Thursday, March 06, 2014

State Department Rebuts Putin Press Conference (transcript).

As Russia spins a false narrative to justify its illegal actions in Ukraine, the world has not seen such startling Russian fiction since Dostoyevsky wrote, “The formula ‘two times two equals five’ is not without its attractions.”
Below are 10 of President Vladimir Putin’s recent claims justifying Russian aggression in the Ukraine, followed by the facts that his assertions ignore or distort.
1. Mr. Putin says: Russian forces in Crimea are only acting to protect Russian military assets. It is “citizens’ defense groups,” not Russian forces, who have seized infrastructure and military facilities in Crimea.

The Facts: Strong evidence suggests that members of Russian security services are at the heart of the highly organized anti-Ukraine forces in Crimea. While these units wear uniforms without insignia, they drive vehicles with Russian military license plates and freely identify themselves as Russian security forces when asked by the international media and the Ukrainian military. Moreover, these individuals are armed with weapons not generally available to civilians.

2. Mr. Putin says: Russia’s actions fall within the scope of the 1997 Friendship Treaty between Ukraine and the Russian Federation.

The Facts: The 1997 agreement requires Russia to respect Ukraine’s territorial integrity. Russia’s military actions in Ukraine, which have given them operational control of Crimea, are in clear violation of Ukraine’s territorial integrity and sovereignty.
3. Mr. Putin says: The opposition failed to implement the February 21 agreement with former Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych.
The Facts: The February 21 agreement laid out a plan in which the Rada, or Parliament, would pass a bill to return Ukraine to its 2004 Constitution, thus returning the country to a constitutional system centered around its parliament. Under the terms of the agreement, Yanukovych was to sign the enacting legislation within 24 hours and bring the crisis to a peaceful conclusion. Yanukovych refused to keep his end of the bargain. Instead, he packed up his home and fled, leaving behind evidence of wide-scale corruption.

4. Mr. Putin says: Ukraine’s government is illegitimate. Yanukovych is still the legitimate leader of Ukraine.
The Facts: On March 4, President Putin himself acknowledged the reality that Yanukovych “has no political future.” After Yanukovych fled Ukraine, even his own Party of Regions turned against him, voting to confirm his withdrawal from office and to support the new government. Ukraine’s new government was approved by the democratically elected Ukrainian Parliament, with 371 votes – more than an 82% majority. The interim government of Ukraine is a government of the people, which will shepherd the country toward democratic elections on May 25th – elections that will allow all Ukrainians to have a voice in the future of their country.
5. Mr. Putin says: There is a humanitarian crisis and hundreds of thousands are fleeing Ukraine to Russia and seeking asylum.

The Facts: To date, there is absolutely no evidence of a humanitarian crisis. Nor is there evidence of a flood of asylum-seekers fleeing Ukraine for Russia. International organizations on the ground have investigated by talking with Ukrainian border guards, who also refuted these claims. Independent journalists observing the border have also reported no such flood of refugees.
6. Mr. Putin says: Ethnic Russians are under threat.
The Facts: Outside of Russian press and Russian state television, there are no credible reports of any ethnic Russians being under threat. The new Ukrainian government placed a priority on peace and reconciliation from the outset. President Oleksandr Turchynov refused to sign legislation limiting the use of the Russian language at regional level. Ethnic Russians and Russian speakers have filed petitions attesting that their communities have not experienced threats. Furthermore, since the new government was established, calm has returned to Kyiv. There has been no surge in crime, no looting, and no retribution against political opponents.

7. Mr. Putin says: Russian bases are under threat.
The Facts: Russian military facilities were and remain secure, and the new Ukrainian government has pledged to abide by all existing international agreements, including those covering Russian bases. It is Ukrainian bases in Crimea that are under threat from Russian military action.
8. Mr. Putin says: There have been mass attacks on churches and synagogues in southern and eastern Ukraine.
The Facts: Religious leaders in the country and international religious freedom advocates active in Ukraine have said there have been no incidents of attacks on churches. All of Ukraine’s church leaders, including representatives of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church-Moscow Patriarchate, have expressed support for the new political leadership, calling for national unity and a period of healing. Jewish groups in southern and eastern Ukraine report that they have not seen an increase in anti-Semitic incidents.
9. Mr. Putin says: Kyiv is trying to destabilize Crimea.

The Facts: Ukraine’s interim government has acted with restraint and sought dialogue. Russian troops, on the other hand, have moved beyond their bases to seize political objectives and infrastructure in Crimea. The government in Kyiv immediately sent the former Chief of Defense to defuse the situation. Petro Poroshenko, the latest government emissary to pursue dialogue in Crimea, was prevented from entering the Crimean Rada.
10. Mr. Putin says: The Rada is under the influence of extremists or terrorists.

The Facts: The Rada is the most representative institution in Ukraine. Recent legislation has passed with large majorities, including from representatives of eastern Ukraine. Far-right wing ultranationalist groups, some of which were involved in open clashes with security forces during the EuroMaidan protests, are not represented in the Rada. There is no indication that the Ukrainian government would pursue discriminatory policies; on the contrary, they have publicly stated exactly the opposite.

Wednesday, March 05, 2014

Back to the Future


Yesterday morning's "Russia is not going to attack" post has not caught fire. :(

The analogies are coming...like a tsunami. We've gone back, back, back, back, back. The Cold War analogy is so, like, yesterday; today we've gone back to 1938 and...1914! Holy Molio. Today was Hitler Day. Roger Cohen (New York Times guy), Hillary Clinton, Lindsey Graham, Marco Rubio, John McCain--all mentioned Hits in the same breath with Poot-poot. There is an analogy to be made there, both used the will of an ethnic minority to...invade...See, that's the problem with analogies; for the sake of this post, I will concede that Putin has invaded Ukrainian Crimea, but you can argue he hasn't! but that's as far as that analogy will take us. So far! Hitler, like, conquered and annexed the Sudetenland on that pretext. Putin has said (I know, he's Russian) he has no such intent. I believe him (I know, I'm an idiot blogger.). However that may be, it is a fact that Putin has not conquered, annexed, and "liberated" the long-suffering ethnic Rooskis in Ukrainian Crimea. "Yet!," say the statesmen...and woman! above. Right. So...what should we do statespeople? If we continue with your analogy, we should use military power to thwart Poot-poot or else we'll all be Neville Chamberlains! Not one of the states proposes that-there military thing. Ha-ha! Five Amigos, you're Neville Chamberlains, ha-ha. They are such cockroaches.

