a bow.
Nathan, why do you look puzzled? Well, because, "As you know, we have been confronted with an unexpected storm that has hit the metropolitan Atlanta area." Actually, Nathan we don't know that, in fact we know exactly the contrary. The storm may have been unexpected to you because you've drunk too much moonshine in your life which has resulted in the death of millions of brain cells which has resulted in you looking puzzled but the storm was expected, Nathan and you were warned 24 hours in advance but instead of acting were at an honorary luncheon...
...very nice Nathan, where the honoree was the man who "leads" Hotlanta, Mayor "Kasim Reed."
Kasim, take a bow.
Kasim, you look puzzled, too. Are you puzzled, Kasim, or just stupid? Kasim also received the storm warnings but was attending the aforesaid honorary luncheon when the first (the first of three inches) snowflakes began falling. Three years ago Atlanta was also paralyzed by a winter storm. Kasim was also the mayor then. Friends and enemies, at top, that is the face of Atlanta, Georgia in three inches of snow. Above, those are the faces of incompetence. Take a walk, Nathan, Kasim.
Kasim, you look puzzled, too. Are you puzzled, Kasim, or just stupid? Kasim also received the storm warnings but was attending the aforesaid honorary luncheon when the first (the first of three inches) snowflakes began falling. Three years ago Atlanta was also paralyzed by a winter storm. Kasim was also the mayor then. Friends and enemies, at top, that is the face of Atlanta, Georgia in three inches of snow. Above, those are the faces of incompetence. Take a walk, Nathan, Kasim.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











.jpg)






