In Beijing: Hu-bris
As this is being written, in an internet cafe southeast of Tianamen Square, Zhao Yan, a New York Times researcher, is awaiting a verdict on bogus leak charges because the Chinese communist government and President Hu Jintao didn't like his reporting on unrest in the countryside.
Times op-ed writer Nicholas D. Kristoff reported on Zhao's "trial" yesterday, the same day that I posted a positive--and accurate, as I saw it--series of impressions on Beijing. That post concluded with a series of questions: Should America be exporting liberal democracy and capitalism? Are the rights which we take to be "self-evident," universal human rights, or just universal American rights?
Walking back to the hotel last night I thought, as I always do in a foreign country, of--to me--the most nettlesome of the costs of the freedoms that we enjoy in America, violent crime. People are more safe, far more safe, in Beijing than in Washington or New York. You can feel it as you walk the streets. Likewise in Cuba. Because of energy shortages Cuba is without lights after dark. Still you feel safe.
When I got back to my hotel room a copy of The International Herald Tribune was at my doorstep and I read Mr. Kristoff's op-ed piece. He properly criticized China and President Hu for recent crackdowns on religious expression, press censorship, as exemplified by Zhao's plight and the lack of a right to a fair trial, as exemplified by Zhao's plight.
However the answers to the questions posed at the end of my previous post remained, for me, unclear. Let's clear the ground of the underbrush of shibboleths, straw men, and scarecrows. With Mr. Kristoff I share these self-evident wishes:
(1) the wish that Mr. Zhao were not imprisoned
(2) the wish that he and all others in China could get a fair criminal trial
(3) the wish that there was greater freedom of speech and religion in China
These areas of agreement do not go very far in answering the questions posed yesterday.
Economists use a standard "basket of goods" as an effective, easy-to-understand measure of a country's economic welfare, and to facilitate comparisons among countries.
A similar, clearly less precise (but that's the point) basket of human desiderata can be created. The American constitution fills our basket up pretty high with the "rights" family of products- speech, religion, presumption of innocence, vote-and the result is, in my personal opinion, the greatest society on earth and the greatest society that ever was.
However it simply is not true that these are the rights and in their proportion that every society and every human being in those societies would put in their basket of human desiderata.
There is also no, or not much, flexibility in the American rights. I have them, and to their fullest extent, and you have them and to their fullest extent. So I can write a lot of hurtful things about you and there's almost nothing that you can do about it.
To continue the economic analogy, Gresham's law, that bad money drives out good money, roughly applies to America's rights as well. I own no television or radio because there's so much "bad currency" there. I have voluntarily diminished my right to that speech.
A lot of Americans, myself included, would be open to the diminution of some of our rights in return for more of some others, like greater freedom from violent crime. A much repeated quote from one of the Founding Fathers has it that "it is better that 100 guilty men go free than one innocent man be convicted." Several years ago The New Yorker published a cartoon of two middle-aged white men walking down the street, conversing. The caption read "Better that 100 guilty men go free than one innocent man be convicted? Who the hell came up with that nonsense!"
American society would not be diminished if I were prohibited from publishing this blog. It would be if I, or anyone else, were murdered.
Americans joke that our basket of freedoms include the right to be poor, homeless, and jobless, and mugged. These negative "rights" are not mutually exclusive with the positive rights but some do tend to run counter to the enjoyment of others. There are hard trade-offs.
A couple of things that Mr. Kristoff wrote were particularly grating from the perspective of this American. He wrote that,
"China now imprisons 32 journalists...And yes, [Zhao's case] is personal."
There is hubris there, that imprisoning innocent journalists is worse than imprisoning innocent coal miners, factory workers or anybody else. There is a belief among some Americans, including this one, that some in the American press are arrogant, self-important and put one freedom, the one that pays their bills, ahead of all the others.
It is also hubris that Zhao's case is "personal" to Mr. Kristoff, as if whether it's personal to him has greater significance than it not being personal to someone else.
"Most Chinese...Are fed up with corruption and lies, with being blocked from Google and Wikipedia..."
Being blocked from Google and Wikipedia??? Oh yeah, I bet those are front-burner issues for "most Chinese." That statement by Mr. Kristoff is Gresham's law at work. There is absolutely no basis for it. Just a week ago Mr. Kristoff's newspaper published the results of a Pew survey on the attitudes of peoples of different countries toward their governments. Eighty percent of Chinese people were reported satisfied with their government. I don't know for an absolute certainty but I would wager a lot that that satisfaction has to do with China's astonishing economic expansion in the last 25 years, a performance that Mr. Kristoff acknowledges and gives President Hu his share of credit for.
I do not believe that Mr. Zhao's case is personal to very many Chinese people, the few who have heard of him, and what's personal to them is at least as important as what's personal to Nicholas D. Kristoff. I would bet that what's personal to the Chinese people is the better economic life that President Hu and the Chinese government have provided them in the last 30 years and the hope of a better life for their children. I would bet that that economic growth which has lifted 250 million Chinese out of a total of 1.3 billion out of poverty in that time period is what is personal to them.*
There is hubris, too much hubris, to Mr. Kristoff and there is too much hubris in America today. Americans have always had a becoming streak of modesty in their national character. We don't claim we're always right, we don't claim we are better than others, we don't claim that we're some god's, "chosen people," we didn't invent ludicrously sweeping philosophies like communism or socialism, and rejected attempts to plant them in our soil.
Let's keep that modest, self-concious streak in our national personality alive. Is our way the best way? Works for me. Is it the "Universal" way? Whoa there man, I just work here. Let's just keep the conversation going about whether it works for everybody else. This is Public Occurrences.
*Smaller Real Regional Income Gap than Nominal Income Gap: A Price-adjusted Study, Xiaojuan Jiang, Hui Li, in China & World Economy, Institute of World Economics and Politics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, Volume 14 No. 3, May-June 2006.
Tuesday, June 20, 2006
Monday, June 19, 2006
In Beijing: Freedoms
In Beijing: Freedoms
It is very hard to visit a "second world" country these days, that world having all but disappeared with the collapse of the Soviet Union. The P.R.C. is one of the few left. Cuba is another.
China (more precisely Beijing) does not feel second world, Cuba (Santiago, Barracoa) did. Beijing is so...up-to-date: airport modern, clean, and user-friendly; taxis omnipresent, modern and clean, inside and out; skyline crowded with robust glass and concrete office buildings. Beijing is efficient and well-organized. Beijing works.
Cuba was old, decaying, unpainted and held together with chewing gum and twine. Inefficient does not begin to describe Cuba. If "antithesis" is stronger than "synonymous," then Cuba was the antithesis of efficient. If there was an inefficient way of doing something that's how Cuba did it and if there wasn't one they invented it.
So many glass and concrete buildings-office buildings in Beijing, business buildings, banks. Banks in a Communist country? No banks worthy of the name in Cuba. China is now communist in government only. It is not communist economically. Capitalism is roaring here. There is petit capitalism, corporate capitalism, multi-national capitalism. If there's a capitalist way of doing things that's how Beijingers (that's what they call them) do it and if there isn't they will invent it.
Beijingers are busy. They work earnestly and hard. There is no work in Cuba and people are bored. There is real rush in Beijing's rush hour. Santiago de Cuba at 8 a.m. or 5:30 p.m. was the same as Santiago de Cuba at 8 p.m. or 5:30 a.m.
Beijingers work, not just some of them and not just those who work for the government. They work like they work in America, in businesses, the service industries, technology companies. They are smartly dressed, they're on their cell phones, they're hustling and bustling.
"The State" is no more visible in everyday life in Beijing than it is in Washington, D.C. There are no posters or billboards of Mao or of the Communist Party, none of those ominous and darkly humorous billboards trumpeting the glories of communism that were everywhere during the Cultural Revolution--people holding little red books aloft, eyes aglow looking to the bright future and Dentyne white smiles.
There is none of that in Beijing. There are billboards, for Lexus automobiles, Nike, McDonald's and KFC. In Cuba there were no commercial billboards, few billboards at all but those there were were of Fidel, Raul, or Che.
Read an article in Smithsonian magazine before leaving for China. It said there was dissatisfaction with the government and unrest just below the surface. Upon arrival my impression was the opposite. Then a day or two later read an article in the International Herald Tribune, a Pew poll showing that 80% of Chinese are happy with their government. Appears there's a lot to be happy with.
What does that say about democracy and our (America's) efforts to export it, indeed to demand it? During the Cold War, conservatives used to make a very plausible sounding distinction between authoritarian and totalitarian forms of government. The former, like Pinochet's Chile, were worthy of our support; capitalism could exist in authoritarian countries and those countries could easily transition from authoritarianism to democracy. Totalitarian forms of government like communism could do neither. Well, China is totalitarian politically but capitalist economically.
Then, after the end of the Cold War, Francis Fukuyama wrote that history itself had ended with liberal democracy's triumph over it's last foe, communism. Democracy was a universal human condition. Where it didn't exist was abberational and temporal. Further, like the conservatives earlier, Fukuyama argued that by their natures democracy and capitalism go together, you can't have one without the other. Well, the Chinese are doing it.
I believe it was Samuel Huntington who rejoined to Fukuyama that America's liberal democracy/capitalism was not universal, it was unique. So should we be trying to plant it in all kinds of soil and climate? Should we be demanding human rights compliance of other countries? Are they "Human" rights, or American rights?
-Benjamin Harris
It is very hard to visit a "second world" country these days, that world having all but disappeared with the collapse of the Soviet Union. The P.R.C. is one of the few left. Cuba is another.
China (more precisely Beijing) does not feel second world, Cuba (Santiago, Barracoa) did. Beijing is so...up-to-date: airport modern, clean, and user-friendly; taxis omnipresent, modern and clean, inside and out; skyline crowded with robust glass and concrete office buildings. Beijing is efficient and well-organized. Beijing works.
Cuba was old, decaying, unpainted and held together with chewing gum and twine. Inefficient does not begin to describe Cuba. If "antithesis" is stronger than "synonymous," then Cuba was the antithesis of efficient. If there was an inefficient way of doing something that's how Cuba did it and if there wasn't one they invented it.
So many glass and concrete buildings-office buildings in Beijing, business buildings, banks. Banks in a Communist country? No banks worthy of the name in Cuba. China is now communist in government only. It is not communist economically. Capitalism is roaring here. There is petit capitalism, corporate capitalism, multi-national capitalism. If there's a capitalist way of doing things that's how Beijingers (that's what they call them) do it and if there isn't they will invent it.
Beijingers are busy. They work earnestly and hard. There is no work in Cuba and people are bored. There is real rush in Beijing's rush hour. Santiago de Cuba at 8 a.m. or 5:30 p.m. was the same as Santiago de Cuba at 8 p.m. or 5:30 a.m.
Beijingers work, not just some of them and not just those who work for the government. They work like they work in America, in businesses, the service industries, technology companies. They are smartly dressed, they're on their cell phones, they're hustling and bustling.
"The State" is no more visible in everyday life in Beijing than it is in Washington, D.C. There are no posters or billboards of Mao or of the Communist Party, none of those ominous and darkly humorous billboards trumpeting the glories of communism that were everywhere during the Cultural Revolution--people holding little red books aloft, eyes aglow looking to the bright future and Dentyne white smiles.
There is none of that in Beijing. There are billboards, for Lexus automobiles, Nike, McDonald's and KFC. In Cuba there were no commercial billboards, few billboards at all but those there were were of Fidel, Raul, or Che.
Read an article in Smithsonian magazine before leaving for China. It said there was dissatisfaction with the government and unrest just below the surface. Upon arrival my impression was the opposite. Then a day or two later read an article in the International Herald Tribune, a Pew poll showing that 80% of Chinese are happy with their government. Appears there's a lot to be happy with.
What does that say about democracy and our (America's) efforts to export it, indeed to demand it? During the Cold War, conservatives used to make a very plausible sounding distinction between authoritarian and totalitarian forms of government. The former, like Pinochet's Chile, were worthy of our support; capitalism could exist in authoritarian countries and those countries could easily transition from authoritarianism to democracy. Totalitarian forms of government like communism could do neither. Well, China is totalitarian politically but capitalist economically.
Then, after the end of the Cold War, Francis Fukuyama wrote that history itself had ended with liberal democracy's triumph over it's last foe, communism. Democracy was a universal human condition. Where it didn't exist was abberational and temporal. Further, like the conservatives earlier, Fukuyama argued that by their natures democracy and capitalism go together, you can't have one without the other. Well, the Chinese are doing it.
I believe it was Samuel Huntington who rejoined to Fukuyama that America's liberal democracy/capitalism was not universal, it was unique. So should we be trying to plant it in all kinds of soil and climate? Should we be demanding human rights compliance of other countries? Are they "Human" rights, or American rights?
-Benjamin Harris
Thursday, June 08, 2006
Things that You'll Like and that are Good for You Too

Thing that You'll Like and that are Good for You Too.
Women's shoes by Cesare Paciotti. This is Public Occurrences.
Friday, June 02, 2006
Cesare Paciotti Shoes
Cesare Paciotti Shoes
Cesare Paciotti makes today's most striking haute couture women's shoes.