But, hell, analogies are fun and they're the play of the day, let's play. I have one. A dictator of a totalitarian country meets with a new, young leader of a democracy and sizes up the democrat as callow and weak. Both the dictator and the democrat know the former bullied and beat the latter at the meeting. A year later the dictator tries to pull a fast one in another country right under the nose of snot-nose. Snot-nose...reacts, he later admits that the dictator's fast one, if successful, would not have altered the strategic balance of power between the dictatorship and the democracy, but would have continued the tip in the political balance of power between the two men that began at the meeting when snot-nose became bloody-nose. The two countries almost ("about a one in three chance," Snot-nose was to say later) went to war over a bloody nose!

The year was 1962. The dictator/bully was Nikita Khrushchev, the democrat/snot-cum-bloody nose was John F. Kennedy. It was the Cuban Missile Crisis. And the world came within a one-in-three chance of going up in a nuclear fireball. Careful with that stuff, you can burn your hands.

Tuesday, March 04, 2014

Russia is not going to attack, annex, or dismember Ukraine. The Russians do not have the intent, did not have the intent, to do any of those things to Ukraine.

Russia has not done much wrong so far. There has been no blood shed from Russian actions. Official and semi-official America have caricatured Russian intent and action in Crimea. The Russian message has been near completely submerged beneath the American media tsunami.

The Russian non-attack will be viewed as a "win" for President Obama over Vladimir Putin. Obama will not have won. This crisis will more embitter Putin and Lavrov toward Obama personally and toward official and semi-official America generally. They will see the various "partnerships"--which they, the Russians, buy into--with America, that official America has sold them, as shams. They will see that America hates Russia under Putin just as it hated the Soviet Union. Obama will assure Putin and Lavrov that he personally was more measured in his statements on Ukraine. This will be partially successful. John Kerry, et al, Susan Rice, Victoria Nuland and the rest, will never be trusted by Putin or Lavrov again.

That is what I believe.

I am Benjamin Harris.
NATO and Russian officials will meet later today in Brussels.
From the Los Angeles Times:

"CIA director John Brennan told a senior lawmaker Monday that a 1997 treaty between Russia and Ukraine allows up to 25,000 Russia troops in the vital Crimea region, so Russia may not consider its recent troop movements to be an invasion, U.S. officials said.

The number of Russian troops that have surged into Ukraine in recent days remains well below that threshold, Brennan said, according to U.S. officials who declined to be named in describing private discussions and declined to name the legislator.

Though Brennan disagrees that the treaty justifies Russia’s incursion, he urged a cautious approach, the officials said. Administration officials have said Moscow violated the treaty, which requires the Russian navy, which bases its Black Sea fleet in Sevastopol, to coordinate all military movements on the Crimean peninsula with Ukraine."


http://www.latimes.com/world/worldnow/la-fg-wn-us-intelligence-russia-ukraine-20140303,0,4657644.story#ixzz2v1K3QLfj

Putin's Press Conference Transcript, March 4, 2014.

This is from the Office of the President of Russia website. I do not understand the "to be continued" at bottom.

