Thursday, June 25, 2009

SAO Barquin Shooting Close Out Memo Conclusion: "Inconclusive."



































1




INTRODUCTION



On Friday, January 16, 2004, at approximately 1:37

p.m., the Miami-Dade Police Department received a 911

telephone call stating that there was a burglary in process

at 14773 Southwest 58th Street. The caller, who spoke

Spanish, said that he lived across the street from the home

being burglarized, and that he had observed two (2) white

males jumping the fence and going into the back yard. Units

were dispatched at 1:39 p.m., from the Hammocks District with

Officer William Nelson assigned as the primary unit and

Officer Jorge Espinosa assigned as the back-up officer.

Officer Espinosa arrived first and, while checking the

exterior of the residence, discovered that a sliding glass

door in the rear of the house was open. Officer Espinosa

entered the residence and confronted two male burglars in the

master bedroom. One of them, later identified as Rolando

Llanes, jumped out of the bedroom window, while the other

man, later identified as Leonardo Barquin, allegedly pointed

a weapon at Officer Espinosa. Officer Espinosa then fired

two shots at Barquin, hitting him at least once. Barquin

then jumped out of the window and ran to climb the fence in

the backyard in an attempt to escape. Officer Espinosa

followed Barquin who allegedly pointed the weapon at the

officer at second time. Officer Espinosa responded by firing
2




one more shot as Barquin went over the fence.

Barquin ran over to Southwest 57th Terrace, where

he collapsed and was subsequently apprehended by Officer

Espinosa. Barquin had been shot twice and was bleeding

profusely. He was airlifted to Jackson Memorial Hospital,

where he expired at 9:56 p.m. that night. Rolando Llanes

continued to flee for several blocks and was later

apprehended. Both Llanes and Barquin were in possession of

items taken in the burglary of the residence at 14773

Southwest 58th Street. Neither Barquin nor Llanes had a

weapon when they were arrested and no weapon was ever

recovered.



SWORN STATEMENT OF OFFICER JORGE ESPINOSA



On February 17, 2004, a month after the shooting

incident, Officer Espinosa stated the following:

On January 16, 2004, he was assigned to uniform

patrol in the Hammocks District and was working the 6:00

a.m., to 2:00 p.m. shift. He was in a marked unit on 147th

Avenue approaching Sunset Drive, when he received a call for

a burglary in process. He quickly arrived in the area of

58th Street; however, he was having trouble locating the

correct address. He saw an older Hispanic male in his front

yard on 58th Street. When Officer Espinosa pulled up to him
3




to seek directions, the man said in Spanish "it is the pink

house". Officer Espinosa then drove his vehicle to the front

of the house (located at 14773 Southwest 58th Street), parked

the vehicle and walked up to the front door, which was

locked. He then saw that the gate leading to the backyard

was propped open. He went through the gate to the backyard

of the residence and noticed that the sliding glass door

leading into the house from the patio was open.

While announcing "police" several times, Officer

Espinosa went into the house with his H & K USP .40 caliber

pistol drawn. Upon entering the house, he heard "loud

noises" in a room to his right, and heard "objects being

thrown in the room." He walked to the room where he heard

the noises, saw that the door was open and announced "police"

two or three more times. Officer Espinosa then explained:

It was a dark room and there was still

throwing - there was objects being thrown inside

the room. I again, announced "police" about two

times and I heard from one of the subjects in the

room, "metro" really loud. I then heard the

shattering of glass inside the room and I saw a

subject with a white sock over his hand, and what

appeared to me as a semi-automatic handgun inside

of his hand, at which point, he pointed it at me

(indicating) and said "I'm kill you, cop" (sic)
4




and turned his body toward me. Simultaneously as

he said, "I'll kill you cop," I just shot at him

right after he said that. He was like at the

window.

According to Officer Espinosa, he was standing at

the foot of the bed when he fired his weapon two times. (See

sketch of bedroom attached as Exhibit A). When asked about

the number of subjects in the room, he said that it appeared

to be two; however, one had already gotten out of the window.

Concerning the subject remaining in the room, subsequently

identified as Leonardo Barquin, the following questions and

answers ensued.

Q. The person who pointed the weapon at you, where was he

standing at when you shot him?

A. He was going through the window.

Q. Do you know if either leg was outside the window?

A. I couldn't tell you.

Q. Or his torso?

A. It was dark and I couldn't tell.

Q. The person who had the white sock on, and the weapon in

his hand, could you tell if he had another sock on the

other hand also?

A. I couldn't tell, I was focused on the weapon in his

hand. I was scared and I was in fear of my life and I

couldn't see it.
5






Q. One question I didn't ask you was while you were inside

the bedroom, could you tell if any objects were being

thrown at you?

A. Again, it was dark inside the bedroom. I couldn't see

any objects being thrown at me, I just could hear a

lot of objects being thrown.



The foregoing quotations from Officer Espinosa's sworn

statement constitute the totality of questioning by the

Miami-Dade Police Department Homicide Detectives about what

happened in the bedroom that day when Espinosa allegedly fired

two shots at the suspect.

However, the questioning does continue seeking to

determine what happened after the subject escaped through the

window:

Q. What happened once this subject made it through the

window?

A. I noticed that they went through the window and I

doubled back where I came in through originally and

when I was approaching the sliding glass door to exit

the house, I advised, "shots fired" on the radio. And

at that time, I ran out toward the outside patio and I

seen the first person get on the fence. It was a

thinner white male. He got on the fence, which is on
6




the northeast corner of the home in question. He got

up there and he stood up on the top of the fence. He

was already on the other side, and the second male, the

larger guy, got up there as the first guy helped him

get on the fence. As I was getting to the fence to try

to get him, to try to detain him, he turns around and

points again his arm at me, with what appeared to be a

semi-automatic black handgun. Again, in fear of my

life, I thought he was going to kill me and I fired at

him one more time.

Q. About how far away from him do you think you were when

you discharged your weapon?

A. About six feet - five feet, six feet.

Q. How many times did you discharge your weapon?

A. One time.

Q. While we are speaking about your weapon, how do you

normally keep your weapon loaded? With how many

rounds?

A. I keep it loaded with the magazine full and one actual

round in the chamber.

Q. Did the subject ever fire any shots at you?

A. Not that I know of.

Q. Once the subject was at the top of the fence and he

pointed a weapon at you, and you fired, what happened

next?
7




A. I heard them fall onto the other side, which would be

the northeast corner lot. They fell on the other side.

Since I knew they had a gun on them and I was scared

that they would shoot me if I got up on the fence, I

decided to get on the air and run around back towards

the entryway where the gates was, where I originally

entered the property.

Q. When you exited the residence after the first

engagement, as you went through the patio area, which

way did you run? Did you go directly towards the

fence?

A. I ran up a little bit towards the east. There was a

table there and I ran around the table.

The foregoing quotations are the entirety of

the information provided by Officer Espinosa about the

third shot fired at the subject.



According to Officer Espinosa, he then ran through the

side gate to the house back to the front yard. Leaving his

marked unit parked in front of the residence, he turned left

and ran down 58th to 147th Avenue(FN1) (FN1, Nine (9) houses

away from the crime scene.) He turned left on 147th Avenue

and then ran to 57th Terrace, which was the next street over

running parallel to 58th Street(FN2) (FN2, The length of two (2)

houses including the front and backyard). Turning left on
8




57th Terrace, he ran until he heard "wheezing types of

noises3". (FN3, Six (6) houses away from 147th Ave.) Officer

Espinosa then stated the following:

On 57th Terrace, I turned left, which would

be westbound on 57th Terrace, and I ran past

about two or three houses to where I approximate

the house would be, in back of where they jumped,

to be where they would be coming out from. At

that point, I heard wheezing types of noises. I

was giving - I was trying to set up a perimeter

on the radio, giving description of the subjects

as I was running toward there, and at that time,

I located the noises and saw the subject lying on

the ground between a house and a fence, with a

white sock on his arm and his hand. I drew down

my weapon on him and advised him to show me his

hands. He spread them out, at which point I got

on the air and I advised that there was one

subject in custody, and I started fire rescue.

Q. Did you ever put handcuffs on that subject?

A. No, I did not. As soon as I called for fire rescue on

my radio, and I still had my gun drawn up on him, I see

a white Maxima type of vehicle - undercover CST unit -

drive up. Two detectives jump out of the vehicle and

begin walking towards me. One detective, Serrano,
9




walks up to me and pulls me aside to where there is a

parked vehicle, and told me to stand there. I stood by

the parked vehicle, and that was like toward the center

of the roadway. At that point, I had a view of the

Southwest neighborhood there. At that point, he told

me, "stay right here, are you okay?" He asked me if I

had been injured. I told him no I didn't have any

injuries.

Officer Espinosa's sworn statement took a total of

fifteen (15) minutes and provided only the information

included above.