Paciotti's stiletto logo is design brilliance. Simplicity in appearance is key to brand identification and the stiletto is immediately identifiable. By contrast, Etro, which makes wonderfully creative mens and womens wear has a busy flying horse logo that is impossible to identify from a distance and difficult even upclose.
The Paciotti logo combines simplicity in appearance with the stiletto's symbolic power, danger and mystery. It is perfect symbolism for today's fashionable woman.
Paciotti adds to the logo's allure by unpredictable and unusual placement. Sometimes the stiletto is on the front near the tip, sometimes it's on the back, sometimes on the side, in one style it is on a brightly colored shoe bottom.
Paciotti sometimes displays the stiletto simply and discreetly, other times more prominently, for example in Svaroski crystals, other times boldly and dramatically, attached to a chain which swings with the step.
Even the most humble part of the shoe, the bottom, is brought into the whole design presentation. Paciotti seems to be defiantly resistent to predictability. As with the different manners of presentation of the stiletto, some--but not all--of his shoes have brightly colored bottoms. This idea is not unique to Paciotti, at least one other manufacturer does it, but it is so unusual and the colors so vivid as to make the shoe impossibly eye-catching. The eye is drawn to the color, the stiletto, the whole shoe, the ankle, the leg and ultimately the woman. Which is the point of the best fashion.
-Benjamin Harris
public occurrences
Cesare Paciotti makes today's most striking haute couture women's shoes.
Paciotti's stiletto logo is design brilliance. Simplicity in appearance is key to brand identification and the stiletto is immediately identifiable. By contrast, Etro, which makes wonderfully creative mens and womens wear has a busy flying horse logo that is impossible to identify from a distance and difficult even upclose.
The Paciotti logo combines simplicity in appearance with the stiletto's symbolic power, danger and mystery. It is perfect symbolism for today's fashionable woman.
Paciotti adds to the logo's allure by unpredictable and unusual placement. Sometimes the stiletto is on the front near the tip, sometimes it's on the back, sometimes on the side, in one style it is on a brightly colored shoe bottom.
Paciotti sometimes displays the stiletto simply and discreetly, other times more prominently, for example in Svaroski crystals, other times boldly and dramatically, attached to a chain which swings with the step.
Even the most humble part of the shoe, the bottom, is brought into the whole design presentation. Paciotti seems to be defiantly resistent to predictability. As with the different manners of presentation of the stiletto, some--but not all--of his shoes have brightly colored bottoms. This idea is not unique to Paciotti, at least one other manufacturer does it, but it is so unusual and the colors so vivid as to make the shoe impossibly eye-catching. The eye is drawn to the color, the stiletto, the whole shoe, the ankle, the leg and ultimately the woman. Which is the point of the best fashion.
-Benjamin Harris
Thursday, June 01, 2006
"Some Look at the World and Ask 'Why?' Some Look at the World and Ask 'Why Not?' "
"Some Look at the World and Ask 'Why?" Others Look at the World and ask, 'Why Not?'"*
Combine the State and Defense Departments.
Currently, State is the department of diplomacy, Defense the department of the military. That builds in bureaucratic conflict internally and produces mixed messages sent abroad.
-Benjamin Harris
*See also October 19, 2003
Combine the State and Defense Departments.
Currently, State is the department of diplomacy, Defense the department of the military. That builds in bureaucratic conflict internally and produces mixed messages sent abroad.
-Benjamin Harris
*See also October 19, 2003
Wednesday, May 31, 2006
The Beginning
The Beginnning
The San Fransisco Earthquate started at precisely 5:12 a.m.
The Titantic stuck the iceberg at precisely one time.
Hitler wrote that his anti-semitism began with one encounter on one day with one Jew in Vienna.*
The AIDS virus has been connected to one man who gave a blood sample in the Congo in 1959.
A person is killed by a cancer that begins at a specific moment with the first mutating cell at.
There is a compulsion to know The Beginnning because of human-kind's need for meaning. It is the rational's need for an explanation of the unexplainable.
Knowing The Beginning is the ultimate starting point in that process. But knowing The Beginnning does not provide meaning. It is the morbid result of the rational process's reductio gone absurdum. The rational is beguiling, it does not provide meaning.
The Big One would have struck San Francisco sometime. AIDS would have made the primate leap in 1960 or 1961. Hitler's anti-semitism would have started sometime.
But they didn't. They struck when they did and we obsess on those moments because we confuse but/for-often random-occurrences with cause and that is a fault of the age of rationality.
-Benjamin Harris
The San Fransisco Earthquate started at precisely 5:12 a.m.
The Titantic stuck the iceberg at precisely one time.
Hitler wrote that his anti-semitism began with one encounter on one day with one Jew in Vienna.*
The AIDS virus has been connected to one man who gave a blood sample in the Congo in 1959.
A person is killed by a cancer that begins at a specific moment with the first mutating cell at.
There is a compulsion to know The Beginnning because of human-kind's need for meaning. It is the rational's need for an explanation of the unexplainable.
Knowing The Beginning is the ultimate starting point in that process. But knowing The Beginnning does not provide meaning. It is the morbid result of the rational process's reductio gone absurdum. The rational is beguiling, it does not provide meaning.
The Big One would have struck San Francisco sometime. AIDS would have made the primate leap in 1960 or 1961. Hitler's anti-semitism would have started sometime.
But they didn't. They struck when they did and we obsess on those moments because we confuse but/for-often random-occurrences with cause and that is a fault of the age of rationality.
-Benjamin Harris
Monday, May 15, 2006
Eastern Thought/Western Thought
Eastern Thought/Western Thought
"It is not truth that makes man great, but man that makes truth great."
-Confucius
"Truth happens to an idea. It becomes true, is made true by events."
-William James
"It is not truth that makes man great, but man that makes truth great."
-Confucius
"Truth happens to an idea. It becomes true, is made true by events."
-William James
Friday, May 12, 2006
Ideas That Make You Want to Slap Yourself on the Forehead and Go "WOW!": LifeStraw
*Ideas That Make You Want to Slap Yourself on the Forehead and Go "Wow!": LifeStraw
LifeStraw is a product made by a company of the same name that filters drinking water of waterborne diseases, thus potentially saving millions of lives a year. As pictured on ABCNEWS website the product is a tube that appears to be about the size of a recorder.
Users can drink contaminated water through it because it is lined with disease-killing filters. The filters remain active through about 700 liters of water or a year or more of normal human water intake.
A single LifeStraw sells for about $3.50, "the mere price of a frappuccino at Starbucks," in the words of ABC. That sounds too much for impoverished nations to pay in the quantities needed. Maybe the price could be cut with mass purchases or maybe the United Nations could chip in to buy them.
ABC also reports that LifeStraw was one of Time's Best Inventions of 2005.
-Benjamin Harris
*See also "Cisterns," 3-15-05.
LifeStraw is a product made by a company of the same name that filters drinking water of waterborne diseases, thus potentially saving millions of lives a year. As pictured on ABCNEWS website the product is a tube that appears to be about the size of a recorder.
Users can drink contaminated water through it because it is lined with disease-killing filters. The filters remain active through about 700 liters of water or a year or more of normal human water intake.
A single LifeStraw sells for about $3.50, "the mere price of a frappuccino at Starbucks," in the words of ABC. That sounds too much for impoverished nations to pay in the quantities needed. Maybe the price could be cut with mass purchases or maybe the United Nations could chip in to buy them.
ABC also reports that LifeStraw was one of Time's Best Inventions of 2005.
-Benjamin Harris
*See also "Cisterns," 3-15-05.
Saturday, May 06, 2006
Lin Yutang
Lin Yutang
"I have always assumed that the end of living is the true enjoyment of it."
"What can be the end of human life except the enjoyment of it?"
Under the chapter subtitle MAN THE ONLY WORKING ANIMAL:
"...if a jungle beast were let loose in a city and gained some apprehension of what busy human life was all about,he would feel a good deal of skepticism and bewilderment about this human society."*
..."Even domestic pets don't have to work...a house dog...takes a nap in the morning...the aristocratic cat...just goes wherever it likes to go. So, then, we have this toiling humanity alone, caged and domesticated...forced by this civilization and society to work..."
"...I cannot believe that, with the coming of better material conditions of life [The Importance of Living was written in 1937], when diseases are eliminated, poverty is decreased and man's expectation of life is prolonged and food is plentiful, man will care to be as busy as he is today."
------
Such fun writing, and so insightful, but the life of leisure that Lin predicted did not come to pass and it's absence is widely regretted. Not here.
A full life is a life full of work. Lin is right that a purposeful life is purposeless, that wealth, status, fame, and power are not what life is about.
Life is about effort.** That is perfectly consistent with Taoism, that there is no destination only journey, that the journey is the destination. But it also goes beyond Taoism's endorsement of a life of leisure, of a species of "loafers," in Lin's word.
We must try because we can.
The brain is not all that there is to mankind, as Lin says, but it is a part of us. Most obviously, our brain allows--forces--us to realize one, that there are many aspects of the world as we find it that are...harsh, and two, that we can change the world as no other species can and sometimes make it better.
Our realization that we can effect change also makes us as normative beings. When we choose one course of conduct we are also not choosing others. We are making value judgments. Later, we can reflect on those choices and the values that informed them, and make the same or different choices next time around.
Most to the point of this disagreement with Lin is the elevation of man's spirit that comes from effort alone. Why climb Everest? "Because it is there," famously answered George Mallory. That answer stuck with people because it went to Anglo-American man's Tao of work: Effort.
* "Body and Soul," Public Occurrences, 10-18-02.
** "The Importance of Being Earnest," Publocc, 10-6-02.
-Benjamin Harris
"I have always assumed that the end of living is the true enjoyment of it."
"What can be the end of human life except the enjoyment of it?"
Under the chapter subtitle MAN THE ONLY WORKING ANIMAL:
"...if a jungle beast were let loose in a city and gained some apprehension of what busy human life was all about,he would feel a good deal of skepticism and bewilderment about this human society."*
..."Even domestic pets don't have to work...a house dog...takes a nap in the morning...the aristocratic cat...just goes wherever it likes to go. So, then, we have this toiling humanity alone, caged and domesticated...forced by this civilization and society to work..."
"...I cannot believe that, with the coming of better material conditions of life [The Importance of Living was written in 1937], when diseases are eliminated, poverty is decreased and man's expectation of life is prolonged and food is plentiful, man will care to be as busy as he is today."
------
Such fun writing, and so insightful, but the life of leisure that Lin predicted did not come to pass and it's absence is widely regretted. Not here.
A full life is a life full of work. Lin is right that a purposeful life is purposeless, that wealth, status, fame, and power are not what life is about.
Life is about effort.** That is perfectly consistent with Taoism, that there is no destination only journey, that the journey is the destination. But it also goes beyond Taoism's endorsement of a life of leisure, of a species of "loafers," in Lin's word.
We must try because we can.
The brain is not all that there is to mankind, as Lin says, but it is a part of us. Most obviously, our brain allows--forces--us to realize one, that there are many aspects of the world as we find it that are...harsh, and two, that we can change the world as no other species can and sometimes make it better.
Our realization that we can effect change also makes us as normative beings. When we choose one course of conduct we are also not choosing others. We are making value judgments. Later, we can reflect on those choices and the values that informed them, and make the same or different choices next time around.
Most to the point of this disagreement with Lin is the elevation of man's spirit that comes from effort alone. Why climb Everest? "Because it is there," famously answered George Mallory. That answer stuck with people because it went to Anglo-American man's Tao of work: Effort.
* "Body and Soul," Public Occurrences, 10-18-02.
** "The Importance of Being Earnest," Publocc, 10-6-02.
-Benjamin Harris
Friday, May 05, 2006
Homeward Bound
Homeward Bound
Ah, homeward bound I go! Let me now on learn to live alone! The world and I are not made for one another, and why drive round like one looking for what he has not found?
-T'ao Yuanming
Ah, homeward bound I go! Let me now on learn to live alone! The world and I are not made for one another, and why drive round like one looking for what he has not found?
-T'ao Yuanming
Wednesday, May 03, 2006
True Crime Stories: Winning-Losing, Life-Death
True Crime Stories: Winning-Losing, Life-Death
The interview was over and I shook hands with the prisoner/witness and started to leave the long interview room.
"Hey," he called to me as I got to the door. I turned around.
"I know you're a professional but, if you lose this trial, you know I'm a dead man."
"I know," I said, knowing.
-Benjamin Harris
PUBLIC OCCURRENCES
The interview was over and I shook hands with the prisoner/witness and started to leave the long interview room.
"Hey," he called to me as I got to the door. I turned around.
"I know you're a professional but, if you lose this trial, you know I'm a dead man."
"I know," I said, knowing.
-Benjamin Harris
Tuesday, May 02, 2006
Lin Yutang
Lin Yutang
"The Chinese as a nation are more philosophic [meaning here, easy-going] than efficient, and that if it were otherwise, no nation could have survived the high blood pressure of an efficient life for four thousand years."
The Importance of Living.