PRESIDENT OF RUSSIA VLADIMIR PUTIN: Good afternoon, colleagues,
How shall we do this? This is what I’d like to suggest: let’s have a conversation, rather than an interview. Therefore, I would ask you to begin by stating all your questions, I will jot them down and try to answer them, and then we will have a more detailed discussion of the specifics that interest you most.
Let’s begin.
QUESTION: Mr President, I would like to ask (you took a lengthy pause, so we have quite a few questions by now) how you assess the events in Kiev? Do you think that the Government and the Acting President, who are currently in power in Kiev, are legitimate? Are you ready to communicate with them, and on what terms? Do you yourself think it possible now to return to the agreements of February 21, which we all talk about so often?
QUESTION: Mr President, Russia has promised financial aid to Crimea and instructions were issued to the Finance Ministry yesterday. Is there a clear understanding of how much we are giving, where the money is coming from, on what terms and when? The situation there is very difficult.
QUESTION: When, on what terms and in what scope can military force be used in Ukraine? To what extent does this comply with Russia’s international agreements? Did the military exercises that have just finished have anything to do with the possible use of force?
QUESTION: We would like to know more about Crimea. Do you think that the provocations are over or that there remains a threat to the Russian citizens who are now in Crimea and to the Russian-speaking population? What are the general dynamics there – is the situation changing for the better or for the worse? We are hearing different reports from there.
QUESTION: If you do decide to use force, have you thought through all the possible risks for yourself, for the country and for the world: economic sanctions, weakened global security, a possible visa ban or greater isolation for Russia, as western politicians are demanding?
QUESTION: Yesterday the Russian stock market fell sharply in response to the Federation Council’s vote, and the ruble exchange rates hit record lows. Did you expect such a reaction? What do you think are the possible consequences for the economy? Is there a need for any special measures now, and of what kind? For instance, do you think the Central Bank’s decision to shift to a floating ruble exchange rate may have been premature? Do you think it should be revoked? 
VLADIMIR PUTIN: Fine, let us stop here for now. I will begin, and then we will continue. Don’t worry; I will try to answer as many questions as possible.
First of all, my assessment of what happened in Kiev and in Ukraine in general. There can only be one assessment: this was an anti-constitutional takeover, an armed seizure of power. Does anyone question this? Nobody does. There is a question here that neither I, nor my colleagues, with whom I have been discussing the situation in Ukraine a great deal over these past days, as you know – none of us can answer. The question is why was this done?
I would like to draw your attention to the fact that President Yanukovych, through the mediation of the Foreign Ministers of three European countries – Poland, Germany and France – and in the presence of my representative (this was the Russian Human Rights Commissioner Vladimir Lukin) signed an agreement with the opposition on February 21. I would like to stress that under that agreement (I am not saying this was good or bad, just stating the fact) Mr Yanukovych actually handed over power. He agreed to all the opposition’s demands: he agreed to early parliamentary elections, to early presidential elections, and to return to the 2004 Constitution, as demanded by the opposition. He gave a positive response to our request, the request of western countries and, first of all, of the opposition not to use force. He did not issue a single illegal order to shoot at the poor demonstrators. Moreover, he issued orders to withdraw all police forces from the capital, and they complied. He went to Kharkov to attend an event, and as soon as he left, instead of releasing the occupied administrative buildings, they immediately occupied the President’s residence and the Government building – all that instead of acting on the agreement.
I ask myself, what was the purpose of all this? I want to understand why this was done. He had in fact given up his power already, and as I believe, as I told him, he had no chance of being re-elected. Everybody agrees on this, everyone I have been speaking to on the telephone these past few days. What was the purpose of all those illegal, unconstitutional actions, why did they have to create this chaos in the country? Armed and masked militants are still roaming the streets of Kiev. This is a question to which there is no answer. Did they wish to humiliate someone and show their power? I think these actions are absolutely foolish. The result is the absolute opposite of what they expected, because their actions have significantly destabilised the east and southeast of Ukraine.
Now over to how this situation came about.
In my opinion, this revolutionary situation has been brewing for a long time, since the first days of Ukraine’s independence.  The ordinary Ukrainian citizen, the ordinary guy suffered during the rule of Nicholas II, during the reign of Kuchma, and Yushchenko, and Yanukovych. Nothing or almost nothing has changed for the better. Corruption has reached dimensions that are unheard of here in Russia. Accumulation of wealth and social stratification – problems that are also acute in this country – are much worse in Ukraine, radically worse. Out there, they are beyond anything we can imagine imagination. Generally, people wanted change, but one should not support illegal change.
Only use constitutional means should be used on the post-Soviet space, where political structures are still very fragile, and economies are still weak. Going beyond the constitutional field would always be a cardinal mistake in such a situation.  Incidentally, I understand those people on Maidan, though I do not support this kind of turnover. I understand the people on Maidan who are calling for radical change rather than some cosmetic remodelling of power. Why are they demanding this? Because they have grown used to seeing one set of thieves being replaced by another. Moreover, the people in the regions do not even participate in forming their own regional governments. There was a period in this country when the President appointed regional leaders, but then the local Council had to approve them, while in Ukraine they are appointed directly. We have now moved on to elections, while they are nowhere near this. And they began appointing all sorts of oligarchs and billionaires to govern the eastern regions of the country. No wonder the people do not accept this, no wonder they think that as a result of dishonest privatisation (just as many people think here as well) people have become rich and now they also have all the power.
For example, Mr Kolomoisky was appointed Governor of Dnepropetrovsk. This is a unique crook. He even managed to cheat our oligarch Roman Abramovich two or three years ago.  Scammed him, as our intellectuals like to say. They signed some deal, Abramovich transferred several billion dollars, while this guy never delivered and pocketed the money. When I asked him [Abramovich]: “Why did you do it?” he said: “I never thought this was possible.” I do not know, by the way, if he ever got his money back and if the deal was closed.  But this really did happen a couple of years ago. And now this crook is appointed Governor of Dnepropetrovsk. No wonder the people are dissatisfied. They were dissatisfied and will remain so if those who refer to themselves the legitimate authorities continue in the same fashion.
Most importantly, people should have the right to determine their own future, that of their families and of their region, and to have equal participation in it. I would like to stress this: wherever a person lives, whatever part of the country, he or she should have the right to equal participation in determining the future of the country.
Are the current authorities legitimate? The Parliament is partially, but all the others are not. The current Acting President is definitely not legitimate. There is only one legitimate President, from a legal standpoint. Clearly, he has no power. However, as I have already said, and will repeat: Yanukovych is the only undoubtedly legitimate President.
There are three ways of removing a President under Ukrainian law: one is his death, the other is when he personally stands down, and the third is impeachment. The latter is a well-deliberated constitutional norm. It has to involve the Constitutional Court, the Supreme Court and the Rada. This is a complicated and lengthy procedure. It was not carried out.  Therefore, from a legal perspective this is an undisputed fact.
Moreover, I think this may be why they disbanded the Constitutional Court, which runs counter to all legal norms of both Ukraine and Europe. They not only disbanded the Constitutional Court in an illegitimate fashion, but they also – just think about it – instructed the Prosecutor General’s Office to launch criminal proceedings against members of the Constitutional Court. What is that all about? Is this what they call free justice? How can you instruct anyone to start criminal proceedings? If a crime, a criminal offence, has been committed, the law enforcement agencies see this and react. But instructing them to file criminal charges is nonsense, it’s monkey business.
Now about financial aid to Crimea. As you may know, we have decided to organise work in the Russian regions to aid Crimea, which has turned to us for humanitarian support. We will provide it, of course. I cannot say how much, when or how – the Government is working on this, by bringing together the regions bordering on Crimea, by providing additional support to our regions so they could help the people in Crimea. We will do it, of course.
Regarding the deployment of troops, the use of armed forces.  So far, there is no need for it, but the possibility remains. I would like to say here that the military exercises we recently held had nothing to do with the events in Ukraine.  This was pre-planned, but we did not disclose these plans, naturally, because this was a snap inspection of the forces’ combat readiness. We planned this a long time ago, the Defence Minister reported to me and I had the order ready to begin the exercise. As you may know, the exercises are over; I gave the order for the troops to return to their regular dislocations yesterday.
What can serve as a reason to use the Armed Forces? Such a measure would certainly be the very last resort.
First, the issue legitimacy. As you may know, we have a direct appeal from the incumbent and, as I said, legitimate President of Ukraine, Mr Yanukovych, asking us to use the Armed Forces to protect the lives, freedom and health of the citizens of Ukraine.
What is our biggest concern? We see the rampage of reactionary forces, nationalist and anti-Semitic forces going on in certain parts of Ukraine, including Kiev. I am sure you, members of the media, saw how one of the governors was chained and handcuffed to something and they poured water over him, in the cold of winter. After that, by the way, he was locked up in a cellar and tortured. What is all this about? Is this democracy? Is this some manifestation of democracy? He was actually only recently appointed to this position, in December, I believe. Even if we accept that they are all corrupt there, he had barely had time to steal anything.