OFFICER JORGE ESPINOSA'S INJURIES



Detective Jaen-Rosello was directed to process the

crime scene beginning at 14773 Southwest 58th Street (the

residence where the shooting occurred), following the blood

trail leading down Southwest 57th Terrace, culminating at

14750 Southwest 57th Terrace (where Barquin was apprehended).

He also processed the third crime scene at 14744 Southwest

55th Terrace, where the second subject, later identified as

Rolando Llanes, was apprehended. These crime scenes will be

discussed in detail at a later point in this memorandum;

however, it is relevant to discuss at this point what he

observed, and Detective Taaffe photographed, concerning
10




Officer Espinosa. After taking the officer's weapon,

detective Jaen-Rosello reports the following:

The following injuries are observed on

officer J. Espinosa. A redness of the skin is

noted on his right rib cage, and abrasion on his

let elbow, a cut of his left thumb, and an

abrasion on his right hand (behind thumb).

These injuries were observed and photographed on

January 16, 2004, immediately after the shooting incident,

and their description was included in a death scene

investigation report approved by detective Jaen-Rosello's

supervisor on February 11, 2004. However, in his sworn

statement taken on February 17, 2004, Officer Espinosa was

never asked about his injuries.



STATEMENT OF OFFICER WILLIAM NELSON



Officer William Nelson gave a sworn statement on

January 16, 2004, at 10:50 p.m. on the evening of the

shooting incident. On January 16th, he was assigned to

uniform patrol in the Hammocks District, and was working the

8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. shift. At approximately 1:39 p.m., he

was dispatched as the primary unit to a burglary in process

at a pink house across the street from 14798 Southwest 58th

Street. The 911 call had originated from the latter
11




location. The dispatcher also advised Officer Nelson that

there were two (2) male subjects in dark clothing. Officer

Jorge Espinosa was also dispatched as the back-up unit;

however, Espinosa arrived at the scene first. A few moments

later, while Officer Nelson was still enroute, he heard

Officer Espinosa in a "very excited" voice request emergency

assistance. A few moments later, he heard Espinosa ask again

for emergency assistance and stating that shots had been

fired. Finally, he heard that Espinosa was at "57" and that

Espinosa was requesting fire rescue.

Assuming that "57" meant 57th Street or 57th

Terrace, Officer Nelson sped to 57th Terrace arriving

approximately two (2) minutes later. Upon arrival at 14750

Southwest 57th Terrace, he saw Officer Espinosa standing in

front of the house with the wounded subject a few feet away.

Officer Nelson ran up to the victim (Barquin) and noticed

that the victim had a white sock on his right hand, and that

he was bleeding profusely. Officer Nelson got his first aid

kit from his vehicle and began to assist the victim. He

believed that the victim had been shot in the left buttocks,

and the left thigh, and had a wound on his right elbow

possibly a graze wound from a bullet.

While administering first aid, Officer Nelson

attempted unsuccessfully to get the victim's name. However,

he did not respond and just "stared into space". Officer
12




Nelson then said, "So, is breaking into a house fun?" At

that point, the victim made eye contact with the officer and

replied, "No." The victim then said, "Please don't let me

die." Fire rescue then arrived and took over the victim's

treatment.

While fire rescue was treating the victim, Officer

Nelson retrieved the victim's pants, which had been cut off

of him in order to facilitate treatment, and emptied the

pockets looking for identification. He did not find any

identification; however, he did recover a watch, a set of

handcuffs, a couple of keys, an American Express card, and a

clear plastic bag containing white pills.

After the victim was airlifted from the scene,

Officer Nelson helped secure the area and began to follow the

blood trail backwards toward where the shooting had occurred.

He lost the blood trail at the side of 14770 Southwest 57th

Terrace, where he observed that the area appeared to have

been recently washed down. He saw a White Latin male, in his

mid-twenties, in the backyard of the residence behind a

locked wrought iron gate; however, he did not speak to him.

The Latin male at 14770 Southwest 57th Terrace was

subsequently identified as Alberto Angel Ferro. (See Ferro's

statement and interviews at page 15, infra)

Officer Nelson told homicide detectives and crime

scene personnel what he had heard and observed, and gave a
13




sworn statement later that night.

MEDICAL TREATMENT OF LEONARDO BARQUIN AT

JACKSON MEMORIAL HOSPITAL



Concern has been expressed about the condition of

the victim's body when viewed by the family; therefore, it

would be both helpful and appropriate to discuss Mr.

Barquin's emergency medical treatment at Jackson Memorial

Hospital.

After being treated at the scene by Officer Nelson

and by Miami-Dade Fire Rescue personnel, Mr. Barquin was

airlifted to Ryder Trauma Center at Jackson Memorial Hospital

and arrived at 2:30 p.m. He was admitted with two (2)

gunshot wounds, an open wound of the forearm, traumatic

shock, and an extensive loss of blood. His estimated blood

loss was forty-two (42) liters, and he was given fifty-two

(52) units of blood products intravenously.

In treating the gunshot wounds, the surgeons found

that the victim had a through-and-through gunshot wound to

the left thigh with massive bleeding through the femoral

artery. He also had a gunshot wound to the right buttocks

with massive bleeding into the abdomen. Before he could even

be operated on, he went into cardiac arrest, and had to be

resuscitated. In an attempt to stop the bleeding, the

surgeons had to make multiple incisions and dissections, and
14




had to pack his body with special bandages. The wounds were

then closed by suture after a very low systolic blood

pressure was established. The open wound on his arm was

determined to not be a gunshot wound, and was not life

threatening. Despite all these efforts, Mr. Barquin expired

at 9:56 p.m. that evening. One spent projectile was

recovered from the body of Mr. Barquin and turned over to the

Miami-Dade Police Department.

Because of the extensive surgical intervention, and

the packing of Mr. Barquin's body with bandages, there was

significant damage to his body as well as significant

swelling. The undersigned Assistant State Attorney reviewed

the condition of Mr. Barquin's body with the Medical Examiner

to determine if there was any evidence of beating or other

trauma as suspected by some in the victim's family. We were

assured by the Medical Examiner that all wounds and marks on

Mr. Barquin's body were consistent with two (2) gunshot

wounds, with injuries caused by jumping through a window and

fleeing, and with surgical intervention at the Ryder Trauma

Center. There was no evidence of beating or other trauma.



REPORT OF THE MEDICAL EXAMINER



Dr. Mark Shuman conducted the autopsy on January

17, 2004. Dr. Shuman determined that the cause of death was
15




multiple gunshot wounds. Leonardo Barquin had two (2)

gunshot wounds, one was a penetrating gunshot wound to the

right buttock, and the other was a perforating gunshot wound

of the left leg. These wounds one described more

specifically as:



PENETRATING GUNSHOT WOUND "A" OF RIGHT BUTTOCK:



An entrance type gunshot wound is 29-3/8 inches

below the top of the head and 2-3/4 inches to the right of

midline on the right upper buttock. It is a 0.9 x 0.5

centimeter, horizontally oriented, oval, skin defect with a

0.2 centimeter, circumferential, abrasion collar that is

irregular inferiorly. No shoot or stipple is associated with

the wound. The projectile continued through the sacrum, into

the pelvis, through the distal descending colon, through a

loop of small bowel that had been repaired surgically, and

was recovered by the surgeons in the right side of the

pelvis.

The direction of the path of the wound is back to

front and right to left.

PERFORATING GUNSHOT "B" OF LEFT LEG:

An entrance type gunshot wound is 38-1/4 inches

below the top of the head and 2-3/4 inches to the right of

the posterior midline of the left thigh. It is a 0.9 x 0.4
16




centimeter, horizontally oriented, oval defect with a 0.1

centimeter, circumferential, abrasion collar. No shoot or

stipple is associated with the wound. The wound is

surrounded by an 8.0 x 3.5 centimeter, pink and purple

ecchymosis. The projectile passed through the muscles of the

left thigh medial to the left femur, injured the left femoral

vein, which has been sutured, and exited the left anterior

thigh. The exit wound is within a surgical incision on the

left thigh. It consists of a 1.6-centimeter, semicircular

defect in the left side of the surgical incision, 37-3/4

inches below the top of the head; and a 1.1-centimeter,

irregular, semicircular defect in the right side of the

surgical incision, 39-1/4 inches below the top of the head.

The direction of the path of the wound is back to

front and slightly right to left.

The victim also had multiple abrasions on his

scalp, arms and legs, and two (2)-scalp contusions. All of

the injuries were consistent with the victim's jumping

through a window, jumping over a fence, and fleeing through

the yards of several residences.

Finally, the victim's body had extensive evidence

of medical intervention, including a number of incisions and

sutures.

It was decided by the undersigned Assistant State

Attorney to first cover Officer Espinosa's account of what
17




happened on January 16, 2004, juxtaposed with the injuries,

medical treatment, and autopsy of the victim, Leonardo

Barquin. With this knowledge, one can better understand the

following crime scene reports and witness statements, and can

better understand the many unanswered questions and

unresolved issues in this investigation.

Crime Scene # 1 (The residence at 147th 73 Southwest 58th

Street)

January 16, 2004



The first crime scene is the location of the

burglary, and the shooting, which is located at 14773

Southwest 58th Street. The crime scene is described as

follows and is depicted in Exhibits A and B.