In previous posts* I have begun an attempt at comparison between art and science in the West and in China. I noted that China is the world's most continuously great civilization, that is it has never fallen into relative insignificance as have the Egyptian, Greek and Roman. Lin writes humorously as the above quote indicates, but also seriously, as the above quote indicates.
Maybe that is why the Chinese have remained continuously great.
*10-4-05, 9-27-05, 9-15-05, 9-5-05.
-Benjamin Harris
"The Chinese as a nation are more philosophic [meaning here, easy-going] than efficient, and that if it were otherwise, no nation could have survived the high blood pressure of an efficient life for four thousand years."
The Importance of Living.
In previous posts* I have begun an attempt at comparison between art and science in the West and in China. I noted that China is the world's most continuously great civilization, that is it has never fallen into relative insignificance as have the Egyptian, Greek and Roman. Lin writes humorously as the above quote indicates, but also seriously, as the above quote indicates.
Maybe that is why the Chinese have remained continuously great.
*10-4-05, 9-27-05, 9-15-05, 9-5-05.
-Benjamin Harris
Saturday, April 29, 2006
John Kenneth Galbraith Died Today
John Kenneth Galbraith Died Today
Such a wonderful, generous-spirited man. His economics will be debated but never his heart. A Canadian who immigrated to America and enriched our country as many others have but none more. God bless him. This is Public Occurrences.
Such a wonderful, generous-spirited man. His economics will be debated but never his heart. A Canadian who immigrated to America and enriched our country as many others have but none more. God bless him. This is Public Occurrences.
On Lin Yutang
Modesty is a great virtue when dealing with immodest challenges, like War, and Philosophy. Americans are modest; Pragmatism, the homegrown American philosophy is modest; Metaphysics, European, is not.
However, modesty must not be failure to act. The Swiss fail to act. Americans do not fail to act.
Modesty is a great virtue when dealing with immodest challenges, like War, and Philosophy. Americans are modest; Pragmatism, the homegrown American philosophy is modest; Metaphysics, European, is not.
However, modesty must not be failure to act. The Swiss fail to act. Americans do not fail to act.
Friday, April 28, 2006
Lin Yutang
"I should have liked also to write the entire book in the form of a dialogue like Plato's."
...
"I do not mean answers and questions like newspaper interviews...I mean really good, long, leisurely discourses..."
"...with many detours, coming back to the original point of discusion by a short cut at the most unexpected spot,..."
"...like a man returning home by climbing over a hedge...Oh, how I love to reach home by climbing over the back fence, and to travel bypaths!"
...
"The [Eastern] ideas expressed here...are hackneyed truths there...nevertheless...they have become a part of my being."..."when I first encountered them, my heart gave an instinctive assent."
...
"If one is too well-read, then one does not know right is right and wrong is wrong."
I believe that that is often true. In the work of some great thinkers there is a remove from right and wrong: in Marx for example killing comes too easily. It is almost as if they are so intellectually above the surface, where everyone else is, that they are beyond good and evil. Nietzsche too? Or like Richard Rorty: such a sensible, modest, American, philosophy. But he got excoriated for seeming to deny that slavery is, always was, and always will be morally wrong. In a footnote, he simply asserted the eternal evil of slavery, not connecting it to his philosophy.
...
"I have not read Locke or Hume or Berkeley, and have not taken a college course in philosophy." ..."Some of my sources are:...a Shanghai street car conductor...a squirrel in Central Park..."
Is Lin going to turn out to be twee? One can, or at least Chinese One's can, gain insight from non-human...things, like squirrels or sunsets. The intellectual tradition of the West is so, so limited by concentration on the mind's abilities. It is fetishitic.
...
"Thus deprived of academic training in philosophy, I am less scared to write a book about it [i.e. philosophy]."
That seems very wise. Philosophy must be a daunting subject to write about.
...
"Courage seems to be the rarest of all virtues in a modern philosopher."
That is a very insightful, very true observation.
...
"But I have always wandered outside the precincts of philosophy and that gives me courage."
At first read that is a thrilling sentence but is it that those inside philosophy cannot have courage? One sometimes gets "courage" from doing something well which one has had no grounding in? In sports, "He's not afraid, he's never been here before; he doesn't know that there is so much to fear?"
-Benjamin Harris
"I should have liked also to write the entire book in the form of a dialogue like Plato's."
...
"I do not mean answers and questions like newspaper interviews...I mean really good, long, leisurely discourses..."
"...with many detours, coming back to the original point of discusion by a short cut at the most unexpected spot,..."
"...like a man returning home by climbing over a hedge...Oh, how I love to reach home by climbing over the back fence, and to travel bypaths!"
...
"The [Eastern] ideas expressed here...are hackneyed truths there...nevertheless...they have become a part of my being."..."when I first encountered them, my heart gave an instinctive assent."
...
"If one is too well-read, then one does not know right is right and wrong is wrong."
I believe that that is often true. In the work of some great thinkers there is a remove from right and wrong: in Marx for example killing comes too easily. It is almost as if they are so intellectually above the surface, where everyone else is, that they are beyond good and evil. Nietzsche too? Or like Richard Rorty: such a sensible, modest, American, philosophy. But he got excoriated for seeming to deny that slavery is, always was, and always will be morally wrong. In a footnote, he simply asserted the eternal evil of slavery, not connecting it to his philosophy.
...
"I have not read Locke or Hume or Berkeley, and have not taken a college course in philosophy." ..."Some of my sources are:...a Shanghai street car conductor...a squirrel in Central Park..."
Is Lin going to turn out to be twee? One can, or at least Chinese One's can, gain insight from non-human...things, like squirrels or sunsets. The intellectual tradition of the West is so, so limited by concentration on the mind's abilities. It is fetishitic.
...
"Thus deprived of academic training in philosophy, I am less scared to write a book about it [i.e. philosophy]."
That seems very wise. Philosophy must be a daunting subject to write about.
...
"Courage seems to be the rarest of all virtues in a modern philosopher."
That is a very insightful, very true observation.
...
"But I have always wandered outside the precincts of philosophy and that gives me courage."
At first read that is a thrilling sentence but is it that those inside philosophy cannot have courage? One sometimes gets "courage" from doing something well which one has had no grounding in? In sports, "He's not afraid, he's never been here before; he doesn't know that there is so much to fear?"
-Benjamin Harris
Monday, March 20, 2006
Amr Khaled: Reforming Provocateur
Amr Khaled: Reforming Provocateur
Imagine a prominent Arab Muslim cleric calling for "a new approach by Muslims, one of reform and dialogue with the rest of the world." An Islamic Martin Luther.
Imagine that the Muslim Reformation has already begun. "For the past three years,with youth across the Islamic world we've been working for a faith-based renaissance in this region, which will not take place by clashes but by coexistence."
It is brave, rational, visionary leaders that Islam must have right now because it is doomed in a clash of civilizations with the West. It is also brave, rational, visionary Muslim leaders that Americans, of all, want now. Because it is we who will be the West's vanguard in the clash, and we to whom war is so execrable and every individual human life so dear.
The utterer of the words above is Amr Khaled, an Egyptian, Islamic televangelist, "young,[38] smiling, teach[ing] love and mercy and ...so popular he's credited with inspiring thousands of women--turned off by dour, traditional clerics--to take on the veil."
The report from which the above quotes was taken was on CNN.com tonight.
CNN writes that Mr. Khaled is using his star power "by trying a new role, as a bridge between Islam and the West at a time when many (Here!) are talking about a clash of civilizations.
Mr. Khaled has taken the Danish cartoon causis belli and turned it into an opportunity for Islamic introspection. This is what can happen if a policy of continual, constructive provocation as advocated here on March 6 is pursued.
"In his sermons, he has avoided politics [separation of mosque and state] and stressed God's mercy, seeking how one can be a good Muslim while still enjoying the activities of modern life," the report states.
"He is so tolerant and friendly,he makes you feel good about your religion and yourself," a young Egyptian woman is quoted as saying.
Khaled as Martin Luther, the beginning of the Islamic Reformation: Mountains out of molehills at this point. And Martin Luther King was murdered before he could over the mountain. But he saw the racial tolerance that lay in the valley beyond.
The Egyptian government banned Mr. Khaled from preaching in 2002. He decamped to England, getting a PhD with a thesis titled "Islam and coexisting with the other." Now he is back in Egypt. "For good," CNN reports hopefully.
We'll see, but eventually Mohammad must go to the mountain. The mountain cannot be brought to Mohammad.
Amr Khaled at least has started the trek. Godspeed to him. This is Public Occurrences.
Imagine a prominent Arab Muslim cleric calling for "a new approach by Muslims, one of reform and dialogue with the rest of the world." An Islamic Martin Luther.
Imagine that the Muslim Reformation has already begun. "For the past three years,with youth across the Islamic world we've been working for a faith-based renaissance in this region, which will not take place by clashes but by coexistence."
It is brave, rational, visionary leaders that Islam must have right now because it is doomed in a clash of civilizations with the West. It is also brave, rational, visionary Muslim leaders that Americans, of all, want now. Because it is we who will be the West's vanguard in the clash, and we to whom war is so execrable and every individual human life so dear.
The utterer of the words above is Amr Khaled, an Egyptian, Islamic televangelist, "young,[38] smiling, teach[ing] love and mercy and ...so popular he's credited with inspiring thousands of women--turned off by dour, traditional clerics--to take on the veil."
The report from which the above quotes was taken was on CNN.com tonight.
CNN writes that Mr. Khaled is using his star power "by trying a new role, as a bridge between Islam and the West at a time when many (Here!) are talking about a clash of civilizations.
Mr. Khaled has taken the Danish cartoon causis belli and turned it into an opportunity for Islamic introspection. This is what can happen if a policy of continual, constructive provocation as advocated here on March 6 is pursued.
"In his sermons, he has avoided politics [separation of mosque and state] and stressed God's mercy, seeking how one can be a good Muslim while still enjoying the activities of modern life," the report states.
"He is so tolerant and friendly,he makes you feel good about your religion and yourself," a young Egyptian woman is quoted as saying.
Khaled as Martin Luther, the beginning of the Islamic Reformation: Mountains out of molehills at this point. And Martin Luther King was murdered before he could over the mountain. But he saw the racial tolerance that lay in the valley beyond.
The Egyptian government banned Mr. Khaled from preaching in 2002. He decamped to England, getting a PhD with a thesis titled "Islam and coexisting with the other." Now he is back in Egypt. "For good," CNN reports hopefully.
We'll see, but eventually Mohammad must go to the mountain. The mountain cannot be brought to Mohammad.
Amr Khaled at least has started the trek. Godspeed to him. This is Public Occurrences.
Saturday, March 11, 2006
Hope and Fear, Tragedy and Reality. Dr. Wafa Sultan on Islam
Hope and Fear, Tragedy and Reality. Dr. Wafa Sultan on Islam.
The truth was made more compelling by the elegant prose:
"The Jews have come from [the Holocaust]
and forced the world to respect them with
their knowledge, not with their terror, with
their work, not with their crying and yelling."
"We have not seen a single Jew blow himself up
in a German restaurant. We have not seen a
single Jew destroy a church. We have not seen a
single Jew protest by killing people."
"Only the Muslims defend their beliefs by burning
down churches, killing people and destroying embassies."
That is from the front page of today's New York Times under the headline "Muslim's Blunt Criticism of Islam Draws Threats and Some Hope." An important message prominently displayed in America's newspaper of record. And by a Muslim. Compelling indeed.
But the tragedy of the story is that the headline is wrong. Wrong because Dr. Wafa Sultan, whose words those are, is not a practicing Muslim, has not been for 27 years. Wrong because the headline genuflects toward a Muslim Reformation, toward a solution from within, the West's magic bullet hope; no, dream; no, fantasy.
Dr. Sultan was raised a Muslim in Syria but in 1979 witnessed the reality of Islam when members of the Muslim Brotherhood broke into her college classroom and killed the professor before her eyes. "They shot hundreds of bullets into him shouting 'God is great!' At that point I lost my trust in their god..."
The tragic quiddity of the story is captured in the article's account of the "debate" she had with a practicing Muslim, an Egyptian religion professor, on Al Jazeera on February 21.
After saying, "I am a secular human being," Dr. Sultan's opposite ended further discussion by asking rhetorically, "Are you a heretic?" The Times wrote that Dr. Ibrahim al-Khouli "then said there was no point in rebuking or debating her, because she had blasphemed against Islam..."
"Are you a heretic" was all that mattered. A heretic is the worst thing there is in Islam, worse than being an infidel, a believer in another religion. But if one is either, one is also (1) therefore not fully human, and consequently (2) one whose life can--should, to some--be ended mercilessly.
The Times headline is wrong because unless practicing Muslims like Dr. al-Khouli say the things that Dr. Sultan is saying there can be no Islamic Reformation. There will only be those, like Dr. Sultan, who left the faith.
It is because of this reality of Islam, as practiced, that brave, brave, wise Dr. Sultan is sorrowfully wrong when she eloquently says:
"The clash we are witnessing around the world
is not a clash of religions or a clash of civilizations.
It is a clash between two opposites, between two
eras...It is a clash between civilization and backwardness..."