And do you know what happened when they seized the Party of Regions building? There were no party members there at all at the time. Some two-three employees came out, one was an engineer, and he said to the attackers: “Could you let us go, and let the women out, please. I’m an engineer, I have nothing to do with politics.” He was shot right there in front of the crowd. Another employee was led to a cellar and then they threw Molotov cocktails at him and burned him alive.  Is this also a manifestation of democracy?
When we see this we understand what worries the citizens of Ukraine, both Russian and Ukrainian, and the Russian-speaking population in the eastern and southern regions of Ukraine. It is this uncontrolled crime that worries them. Therefore, if we see such uncontrolled crime spreading to the eastern regions of the country, and if the people ask us for help, while we already have the official request from the legitimate President, we retain the to use all available means to protect those people. We believe this would be absolutely legitimate. This is our last resort.
Moreover, here is what I would like to say: we have always considered Ukraine not only a neighbour, but also a brotherly neighbouring republic, and will continue to do so. Our Armed Forces are comrades in arms, friends, many of whom know each other personally. I am certain, and I stress, I am certain that the Ukrainian military and the Russian military will not be facing each other, they will be on the same side in a fight.
Incidentally, the things I am talking about – this unity – is what is happening in Crimea. You should note that, thank God, not a single gunshot has been fired there; there are no casualties, except for those crushed by the crowd about a week ago. What was going on there? People came, surrounded units of the armed forces and talked to them, convincing them to follow the demands and the will of the people living in that area. There was not a single armed conflict, not a single gunshot.
Thus the tension in Crimea that was linked to the possibility of using our Armed Forces simply died down and there was no need to use them. The only thing we had to do, and we did it, was to enhance the defence of our military facilities because they were constantly receiving threats and we were aware of the armed nationalists moving in. We did this, it was the right thing to do and very timely. Therefore, I proceed from the idea that we will not have to do anything of the kind in eastern Ukraine.
There is something I would like to stress, however. Obviously, what I am going to say now is not within my authority and we do not intend to interfere. However, we firmly believe that all citizens of Ukraine, I repeat, wherever they live, should be given the same equal right to participate in the life of their country and in determining its future.
If I were in the shoes of those who consider themselves the legitimate authorities, I would not waste time and go through all the necessary procedures, because they do not have a national mandate to conduct the domestic, foreign and economic policy of Ukraine, and especially to determine its future.
Now, the stock market. As you may know, the stock market was jumpy even before the situation in Ukraine deteriorated. This is primarily linked to the policy of the US Federal Reserve, whose recent decisions enhanced the attractiveness of investing in the US economy and investors began moving their funds from the developing markets to the American market. This is a general trend and it has nothing to do with Ukraine. I believe it was India that suffered most, as well as the other BRICS states. Russia was hit as well, not as hard as India, but it was. This is the fundamental reason.
As for the events in Ukraine, politics always influence the stock market in one way or another. Money likes quiet, stability and calm. However, I think this is a tactical, temporary development and a temporary influence.
Your questions, please.
QUESTION: Mr President, can you tell us if you expected such a harsh reaction to Russia’s actions from your western partners? Could you give us any details of your conversations with your western partners? All we’ve heard was a report from the press service. And what do you think about the G8 summit in Sochi – will it take place?
VLADIMIR PUTIN: Regarding the expected reaction, whether the G8 will meet and about the conversations. Our conversations are confidential, some are even held over secure lines. Therefore, I am not authorised to disclose what I discussed with my partners. I will, however, refer to some public statements made by my colleagues from the west; without giving any names, I will comment on them in a general sense.
What do we pay attention to? We are often told our actions are illegitimate, but when I ask, “Do you think everything you do is legitimate?” they say “yes”. Then, I have to recall the actions of the United States in Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya, where they either acted without any UN sanctions or completely distorted the content of such resolutions, as was the case with Libya. There, as you may know, the resolution only spoke of closing the airspace for government aircraft, while it all ended with bomb attacks and special forces land operations.
Our partners, especially in the United Sates, always clearly formulate their own geopolitical and state interests and follow them with persistence. Then, using the principle “You’re either with us or against us” they draw the whole world in. And those who do not join in get ‘beaten’ until they do.
Our approach is different. We proceed from the conviction that we always act legitimately. I have personally always been an advocate of acting in compliance with international law. I would like to stress yet again that if we do make the decision, if I do decide to use the Armed Forces, this will be a legitimate decision in full compliance with both general norms of international law, since we have the appeal of the legitimate President, and with our commitments, which in this case coincide with our interests to protect the people with whom we have close historical, cultural and economic ties. Protecting these people is in our national interests. This is a humanitarian mission. We do not intend to subjugate anyone or to dictate to anyone. However, we cannot remain indifferent if we see that they are being persecuted, destroyed and humiliated. However, I sincerely hope it never gets to that.
QUESTION: How do you asses the reaction of the west to the events in Ukraine and their threats regarding Russia: are we facing the possibility of sanctions or withdrawal from the G8?
VLADIMIR PUTIN: Regarding sanctions. It is primarily those who intend to apply them that need to consider their consequences. I believe that in the modern world, where everything is interconnected and interdependent, it is possible to cause damage to another country, but this will be mutual damage and one should bear this in mind.  This is one thing.
The second and the most important thing. I have already told you what motivates us.  And what motivates our partners? They supported an unconstitutional armed take-over, declared these people legitimate and are trying to support them. By the way, despite all of this we have been patient and even ready to cooperate; we do not want to disrupt our cooperation. As you may know, a few days ago I instructed the Government to consider how we can maintain contacts even with those powers in Kiev that we do not consider legitimate in order to retain our ties in the economy and industry. We think our actions have been absolutely reasonable, while any threat against Russia is counterproductive and harmful.
As for the G8, I do not know. We will be ready to host the summit with our colleagues. If they do not want to come – so be it.
QUESTION: Can I add about contacts? The way I see it, you consider the Prime Minister of Crimea Mr Aksyonov to be a legitimate representative of government authorities. Are you ready to have any contacts with those who consider themselves the legitimate authorities in Kiev?
VLADIMIR PUTIN: I have just spoken about it. You must have missed it.
QUESTION: I mean, at the top level for a political solution.
VLADIMIR PUTIN: I do not have a partner at the top level there. There is no president there, and there cannot be one until the general elections.
As for Crimea, the Parliament there was formed in 2010, in December 2010 if I remember correctly. There are 100 MPs representing six political parties. After the previous Prime Minister resigned, the Crimean Parliament, in compliance with the existing legislation and procedures elected a new Prime Minister at a session of the Crimean Supreme Council. He is definitely legitimate.  They have complied with all the procedures envisaged by the law; there is not a single violation. However, when a few days ago a group of armed men tried to occupy the building of the Crimean Supreme Soviet, this caused the concern of the local residents. It seemed as though someone wanted to apply the Kiev scenario in Crimea and to launch a series of terrorist attacks and cause chaos. Naturally, this causes grave concern among the local residents. That is why they set up self-defence committees and took control over all the armed forces.
Incidentally, I was studying the brief yesterday to see what they took over – it is like a fortified zone. There are several dozen C-300 units, several dozen air-defence missile systems, 22,000 service members and a lot more.  However, as I said, this is all in the hands of the people of Crimea and without a single gunshot.
QUESTION: Mr President, a clarification if I may. The people who were blocking the Ukrainian Army units in Crimea were wearing uniforms that strongly resembled the Russian Army uniform. Were those Russian soldiers, Russian military?
VLADIMIR PUTIN: Why don’t you take a look at the post-Soviet states. There are many uniforms there that are similar. You can go to a store and buy any kind of uniform.
QUESTION: But were they Russian soldiers or not?
VLADIMIR PUTIN: Those were local self-defence units.
QUESTION: How well trained are they? If we compare them to the self-defence units in Kiev…
VLADIMIR PUTIN: My dear colleague, look how well trained the people who operated in Kiev were. As we all know they were trained at special bases in neighbouring states: in Lithuania, Poland and in Ukraine itself too. They were trained by instructors for extended periods. They were divided into dozens and hundreds, their actions were coordinated, they had good communication systems. It was all like clockwork.  Did you see them in action? They looked very professional, like special forces. Why do you think those in Crimea should be any worse?
QUESTION: In that case, can I specify: did we take part in training Crimean self-defence forces?
VLADIMIR PUTIN: No, we did not.
QUESTION: How do you see the future of Crimea? Do you consider the possibility of it joining Russia?
VLADIMIR PUTIN: No, we do not. Generally, I believe that only residents of a given country who have the freedom of will and are in complete safety can and should determine their future. If this right was granted to the Albanians in Kosovo, if this was made possible in many different parts of the world, then nobody has ruled out the right of nations to self-determination, which, as far as I know, is fixed by several UN documents.  However, we will in no way provoke any such decision and will not breed such sentiments.
I would like to stress that I believe only the people living in a given territory have the right to determine their own future.
To be continued.
This is another view to Fox News':