The scene is the three-bedroom, two-bath,

single-family home, located on the north side of

the street facing south, with the above listed

address. The rear yard of the house is

surrounded by a wooden fence. There is a small

palm tree in the northeast corner of the yard.

There is a plastic chair up against the tree

facing the rear fence. The chair is

bloodstained. There are also bloodstains on the

fence, above the chair, on the side that faces

south as well as on the side that faces west.
18




There is a toy gun on the ground in the southeast

quadrant of the yardFN4. (FN4, According to the

crime scene personnel, the toy gun had the

appearance of having been in the yard for a great

deal of time. It was not suspected to be the

weapon allegedly wielded by Barquin.)

The south master bedroom awning window is

broken. On the ground, below the window, there

are broken pieces of aluminum from the window

frame, glass fragments, and broken pieces of the

wooden Venetian blind. A set of storm panels and

a white sweat sock are lying nearby. There are

bloodstains on top of the storm panels on a glass

fragment, on a piece of wooden slat, and on the

white sock.

The sliding glass door that leads to the

rear yard from the family room is open. Beside

the door is a sofa upon which is a piece of 2 x 4

wood. Reportedly, the wood was used by the owner

to secure the sliding door. The front door is

secured from the inside bay chain lock.

There is extensive ransacking in the master

bedroom. The armoire, dresser, and chest of

drawers have open drawers. Much clothing and

many documents are strewn about the floor. The
19




dresser is located along the east wall, across

from the bed. A small top drawer on the dresser

is open, revealing women's lingerie. A casing,

head stamped "Federal S & W", is located on the

lingerie.

The broken rear window is located in the

north bedroom wall. On the floor, below the

window, is a bent bloodstained screen. There are

also bloodstains on the floor and windowsill.

There is an exercise machine near the west side

of the window. Under the machine is a

projectile.

January 17, 2004

On January 17, 2004, the owner of the burglarized

residence called the Miami-Dade Police Department with a

surprising discovery. He had discovered another shell casing

while cleaning up the debris. Mr. Lopez, the homeowner,

reported that the casing was under the glass and debris, and

that he had not touched or moved it. The following describes

the crime scene as reported by Detective Jaen-Rosello at

approximately 5:20 p.m., on January 17th, and depicted in the

sketch attached as Exhibit B:

The scene is the residence located at 14773

Southwest 58th Street. The scene is confined to

the Southwest portion of the back yard. Located
20




on the ground under the master bedroom window is

a "Federal S & W .40 caliber" casing. The casing

is observed among and under pieces of glass and

other debris, which came from the broken window.

According to Detective Gallagher the casing was

found by the homeowner while cleaning the debris.

The casing is approximately eight feet east of

the west wooden fence, and one foot six inches

from the bedroom exterior north wall. For an

exact location, please refer to the backyard

sketch prepared by Crime Scene Detective C.

Green. The rest of the scene is unremarkable.

The second casing was not all that was found on

January 17, the day after the shooting. A third casing was

discovered in the backyard near the fence where Barquin had

fled. This scene is described as follows and is also

depicted in Exhibit B:

The scene is the rear (north) yard of the

residence. The yard consists of grass with palm

trees. There is a rear patio with furniture

directly behind the house and a hot tub located

at the northwest corner. A single chair is

located in the northeast corner of the rear yard

by the fence corner.

Homicide Detective Chavarry requested that
21




a metal detector be utilized to locate a missing

casing. One (1) Federal .40 S & W casing was

visually found near the northeast corner of the

rear yard. Photographs are taken of the casing

and its location.



The Blood Trail and Crime Scene # 2

(The residence at 14750 Southwest 57th Terrace

Where Leonardo Barquin was apprehended.)



Detective Jaen-Rosello prepared the report on the

secondary crime scene, which is sketched in Exhibit C.

The secondary scene consists of 14780,

14770, 14760, and 14750 Southwest 57th Terrace.

The residences extend northeast from the primary

scene located at 14773 Southwest 58th Street, and

all face north. The first residence which is

14780 Southwest 57th Terrace. Blood is noted on

the inside wooden fence (Marker 1), and also on

the concrete slab (Markers 2 & 3) located in the

southwest corner of the yard. The trail

continues on a northeasterly direction along the

tile walkway (Marker 4), and on the inner and

outer side of the gate (Markers 5 & 6) located on

the east side of the residence.
22




The blood trail continues east onto the

property of 14770 Southwest 57th Terrace. Blood

is noted on the north end of the exterior west

wall (Marker 7), on the southwest corner of the

driveway, and also on the west side of the

walkway (Marker 8).

The blood trail continues east onto the

property of 14760 Southwest 57th Terrace.

Several planters with various types of trees and

plants are located in front of the residence;

each planter is enclosed by concrete borders.

Blood is noted along the concrete borders, and

also on the plants located in the planter in the

west side of the walkway (closest to the front

door), on the walkway near the front door, on the

driveway, and along the planter's concrete

borders located on the east side of the driveway

(Markers 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 & 15).

The end of the blood trail is located along

the east side of 14750 Southwest 57th Terrace.

This is the location where the victim collapsed

and was apprehended. A concrete walkway is

located on the west side of the residence, and

leads to an iron gate, which is closed. Blood is

noted on the west exterior wall of the residence,
23




which is situated along the east side of the

walkway. Blood is also noted on the walkway

itself, and on the outer side of the wooden fence

located on the west side of the walkway.

Discarded fire rescue supplies are lying on the

grass near the north end of the walkway. Lying

on the concrete walkway are a white "Polo" sock,

a pair of light blue boxer shorts, a pair of

black shorts, a book of matches, an "American

Express" credit card with numbers

"371128729711002" and the name "Gus Minguez" on

it, several loose coins, a set of keys, a white

metal watch, a cigarette lighter, a pair of

handcuffs with the numbers "14324" on them, and a

clear plastic bag containing several white pills.

The shorts and boxer shorts were cut off the

victim by fire rescue personnel. The clothing

and all the before mentioned items were stained

with blood. The rest of the secondary scene is

unremarkable.

Crime scene # 3 (The residence at 14744 Southwest 55th Terrace

where Rolando Llanes was apprehended.)



The third crime scene was where Rolando Llanes was

apprehended. This scene is described as follows; however,
24




there is no corresponding sketch:

One (1) floor CBI facing north. A

stonewall is located in front of the house.

Behind the stonewall, property taken from a

residence located at 14773 Southwest 58th Street

was recovered. The west side of the residence is

bordered with a wooden fence. Inside the fence,

markings in the soil indicate the fence was

scaled to allow entry into the rear yard.

The following was collected and signed over to

Detective B. Nichols:

One (1) Swiss Army watch, white metal, S/N

700013131.

One (1) Seiko watch, white metal, S/N 1D3580.

One (1) Enicar watch, white metal, S/N Unknown.

One (1) Flat head screwdriver.

One (1) Electrical device.

One (1) Pair of sweat socks.



Laboratory Analysis Report from the Firearm and

Tool Mark Unit.



In a report prepared by Firearms and Tool Mark

Unit, it was determined that the three (3) casings, and two

(2) projectiles (one from the master bedroom, and one
25




recovered from the victim), all were fired in the H & K USP

.40 caliber pistol used by Officer Espinosa on January 16,

2004.

Latent Fingerprint Report



In a report prepared by the Crime Scene

Investigation Bureau, Identification Section, only one latent

print could be identified. The latent print of Rolando

Llanes was lifted from the glass sliding door of 14733

Southwest 58th Street.



Forensic Biology Analysis Report



On its Forensic Biology Analysis Report, the Crime

Laboratory Bureau determined that all of the blood samples

and swabs collected from the master bedroom, and backyard of

14773 Southwest 58th Street, as well as the blood trail

leading to 14750 Southwest 57th Terrace (where Barquin was

apprehended) belonged to Leonardo Barquin.

It should be noted that there is no report nor any

indication that the projectile recovered in the master

bedroom under the treadmill was analyzed to determine if it

had the victim's DNA on it, and to possibly confirm that it

was the result of a through-and-through shot to the victim's

thigh.
26






Statement of Rolando Llanes



Rolando Llanes was a friend of Leonardo Barquin,

and helped him burglarize the residence at 14773 Southwest

58th Street, on January 16, 2004. He was arrested shortly

after the burglary, after fleeing and hiding in the yard of

14744 Southwest 55th Terrace. After his arrest, Mr. Llanes

was interviewed by Miami-Dade detectives, and gave a sworn

statement at 6:58 p.m., on the same day. The following

summarizes the information provided by Mr. Llanes:

Mr. Llanes, who was eighteen years old at the time,

was a friend of Leonardo Barquin, and was called on the

telephone by him at approximately 11:00 a.m., on January

16th. They agreed to meet at the Amoco Station on 152nd

Avenue Southwest and Southwest 56th Street to "just chill"

and to "just walk around". Mr. Llanes did, however, bring a

pair of white socks with him just in case they decided to

break into a house. Mr. Barquin had a pair of white socks

also. The two met at approximately noon and began to walk

around the residential neighborhoods looking for a house to

burglarize. They located a house (14773 Southwest 58th

Street), knocked on the door, and determined that no one was

home. They went to the backyard and saw that a window was

"cracked open." Mr. Llanes climbed into this window, which
27




turned out to be the master bedroom. He then went around to

the family room, and opened the sliding glass door for Mr.