This is also the consensus of the American foreign policy intelligentsia. It was Sen. Kerry's argument that it is not a war with Islam that we're in but a battle between Chaos and Civilization.
It is also the nonsense that produced one of President Bush's most notorious blunders, his ridiculous "Axis of Evil" speech that lumped paranoid, hapless North Korea together with Muslim Iran and Iraq. It is the nonsense that there is some kind of terrorism gene that links the Muslim Brotherhood and...the Irish Republican Army...Basque separatists...Chechyn rebels.
It is the moral bankruptcy that also lumps together backward Saudi Arabia and America in one "Civilization."
No, Dr. Sultan, heartbreakingly no, it is not a "clash between two eras." The clash is occurring between two peoples existing in the same era, now. It is a clash of civilizations, of two contemporaneously existing civilizations not a clash between Civilization and Chaos. "I believe our people are hostages to our own beliefs and teaching," as brave Dr. Sultan said herself.
The terrible, terrifying truth is that the war is with Islam, that if Islam does not Reform from within and attacks America again, it will be Reformed from without in a literal Apocalypse, come from the sky, by American nuclear and thermonuclear weapons. "I am become Death, destroyer of worlds," said an awestruck J. Robert Oppenheimer at Trinity, quoting Hindu, another of Islam's countless enemies. It is a Death that America does not want to inflict, that Americans can not yet even think, but which America will deliver if it has to. This is Public Occurrences.
The truth was made more compelling by the elegant prose:
"The Jews have come from [the Holocaust]
and forced the world to respect them with
their knowledge, not with their terror, with
their work, not with their crying and yelling."
"We have not seen a single Jew blow himself up
in a German restaurant. We have not seen a
single Jew destroy a church. We have not seen a
single Jew protest by killing people."
"Only the Muslims defend their beliefs by burning
down churches, killing people and destroying embassies."
That is from the front page of today's New York Times under the headline "Muslim's Blunt Criticism of Islam Draws Threats and Some Hope." An important message prominently displayed in America's newspaper of record. And by a Muslim. Compelling indeed.
But the tragedy of the story is that the headline is wrong. Wrong because Dr. Wafa Sultan, whose words those are, is not a practicing Muslim, has not been for 27 years. Wrong because the headline genuflects toward a Muslim Reformation, toward a solution from within, the West's magic bullet hope; no, dream; no, fantasy.
Dr. Sultan was raised a Muslim in Syria but in 1979 witnessed the reality of Islam when members of the Muslim Brotherhood broke into her college classroom and killed the professor before her eyes. "They shot hundreds of bullets into him shouting 'God is great!' At that point I lost my trust in their god..."
The tragic quiddity of the story is captured in the article's account of the "debate" she had with a practicing Muslim, an Egyptian religion professor, on Al Jazeera on February 21.
After saying, "I am a secular human being," Dr. Sultan's opposite ended further discussion by asking rhetorically, "Are you a heretic?" The Times wrote that Dr. Ibrahim al-Khouli "then said there was no point in rebuking or debating her, because she had blasphemed against Islam..."
"Are you a heretic" was all that mattered. A heretic is the worst thing there is in Islam, worse than being an infidel, a believer in another religion. But if one is either, one is also (1) therefore not fully human, and consequently (2) one whose life can--should, to some--be ended mercilessly.
The Times headline is wrong because unless practicing Muslims like Dr. al-Khouli say the things that Dr. Sultan is saying there can be no Islamic Reformation. There will only be those, like Dr. Sultan, who left the faith.
It is because of this reality of Islam, as practiced, that brave, brave, wise Dr. Sultan is sorrowfully wrong when she eloquently says:
"The clash we are witnessing around the world
is not a clash of religions or a clash of civilizations.
It is a clash between two opposites, between two
eras...It is a clash between civilization and backwardness..."
This is also the consensus of the American foreign policy intelligentsia. It was Sen. Kerry's argument that it is not a war with Islam that we're in but a battle between Chaos and Civilization.
It is also the nonsense that produced one of President Bush's most notorious blunders, his ridiculous "Axis of Evil" speech that lumped paranoid, hapless North Korea together with Muslim Iran and Iraq. It is the nonsense that there is some kind of terrorism gene that links the Muslim Brotherhood and...the Irish Republican Army...Basque separatists...Chechyn rebels.
It is the moral bankruptcy that also lumps together backward Saudi Arabia and America in one "Civilization."
No, Dr. Sultan, heartbreakingly no, it is not a "clash between two eras." The clash is occurring between two peoples existing in the same era, now. It is a clash of civilizations, of two contemporaneously existing civilizations not a clash between Civilization and Chaos. "I believe our people are hostages to our own beliefs and teaching," as brave Dr. Sultan said herself.
The terrible, terrifying truth is that the war is with Islam, that if Islam does not Reform from within and attacks America again, it will be Reformed from without in a literal Apocalypse, come from the sky, by American nuclear and thermonuclear weapons. "I am become Death, destroyer of worlds," said an awestruck J. Robert Oppenheimer at Trinity, quoting Hindu, another of Islam's countless enemies. It is a Death that America does not want to inflict, that Americans can not yet even think, but which America will deliver if it has to. This is Public Occurrences.
Investment Advice
Investment Advice take the $2 you normally spend on Powerball or the like, take the odds and put it on the University of Pittsburgh to reach the Final Four. Put another two-bill with the odds for the Deserted Steel Mills to win the national championship. -Benjamin Harris
Thursday, March 09, 2006
Signs of Water on Saturn's Moon Enceladus
Signs of Water on Saturn's Moon Enceladus
Headline on CNN.com today; what looks to the scientists like an Old Faithful-type geiser spewing liquid water into the "atmosphere" of Enceladus, which immediately freezes on the incomprehensibly cold -300 degree surface.
Everywhere there is water on earth we have found life. We have found strong evidence of it in likely places like Mars and Europa; now in the unlikely place of Enceladus.
Water is all around us in our own middle class solar system in the suburbs of one of a billion other typical galaxies. Life is also all around us in the cosmos and we will find it in our human lifetimes.
-Benjamin Harris
Headline on CNN.com today; what looks to the scientists like an Old Faithful-type geiser spewing liquid water into the "atmosphere" of Enceladus, which immediately freezes on the incomprehensibly cold -300 degree surface.
Everywhere there is water on earth we have found life. We have found strong evidence of it in likely places like Mars and Europa; now in the unlikely place of Enceladus.
Water is all around us in our own middle class solar system in the suburbs of one of a billion other typical galaxies. Life is also all around us in the cosmos and we will find it in our human lifetimes.
-Benjamin Harris
Saturday, February 04, 2006
Danish Cartoons, Islamic Rage, The West Squirms
Danish Cartoons, Islamic Rage, The West Squirms
Islam is rioting over a series of offensive cartoons and the West is squirming.
Islam does not recognize freedom of speech. That is because it is a totalitarian philosophy with a religion's patina. For the same reason Islam dictates everything from subordinate status for women to which way toilets may face (never towards Mecca).
It is official policy (though the dissenters have been getting louder) that there is no "clash of civilizations" with Islam, that the word as a unitary is a hateful caricature, that there are "good" Muslims and leaders and states.
To use Islam as a unitary is no more hateful than using Germany as a unitary during World war II was hateful. There were peaceful Germans then, there are peaceful Muslims now. We should not have slaughtered "innocent" German men, women and children then; we should not attack the Pakistani grocery store owner down the street now. We must not hate.
In both cases however, the masses adhere to a totalitarian philosophy and nowhere does Islam live in peace with its neighbors: Islam has bloody borders. We must not be blind.
According to CNN it wasn't just "bad" Muslims in "bad" countries that rioted either. "Rage...poured out across the Muslim world...with aggrieved believers calling for the execution of those involved."
It is dangerous hokum to insist on a fractured Islam with "good" and "bad" variants and nations when there were cheering street demonstrations on the West Bank and Gaza on September 11; when our "friend" Pakistan has its madrasahs inculcate her children in hatred of "infidels"; when our "friend" Saudi Arabia gives state support to one of the most intractable and violent strains of an already intractable, violent religion; when an influential cleric in that same Saudia Arabia recently gave Koranic blessing to the use of nuclear weapons against the U.S. by al Qaeda, founded and led by one of her sons; when that same Saudi Arabia sent a delegation to a meeting with President Bush that included another cleric who proximately had called for the enslavement of Jewish women for the pleasure of Muslim men.
And those are our friends.
There is also Iran and Syria and Hamas, with its new democratic imprimatur. And so, today, Syrians overran the Danish embassy, by international law Danish soil. A high-ranking leader of Hamas--the chosen of the Palestinian people--opined that "we should have killed all those who offend the Prophet and instead here we are, protesting peacefully."
Other, nongovernmental, buildings were also stormed. Islam does not separate church and state. Islam is all, it is total. Islam does not distinguish between state and private acts; in fact that conjunction was one of the justifications for the attack on the innocents of 9/11.
And the West squirms. Governments, including the United States, have issued statements condemning the offensive cartoons, rather than acknowledge that the problem is with Islam, rather than tell Islam to grow up.
And the West appeases. The Vatican, its own totalitarianism gone half a millenium but still mourned, issued a statement calling the cartoons "unacceptable provocation," the consequence of a freedom that "cannot entail the right to offend the religious sentiment of believers."
The Vatican, and Old Europe. Morally exhausted worn-out collaborators and appeasers, then and now.
And the United States. President Bush, faineant, having exerted himself and gotten good grades in his first term, willing to coast now in his second, trying only to avoid flunking, keeping his head low and his mouth shut so that the professor doesn't call on him, refusing to grasp reality, refusing a grasp at greatness. The legacy's life.
A Danish newspaper published some offensive cartoons and Islam is in a rage. Meanwhile Muslim Iran continues to pursue a nuclear capability.
And the West squirms. This is Public Occurrences.
Islam is rioting over a series of offensive cartoons and the West is squirming.
Islam does not recognize freedom of speech. That is because it is a totalitarian philosophy with a religion's patina. For the same reason Islam dictates everything from subordinate status for women to which way toilets may face (never towards Mecca).
It is official policy (though the dissenters have been getting louder) that there is no "clash of civilizations" with Islam, that the word as a unitary is a hateful caricature, that there are "good" Muslims and leaders and states.
To use Islam as a unitary is no more hateful than using Germany as a unitary during World war II was hateful. There were peaceful Germans then, there are peaceful Muslims now. We should not have slaughtered "innocent" German men, women and children then; we should not attack the Pakistani grocery store owner down the street now. We must not hate.
In both cases however, the masses adhere to a totalitarian philosophy and nowhere does Islam live in peace with its neighbors: Islam has bloody borders. We must not be blind.
According to CNN it wasn't just "bad" Muslims in "bad" countries that rioted either. "Rage...poured out across the Muslim world...with aggrieved believers calling for the execution of those involved."
It is dangerous hokum to insist on a fractured Islam with "good" and "bad" variants and nations when there were cheering street demonstrations on the West Bank and Gaza on September 11; when our "friend" Pakistan has its madrasahs inculcate her children in hatred of "infidels"; when our "friend" Saudi Arabia gives state support to one of the most intractable and violent strains of an already intractable, violent religion; when an influential cleric in that same Saudia Arabia recently gave Koranic blessing to the use of nuclear weapons against the U.S. by al Qaeda, founded and led by one of her sons; when that same Saudi Arabia sent a delegation to a meeting with President Bush that included another cleric who proximately had called for the enslavement of Jewish women for the pleasure of Muslim men.
And those are our friends.
There is also Iran and Syria and Hamas, with its new democratic imprimatur. And so, today, Syrians overran the Danish embassy, by international law Danish soil. A high-ranking leader of Hamas--the chosen of the Palestinian people--opined that "we should have killed all those who offend the Prophet and instead here we are, protesting peacefully."
Other, nongovernmental, buildings were also stormed. Islam does not separate church and state. Islam is all, it is total. Islam does not distinguish between state and private acts; in fact that conjunction was one of the justifications for the attack on the innocents of 9/11.
And the West squirms. Governments, including the United States, have issued statements condemning the offensive cartoons, rather than acknowledge that the problem is with Islam, rather than tell Islam to grow up.
And the West appeases. The Vatican, its own totalitarianism gone half a millenium but still mourned, issued a statement calling the cartoons "unacceptable provocation," the consequence of a freedom that "cannot entail the right to offend the religious sentiment of believers."
The Vatican, and Old Europe. Morally exhausted worn-out collaborators and appeasers, then and now.
And the United States. President Bush, faineant, having exerted himself and gotten good grades in his first term, willing to coast now in his second, trying only to avoid flunking, keeping his head low and his mouth shut so that the professor doesn't call on him, refusing to grasp reality, refusing a grasp at greatness. The legacy's life.
A Danish newspaper published some offensive cartoons and Islam is in a rage. Meanwhile Muslim Iran continues to pursue a nuclear capability.
And the West squirms. This is Public Occurrences.
Saturday, January 28, 2006
The New Yorker Reader Finis: More Ads: Oil Paintings of Dogs; Custom-made SUV Floor Mats.