The Ukraine crisis: John Kerry and Nato must calm down and back off

The hysterical reaction to Russian military movements in Crimea won't help. Only Kiev can stop this crisis becoming a catastrophe

Both John Kerry's threats to expel Russia from the G8 and the Ukrainian government's plea for Nato aid mark a dangerous escalation of a crisis that can easily be contained if cool heads prevail. Hysteria seems to be the mood in Washington and Kiev, with the new Ukrainian prime minister claiming, "We are on the brink of disaster" as he calls up army reserves in response to Russian military movements in Crimea.
...


Kerry's rush to punish Russia and Nato's decision to respond to Kiev's call by holding a meeting of member states' ambassadors in Brussels today were mistakes. Ukraine is not part of the alliance, so none of the obligations of common defence come into play. Nato should refrain from interfering in Ukraine by word or deed. The fact that it insists on getting engaged reveals the elephant in the room: underlying the crisis in Crimea and Russia's fierce resistance to potential changes is Nato's undisguised ambition to continue two decades of expansion into what used to be called "post-Soviet space", led by Bill Clinton and taken up by successive administrations in Washington.

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/02/not-too-late-for-ukraine-nato-should-back-off

"Comrade Putin Explains It All."-Fox News.

The rhetoric is out of control. There is building a tsunami of rhetoric, as there was over Syria, for harsh measures against Russia. Tsunamis are hard to resist.
There was a report yesterday originating with official Kiev and given to Reuters: The Rooskis were coming. The Russian military had given Ukrainian forces a "surrender deadline" of 4 or 5 am local time, 10 pm Normal People Time. Naturally, the story flared intensely for a few hours and was picked up by googles of other news outlets. Official Washington had not heard of it and the Russians issued a denial, but nobody believes the Russians. The story turned out to be not true.

"Fears of anti-Semitism Spread in Ukraine."-World Policy Blog, March 3, 2014.

Could Europe witness its first pogrom against Jews since the 1940s? As Ukraine inches closer to civil war, the country’s Jewish population is growing anxious. Late last month, a Kiev rabbi made headlines when he urged his co-religionists to leave the country. A Ukrainian-born member of the U.S. Jewish advocacy group UJA Federation recently told me that his organization is monitoring the situation in Ukraine with great concern.

Cause for the anxiety is the rise of the Right Sector, a nationalist militant group crucial to President Viktor Yanukovych’s overthrow that now appears to hold great sway over the fragile Ukrainian government. Some members of the Right Sector are overt anti-Semites. Isolated beatings of Jews around Kiev’s independence square have already been reported. This weekend, the Right Sector called for its members to mobilize against a Russian intervention. The prospect of an armed, anti-Semitic mob in a largely lawless country should give everyone cause for alarm.
Simferopol, Ukraine (CNN) - Russia is not considering trying to make Crimea a part of Russia, Russian President Vladimir Putin said Tuesday. Only people who live in Crimea can determine their future, he said.
...
Putin said there was no need for the use of the military so far, and any use of military force would be the last resort.
...