Barquin. Putting white socks onto both hands, they both went

back to the master bedroom, and began rummaging around

looking for items to steal. After about five (5) minutes, he

heard "police...stop...police! Upon hearing the police, both

he and Barquin ran toward the window. Llanes managed to get

out, being the thinner man, while Barquin got stuck. As

Llanes ran to the fence in the backyard, he heard two (2)

shots, and heard Barquin make "a hurt noise." He kept

running, then heard two (2) more shots. As he heard the

second two (2) shots, he jumped the fence, ran through

several yards, and went to a nearby shopping center on 57th

Terrace. He never saw the police officer who shot Mr.

Barquin. He tried to hide in the restroom of the

Blockbusters Video store; however, it was locked and he could

not get in. When he ran back outside, he was spotted by the

police and began running again. He ran to 14744 Southwest

55th Terrace, where he hid and emptied his pockets of the

items, which he had stolen in the burglary. He never saw

what Barquin had taken in the burglary. However, he did

state that neither he nor Barquin had a weapon.

He was arrested a few minutes later. The following

items were recovered on the ground adjacent to where he was

arrested: A Swiss Army Men's watch, a Seiko Men's watch, an
28




Enican Men's watch, a flat head Stanley screwdriver, an

unknown electronic device, and two (2) white socks, two (2)

pair of silver earrings, one (1) pair of gold earrings, a

gold I.D. bracelet ("Carolina"), a gold bracelet with

multi-color stones, a gold ring, a silver bracelet, blue

plastic bead bracelet, a silver necklace, and a gold "Angel"

pin.

Interviews of Daniel and Elizabeth Lopez



Daniel and Elizabeth Lopez owned the home at 14773

Southwest 58th Street, which was burglarized by Mr. Barquin

and Mr. Llanes. Mr. Lopez was notified by his alarm company

at approximately 1:50 p.m. that his home alarm had been

activated. He was in Broward County and believed it was

likely a false claim; therefore, he did not go home at that

time. When asked about a weapon in the house, he stated, "I

don't own a gun, nor have I ever had one."

Elizabeth Lopez stated that she and her husband

were having marital problems, and that she had not been home

since Wednesday, (2 days before). She stated that when she

left, there had been a black revolver with wooden grips in a

zippered bag in the closet in the master bedroom.

Daniel Lopez was questioned again about a weapon

and he admitted that he had a felony conviction, and did not

want to admit to possession of a firearm. However, he stated
29




that he did, in fact, have a .22 caliber black revolver with

wooden grips, and that it was kept in a pouch. He also

admitted that he moved the weapon from his house to his place

of business, a tree farm, when his marital problems began.

At 8:30 p.m., on the night of January 16th,

detectives went to the tree farm at 21975 Southwest 264th

Street in Homestead, with Mr. Daniel Lopez, and observed a

black .38-caliber Colt Detective Special, two (2) inch

revolver with wooden grips.

As far as the items recovered from the pockets of,

and nearby Barquin, and Llanes, Mr. and Mrs. Lopez identified

all items as belonging to them, except for the white socks

and screwdriver. The American Express credit card in

Barquin's pocket was in the name of "Gustavo Minguez" who is

the brother of Elizabeth Lopez.



Statement of Sergeant Francisco Armendariz



Francisco Armendariz is a Sergeant in the General

Investigations Unit and is assigned to the Hammocks District.

On January 16, 2004, he responded to the radio call for an

officer needing assistance. He received the call at

approximately 1:45, and arrived in the area a few minutes

later.

He went to the location where Rolando Llanes had
30




been arrested and saw him seated in the back seat of a marked

unit. Sergeant Armendariz immediately recognized Rolando

Llanes since he had investigated his activities for some

time, and had, in fact, arrested him for burglary six (6)

months before. When Sergeant Llanes spoke to him, Llanes

responded: "Why did you have to shoot my homeboy, Leo?"

Sergeant Armendariz asked if he meant Leonardo Barquin, to

which Llanes responded, Yeah, that's him."

Sergeant Armendariz also was familiar with Leonardo

Barquin whom he (the Sergeant) had surveilled for numerous

hours as a known burglar.



Statement of Alberto Ferro



Alberto Ferro was the individual seen by Officer

Nelson in the backyard of 14770 Southwest 57th Terrace

shortly after Leonardo Barquin was arrested. Mr. Ferro

became an object of intense scrutiny by both the Miami-Dade

Police Department, and the FBI in their attempt to locate the

weapon allegedly pointed at Officer Espinosa by Barquin. As

previously noted, neither Leonardo Barquin or Rolando Llanes

had a weapon when arrested, and no weapon was ever recovered

from the crime scenes. Therefore, in addition to the

physical search of the ground covered by Llanes and Barquin

during their flight attempt, the focus turned to Mr. Ferro
31




since he lived just behind, and to the east side of the

location where Barquin had been shot and was at home during

the incident. Additionally, the blood trail left by Barquin

passed by and through Ferro's yard.

Mr. Ferro was first interviewed and gave a sworn

statement at approximately 8:00 p.m., on the evening of the

incident. Mr. Ferro, who was twenty (20) years old at that

time, stated that he lived at 14770 Southwest 57th Terrace

with his parents, and was at home on the day in question. In

the interview, the detective asked about events happening at

approximately 2:30 p.m., however, one can properly assume the

meant approximately 1:30 p.m., since Ferro responded by

discussing the incident in question. Ferro stated that he

was in his room playing videogames, and saw a person in black

running past his window wearing "a long sleeve black - kind

of looked like a hoodie." A moment later, he went to his

front yard to bring in the garbage a can and saw an officer,

firearm drawn, running toward him from the east approximately

from four (4) houses down. The officer yelled at him to get

down, to which Ferro raised his hands. He told the officer

that he lived there, and then he walked to the back of the

house. According to Ferro, while in the backyard, he heard

what he believed was two (2) gunshots. He did not see anyone

fire the shots; however, he returned to the front of his

house and saw two (2) officers this time walking toward him.
32




He stated that he heard one officer (the one that he had seen

first running toward him) tell the other officer that he "had

to shoot him because he saw a weapon, and the person had a

weapon or something." The sworn statement was concluded with

Ferro denying that he had neither seen nor retrieved any

evidence from his yard.

Before the sworn statement, Mr. Ferro was

interviewed by detective P. Diaz and Detective C. McCully.

According to the report filed by Detective Diaz on January

29, 2004, Ferro repeated almost verbatim what he had told

Detectives Diaz and McCully in the sworn statement taken

later that evening at police headquarters. Detective Diaz is

also the individual who took Ferro's sworn statement.

However, Detective McCully's report, prepared on

April 28, 2004, tells a different version of the interview

with Ferro conducted before his sworn statement. Detective

McCully wrote the following:

On January 16, 2004, Ferro had acknowledged

to this investigator and to Detective Diaz that

he knew Barquin and Llanes. Detective Diaz went

on to take Ferro's statement, which stated in

part that although he knew Barquin and Llanes, he

was not involved in this burglary, and that he

did not receive a firearm from either of the

above subjects after they exited the burglary
33




victim's residence....

Detective McCully recontacted Ferro on February 27,

2004, and asked him to take a polygraph. Ferro agreed and

the examination was scheduled for March 12, 2004.

After Detective McCully made repeated attempts to

contact Ferro about his scheduled polygraph examination,

Ferro finally called him. Slattery Associates conducted the

examination. In the pre-interview, Ferro admitted that he

was involved in a burglary attempt with Leonardo Barquin and

several others in approximately April 2003. Ferro also

stated that he believed Barquin was a member of the Latin

Kings; however, he denied his own membership.

Ferro was asked three (3) relevant questions during

the polygraph examination:

1. Did you take part in the burglary

involving Leo Barquin?

[Writer's note: "that burglary" is not

identified].

2. Did you take or conceal a gun, which

Leo Barquin may have had on January 16, 2004?

3. Are you intentionally withholding

information about that burglary and shooting

involving Leo Barquin?

Ferro answered "no" to all three (3) questions to

which George Slattery determined the answers were consistent
34




with deception. Unable to explain "why he failed the

polygraph examination, Ferro was allowed to go home.

Ferro was re-interviewed and given a polygraph

examination by the FBI on December 10, 2004. He was asked

two (2) questions:

1. Did [you] plan with Leonardo or Rolando

to steal from that house?

2. Do you know for sure if Leonardo had a

gun that day? (Emphasis added).

Ferro responded "no" to both questions and it was

the examiner's opinion that his responses were indicative of

deception.