We noticed a lot of lifestyle-type ads:
"The Retreat at Sheppard Pratt. A first class setting for world class care. Psychotherapeutic milieu."
We take Thorazine, they take Thorazine, but WE go to the Free Clinic to get it; THEY go to The Retreat at Sheppard Pratt.
We determined to change our milieu.
"The Vein Treatment Center."
We shoot heroin; they shoot heroin!
"Structure House, a renowned facility and community for weight loss, diabetes management, and lifestyle change."
Dr. Hersh, our Urologist at the Free Clinic and a New Yorker writer "on the side," had often talked to us about a lifestyle change and our need for more structure.
"Are you a Sybarite?"
Not since Dr. Hersh gave us shots of the penicillin.
We then began to see a pattern in the ads:
"World's BEST Beds."
"Upton Tea Imports, purveyor of the world's FINEST teas." Purveyor means seller, we looked it up.
"Terroir: only the freshest and FINEST coffees."
"Classic Legacy Perfumes. FINEST Quality Formulations."
"Best," "Finest:" Whatever the expense only the best will do. That is the quintessence of The New Yorker reader.
"Custom-Made Floor Mats. Perfectly tailored to fit your car, van, truck or SUV."
Even with FLOOR MATS only the best will do. We had a pickup truck that we could accessorize with one of these.
"Fine Dog Portraits in Oil."
We have a dog, Tilley. We have some Polaroid pictures of her but the difference between us and Them is that They paid for fine oil portraits of their dogs. This threw some needed light on the "Love your pet in style" ad that had flummoxed us earlier. We loved Tilley but to REALLY love Tilley we had to show it by spending whatever was required to love her "in style."
We then saw the Cold Fusion Yo-Yo ad for the first time since The Undersigned showed it to us at the Free Clinic. It cost $90. It was by Duncan, which is to yo-yos what The New Yorker is to magazines.
$90 for a yo-yo. We used to get a Duncan yo-yo for 99 cents when we were young.
Who would pay $90 for a yo-yo? New Yorker readers obviously, but why...why?
Because it was the BEST, that's why! And whether it's floor mats, boat shoes or yo-yos only the best is good enough for the best and the brightest (i.e. New Yorker readers).
It was all beginning to make sense.
Then...we saw the Rosanna Stone of our inquiry:
www.joannerossman.com.
"Purveyor of the Unnecessary & the Irresistible."
New Yorker readers bought a lot of things from "purveyors." They seemed to be an integral part of The New Yorker reader "milieu."
We had another head click. Unnecessary and irresistible, unnecessary and irresistible...peut-etre as in cocaine and heroin, which we were familiar with? We see said the blind man!
We thought to ourselves that this Joanne Rossman must be to New Yorker readers what Playboy centerfolds are to women: the standard in style by which all others are measured.
It was all in the style. If you had business savvy and style you could purvey all manner of
unnecessary and irresistible things.
We resolved to suggest a business card to Tyrone the next time we saw him at the Free Clinic:
"Tyrone, Purveyor of the Unnecessary and Irresistible
The Finest Essence of Coca and the Best French Opiates
Located under the tree by the 7/11, corner of Washington and State
Open 2-6 a.m. nightly."
And after a while of purchasing Tyrone's purveyances one could check into The Vein Treatment Center or The Retreat at Shepphard Pratt.
It was closing time at the library and we felt that we had accomplished our objective.
We had tested ourselves, we had read The New Yorker, but we had not read The New Yorker as a magazine, we had read it as an anthropologist had read the Rosanna Stone, we had analyzed it as a cultural hermeneutic; we had "read" it maybe as New Yorker readers didn't even do.
It wasn't the articles that separated New Yorker readers from the riff-raff. They didn't read the articles. It wasn't even the cartoons. Lots of magazines have witty, erudite cartoons. It was Style, as exemplified in boat shoes with 18 karat gold eyelets, in oil paintings of dogs, in the unnecessary and irresistible. It was a certain, how to say, je ne sais quoi.
We thought of submitting our anthropological analysis to The New Yorker for publication, but then we thought that was stupid, no one would ever read it.
"The Retreat at Sheppard Pratt. A first class setting for world class care. Psychotherapeutic milieu."
We take Thorazine, they take Thorazine, but WE go to the Free Clinic to get it; THEY go to The Retreat at Sheppard Pratt.
We determined to change our milieu.
"The Vein Treatment Center."
We shoot heroin; they shoot heroin!
"Structure House, a renowned facility and community for weight loss, diabetes management, and lifestyle change."
Dr. Hersh, our Urologist at the Free Clinic and a New Yorker writer "on the side," had often talked to us about a lifestyle change and our need for more structure.
"Are you a Sybarite?"
Not since Dr. Hersh gave us shots of the penicillin.
We then began to see a pattern in the ads:
"World's BEST Beds."
"Upton Tea Imports, purveyor of the world's FINEST teas." Purveyor means seller, we looked it up.
"Terroir: only the freshest and FINEST coffees."
"Classic Legacy Perfumes. FINEST Quality Formulations."
"Best," "Finest:" Whatever the expense only the best will do. That is the quintessence of The New Yorker reader.
"Custom-Made Floor Mats. Perfectly tailored to fit your car, van, truck or SUV."
Even with FLOOR MATS only the best will do. We had a pickup truck that we could accessorize with one of these.
"Fine Dog Portraits in Oil."
We have a dog, Tilley. We have some Polaroid pictures of her but the difference between us and Them is that They paid for fine oil portraits of their dogs. This threw some needed light on the "Love your pet in style" ad that had flummoxed us earlier. We loved Tilley but to REALLY love Tilley we had to show it by spending whatever was required to love her "in style."
We then saw the Cold Fusion Yo-Yo ad for the first time since The Undersigned showed it to us at the Free Clinic. It cost $90. It was by Duncan, which is to yo-yos what The New Yorker is to magazines.
$90 for a yo-yo. We used to get a Duncan yo-yo for 99 cents when we were young.
Who would pay $90 for a yo-yo? New Yorker readers obviously, but why...why?
Because it was the BEST, that's why! And whether it's floor mats, boat shoes or yo-yos only the best is good enough for the best and the brightest (i.e. New Yorker readers).
It was all beginning to make sense.
Then...we saw the Rosanna Stone of our inquiry:
www.joannerossman.com.
"Purveyor of the Unnecessary & the Irresistible."
New Yorker readers bought a lot of things from "purveyors." They seemed to be an integral part of The New Yorker reader "milieu."
We had another head click. Unnecessary and irresistible, unnecessary and irresistible...peut-etre as in cocaine and heroin, which we were familiar with? We see said the blind man!
We thought to ourselves that this Joanne Rossman must be to New Yorker readers what Playboy centerfolds are to women: the standard in style by which all others are measured.
It was all in the style. If you had business savvy and style you could purvey all manner of
unnecessary and irresistible things.
We resolved to suggest a business card to Tyrone the next time we saw him at the Free Clinic:
"Tyrone, Purveyor of the Unnecessary and Irresistible
The Finest Essence of Coca and the Best French Opiates
Located under the tree by the 7/11, corner of Washington and State
Open 2-6 a.m. nightly."
And after a while of purchasing Tyrone's purveyances one could check into The Vein Treatment Center or The Retreat at Shepphard Pratt.
It was closing time at the library and we felt that we had accomplished our objective.
We had tested ourselves, we had read The New Yorker, but we had not read The New Yorker as a magazine, we had read it as an anthropologist had read the Rosanna Stone, we had analyzed it as a cultural hermeneutic; we had "read" it maybe as New Yorker readers didn't even do.
It wasn't the articles that separated New Yorker readers from the riff-raff. They didn't read the articles. It wasn't even the cartoons. Lots of magazines have witty, erudite cartoons. It was Style, as exemplified in boat shoes with 18 karat gold eyelets, in oil paintings of dogs, in the unnecessary and irresistible. It was a certain, how to say, je ne sais quoi.
We thought of submitting our anthropological analysis to The New Yorker for publication, but then we thought that was stupid, no one would ever read it.
Friday, January 27, 2006
Democrats Should Oppose Alito
Democrats Should Oppose Alito
Judge Samuel Alito's elevation to the Supreme Court is all but inevitable. He is unquestionably qualified, the Senate Republican majority is so right-wing and the Democrats so impotent and rudderless that there is no serious threat to his confirmation, but this is (tired metaphor alert) one of those political watersheds, like the Gulf of Tonkin resolution.
Alito, nicknamed "Scalito" for his commonality with Justice Antonin Scalia, will almost surely replace Sandra Day O'Connor's vote upholding Roe v Wade with a vote to overrule it.
Political correctness dictates that a politician never say that (same metaphor alert) he/she has a "litmus test" for judicial nominees.
Abortion rights should be a litmus test. Any Democrat who votes to confirm Alito or even silently casts a no vote is betraying the principles of his/her party on the one domestic issue that has most clearly distinguished the parties for over a generation.
Sen. John Kerry called for a filibuster earlier this week to stop Alito's confirmation but he doesn't have the votes. The Democratic half of "The Gang of 14" has agreed not to filibuster President Bush's judicial nominees, the Republican half has agreed to oppose attempts to abolish the filibuster procedure altogether. Two of the seven Democrats have also announced that they will vote to confirm Alito.
This group of appeasors will regret their actions. As an earlier group of Democrats had to answer the question of how they voted on the Gulf of Tonkin resolution, this group will have to answer to their daughters and granddaughters on what they did when the right to abortion was to be upheld or wiped out.
-Benjamin Harris
Judge Samuel Alito's elevation to the Supreme Court is all but inevitable. He is unquestionably qualified, the Senate Republican majority is so right-wing and the Democrats so impotent and rudderless that there is no serious threat to his confirmation, but this is (tired metaphor alert) one of those political watersheds, like the Gulf of Tonkin resolution.
Alito, nicknamed "Scalito" for his commonality with Justice Antonin Scalia, will almost surely replace Sandra Day O'Connor's vote upholding Roe v Wade with a vote to overrule it.
Political correctness dictates that a politician never say that (same metaphor alert) he/she has a "litmus test" for judicial nominees.
Abortion rights should be a litmus test. Any Democrat who votes to confirm Alito or even silently casts a no vote is betraying the principles of his/her party on the one domestic issue that has most clearly distinguished the parties for over a generation.
Sen. John Kerry called for a filibuster earlier this week to stop Alito's confirmation but he doesn't have the votes. The Democratic half of "The Gang of 14" has agreed not to filibuster President Bush's judicial nominees, the Republican half has agreed to oppose attempts to abolish the filibuster procedure altogether. Two of the seven Democrats have also announced that they will vote to confirm Alito.
This group of appeasors will regret their actions. As an earlier group of Democrats had to answer the question of how they voted on the Gulf of Tonkin resolution, this group will have to answer to their daughters and granddaughters on what they did when the right to abortion was to be upheld or wiped out.
-Benjamin Harris
Thursday, January 26, 2006
"Boswell felt that the act of writing regularly was beneficial in itself, both as a discipline which would encourage the habit of application and as a means of staving off the depression which often resulted from inactivity. Morever, he hoped that 'knowing that I am to record my transactions will make me more careful to do well.' "
Adam Sisman, Boswell's Presumpuous Task; The Making of the life of Dr. Johnson.
Adam Sisman, Boswell's Presumpuous Task; The Making of the life of Dr. Johnson.
Tuesday, January 10, 2006
Could We Be a New Yorker Reader: Parte Tres
The New Yorker Horror
Parte Tres. "The Ads.
You're Looking at the
Ads."
How could we recognize a New Yorker reader? More importantly how could we look like one our ownselves and subtly signal our status to our brethren and sistren?
Cleverly, we thought to ourselves, "Look at the Ads." Isn't that how this all started, with The Undersigned's mention of the cold fusion yo-yo ad at the Free Clinic?
Yes it was.
Suddenly we realized that right here, in this library, lurking in that aisle over there or seated at that desk here, might be a New Yorker reader, invisible to our untrained eye because she was not playing with her cold fusion yo-yo at the moment. But if we knew other things they bought, the kinds of clothes they wore, we might be able to spot them.
We saw an ad in the October 17, 2005 issue,
"Love your pet in style! Poochstyle."
Uhh...
In the November 7 issue there was,
"Self-Indulgence-You Deserve it. Treat yourself to the luxury of a silk smoking jacket for the holidays!"
Now we were cookin' with gas! A silk smoking jacket!
In the same issue,
"For the Sportsman who has everything. Except boat shoes with [18 karat] gold eyelets and deerskin linings."
We had never thought of something like this before BECAUSE WE WERE NOT NEW YORKER READERS BEFORE!
An ad for a "European Beret" was in the October 17 issue and one for a "Greek Fisherman's Cap" in the November 14 issue.
We began to See: Going back to Eustace, Hats--but only certain kinds--distinguished New Yorker readers from the unsophisticated and unintelligent.
Our instinct was confirmed by two other ads from 21 November, "The Cashmere Watch Cap," and "The Traditional Night Cap." There was even an article in the October 17 issue titled "Old Hat." (And they didn't think we'd get that hint :)
We saw "Beau Ties Ltd of Vermont. Handcrafted silk bow ties..."