Ordered back
Earlier Tuesday, about 150,000 Russian troops taking part in military exercises near the Ukrainian border were ordered back to their bases, but thousands of others remain in control of much of Crimea.
Putin ordered the troops' return after six days of snap exercises at Ukraine's doorstep. He said the exercises, which began Wednesday, were long planned and had nothing to do with events in Ukraine.
...
"Firstly, we have a request of the legitimate President Yanukovych to protect the welfare of the local  and anti-Semites in parts of Ukraine, including Kiev," Putin said.

...
"Of course people wanted change," Putin said of the protests in Kiev's Independence Square. "But [people] cannot impose illegal change ...you need to use only constitutional means."-Fox News.
...
"Why did they need to take unconstitutional steps and bring the country into the chaos that now reigns there?" Putin asked Tuesday,according to The Guardian.
...

There's Putin's Nazis/anti-Semites statement and there were reports earlier that these military exercises were pre-planned. All this is good for the overall situation in Ukraine. It is bad for the American beliefs on what is happening there. Has Official America overreacted here? Is it going to have to "walk back" some, all, of its rhetoric the last couple weeks?

Monday, March 03, 2014

"Ukraine Crisis: Does Russia Have a Case."-BBC

I have so little trust in the American government, my faith in the "narrative" on this thing is easily shaken. I only skimmed the BBC article.

What if Russia is right, in some sense, here? Russia had the solution to the Syrian crisis last summer. The Obama's had John "The Mouth" Kerry. How many Syrians killed by chemical wmd? What day is it? The Obamas hate Russia; Russia outmaneuvered Obama on Syria, out-maneuvered him on Egypt, humiliated him over Snowden, and Putin can't stand to be in the same room with Obama.

After the trouble-free Sochi Olympics, I almost wrote here of my doubts about the Americans pre-Olympic message, which was pretty uniform for awhile, that the Olympics were not safe. Then not long before the opening Obama announced that they were safe. I thought, after the fact, that Official America might have been out to get Russia with that pre-Olympic chatter, literally to spoil their party.

I have skim-read tonight something about "Far Right extremists" among the protesters in Ukraine, I read something a couple days ago about political anti-Semitism in Ukraine, and I recalled the Russian statements, nearly drowned out, calling the change of government a "coup" by "Nazis." What if they're right? Nah, I still trust America more.
I just read an article in The New York Times that early on used the term "Cold War" with respect to the current crisis in Ukraine. Curious, I scanned the article for other uses of the term and found one more.   I searched for "Cold War" on Google, under "news" and filtered the search for the last 24 hours:

19,304.

19,304 uses of the term "Cold War" in the news, in the last 24 hours. 

No. Friends and enemies, this is not the Cold War. It's just not. Maybe it's not that bad, I don't think it is, maybe it's worse, I doubt it, but better or worse, it's not the same. It just isn't. The Soviet Union, like, doesn't exist anymore. That's what's called a "fact." The Cold War was with the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union was communist. Russia is not communist. You can't have the Cold War without the communist Soviet Union. That's a fact, you just can't. I don't know if we, Official We, have to figure out what this is, beyond the obvious facts on the ground, an invasion of Ukraine by Russia, but if we do!, if we do have to figure out what this is beyond the obvious, these 19,000 news articles are not going to help us figure it out, they're going to get Us on the wrong track because this is never going to turn out to be the Cold War! Period, there...Exclamation point, rather. Paragraph. I am Benjamin Harris, this is Public Occurrences, and this is not the Cold War. Thank you. End of post.
Interesting: 16 pageviews from Ukraine right now, all fed from http://teplolidoma.ru/, about which I can find no information on Googs.
Hey: Germany's Angela Merkel has told Obama that in a phone conversation with Putin, the latter was "living in another world" and she wondered if Putin "was still in touch with reality." Nice to hear that. 

On China.

Dr. Mo sent the following article with this cover email:

Hi Ben,

Remember I mentioned the deeply-set racism in Chinese culture. Chinese rulers always believe no matter where you live, so long as you are ethnically Chinese, you should identify with me. Read the above article, you know what I mean.
Weimin


Gary Locke is the out-going U.S. Ambassador to China. This is from the official China News Service!

"...an extended comparison of Mr. Locke, a Chinese-American, to a banana.
“Gary Locke is a U.S.-born, third-generation Chinese-American, and his being a banana — ‘yellow skin and white heart’ — became an advantage for Obama’s foreign policy,’’ opened the commentary, written by a person identified as Wang Ping. (Many Asian-Americans consider “banana” an offensive term.) ["Many?" If an American called an Asian person a "banana"...there'd be a problem.]

“However,” the commentary continued, “after a while, a banana will inevitably start to rot.’’

The China News Service commentary also referred disparagingly to Mr. Locke’s dealings with the blind legal activist Chen Guangcheng, who sought shelter in the American embassy after escaping house arrest in 2012, calling him Mr. Chen’s “guide dog.” Mr. Chen was subsequently allowed to travel to the United States. [A "guide dog!" Insulting the blind, too! Unbelievable.]

I, of course, have never been the target of racism. I am "white." But this hurt me! I think because intellectually I know, as an American, how painful racism is to others. It's insulting, too, obviously, but my main reaction was hurt. Can you imagine what Chinese say about President Obama? I don't like to think about that. 



Wait a minute...

My goodness, it is a beautiful game. Vinnie, scram.

Whoo-wah, whoa-ah. More than one trophy at the Etihad yesterday.



Sporting News.


And now for the sporting news. In the beautiful game, God's Team of Righteous Angels in Blue won the "Capital One Cup," which sounds like a college tackle football bowl game...My God, it is a bowl game...by defeating the Sunderland "Black Cats," who nonetheless wear red and white vertical-striped sweaters that make them look like barber poles, 3-1. The bird hit the air pump when Captain Vincent Kompany raised the "Capital One Cup Trophy," as the thing fell apart. Vinnie, always an able defender, recovered quickly and secured the bottom to the rest of the trophy.

Sunday, March 02, 2014

Ukraine Has Not Yet Died.