After being told of the deceptive results, Ferro

admitted the following as contained in an FBI report dated

December 27th, 2004:

Ferro admitted that he knew and associated

with Barquin and Rolando. Early in 2003, Ferro,

Barquin and Michael last name unknown (LNU)

attempted a burglary in the South Miami area.

Also, in June 2003, Barquin was supposed to do a

burglary with Ferro, but he never showed up.

That day Ferro was arrested by MDPD in the

process of committing said burglary. Ferro has

been present at Michael's house when Barquin and

Rolando talked about prior burglaries and planned
35




future ones.

On more than one occasion, Barquin offered

to sell Ferro items that he stole from homes he

burglarized. Ferro denied purchasing any of the

stolen property offered by Barquin. Ferro added

that one time Barquin was selling two guns that

he (Barquin) claimed were stolen. Ferro saw the

guns, described one as a black pistol, possibly a

Glock and the other a small "silver pistol"

similar to the ones "seen in James Bond movies."

Barquin bragged that he had burglarized a police

officer's home and stole a gun. Ferro observed

Barquin was always talking about having guns and

selling stolen guns. Ferro never purchased a gun

from Barquin.

Ferro described Barquin as a violent

individual who was always talking about fighting

and hurting people. Ferro stated that Barquin

claimed he was Latin King gang member. One time,

Ferro observed Barquin produce a baseball bat and

attack someone he was having an argument with.

Ferro stated that Barquin and Michael sold

marijuana and cocaine. Ferro frequently

purchased marijuana and cocaine from Michael, but

admitted that he has purchased marijuana from
36




Barquin. Ferro, Barquin and Michael regularly

gathered at Michael's house to socialize and

smoke marijuana.

Regarding the burglary and police shooting

on January 16th, 2004, Ferro stated that he was

home with his grandmother and housekeeper that

day. Ferro explained that he was in his bedroom

playing a television game when he observed

through his window someone running across the

front of his house. Ferro could not describe the

person, but said the individual was wearing a

black sweatshirt with a hood. He stated that

this is the attire that burglars wear because it

helps conceal their faces. Ferro immediately

proceeded outside to investigate what was

happening. As Ferro exited the front of his

house, he observed blood dropping on his driveway

and two MDPD officers running towards him. The

MDPD officer closest to him was holding a gun and

a police radio, and shouting, "freeze." Ferro

stated that he stopped and raised his hands.

Moments later, Ferro observed said officer turn

away from him and point his weapon towards the

back of his neighbors house. Ferro could not see

from where he was standing who the officer was
37




pointing the gun at. Realizing that he was not

the person that officer was shouting at, Ferro

grabbed a garbage can that his grandfather left

outside earlier that day and returned it to his

backyard where it is normally kept. Then Ferro

entered his house through the rear sliding glass

door and told his grandmother and housekeeper to

stay in the house, because there was police

activity outside. Ferro later opened his front

door and stood in the doorway, smoked a cigarette

and watched the police activity outside. While

standing in the doorway, Ferro observed a large

police presence in the neighborhood, and was

instructed by an MDPD officer to say inside.

Ferro claimed that he did not know at that time

who the police were chasing. It was not until

later that evening that a neighbor informed Ferro

that Barquin had been shot and killed by the

police.

Ferro denied finding a gun on his property

that day or anytime subsequent to the incident.

He denied knowing that Barquin or Rolando were

going to commit a burglary in his neighborhood

that day. He advised that he has never

burglarized houses in his neighborhood, but
38




stated that in 2003, Barquin and Rolando

burglarized a house about four blocks from his

house. Ferro denied having any contact with

Barquin and Rolando on January 16, 2004. Ferro

stated that a couple of days after the shooting,

he was outside his house when Michael drove up in

his car, and commented about Barquin's death.

Michael did not say anything about Barquin having

a gun the day of the shooting.

Ferro believes that Barquin probably had a

gun the day of the shooting. He explained that

Barquin stole guns from the houses he

burglarized, sold guns and talked about carrying

a gun on his person. Ferro added that Barquin

talked about having a gun on him when he

burglarized homes. Ferro believed that Barquin

was capable of shooting someone, but Ferro did

know if Barquin ever shot or attempted to shoot

anyone.

Ferro advised that a few days after the

shooting, a man claiming to be Barquin's

step-father tried two times to make contact with

him. Ferro did not know the man's name. The man

came to Ferro's house twice wanting to talk to

him, but he was not home. The first time the man
39




spoke with Ferro's father and the second time he

spoke with Ferro's grandfather. Ferro believes

that the reason for the visit was to influence

his statements to the police and attorneys

regarding the shooting and his knowledge of

Barquin's past. Ferro added that Barquin's

family stands to make a lot of money for the

shooting and want him to help them with the

lawsuit. About three weeks ago, Ferro was

approached by Michael's older brother, Ramiro

(LNU) at the Dadeland Mall. Ramiro brought up

Barquin's shooting and told Ferro that Barquin's

mother wanted to talk to him about the shooting.

Ferro stated that Barquin's mother wanted to talk

to him because she is suing the MDPD. Ferro

said, "I know she wants to offer me money to say

things to the police that would help her with the

lawsuit." Ferro stated that someone at TGK, Dade

County's Correctional Facility, made two, three

attempts to call him at home. All the calls were

received by his grandfather and occurred at 2:00

or 3:00 in the morning. Ferro advised that his

grandfather never said if he spoke with the

caller, but Ferro believes it was Rolando trying

to make contact with him.
40




Ferro did not provide any further

information at this time.

Two points should be noted in Ferro's FBI

interview: (1) He does not mention hearing two gunshots

while he was in his backyard, and (2) he continues to deny

finding a weapon belonging to either Barquin or Llanes on the

day of the shooting.



The Professional Compliance Bureau Investigation



Officer Jorge Espinosa resigned from the Miami-Dade

Police Department on March 1, 2006. From at least as early

as May 2003 until at least the date of his resignation,

Officer Espinosa was under criminal investigation by the

Professional Compliances Bureau (PCB) of the Miami-Dade

Police Department. According to PCB reports and interviews

conducted by the undersigned Assistant State Attorneys with

PCB investigators, Officer Espinosa was suspected of engaging

in a wide range of criminal activities including acting as a

lookout for narcotics rip-offs, arson, insurance fraud,

credit card fraud, and involvement in residential burglaries.

In fact, on January 16th, 2004, the day of the shooting

incident, Officer Espinosa's vehicle was secretly equipped

with an electronic tracking device (Teltrac) so that PCB

investigators could monitor his travels while on duty.
41




Upon learning of this information, the undersigned

Assistant State Attorneys decided to keep the police shooting

investigation open to determine if any of Officer Espinosa's

suspected criminal activities related in any fashion to the

shooting of Leonardo Barquin of Leonardo Barquin (specially

the allegations of involvement in residential burglaries).

It was also decided to keep the shooting case open in the

hope that, if Espinosa or any of his associates were arrested

as a result of the PCB's or any other police agencies'

investigations, new witnesses or new information might be

developed which could shed new light on the shooting of

Leonardo Barquin.



UNANSWERED QUESTIONS AND OPEN ISSUES



At the outset, the undersigned Assistant State

Attorneys are concerned that, despite the known issues with

the crime scene and the placement of the casings and

projectiles, despite the fact that no weapon was found, and

despite the fact that Barquin had been shot from behind, the

sworn statement of Officer Espinosa took only fifteen (15)

minutes. The statement was taken a month after the incident

after the problems listed above were well known; yet the

interview was cursory and made no attempt to resolve these

serious issues. Furthermore, it is the policy of the
42




Miami-Dade Police Department and the Police Benevolent

Association (which provides union and legal representation to

the police officers) to not allow prosecutors to interview

the officer, to attend the talking of the sworn statement, or

even to provide any questions or input to the detective

conducting the interview. Therefore, the office of the State

Attorney had nothing to do whatsoever with the taking of the

sworn statement.

As can be seen, Officer Espinosa was simply allowed

to state his version of the events with no follow-up

questions and no attempt to address the inconsistencies

within his own statement. The detectives who conducted this

investigation are experienced professionals who would never

allow a civilian witness to be questioned in such a cavalier

fashion. Allowing such minimal questioning to occur creates

the perception that police officers do not effectively

questions one of their own. Once the reports are turned over

to the prosecutors months later, the crime scene no longer

exists, the shooting officer will not speak to prosecutors,

and there is little that can be done by prosecutors at that

point to obtain additional information. Yet flawed

investigation or not, we are required to make the important

determination of whether or not the killing of a human being

is justified.

With this background, and in addition to the issues
43




previously noted in this report, the following is the list of

the serious and significant unanswered questions that we

have:

(1) Why were the crime scene sketches of

the bedroom and the yard not used in the

questioning of Officer Espinosa? The exact

locations of Espinosa and Barquin at the time of

the three (3) shots, both in the bedroom and the

backyard, is invaluable information in

determining whether the shooting was justified or

not.

(2) why did the officer advance so far into

the bedroom (from the door to the foot of the

bed) before firing a shot? Officer Espinosa is

never asked and never addresses this point.