Beau/bow: tres clever, neau?
Then, "Mr Happy Crack says...'A dry crack is a happy crack' T-shirts, boxers ballcaps, thongs, onesies"
We felt more like a typical New Yorker reader when we saw this ad from The Happy Crack Company, which we were familiar with.
We now had a plethora of headwear ideas, we knew what kind of shoes to look for, we had our silk smoking jacket, our beau ties, even our Happy Crack "onesies." We looked to complete our ensemble and on page 95 of the November 1 issue we saw,
"Finally, horizontal corduroy pants."
We thought for a moment that maybe New Yorker readers had been so difficult to spot before because they had been staying indoors until this invention but then we thought that was stupid.
We had to admit that a gent or gent-ette dressed in a Watch cap, smoking jacket, boat shoes with gold eyelets and deerskin linings and playing with a cold fusion yo-yo would stand out even more than Tyrone in his gangster suit, spats and black shirt.
We now felt adequately prepared to spot a New Yorker reader and thought a library as good a place as any to find one, probably several, so we got up from the periodicals circulation desk and walked around.
Not a pair of horizontal corduroys in sight. Or any Watch caps or Nightcaps.
Finally on the third floor we saw One. It was a she One, a beautiful she One, and she was wearing a European beret!
She was seated in one of those double carrels that enabled us to sit directly opposite her. Giddily we approached the carrel. We noticed that she was wearing a fashionably short skirt, which we thought the very image of New Yorker sophistication. We sat down opposite her.
After a few heady moments we realized that we couldn't see if she was wearing boat shoes with gold eyelets and deerskin linings so we bent way down and looked under our desk because she had uncrossed her legs and was resting her knees on her desk.
We promised the security guard that we would not do that again and were permitted to stay in the library. We went back to our magazines at the periodical desk.
-Benjamin Harris
Parte Tres. "The Ads.
You're Looking at the
Ads."
How could we recognize a New Yorker reader? More importantly how could we look like one our ownselves and subtly signal our status to our brethren and sistren?
Cleverly, we thought to ourselves, "Look at the Ads." Isn't that how this all started, with The Undersigned's mention of the cold fusion yo-yo ad at the Free Clinic?
Yes it was.
Suddenly we realized that right here, in this library, lurking in that aisle over there or seated at that desk here, might be a New Yorker reader, invisible to our untrained eye because she was not playing with her cold fusion yo-yo at the moment. But if we knew other things they bought, the kinds of clothes they wore, we might be able to spot them.
We saw an ad in the October 17, 2005 issue,
"Love your pet in style! Poochstyle."
Uhh...
In the November 7 issue there was,
"Self-Indulgence-You Deserve it. Treat yourself to the luxury of a silk smoking jacket for the holidays!"
Now we were cookin' with gas! A silk smoking jacket!
In the same issue,
"For the Sportsman who has everything. Except boat shoes with [18 karat] gold eyelets and deerskin linings."
We had never thought of something like this before BECAUSE WE WERE NOT NEW YORKER READERS BEFORE!
An ad for a "European Beret" was in the October 17 issue and one for a "Greek Fisherman's Cap" in the November 14 issue.
We began to See: Going back to Eustace, Hats--but only certain kinds--distinguished New Yorker readers from the unsophisticated and unintelligent.
Our instinct was confirmed by two other ads from 21 November, "The Cashmere Watch Cap," and "The Traditional Night Cap." There was even an article in the October 17 issue titled "Old Hat." (And they didn't think we'd get that hint :)
We saw "Beau Ties Ltd of Vermont. Handcrafted silk bow ties..."
Beau/bow: tres clever, neau?
Then, "Mr Happy Crack says...'A dry crack is a happy crack' T-shirts, boxers ballcaps, thongs, onesies"
We felt more like a typical New Yorker reader when we saw this ad from The Happy Crack Company, which we were familiar with.
We now had a plethora of headwear ideas, we knew what kind of shoes to look for, we had our silk smoking jacket, our beau ties, even our Happy Crack "onesies." We looked to complete our ensemble and on page 95 of the November 1 issue we saw,
"Finally, horizontal corduroy pants."
We thought for a moment that maybe New Yorker readers had been so difficult to spot before because they had been staying indoors until this invention but then we thought that was stupid.
We had to admit that a gent or gent-ette dressed in a Watch cap, smoking jacket, boat shoes with gold eyelets and deerskin linings and playing with a cold fusion yo-yo would stand out even more than Tyrone in his gangster suit, spats and black shirt.
We now felt adequately prepared to spot a New Yorker reader and thought a library as good a place as any to find one, probably several, so we got up from the periodicals circulation desk and walked around.
Not a pair of horizontal corduroys in sight. Or any Watch caps or Nightcaps.
Finally on the third floor we saw One. It was a she One, a beautiful she One, and she was wearing a European beret!
She was seated in one of those double carrels that enabled us to sit directly opposite her. Giddily we approached the carrel. We noticed that she was wearing a fashionably short skirt, which we thought the very image of New Yorker sophistication. We sat down opposite her.
After a few heady moments we realized that we couldn't see if she was wearing boat shoes with gold eyelets and deerskin linings so we bent way down and looked under our desk because she had uncrossed her legs and was resting her knees on her desk.
We promised the security guard that we would not do that again and were permitted to stay in the library. We went back to our magazines at the periodical desk.
-Benjamin Harris
Wednesday, January 04, 2006
Could We Be a New Yorker Reader? Parte Deux
Could We Be A New Yorker Reader?
Parte Deux: Dr. Seymour M. Hersh
and the Inspiration of Tyrone.
Did we have the "right stuff" to be a New Yorker reader?
As we took our hands off our eyes and began reading the first article we were pleasantly surprised. One article was called "Letter from Pennsylvania, Darwin in the Dock, Intelligent design goes to school."
We already knew where Pennsylvania was and so we didn't feel the need to read that one.
"Corduroy rules," was the title of a USA Today-length article in a section called "The Talk of the Town" on December 5. As a guy living in Peoria, we have owned corduroy pants our whole lives.
In another issue we saw, "How the White Sox won." Besides the cartoons, The New Yorker had sports too. There was just more and more common ground between us and readers of The New Yorker.
Since we already got Sports Illustrated, The Sporting News, ESPN The Magazine, and USA Today we already knew that the (Chicago) White Sox won the (baseball) World Series so we didn't need to read that article either.
In reading another article we saw that the writer was Seymour M. Hersh, who is also our urologist at the County Free Health Clinic! We actually knew a writer for The New Yorker!
So having read a "critical mass" of the "allegedly" "daunting" "articles" in The New Yorker we now just leafed through some other issues, to soak up the "milieu" as a New Yorker reader would say.
As we went through more and more we noticed that apparently they had a mascot, "Eustace," we forget his last name, who was pictured on the index of every issue.
"Eustace" wore a top hat and looked down his nose at a butterfly through a pair of those old-fashioned glasses that you have to hold up to your eyes because they don't go behind your ears.
Then something clicked in our head again like it did when we saw the sign "This is not a library!" in Abdul's newsstand: How could we spot a New Yorker reader when we saw one?
We thought for a second that maybe they all dress like Eustace but then we thought that was stupid. Do the Philadelphia Phillies dress like the Phillie Phanatic?
Don't make us laugh.
What it was was that The New Yorker was a very old magazine. It went back to the Truman administration in the 1920s and more people back then must have dressed like Eustace. They just didn't update the mascot's look.
What clicked in our heads when we were thinking about all of this was that to be a New Yorker reader you had to LOOK like a New Yorker reader. We recalled something our friend Tyrone said one time at the Free Clinic when we asked him why he was dressed in a gangster-striped suit, spats, and a black shirt. Tyrone said, "If I'm going to be impo'tent, I'm going to look impo'tent."
We had always remembered that.
We needed to find out what modern New Yorker readers wore and what stuff they bought if we were to be able to recognize them, go to the places they went, hopefully meet some of them, do the things they do, and ultimately, BECOME one of them.
-Benjamin Harris
Parte Deux: Dr. Seymour M. Hersh
and the Inspiration of Tyrone.
Did we have the "right stuff" to be a New Yorker reader?
As we took our hands off our eyes and began reading the first article we were pleasantly surprised. One article was called "Letter from Pennsylvania, Darwin in the Dock, Intelligent design goes to school."
We already knew where Pennsylvania was and so we didn't feel the need to read that one.
"Corduroy rules," was the title of a USA Today-length article in a section called "The Talk of the Town" on December 5. As a guy living in Peoria, we have owned corduroy pants our whole lives.
In another issue we saw, "How the White Sox won." Besides the cartoons, The New Yorker had sports too. There was just more and more common ground between us and readers of The New Yorker.
Since we already got Sports Illustrated, The Sporting News, ESPN The Magazine, and USA Today we already knew that the (Chicago) White Sox won the (baseball) World Series so we didn't need to read that article either.
In reading another article we saw that the writer was Seymour M. Hersh, who is also our urologist at the County Free Health Clinic! We actually knew a writer for The New Yorker!
So having read a "critical mass" of the "allegedly" "daunting" "articles" in The New Yorker we now just leafed through some other issues, to soak up the "milieu" as a New Yorker reader would say.
As we went through more and more we noticed that apparently they had a mascot, "Eustace," we forget his last name, who was pictured on the index of every issue.
"Eustace" wore a top hat and looked down his nose at a butterfly through a pair of those old-fashioned glasses that you have to hold up to your eyes because they don't go behind your ears.
Then something clicked in our head again like it did when we saw the sign "This is not a library!" in Abdul's newsstand: How could we spot a New Yorker reader when we saw one?
We thought for a second that maybe they all dress like Eustace but then we thought that was stupid. Do the Philadelphia Phillies dress like the Phillie Phanatic?
Don't make us laugh.
What it was was that The New Yorker was a very old magazine. It went back to the Truman administration in the 1920s and more people back then must have dressed like Eustace. They just didn't update the mascot's look.
What clicked in our heads when we were thinking about all of this was that to be a New Yorker reader you had to LOOK like a New Yorker reader. We recalled something our friend Tyrone said one time at the Free Clinic when we asked him why he was dressed in a gangster-striped suit, spats, and a black shirt. Tyrone said, "If I'm going to be impo'tent, I'm going to look impo'tent."
We had always remembered that.
We needed to find out what modern New Yorker readers wore and what stuff they bought if we were to be able to recognize them, go to the places they went, hopefully meet some of them, do the things they do, and ultimately, BECOME one of them.
-Benjamin Harris
Sunday, January 01, 2006
Could We Be A New Yorker Reader? Parte Une
Could We Be A New Yorker Reader?
Do We Have The "Right Stuff?"
Parte Une: "The Cold Fusion Yo-Yo."
We were chatting with a friend the other day when he said something about a "Cold Fusion Yo-Yo" in "The New Yorker."
We had no idea what our friend, at whose request we will identify only as "The Undersigned," was talking about but not wanting to look stupid we copied his facial expressions and shook our heads in amazement whenever he did.
Cleverly, we asked The Undersigned to show us and in this way found out without having to ask and look stupid that it was an ad in a magazine. We read the ad but still didn't understand it. However we did not feel stupid because neither did The Undersigned.
We wondered to ourselves why someone who lives in Peoria, Illinois would read a magazine for people who live in New York City but cleverly decided to ask a slightly but significantly different question, "Why do you read that?"
In this way we could appear to be not unfamiliar with The New Yorker and at the same time find out what kind of magazine it was. The Undersigned said that he got The New Yorker because "intelligent, powerful and sophisticated people" read it and because it had been called "perhaps the best magazine that ever was."
That appealed to us because we like things that are the best, which is why we get The Sharper Image catalog.
So being intellectually curious and a "social climber" who associates only with "the best and the brightest" like The Undersigned, we were now intrigued by this The New Yorker and wanted to look at it for ourselves but The Undersigned threw it in the bio-hazardous wastebasket before we could.
After leaving the County Free Health Clinic we then got on the bus to go home but we had so many thoughts going through our head that we got off at the newsstand to buy a copy of The New Yorker.
We were familiar with the location of Maxim magazine on the magazine rack and cleverly figured that since Maxim starts with an "M" that The New Yorker should be right nearby. We did not see it however.
We looked behind some issues of Maxim to see if a copy of The New Yorker got misfiled there. We opened an issue of Maxim to see if one got stuffed between the pages.
We spent an hour doing this.
We asked Abdul, who owns the newsstand, if he carried The New Yorker. We were told no. We went to leave but Abdul motioned to a sign in the store that said, "This is not a library!" We paid for a copy of Maxim but the sign clicked something in our head and we asked Abdul if he knew where a library was.
He did not.
After inquiring of several other people we were told that the library was located in the Government Center near the County Free Health Clinic, which we were familiar with.
We took a bus back downtown and in short order found the library. We went up to the periodicals circulation desk and asked for The New Yorker. We were given a month's worth at a time.
We noted that every cover had a drawing on it, like a cartoon. We were impressed. We leafed through the issue and saw more cartoons. There were lots and lots of cartoons. We thought maybe this was their annual cartoon issue, like Nickelodeon used to have its JuneBuggs Buggs-Bunny marathon every year, which we greatly missed.