These are unhe'pful:

The head of Ukraine's Navy has defected...to Russian-occupied Crimea!  They don't even have a government yet. Sheesh.

Germany's Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeir has come out--already--against expelling Russia from the G8. Thanks, Frank-Walter. Bitch.


Ukraine Has Not Yet Died.

United States Secretary of State John Kerry will go to Kiev on Tuesday as symbolic support. From the Sunday news shows in America: Note how many of the proposals here are symbolic, all are diplomatic or economic, none are military:

Kerry:

There are visa bans, asset freezes, isolation with respect to trade, investment. American businesses may well want to start thinking twice about whether they want to do business with a country that behaves like this. These are serious implications.”
...
Kerry said that he spoke Saturday with foreign ministers from the G-8 and other nations and that “every single one of them are prepared to go to the hilt in order to isolate Russia. They’re prepared to put sanctions in place,” he said. “They’re prepared to isolate Russia economically. The ruble is already going down. Russia has major economic challenges. I can’t imagine that an occupation of another country is something that appeals to a people who are trying to reach out to the world, and particularly if it involves violence.”
...
Kerry’s visit to Ukraine on Tuesday will be a diplomatic show of force that is unlikely to be matched with significant military action.
“The last thing anybody wants is a military option,” Kerry said. “We want a peaceful resolution through the normal processes of international relations.”
...
Republican Senator Marco Rubio:
“If you’re asking me whether the U.S. should be taking military strikes against Russian troops in Ukraine or in Crimea, I would argue to you that I don’t think anyone is arguing for that,” he said on NBC.
...
Sen. Lindsey O. Graham (R-S.C.) suggested suspending Russia’s membership in the G-8 for at least a year, “starting right now.”
“Let’s challenge him where we can,” Graham said of Putin.
...
China’s Foreign Ministry posted a statement on its Web site Sunday evening condemning what it called “recent acts of extreme violence in Ukraine.”
Spokesman Qin Gang urged “all parties concerned in Ukraine to resolve their internal dispute within the legal framework, and earnestly protect the legal rights and interests of all Ukrainian people to restore normal social order as soon as possible.”
...
Unlike in 2008, when Russian troops entered neighboring Georgia, there were no immediate signs that the United States or other nations were positioning military forces or equipment in response. The conflict with U.S.-backed Georgia, like Ukraine a former Soviet republic, brought U.S. relations with Moscow to a new low. Nearly eight years later, Russian troops remain in Georgia.

Ukraine Has Not Yet Died.

DAVID GREGORY:

But isn't it interesting that I heard the president say, "Look, we don't want to look at this like the Cold War." But isn't that how Vladimir Putin views all of this? Doesn't he look at this sphere of influence very much in a Cold War context?


SUSAN RICE:

He may. But if he does, that's a pretty dated perspective that doesn't reflect where the people of Ukraine are coming from. This is not about the U.S. and Russia, this is about whether the people of Ukraine have the opportunity to fulfill their aspirations and be democratic and be part of Europe, which they choose to be.

That is also from the February 23 NBC interview quoted in the last post. Do we notice the contradiction? That "this is not about the U.S. and Russia" but the Russian president "may" view the Ukraine crisis in a Cold War context? Putin was a KGB official in the Soviet Union. He has said that the breakup of the USSR was the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the 20th century. Think about that: In the 20th century, the geopolitical catastrophe that was the Soviet Union was born; the geopolitical catastrophe of World War I occurred, World War II, after which the geopolitical entity of Prussia was killed off, the geopolitical catastrophe of the People's Republic of China was born...That's enough, right? So, yeah Putin "may" view Ukraine from a Cold War perspective. 
Is Susan Rice truly in doubt about that? Is her boss, the Electrification Engineer for Africa? Are they thick to have made statements that the U.S. and Russia had shared interests in Ukraine or were they trying to convince themselves, and Putin. I believe it was the latter; they are not so thick as to believe truly the former. 
It was a mistake. It was a mistake for Susan Rice, Barack Obama, and the Minister of Talk, John Kerry, to make the argument of shared interests to the Russians, to these Russians.
The Obamas mistake has the patina of precedent; it is a rich patina, precedent. The precedent here is Bush43's (a lot of precedents are his) which makes its patina less rich.  Bush "looked into the eye" of Putin and saw a good man. Bush vouched for Putin, literally brought him into the club of Good Men, the G8. They, and their countries, were to be "partners" henceforth, not enemies in running the world. Bush made a mistake. Bush saw something in Putin's eyes that wasn't there. Uncannily, Ukraine is a reprise of Putin's 2008 dismemberment of Georgia, which Bush learned of at the Beijing Olympics. Bush now considers Putin "cold." Obama, the lazy constitutional law lecturer, knows well the power of precedent, even one whose patina looks less rich and more like just rust, and Obama tried to "reset" American-Russian relations. Then they met. Obama and Putin met and Obama couldn't look into Putin's eye because Putin was looking at the floor in boredom. Obama now considers Putin childish and Putin considers Obama weak.
But history is bunk, right? Henry Ford said that and we all like Ford trucks and what's the diff? What is the "cash value," we remember "cash value" from our studies of Pragmatism, what is the cash value of this historical precedent, whether rich or rusty? Here's Susan Rice again from that same interview:
SUSAN RICE:
"David, first of all, we have to be very pragmatic. [She's a pragmatist!] And President Obama has been exceedingly pragmatic [He's an exceeding pragmatist!] about our dealings with Russia. There are areas where we can cooperate with them." Viz, she then went on to viz, this is the viz part:

"But let's look at both sides of the ledger. [Looking at ledgers, tres pragmatique.]We have been able to reach a new and very important arms control agreement with them, The New Start Treaty. We've been able to cooperate on Afghanistan and Russia's role in enabling us to move our equipment and personnel in and out of Afghanistan. It's been very important. On Iran, we've actually been working together on the effort to use diplomacy to see if we can't obtain a nuclear agreement. They've been 
cooperative in that.
...