Instead, he implies that the shooting happened

immediately upon his entry into the bedroom.

(3) were the two (2) shots fired in the

bedroom fired from the same location or did the

officer move between the first shot and the

second shot? This answer would assist in

answering question number four (4).

(4) How do you explain one casing in the

open desk drawer and one casing outside of the

window, on the ground, under the grass and
44




debris? Did the officer fire out of the window?

(5) How do you explain the officer's

statement that the victim was facing the officer

and pointing a weapon at him with the officer's

other statement that the victim was going out the

window? Some explanation and a reenactment would

have provided essential information on this

point.

(6) Was it possible for the victim to point

a gun at the officer, yet be shot from behind?

(7) How do you explain the officer's

statement that he saw the victim pointing a gun

at him in the bedroom, yet it was too dark to see

anything else? What were the lighting conditions

in the room at the time?

(8) Could a person with a sock on his hand

also hold a weapon and point it at someone?

(9) Could the officer tell what shots

actually struck the victim? How did the victim

react physically when the three (3) shots were

fired?

(10) Was the projectile recovered on the

bedroom floor under the treadmill the result of a

through-and-through shot to the victim's thigh?

(11) Was the victim struck two (2) times
45




inside the bedroom or one inside and one outside

in the yard?

(12) What was the explanation for the bent

screen (with blood) on the floor in the bedroom?

Was it bent and knocked out upon Llanes entry

through the window?

(13) As for the shot fired at the victim in

the backyard, if the officer knew that the victim

had a weapon, why did the officer get so close to

him? On his sworn statement, the officer said

that he was five (5) to six (6) feet away from

the victim when he fired.

(14) Where exactly was the officer when he

fired the shot at the victim as he was climbing

over the fence? Is this consistent with the

location of the shell casing?

(15) Was it possible for the wounded victim

to climb the fence with a sock on his hand and

still turn and point the gun at the officer? The

officer should have been closely questioned about

this point.

(16) Why did the detectives and crime scene

personnel fail to find the casing below the

window and the casing in the backyard until the

next day when the homeowner called? This failure
46




rendered the finding of the casings virtually

useless as evidence and leaves open the

speculation that they could have been improperly

placed there after crime scene personnel left the

scene.

(17) Was it physically possible for Rolando

Llanes to be standing on top of the fence helping

the victim to get over the fence like the officer

testified?

(18) Why did the officer run so far (i.e.,

down 58th Street, up 147th Avenue, and down 57th

Terrace) in his attempt to apprehend the wounded

victim, rather than using his police vehicle

which was parked in front of the residence and

which the officer had to run past? It is

possible that Officer Espinosa jumped the fence,

like Barquin and Llanes, and followed behind

Barquin to where he collapsed. This possibility

was never considered in the officer's interview

and could have provided an explanation for

Espinosa's injuries.

(19) What was the explanation for the

officer's injuries? Nothing in his statement

explains the injuries noted and photographed by

crimes scene personnel immediately after the
47




shooting.

(20) Did the officer know the victim?

According to the statements of other officers,

Barquin was reasonably well known in the Hammocks

District.

(21) Why was ASA Miller-Batiste kept away

from the crime scene while the PBA attorney was

given full access?

Because of these unanswered questions and the

ongoing criminal investigations of Officer Espinosa, the

undersigned ASA's have been reluctant to issue a final

closeout memorandum in this case. We have serious doubts

about the truthfulness of Officer Espinosa and the

investigation conducted by the Miami-Dade Police Department

did nothing to dispel these doubts. In fact, several aspects

of the investigation, as discussed above, increased our

doubts and made clearing or charging Officer Espinosa even

more difficult.

After being provided with the investigative file

concerning the shooting, the undersigned ASA's engaged in

several efforts to gain additional information so that this

case could be brought to closure with either a clearance or

an arrest. For example, we contacted the attorney for

Officer Espinosa and requested an opportunity to speak with

him in order to clear up several issues not covered in the
48




police investigation. We informed the attorney that we were

unable to close out the shooting investigation until we could

resolve these issues and that the investigation would remain

open and "hanging over the officer's head." The attorney

declined our request without a subpoena to compel his

testimony. Since the subpoena, by operation of state law,

would confer immunity on Officer Espinosa, we of course

declined.

We also contacted the Office of the United States

Attorney and the FBI on two (2) occasions to request that

they take a fresh look at the case by utilizing the

investigative power of a Federal Grand Jury. The undersigned

ASA's contacted both agencies in July of 2006 and Chief

Assistants Jose Arrojo and Don Horn made the same request in

December of 2005. The State Attorney herself even wrote a

letter to the United States Attorney and the FBI in August of

2006 requesting their assistance. To all of our entreaties,

we were informed that the FBI had reviewed the case in late

2003 and early 2004 and had determined that no federal

investigation was warranted.

When Officer Espinosa resigned from the Department

on March 1, 2006, we felt that some of the pressure for

acting swiftly had been relieved since he was no longer

carrying a badge and a gun. However, we still wanted to keep

the case open hoping for new information. We had hoped, and
49




in fact still hope, that the criminal investigations

involving Espinosa might develop new information. That is

why, as we have previously explained, we kept the case open.

We originally requested in the summer of 2008, that

the Miami-Dade Police Department release Officer Espinosa's

PCB investigative file so that we could discuss it in the

present report. For reasons that are unclear, this file was

finally produced on April 3, 2009.

After all of these efforts and with all of the

aforementioned unanswered questions and unresolved issues, we

have now reluctantly to close out this investigation for the

reasons that follow.



Legal Analysis



The legal analysis must consider (1) whether the

shooting of Leonardo Barquin was justified by Officer

Espinosa's belief that he was in fear of imminent bodily harm

or death from Barquin's pointing a gun at him on two

occasions; (2) whether Officer Espinosa was justified

shooting Barquin as a fleeing felon or (3) whether Officer

Espinosa's shooting of Barquin was not justified and,

therefore, Espinosa should be subject to criminal charges.

Florida Statute 776.05 provides in pertinent part:

A law enforcement officer need not retreat
50




or desist from efforts to make a lawful arrest

because of resistance or threatened resistance to

the arrest; the officer is justified in the use

of any force:

(1) Which he or she reasonably believes to

be necessary to defend himself or herself or

another from bodily harm while making the arrest;

(2) When necessarily committed in arresting

felons fleeing from justice....



Based upon the flawed and incomplete investigation

in this case, there is simply not enough information to make

a determination that the officer was attempting to defend

himself from bodily harm. Likewise, there is an insufficient

record to make a determination beyond a reasonable doubt that

the officer did not believe that he was at risk, thus making

the use of force not legally justified.

Because of the aforementioned insufficient evidence

and incomplete record; it is our determination that, Officer

Espinosa can be neither cleared nor charged criminally under

the provision of the statute relating to the defense from

bodily harm.

Next we turn to the use of force necessary to

arrest a fleeing felon. Although, this justification was not

offered by Officer Espinosa, legally it must still be
51




considered. Despite the flawed investigation, three (3)

pertinent facts are known: (1) The victim, Leonardo Barquin,

and his accomplice, Rolando Llanes, were burglarizing the

residence at 14773 Southwest 58th Street; (2) Both Barquin

and Llanes fled the scene of the crime of burglary, and

burglary is a felony; (3) Barquin was shot while attempting

to flee from justice after committing a felony. The only

element remaining for a legally justified use of force under

this provision is, was such use of force necessary? This

requirement has troubled the undersigned ASAs from the

beginning of this investigation. Was it necessary to shoot

Barquin to prevent him from fleeing if he had a weapon? Was

it necessary to shoot Barquin to prevent him from fleeing if

he did not have a weapon? Unfortunately, the law in Florida

instructs us that it does not matter whether the fleeing

felon was armed or not. A fleeing felon can be shot in the

back while unarmed and while not posing any risk to anyone,

and the law makes it perfectly clear that the officer's use

of deadly force is legally justified.

Under Florida Statutes, and given the flawed and

incomplete records before us, we are unable to state beyond a

reasonable doubt that the shooting of Mr. Barquin was not

necessary to prevent him from fleeing. Yet despite this

conclusion, we are reluctant to, and will not, conclude that

the shooting of Mr. Barquin was necessary and thereby render
52




Officer Espinosa's use of deadly force legally justified.

The sad and unsatisfying conclusion to this case is that

since we are unable to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that

Officer Espinosa's actions were unlawful, and likewise unable

to prove that his actions were legally justified, we have no

other choice at this point to close the case as inconclusive.

This will allow the matter to be litigated in civil court,

where the burden of proof is different and the standards for

the justified use of force against a fleeing felon are

different, should the parties wish to do so.



Prepared by:







Assistant State Attorney Assistant State Attorney

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

China's Great Wall of Silence: Publication in "Open" Magazine



My heartfelt thanks to Open Magazine in Hong Kong for serializing the articles on my November 2008 trip to Beijing in their June and July issues.