However we discovered that every issue of The New Yorker had tons of cartoons. We were thrilled that maybe the best magazine that ever was had cartoons in it, just like Playboy, which we were familiar with. And that just like the only reason we bought Playboy was for the cartoons, we learned that a lot of people only got The New Yorker for the cartoons.
We were beginning to see that we had a lot in common with the movers and shakers who read The New Yorker.
Even with our confidence soaring, we got butterflies in our stomach when we prepared to read the articles. We read USA Today when we have the time to devote to it but we inferred from the things that The Undersigned said that The New Yorker was even tougher.
Did we have "the right stuff" to be a New Yorker reader?
-Benjamin Harris
Do We Have The "Right Stuff?"
Parte Une: "The Cold Fusion Yo-Yo."
We were chatting with a friend the other day when he said something about a "Cold Fusion Yo-Yo" in "The New Yorker."
We had no idea what our friend, at whose request we will identify only as "The Undersigned," was talking about but not wanting to look stupid we copied his facial expressions and shook our heads in amazement whenever he did.
Cleverly, we asked The Undersigned to show us and in this way found out without having to ask and look stupid that it was an ad in a magazine. We read the ad but still didn't understand it. However we did not feel stupid because neither did The Undersigned.
We wondered to ourselves why someone who lives in Peoria, Illinois would read a magazine for people who live in New York City but cleverly decided to ask a slightly but significantly different question, "Why do you read that?"
In this way we could appear to be not unfamiliar with The New Yorker and at the same time find out what kind of magazine it was. The Undersigned said that he got The New Yorker because "intelligent, powerful and sophisticated people" read it and because it had been called "perhaps the best magazine that ever was."
That appealed to us because we like things that are the best, which is why we get The Sharper Image catalog.
So being intellectually curious and a "social climber" who associates only with "the best and the brightest" like The Undersigned, we were now intrigued by this The New Yorker and wanted to look at it for ourselves but The Undersigned threw it in the bio-hazardous wastebasket before we could.
After leaving the County Free Health Clinic we then got on the bus to go home but we had so many thoughts going through our head that we got off at the newsstand to buy a copy of The New Yorker.
We were familiar with the location of Maxim magazine on the magazine rack and cleverly figured that since Maxim starts with an "M" that The New Yorker should be right nearby. We did not see it however.
We looked behind some issues of Maxim to see if a copy of The New Yorker got misfiled there. We opened an issue of Maxim to see if one got stuffed between the pages.
We spent an hour doing this.
We asked Abdul, who owns the newsstand, if he carried The New Yorker. We were told no. We went to leave but Abdul motioned to a sign in the store that said, "This is not a library!" We paid for a copy of Maxim but the sign clicked something in our head and we asked Abdul if he knew where a library was.
He did not.
After inquiring of several other people we were told that the library was located in the Government Center near the County Free Health Clinic, which we were familiar with.
We took a bus back downtown and in short order found the library. We went up to the periodicals circulation desk and asked for The New Yorker. We were given a month's worth at a time.
We noted that every cover had a drawing on it, like a cartoon. We were impressed. We leafed through the issue and saw more cartoons. There were lots and lots of cartoons. We thought maybe this was their annual cartoon issue, like Nickelodeon used to have its JuneBuggs Buggs-Bunny marathon every year, which we greatly missed.
However we discovered that every issue of The New Yorker had tons of cartoons. We were thrilled that maybe the best magazine that ever was had cartoons in it, just like Playboy, which we were familiar with. And that just like the only reason we bought Playboy was for the cartoons, we learned that a lot of people only got The New Yorker for the cartoons.
We were beginning to see that we had a lot in common with the movers and shakers who read The New Yorker.
Even with our confidence soaring, we got butterflies in our stomach when we prepared to read the articles. We read USA Today when we have the time to devote to it but we inferred from the things that The Undersigned said that The New Yorker was even tougher.
Did we have "the right stuff" to be a New Yorker reader?
-Benjamin Harris
Friday, December 09, 2005
"The Cold Fusion Yo-Yo"
"The Cold Fusion Yo-Yo"
"by Duncan, a high-tech precision 62g aircraft aluminum yo-yo with steel ballbearigs. World record 7 minute spins. Red and black special edition limited to 1600 pieces. $90 plus $6.00 S&H."
www.yoyoguy.com
"Infinite Illusions"
This page did not go looking for the above. As with "Dead Sparrow Overshadows Domino World" it simply appeared in perusal of mainstream pubs.
(ASIDE: perusal has to be the only word in the English language with two opposite meanings. The first, preferred, usage is to read thoroughly. The second, discouraged, but much more common, is to skim.)
"Cold Fusion Yo-Yo" was encountered in a quick thumbing of a recent issue of The New Yorker magazine.
Even moreso than with "Dead Sparrow" the mind cracked when stumbling across "Cold Fusion Yo-Yo."
"Cold Fusion" is as synonymous with scientific quackery as perpetual motion machines. When conjoined with "Yo-Yo," itself a substitute for daft-ness, the implication is of something with the gravitas of the pet rock, or a spoof in the spirit of Orson Welles.
Perhaps it is, since the undersigned will not be paying $90 + S&H to find out.
Perhaps it is a goof on the middle-brow readership of The New Yorker, or a hermeneutic for that ethnological subgroup.
It says here though that it is not a goof. However, there is cultural meaning.
The undersigned believes that if you send the money to "Yo-Yo guy" at "Infinite Illusions" you will get the objet d'art pictured in the ad. I believe that the object is truly manufactured by Duncan, which is to the manufacture of Yo-Yo's what Apple is to the manufacture of personal computers.
In the undersigned's (childhood) experience, a Yo-Yo by other than Duncan was the equivalent of wearing "sneakers" by other than Converse, that is, an irrebuttable presumption that you ate paste made of nose dirt and still slept with your mommy.
It is inconceivable to the undersigned that Duncan would lend itself to a goof like this here.
Too, the specs of this object, "62 g aircraft aluminum," and "steel ball-bearings" has the ring of validity, as appealing to those of normal I.Q. but super-normal bank balances and super-super-normal social ambition,; to those who want "the best," who get their gifts and their gift-giving ideas from The Sharper Image, who pay super-normal prices to buy their normal I.Q.'d children admission to The Dalton School and like that.
In short, this object seems to have been marketed to it's perfect target audience.
All of this still seems to leave unexplained the object's description. A "cold fusion yo-yo" would seem to raise red flags with even non-Mensa members but even the undersigned (who is NOT eligible for Mensa membership) knows of the snake-oil reputation of cold fusion.
The description is alerting enough that the undersigned can imagine questions of the type, "Geoff dear, what is cold fusion?," but the undersigned cannot imagine even know-it-all men like Geoff replying with, "Why, it's the newest advance in Yo-Yo's Heather, you dumb-ass. I read about it last month in Men's Health."
But it must be so because Duncan is the manufacturer and a journal with the social standing and ambition of The New Yorker would not allow itself to be so hood-winked.
The undersigned has to believe that there is such a critical mass of dumb-asses out there, and that they read The New Yorker in such numbers, as to make the cold-fusion yo-yo the perfect holiday gift for the likes of Geoff and Heather.
Which is why the undersigned is reconsidering his opposition to the death penalty, nay to mass murder.
-The Undersigned
"by Duncan, a high-tech precision 62g aircraft aluminum yo-yo with steel ballbearigs. World record 7 minute spins. Red and black special edition limited to 1600 pieces. $90 plus $6.00 S&H."
www.yoyoguy.com
"Infinite Illusions"
This page did not go looking for the above. As with "Dead Sparrow Overshadows Domino World" it simply appeared in perusal of mainstream pubs.
(ASIDE: perusal has to be the only word in the English language with two opposite meanings. The first, preferred, usage is to read thoroughly. The second, discouraged, but much more common, is to skim.)
"Cold Fusion Yo-Yo" was encountered in a quick thumbing of a recent issue of The New Yorker magazine.
Even moreso than with "Dead Sparrow" the mind cracked when stumbling across "Cold Fusion Yo-Yo."
"Cold Fusion" is as synonymous with scientific quackery as perpetual motion machines. When conjoined with "Yo-Yo," itself a substitute for daft-ness, the implication is of something with the gravitas of the pet rock, or a spoof in the spirit of Orson Welles.
Perhaps it is, since the undersigned will not be paying $90 + S&H to find out.
Perhaps it is a goof on the middle-brow readership of The New Yorker, or a hermeneutic for that ethnological subgroup.
It says here though that it is not a goof. However, there is cultural meaning.
The undersigned believes that if you send the money to "Yo-Yo guy" at "Infinite Illusions" you will get the objet d'art pictured in the ad. I believe that the object is truly manufactured by Duncan, which is to the manufacture of Yo-Yo's what Apple is to the manufacture of personal computers.
In the undersigned's (childhood) experience, a Yo-Yo by other than Duncan was the equivalent of wearing "sneakers" by other than Converse, that is, an irrebuttable presumption that you ate paste made of nose dirt and still slept with your mommy.
It is inconceivable to the undersigned that Duncan would lend itself to a goof like this here.
Too, the specs of this object, "62 g aircraft aluminum," and "steel ball-bearings" has the ring of validity, as appealing to those of normal I.Q. but super-normal bank balances and super-super-normal social ambition,; to those who want "the best," who get their gifts and their gift-giving ideas from The Sharper Image, who pay super-normal prices to buy their normal I.Q.'d children admission to The Dalton School and like that.
In short, this object seems to have been marketed to it's perfect target audience.
All of this still seems to leave unexplained the object's description. A "cold fusion yo-yo" would seem to raise red flags with even non-Mensa members but even the undersigned (who is NOT eligible for Mensa membership) knows of the snake-oil reputation of cold fusion.
The description is alerting enough that the undersigned can imagine questions of the type, "Geoff dear, what is cold fusion?," but the undersigned cannot imagine even know-it-all men like Geoff replying with, "Why, it's the newest advance in Yo-Yo's Heather, you dumb-ass. I read about it last month in Men's Health."
But it must be so because Duncan is the manufacturer and a journal with the social standing and ambition of The New Yorker would not allow itself to be so hood-winked.
The undersigned has to believe that there is such a critical mass of dumb-asses out there, and that they read The New Yorker in such numbers, as to make the cold-fusion yo-yo the perfect holiday gift for the likes of Geoff and Heather.
Which is why the undersigned is reconsidering his opposition to the death penalty, nay to mass murder.
-The Undersigned
Monday, December 05, 2005
Books and Covers
Books and Covers
During the transition from the Carter to the Reagan administration William F. Buckley, Jr. said that he anticipated that there would be less hugging and cheek-kissing between the new American president and the General Secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union than there had been previously.
Buckley went on to wonder aloud about the psychology behind this literal embrace of the dictator of a hostile superpower by the leader of the Free World.
Jimmy Carter's insouciance was part of the reason for his desire for a personal bonding with Leonid Brezhnev but there has always been the belief in diplomacy that a personal connection can lead to greater understanding and hence to conflict resolution.
The opposite is also felt to be true, personal animus makes dealing with the issues that are really at stake more difficult.
The perils of following these truisms need no itemization. As a conscious act of diplomacy personal friendliness as a means to the strategic end of conflict resolution is a proven failure.
It is not a rational act, or at least not just a rational act. It is purely an emotional human thing.
People want to like other people and to be liked by them. When we meet political figures whose views we share we want to have that political commonality conjoined with personal warmth. When we meet those with whom we disagree politically we often experience dissonant feelings if they have pleasant personalities.
I met William Kristol and Maureen Dowd at a bookfair recently.
One's political leanings--as opposed sometimes to one's views on a particular issue--are more instinctive than studied. Genes, upbringing, family, friends, teachers--and some facts--produce an inclination that is perhaps dignified by the term "world-view" but is something like that.
In me those factors have formed an opinionated, confrontational, angry, yelling, right-leaning, curious, reasonably bright, pretty well-read, pretty standard-issue, know-it-all American male.
My world-view is approximate to that of William Kristol. Kristol's avuncular TV persona is reinforcing to this political commonality.
I cannot ever remember a political issue on which I have identified with Maureen Dowd and her op-ed persona grates on me, as it does on many, especially on men. She was at the bookfair promoting her book "Are Men Necessary?"
My girlfriend holds dual French and American citizenship. She moved to the U.S. at 13, and is strong, intelligent, highly analytical, empathetic and modest in stating her political opinions on specific issues.
Her world view is that of a left-leaning Democrat.
When my girlfriend and I went over the book fair agenda I had enthusiastically circled Kristol's talk, to which she assented (by silence). She is still personally fond enough of me to sit peaceably with me through a talk by William Kristol.
Dowd and Kristol spoke on the same day in the same lecture room. Dowd's talk was before Kristol's.
Dowd was bright, witty, personable, generous with her questioners, modest. In an admittedly gender-engendered reaction she was also attractive. She has a beautiful face and gorgeous Irish red hair but I had seen pictures of her before. It was her personality that added so much to her attractiveness.