 "And yesterday, because of U.S. leadership and that of other partners, we were able, for the first time, to get a resolution in the United Nations Security Council that binds the Syrian government to allow humanitarian assistance in."
Well, I think that is a pretty impressive viz! If we ask ourselves a related question to "What's the diff?," if we ask ourselves a question also with a rich patina of precedent, "Are we better off now than  we were during the real Cold War?," the answer is "Are you fucking stupid, of course we are!" The world is better off, America is better off, Russia is better off. That is, Susan Rice is right, Barack Obama is right: War, Cold or hot, is interactive, you cannot war without a "partner." The Obamas are right to refuse to engage with Russia over Putin's Cold War real war on Ukraine. They are right that this is not about the U.S. and Russia. "Pragmatism explains everything..." Louis Menand wrote. It explains this, it gives guidance on Ukraine. The U.S. and the world should "cost" Russia for this naked aggression but it should not cost Russia back into the Cold War.

"...except what a man is to die for," was Menand's conclusion to that sentence. The Obamas pragmatism does not, of course, explain why Ukraine must die. "But it must," is the honest, agonized, brutal answer that Pragmatism, the Obamas, and I give. I am Benjamin Harris.

Saturday, March 01, 2014

Ukraine Has Not Yet Died.

 "This is not about the U.S. and Russia."
...
"From the U.S. point of view, our interest had been clear all along.  We want to see a de-escalation of violence.  We want to see constitutional change.  We want to see democratic elections...The United States is on the side of the Ukrainian people."
...
On a Russian invasion:"That would be a grave mistake.  It's not in the interests of Ukrainian (sic) or of Russia or of Europe or the United States to see the country split."-U.S. National Security Adviser Susan Rice, February 23.

"I also spoke several days ago with President Putin, and my administration has been in daily communication with Russian officials, and we've made clear that they can be part of an international community’s effort to support the stability and success of a united Ukraine going forward, which is not only in the interest of the people of Ukraine and the international community, but also in Russia’s interest."
...
"[T]he United States will stand with the international community in affirming that there will be costs for any military intervention in Ukraine."-President Barack Obama, February 28.

"Russia and the West both have legitimate interests in Ukraine and its future."-The New York Times Editorial Board, February 28.

Russia has now invaded. Rice, Obama and the Times therefore have been proved wrong that "both" the U.S. and Russia have an interest against Russian invasion.

The only U.S. interest in Ukraine is contained in Ambassador Rice's second quoted statement above. "Interest"  is so vague, so broad that it provides no guidance to action. Nor, for the same reason, is it sufficient. Even Rice's very specific "democratic elections" is not sufficient. It was not sufficient for President Franklin Roosevelt--or the West--during Adolph Hitler's electoral ascent to power in Germany; it was not sufficient for President Barack Obama in Mohammad Morsi's electoral ascent to power in Egypt

The United States is not contemplating any military action, even indirect, against Russia for it's military seizure of Ukrainian Crimea. Therefore, for the U.S. National Security Adviser, the President of the United States, even The New York Times, to state, or imply by virtue of the positions they hold, that the consideration for U.S. action here is U.S. "interest" is dangerous and wrong. The touchstone for the American National Security Adviser to say that another country's action would be a "grave mistake" is when American national security, not interest, would be threatened. Coming from the National Security Adviser, "grave mistake" strongly implies military action.

United States national security is not threatened by Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Therefore, American military action is not being considered. The rhetoric at this level should match, not exceed the stakes. Russian interest in Ukraine is deeper in almost every way than is America's.

On an issue with some similarities to that with Ukraine, I have been proved wrong myself previously. I was proved wrong in believing, truly believing, that Susan Rice, Barack Obama, The New York Times, official and semi-official America, wanted what Rice said above on Ukraine for the people of Egypt. I believe that those aforementioned want what Rice said they want for Ukraine. That interest, in a free, secure Ukraine, is the only interest America has which exceeds Russia's interest. This hideous action by Russia is in keeping with what most of America, official and unofficial, thinks of Russia. I believe that Obama is right that there should be costs to Russia for this outrage, and that those costs should be imposed by the U.S. working with the international community.

I am Benjamin Harris and this is Public Occurrences.

Ukraine Has Not Yet Died.

Russia has successfully invaded and is now in control of Crimea.
May God keep the people of Ukraine.
Twenty-seven people were murdered today at a train station in China by a "knife-wielding mob." That's a lot of people in one attack. Knife attacks are common in China. We use guns or bombs in the U.S. We're more "advanced."

Ukraine Has Not Yet Died.

The Federation Council, the upper chamber of Russia's legislature, has voted to send troops to the Ukrainian Crimea.

Friday, February 28, 2014

Ukraine Has Not Yet Died.

Ukraine's glory has not yet died, nor her freedom,
Upon us, fellow compatriots, fate shall smile once more.
Our enemies will vanish, like dew in the morning sun,
And we too shall rule, brothers, in a free land of our own.
CHORUS x2
Souls and bodies we'll lay down, all for our freedom,
And we will show that we, brothers, are of the Cossack nation!

Ukraine Has Not Yet Died.

Russian troops have entered Ukraine at the Crimean peninsula. I heard an interview with Khruschev's daughter today. Asked if she thought Russia would invade she said she did, that where there are Russian tanks Russian troops are not far behind. God damn it.
One time, somebody wrote to me with a picture attached to the email and asked, "Is this you, Ben?" Below are all photographs of "Benjamin Harris:"

I've cut way back on my heroin use since this.

I have recovered from my heart attack since this.

I've lost weight since this.

Shaved since this.

Cut my hair since this.

My anti-social personality test score is lower since this.


I guess this was too easy. Here I am with the lovely CCC.
Speaking of Muslims, you never know when Mohammad is going to rear his ugly head again and murder innocent civilians, so it has been my practice over the years to gratuitously, randomly, and preemptively insult Islam. So:

Islam, you SUCK!
Mohammad was a paranoid schizophrenic.
Innocence of Muslims is my favorite movie of ALL-TIME!
Kurt Westergaard is my favorite political cartoonist of ALL-TIME.
Your civilization, political ideas, morality, not to mention your concepts of personal hygiene, are stuck in the 10th century.

Oh, and it's Friday!  Your holy day. Happy Sabbath.