My inestimable thanks to my long-time friends Youqin Wang and Rongfen Wang, and a new friend Bei Su Ni, for voluntarily translating the articles.

Saturday, May 16, 2009

Index

There are over seven hundred posts on this website now covering a variety of topics. Occasionally we publish an abridged index to some of the other topics that don't appear on the first page.


Essays

-The Importance of Being Earnest, October 6, 2002.
-Body and Soul, October 18, 2002.
-Spirits, August 18, 2002.
-Lost in Translation, September 16, 2003
-Evening Walk, December 2, 2004.
-A Man and His Dog, December 5, 2004.
-A Fish Story, December 3, 2004.
-Richard Wagner, December 7, 2004.



Foreign Policy


-To the Future, June 23, 2002.
-International Federalism, June 30, 2002
-Our Friends in Pakistan, May 29, 2002.
-While America Sleeps, May 25, 2002.
-The New War, May 17, 2002.


Things That You'll Like and


That Are Good For You Too



-August 18, 2003.
-June 10, 2003



Crime Photographs

- October 24, 25, 26.
- September 30, 18, 13, 12, 10, 6.
- August 31, 26, 22, 24, 16, 14, 13, 11, 4.
- July 30, 28, 27, 2006.



True Crime Stories


-September 19, 14, 2006.
-January 3, 2005.
-December 25, 2007.
-November 19, 2004.


Islam in Its Own Words

-September 19, 14, 2006.
-June 23, 2002.



What a Wonderful World

-April 19, 2002
-October 29, 2002.





Friday, May 15, 2009

What a Wonderful World: Susan Boyle


Publick Occurrences, the inspiration for this little blog, was the first newspaper published in North America. Its three purposes were to, "encourage knowledge of affairs here and abroad, to combat the spirit of lying that prevails amongst us, and to document memorable providences," that is, miracles.

The belief in miracles has had a tough go of it since 1690. Perhaps only a minority believe literally in them today. Faith has always given believers hope, and hope helps sustain us in doing the work here on earth that we must do.

But hope is not just a tool with which we work. It is a good in itself. Human beings are capable of unimagineable cruelty but as Jonathan Spence has written, "...[I]n every country, too, humans have shown a love of beauty...a gentleness, an exuberant sensuality...that have cut across the darkness and filled their world with light." * There is still joy in life, and sometimes that joy is so unexpected as to seem miraculous.

I could not post this link to Susan Boyle's recital without trying to describe, with these insufficient words, what it meant to me to view it and to hear Ms. Boyle sing. I am not alone. Over 12,000,000 people have watched this miracle on YouTube, and note the looks on the judges faces as they come to realize that they are face to face with something providential.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9lp0IWv8QZY

* The Search for Modern China. Spence. xix

Saturday, May 09, 2009

A Million Drops of Blood: "Looking for Lin Zhao's Soul" by Hu Jie. English translation by Ye Weiyou. Parts I-III




Hu Jie's magnificent film, Looking for Lin Zhao's Soul, gives name and face to one of the million drops of blood shed during the Maoist period in China, 1949-1976. This is the first English translation of the commentary in the film. It is the work of Ye Weiyou, to whom Hu Jie and all of us express our gratitude.

-BH






(Part One)

Lin Zhao was born in December 1932 and killed in April 1968. She lived on her miserable land--Mainland China-- for just over 35 years. But her life was really great and her death was indeed glorious. This pretty girl's surname is Peng, but after joining the Red Revolution in 1950, she changed it to Lin for a determination--making a cleanbreak with her so-called counter-revolutionary family. Lin Zhao's father, Mr.Peng, having studied politics and economics in Britain,was chosen Provincial Head as a result of number one in a nation-wide examination. But after 1949, he was soon held in control for his service to Guomindang (The National Party organized by Sun Zhongshan and then by Jiang Jieshi) who was defeated by Mao and escaped to Taiwan )In the Movement to Suppress Counter-Revolu-tionaries from 1950-1952,Peng was shut in prison.Her mother Ms.Xu first joined the CPC but then withdrew from itand joined guomindang.In the Anti-Japanese War,patriotic Xu stayed in prison with her little daughter Lin Zhao for a period.For this, she had much better fortune and was selected as a local committee member of CPPCC of Suzhou (China People's Political Consultation Conference)Lin Zhao was a sharp-mouthed girl,when having truth in herpart,she would not give up,persisting in arguing with the wrongside till they admitted their mistakes.In 1950,a student of two year-News College,Lin Zhao joined the revolutionary work:land reform movement.In the work team,when finding some cadre's(mostly communists) bad behavior,she would point out and give criticism,i.e.quite a few of them deserted their virtual country wives for a new one,Lin openly compared them to the heartless Chen Shimei in the play .This of course offended the immoral men and they tried every way to find fault with her.Lin Zhao's father Mr.Peng committed suicide in jail in 1960when learning about his daughter Lin Zhao's being arrested.During the C.R.(Cultural Revolution)her mother Xu was held in control by the localpolice as a reactionary.After Lin Zhao was killed on April 29of 1968,a policeman came to demand five fen for the bullet.Poor Xu did not understand the man?s words with northern accent,but her 2nd daughter understood and gave the man the money.After the policeman's leave,when learning about the sad thing,Xu fainted.(in the film there is the recording of Zhao sister'saccount)In mid-1970s,Xu was seen dead at waitan,on a street nearthe dock in Shanghai.Nobody knows how she died,murdered or of asudden death.)

( Part Two )

In 1949 Lin Zhao firmly rejected her mother's plan for her togo to U.S.for further studies,and soon she even separated withher family for revolutionary work.Lin's good classmate in thetwo-year college of journalism Ms Ni said that at that time Lin adored Mao so much,simply taking him as her father.In the film Ni read some words from two letters Lin sent to her:

"I know he(Mao)is now in Beijing or Moscow,I am so far from him and miss him...I find my feelings toward my family is not as deep as before..."
" I used to think my father was not reactionary,but with classmates' help,I now see that working for Guomindang itself is really reactionary.I must try to reform my thoughts to live up to the Party's request....."

In 1954 Lin Zhao entered Beijing University,Dept.of Chinese with an excellent grade in the exams.She is said to be very smart,warm,considerate and good at dressing,just looking like the pretty and delicate girl Lin Daiyu,a main character in thefamous classic novel .So many students called her Lin meimei,( Lin Daiyuss common petname, meimeimeans younger sister). In Beijing Univ.Lin Zhao had good relationship with an engineering girl-student Li who came from a poor peasantss family.Li introduced that Lin was warm-hearted and clever.Finding her love for a boy-student who was sent to a reform-through-labor farm,Lin got the boy's address of the farm for her.Coming from the countryside,Li said that she dressed bad and ugly.Out of sympathy and concern,Lin often gave her good clothes.The two girls had a picture taken.On the back of the picture Lin wrotea poem of dissatisfaction about the political situation at thattime.For safety's sake Li daubed the poem with ink immediatelybut the date is still there(we see this in the film)Li went on that Lin lived sort of bourgeoisie's life:having herclothes washed in a laundry,keeping a commemorative album forwriting poems and asking some poets to sign their names withwords,simply like a Russian rich woman's life style...So how could she enjoy the then proletariat life-style? Li continued: She(Lin)thought she understood Marxism and agreed to it but actually she represented the advanced capitalist class.When loving,she loved deeply,when hating,she hated greatly,anextreme girl.So depressed of the political atmosphere,she then was often found weeping at night by Weiming lake on the campus."You see," Li went on,"the proletariat revolution then was sohot-made,so terrible,but now it proved to be a failure so wehave stopped doing it.But at that time in the height of the redrevolution,Lin was so sharp and stubborn that I just expected she would have no good end...." In 1956,shocked by Khruschev's secret report at the 20th Soviet Communist Congress--exposure of Stalin's personal cult and his mass killing his comrades in the mid-1930s, Mao began to watch Chinese intellectuals with alertness.And the rebellion happenedin some Eastern European socialist countries also threatened MaoIn such a situation,in 1957 the dictator Mao made a plan to entice intellectuals,mainly professors,lecturers and minorityparty members to give the Party criticism and suggestion butactually,Mao said,to let them grieve,to pour out their poisonas much as they could so as to finally wipe them out totally.Kept in the dark of Mao's scheme,many patriotic and braveChinese in the intellectual circles were fooled and thus,in1958,55 hundred thousand people were labeled rightists and thusgreat disaster happened to them--so many rightists were tortureddead in the terrible thought-reform through-labor farms.(Note:I have an article on that campaign.There are a few books on theevent but recently hard to get in the state-run bookshops. Together with the DVD on Lin Zhao with English subtitles,the maker of this documentary Mr.Hu Jie mailed me another one on the same event--a group of survived rightists'blood and tear complaint about their horrible suffering from 1957-1962 till their labels of rightist were removed by their authority.)In Beijing University the two pieces of news--Kruchove's secret port and therebellion in Eastern European contries secretly came to Beida's campus and somepolitically sensitive students began to have hot but underground discussion. In 1947-48, Lin was a contributor to newspapers and magazines attacking the oldgovernment?s autocracy and corruption.)In early 1950s Lin had somedissatisfaction about thought-remold(brain-washing)movement among theintellectuals.To the action of pulling down a church nearby for construction,Lin said to the local gov.that the "General Principle" of CCP gave Chinese freedom of religious belief so churches should be preserved,but itwas useless!