Curiously I didn't take any note of her figure until Lorna and I got to the front of the book-signing line. I leaned over the table behind which she was seated to ask her if she had heard about the domino-toppling Dutch sparrow and noted that she was wearing a pretty low-cut top that highlighted a full bosom.
During her thirty minute talk Dowd mentioned her mother, who died over the summer, three times. The references were appropriately placed in her talk but after two it was clear that she was still deeply affected by it. At the third mention her voice almost cracked.
The reserved, almost shy, way in which she looked at my girlfriend and me was so natural and unaffected. She responded to my sparrow news alert with nothing in particular, something like "No I hadn't heard of that. I'll have to check that out when I get done here," but it was not dismissive. It was not delighted but it was responsive.
The tone of her reply, the way she looked at us and the tone and content of her talk all suggested to me, correctly or incorrectly, that she was feeling vulnerable, maybe even clinically depressed. She was just so human.
I ran into Kristol as he was entering the lecture hall. He is short of stature which I hadn't expected.
"Mr. Kristol it's a pleasure to meet you," I said.
"Bill Kristol," he replied distractedly as if he was introducing himself to me and hadn't heard that I had just used his name so as to make it unnecessary for him to repeat it. He made only the briefest, most flitting eye contact.
Before Kristol spoke I gave Lorna a brief bio of him which was self-satisfyingly echoed by the man who introduced Kristol. "Bill Kristol is the editor of the most influential, most read magazine in Washington..."
The editor of the most influential magazine in Washington then gave a thirty minute talk exclusively promoting a book which was a compendium of essays from his magazine's first ten years; a Greatest Hits of The Weekly Standard. It was a bit crass.
There was nothing about "the state of the world" or even of current Washington, D.C. in his talk. No insight from one so influential with the Bushies. The smiles that he sprinkles about frequently when he speaks, which are so effective a part of his TV package, appeared more like facial tics in person. They were displayed randomly, often non sequiters to the subject.
I grew restless, impatient and then embarrassed. My girlfriend, with her world view, not wanting to rub it in, sat beside me respectfully in silence but this time it was not a silence of assent. Finally I voiced the frustration that we both felt at this disappointing presentation.
After his talk was over I attempted to speak to him.
"Mr. Kristol, do you have time for a question or do you have to go?"
"Well, I think I have to go to the book-signing," he said with the same distraction and disinterest.
My political leanings didn't change from approximate to Kristol to approximate to Dowd as a result of meeting these two cognoscenti but I'd sure rather my girlfriend and I have Maureen Dowd over for dinner than William Kristol.
-Benjamin Harris
During the transition from the Carter to the Reagan administration William F. Buckley, Jr. said that he anticipated that there would be less hugging and cheek-kissing between the new American president and the General Secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union than there had been previously.
Buckley went on to wonder aloud about the psychology behind this literal embrace of the dictator of a hostile superpower by the leader of the Free World.
Jimmy Carter's insouciance was part of the reason for his desire for a personal bonding with Leonid Brezhnev but there has always been the belief in diplomacy that a personal connection can lead to greater understanding and hence to conflict resolution.
The opposite is also felt to be true, personal animus makes dealing with the issues that are really at stake more difficult.
The perils of following these truisms need no itemization. As a conscious act of diplomacy personal friendliness as a means to the strategic end of conflict resolution is a proven failure.
It is not a rational act, or at least not just a rational act. It is purely an emotional human thing.
People want to like other people and to be liked by them. When we meet political figures whose views we share we want to have that political commonality conjoined with personal warmth. When we meet those with whom we disagree politically we often experience dissonant feelings if they have pleasant personalities.
I met William Kristol and Maureen Dowd at a bookfair recently.
One's political leanings--as opposed sometimes to one's views on a particular issue--are more instinctive than studied. Genes, upbringing, family, friends, teachers--and some facts--produce an inclination that is perhaps dignified by the term "world-view" but is something like that.
In me those factors have formed an opinionated, confrontational, angry, yelling, right-leaning, curious, reasonably bright, pretty well-read, pretty standard-issue, know-it-all American male.
My world-view is approximate to that of William Kristol. Kristol's avuncular TV persona is reinforcing to this political commonality.
I cannot ever remember a political issue on which I have identified with Maureen Dowd and her op-ed persona grates on me, as it does on many, especially on men. She was at the bookfair promoting her book "Are Men Necessary?"
My girlfriend holds dual French and American citizenship. She moved to the U.S. at 13, and is strong, intelligent, highly analytical, empathetic and modest in stating her political opinions on specific issues.
Her world view is that of a left-leaning Democrat.
When my girlfriend and I went over the book fair agenda I had enthusiastically circled Kristol's talk, to which she assented (by silence). She is still personally fond enough of me to sit peaceably with me through a talk by William Kristol.
Dowd and Kristol spoke on the same day in the same lecture room. Dowd's talk was before Kristol's.
Dowd was bright, witty, personable, generous with her questioners, modest. In an admittedly gender-engendered reaction she was also attractive. She has a beautiful face and gorgeous Irish red hair but I had seen pictures of her before. It was her personality that added so much to her attractiveness.
Curiously I didn't take any note of her figure until Lorna and I got to the front of the book-signing line. I leaned over the table behind which she was seated to ask her if she had heard about the domino-toppling Dutch sparrow and noted that she was wearing a pretty low-cut top that highlighted a full bosom.
During her thirty minute talk Dowd mentioned her mother, who died over the summer, three times. The references were appropriately placed in her talk but after two it was clear that she was still deeply affected by it. At the third mention her voice almost cracked.
The reserved, almost shy, way in which she looked at my girlfriend and me was so natural and unaffected. She responded to my sparrow news alert with nothing in particular, something like "No I hadn't heard of that. I'll have to check that out when I get done here," but it was not dismissive. It was not delighted but it was responsive.
The tone of her reply, the way she looked at us and the tone and content of her talk all suggested to me, correctly or incorrectly, that she was feeling vulnerable, maybe even clinically depressed. She was just so human.
I ran into Kristol as he was entering the lecture hall. He is short of stature which I hadn't expected.
"Mr. Kristol it's a pleasure to meet you," I said.
"Bill Kristol," he replied distractedly as if he was introducing himself to me and hadn't heard that I had just used his name so as to make it unnecessary for him to repeat it. He made only the briefest, most flitting eye contact.
Before Kristol spoke I gave Lorna a brief bio of him which was self-satisfyingly echoed by the man who introduced Kristol. "Bill Kristol is the editor of the most influential, most read magazine in Washington..."
The editor of the most influential magazine in Washington then gave a thirty minute talk exclusively promoting a book which was a compendium of essays from his magazine's first ten years; a Greatest Hits of The Weekly Standard. It was a bit crass.
There was nothing about "the state of the world" or even of current Washington, D.C. in his talk. No insight from one so influential with the Bushies. The smiles that he sprinkles about frequently when he speaks, which are so effective a part of his TV package, appeared more like facial tics in person. They were displayed randomly, often non sequiters to the subject.
I grew restless, impatient and then embarrassed. My girlfriend, with her world view, not wanting to rub it in, sat beside me respectfully in silence but this time it was not a silence of assent. Finally I voiced the frustration that we both felt at this disappointing presentation.
After his talk was over I attempted to speak to him.
"Mr. Kristol, do you have time for a question or do you have to go?"
"Well, I think I have to go to the book-signing," he said with the same distraction and disinterest.
My political leanings didn't change from approximate to Kristol to approximate to Dowd as a result of meeting these two cognoscenti but I'd sure rather my girlfriend and I have Maureen Dowd over for dinner than William Kristol.
-Benjamin Harris
Tuesday, November 29, 2005
On "Dead Sparrow Overshadows Domino World"
On "Dead Sparrow Overshadows Domino World"
I did not know that there was a "Domino World."
I have heard of a "Raider Nation," I was aware that there were groups of people dedicated to coin collecting, bird watching, surviving cancer and drunk drivers, sexual bondage (dedicated to, not surviving, I think), but I did not know of a "domino world."
I know where Holland is, I know that it's people are called Dutch, I don't know why the people of Holland are called Dutch though, I know of their windmills and wooden shoes, I know Amsterdam is their capital, that it has a famous red light district and a museum dedicated to Van Gogh. But I did not know that Holland was the, or a, center of this domino world.
I don't know why Holland would be a center of a domino world, if it is a national pastime, or if there's some hermeneutic wood thing between the shoes and the domino.
I had never considered the Dutch to be obsessive or prone to overreaction. My image of them had been as a placid, content, moderate people. I had no referent for a Dutch psyche that would attempt to break the world record for domino falling, or for it being televised, or for it being taken so seriously that a wayward bird would be extinguished for interfering, or for the shooter to receive death threats, for the creation of an impromptu web site on the incident, for 5,000 Dutch to sign a condolence card for the bird, for the head of a Dutch bird group to appeal to the people of Holland for calm.
I did not know.
The bird was the common sparrow, officially on some endangered list in Holland, but one whose even current diminished numbers were still 1,000,000 mating COUPLES.
I don't know what the Dutch reaction to the killing of a domino-interfering Bald Eagle or Ivory-billed Woodpecker would have been.
I don't know why this story appeared on ESPN.com.
There are so many aspects to this: the true nature of the inscrutable Dutch; the limits of one person's, or one people's, ability truly to understand another; the limits of knowledge generally; trans-species empathy; the allure of falling dominos; air-pistol control; what passes for culture; what passes for entertainment; the qualifications of the person who edits ESPN.com.; the concept of responsible journalism; the impact of televised violence.
I do not know.
-Benjamin Harris
I did not know that there was a "Domino World."
I have heard of a "Raider Nation," I was aware that there were groups of people dedicated to coin collecting, bird watching, surviving cancer and drunk drivers, sexual bondage (dedicated to, not surviving, I think), but I did not know of a "domino world."
I know where Holland is, I know that it's people are called Dutch, I don't know why the people of Holland are called Dutch though, I know of their windmills and wooden shoes, I know Amsterdam is their capital, that it has a famous red light district and a museum dedicated to Van Gogh. But I did not know that Holland was the, or a, center of this domino world.
I don't know why Holland would be a center of a domino world, if it is a national pastime, or if there's some hermeneutic wood thing between the shoes and the domino.
I had never considered the Dutch to be obsessive or prone to overreaction. My image of them had been as a placid, content, moderate people. I had no referent for a Dutch psyche that would attempt to break the world record for domino falling, or for it being televised, or for it being taken so seriously that a wayward bird would be extinguished for interfering, or for the shooter to receive death threats, for the creation of an impromptu web site on the incident, for 5,000 Dutch to sign a condolence card for the bird, for the head of a Dutch bird group to appeal to the people of Holland for calm.
I did not know.
The bird was the common sparrow, officially on some endangered list in Holland, but one whose even current diminished numbers were still 1,000,000 mating COUPLES.
I don't know what the Dutch reaction to the killing of a domino-interfering Bald Eagle or Ivory-billed Woodpecker would have been.
I don't know why this story appeared on ESPN.com.
There are so many aspects to this: the true nature of the inscrutable Dutch; the limits of one person's, or one people's, ability truly to understand another; the limits of knowledge generally; trans-species empathy; the allure of falling dominos; air-pistol control; what passes for culture; what passes for entertainment; the qualifications of the person who edits ESPN.com.; the concept of responsible journalism; the impact of televised violence.
I do not know.
-Benjamin Harris
Saturday, November 19, 2005
"Dead Sparrow Overshadows Domino World"
"Dead Sparrow Oveshadows Domino World"
Linguists like Noam Chomsky have given examples of meaningless sentences that can be constructed by using the rules of the language.
The dead sparrow sentence above is not one of these however.
It was the title of an article on ESPN.com a couple of days ago.
Clicking on the article I learned that some Dutch TV station had been trying to break its own record for falling dominos when the doomed sparrow accidentally knocked one over causing 23,000 others to fall before the China Syndrome was stopped.
A security guard then shot the bird dead with an air pistol and the TV station went on to break the record with over 4,000,000 dominos falling.
The assasination of the bird had been witnessed by a crowd however and they were distraught by the incident, hence the "overshadowing."
A web site was instantly created and over 5,000 people signed a petition in memory of the bird.
The marksman received death threats.
The head of a Dutch bird group called for channeling the passion into constructive efforts to save birds and urged calm in the nation.
-Benjamin Harris
Linguists like Noam Chomsky have given examples of meaningless sentences that can be constructed by using the rules of the language.
The dead sparrow sentence above is not one of these however.
It was the title of an article on ESPN.com a couple of days ago.
Clicking on the article I learned that some Dutch TV station had been trying to break its own record for falling dominos when the doomed sparrow accidentally knocked one over causing 23,000 others to fall before the China Syndrome was stopped.
A security guard then shot the bird dead with an air pistol and the TV station went on to break the record with over 4,000,000 dominos falling.
The assasination of the bird had been witnessed by a crowd however and they were distraught by the incident, hence the "overshadowing."
A web site was instantly created and over 5,000 people signed a petition in memory of the bird.
The marksman received death threats.
The head of a Dutch bird group called for channeling the passion into constructive efforts to save birds and urged calm in the nation.
-Benjamin Harris
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)