(Part Three)

In 1956, not knowing Mao's scheme---luring snakes out of holes, hot-blooded students and teachers began to put up big-character posters giving sincere butmild criticism and opinions to the school leaders or to the Party. More andmore posters appeared on the campus and according to the posters, spontaneousdebates started. One poster with the title "It Is Time",attacking the then dead political atmosphere in school and in society-whole nation was of onevoice---attracted many readers. At once, around that poster appeared quite alot, for and against. Zhang Yuanxun, one of the writers of that powerful posterbegan to get severe criticism from the left students who questioned the articles writers "What time is it?" "Is it the time for you right students to attack our great Party?! No Way!" But more articles supported that poster,more and more, hotter and hotter debates going on. One night, Zhang Yuanxun,the main writer of that poster was dragged to theplayground ,strongly criticized by a group of left students with slanders andpersonal attack. At this, Lin Zhao jumped onto a table used as a stage,started her criticism to the left students:

"For what are you doing this way? Is this a debate or a public accusation meeting? If it an accusation, no need, Zhang is not an enemy. We need reason, need peaceful talk and discussion...."

With her sweet mezzo-soprano voice, speaking common Chinese with southern accent her powerful beautiful speech immediately silenced the crowd. But suddenly, a rude voice sounded:

"Who are you?!?? Who are you ?! What right have you got todemand me that way?! But I can tell you, my name is Lin Zhao. Since I have come here, now I do not care whether the knife is on my mouth or on neck!..."

Look, the words showed Lin Zhao's spirit.As expected, Lin Zhao and quite many patriotic and brave students were labeled rightists. All of them were not allowed to speak each other openly and the non-rightist ones were also warned from talking with the rightist students. One morning after that, Shen Zeyi,also a right student, who was in love with Lin inheart,found Lin having simple breakfast at a small restaurant near the school.They both glanced at each other without any words. When asked how Lin lookedthen, Shen said that in a white blouse, pale-faced, she looked so holy, evenholier than before.In 1958, after graduation, Lin was given a special care by the schoolauthority: unlike many other rightist graduates, she was not sent to the remotethought-reform-through-labor farms, but assigned to People?s University,working in the reference room. In this school, Lin met with another rightistboy-student named Gan Cui assigned there from another college. They worked inthe same office. Almost every day a male and female walking together to and frothe dinning hall made people around suspect their relationship: in love.Soon,they were warned by the authority that rightists should not have thatrelationship. Gan said actually they were not at all in love then, but the twostrong-personality young people just had a spirit to fight back."Well, you donot allow us to be in love. We must show we are!?"

So they pretended to walk holding their hands to let people see! Nowadays it is so common and evenbravier that that, but in those days it was really a daring action! Not longthe false play became true: they wrote an application to the authority for acertificate to marry. Of course, it was rejected with the same reason:rightists are not permitted to get married! During the time they worked together Christian Lin led boy Gan to know God by taking him to a churchregularly on Sunday and telling him Bible stories. With their application formarriage turned down,Gan was soon sent to a thought-reform-through-labor farmin Xinjiang(northwest) and there he had endured hell-like days for 20 years! The year of 1981 was a relatively good time for putting right all thepolitically wrong cases in the past decades and over 90% of rightists regainedtheir reputation, though did not get back the cut salary in the past overtwenty years. The salary for college graduates from 1950s till 70s was all 54or 46 yuan, depending on the length of time in higher learning institution:5years 54,while 4 years 46. But all the rightist graduates?were given only 18yuan a month to keep soul and body together as a punishment till the label wasremoved by the above. Whether the label could be removed after a few years of?thought reform? depended on their behavior: doing labor well, making one afteranother sincere self-criticism, etc and of course, mostly depended on theirrelationship with the direct boss!Taking advantage of the good situation of rehabilitation in 1981, Chen Weisi,areporter in the magazine named Democracy & Law in Shanghai got the permissionand went to Tilanqiao Jail(in Shanghai) for reading files on Lin Zhao. He thenwrote an article The DVD maker Hu asked Chen if what heheard was right that all Lin Zhao's answer to the interrogators was wonderful,Chen said "Indeed very wonderful, so smart and powerful. It's a great pity that quite many materials were forbidden to take out and was not allowed totake down on paper." Chen tried his best to memorize as much as possible and hetook pictures of the poems Lin Zhao wrote with her blood on the paper given forher to write confection and exposure of others. Instead of writing what she wasordered Lin wrote articles, poems and declarations to constantly attacking Maoand his autocratic regime.Thanks to reporter Chen's effort,in the film we seethe blood written things,so many,earthshaking heroism!! Lin?s good classmate Li said: "The poems she wrote were as if blood pouring outfrom her heart,we simply had no such feelings,so we had no ability to write...,Lin was such a pure person..."

Sunday, April 26, 2009

A Million Drops of Blood: "Outside the Spotlights," by Yiyun Zhou


You have so many interesting stories, you have to write them down,” my friends often say. I always answer them, “No, these stories are too Chinese and not Chinese enough at the same time.”
My answer is not just an excuse for my laziness, which I am.
Due to the fact that (ethnic) Chinese, communists or otherwise, who could write in English and got published were more or less from the same background, these stories have been told so many times: a big family of several generations, whose members are generals, politicians, scholars, revolutionaries, artists, etc. Though play different roles, they endured the same events in the 20th. Century China: the Revolution ending two-thousand-year-old Imperial era in 1911, the “May 4th. Movement” led to individualism and women’s emancipation, the Japanese invasion and the War of Resistance, the Chinese part of WWII from 1937 to 1945, the civil war between the Nationalists and the Communists. Then it was the establishment of the People’s Republic, The Great Leap Forward, the Cultural Revolution, and so on and so forth. My family and friends could barely escape all these; they are, though probably not under the spot lights, but after all actors against these backgrounds. There was no need for me to tell such a family saga once more.
Yet my stories are not Chinese enough, to some western readers at least. Neither of my grandmothers, maternal or paternal grandmother had bound-feet, nor was either of them concubine. Both of them had names to be registered, i.e., official identities, instead of “girl no. X” before getting married and “Mrs. so and so” afterwards. Neither of them was old-fashioned enough to marry my grandfather solely by parents’ arrangement, and they were not modern enough to do so by “free love”. Their marriages were arranged by their parents, who could not do it without their consensus. Both my grandmothers could read newspapers and novels and write a little. Against the marital troubles they suffered, they could blame neither the Age nor social conditions but themselves. They were not interested in study to become independent women, so that they had no choice but dependence on their husbands, who were not always loyal. In short, they found themselves in a transition status.
Everything changed in the summer of 2007. I went to Wuhan, a metropolis in mid China, to celebrate my aunt, my father’s sister’s 80th. birthday. My cousin Hong came from Japan to the same purpose. We shared the same hotel room, and she told me many things I never knew, for example, our great grandmother was a concubine, and presumably had bound feet. My aunt was a great story-teller too. I helped her with typing some family stories into the computer, so I got known even more.
Now, let’s begin with the big family of generations.
I.
At the southeast coast of China, there was a small town called Xiamen in Fujian province. This was a transcription of northern pronunciation; in old days this city was known as Amoy, closer to the local dialect. Amoy was a small town, but for centuries it was a place loved by merchants, poets, heroes, monks, and foreigners. Thanks to the pressure from the nomads in the North, the center of Chinese civilization kept moving down to the South. There were at least three major waves of migration to the South (ca. 310, 755, 1126 AD), and Fujian was one of the places favored by them. Jianzhen (687-763), the monk contributed great to the development of Buddhism in Japan, set off from Amoy. Shortly after Islam came to the world, the Persian and Arabian traders arrived at the city, and settled down here. In The Treaty of Wanghia signed on 3 July 1844 between the Qing Empire and the United States, Amoy was one of the five treaty ports with fixed tariffs and permission to erect churches and hospitals.
In 1897, great news arrived at the Zhou family in the city: two brothers successfully passed the imperial examination at the provincial level and became candidates! The Zhous were an old family that came from central China five hundred years ago. They cause of their migration was unclear, probably was to escape from the turmoil caused by war, but obviously not one of the three major waves. Now they grew up into a big family with several generations under the same roof. They were not rich, but they had a small fortune that was just enough for them to keep being “cultivated”. Hearing the happy news, the whole family, from grandparents to grandchildren, from masters and mistress to servants, were in great joy. The local authority sent them a board with horizontal inscription of “Same family, same year” to congratulate them, commending their appropriation of educating children. To some extent this inscription betokened the Zhous’ destiny; many members of this big family were educators, from university professors to middle school teachers, including me.

My great grandfather
Courtesy to http://www.xmculture.com
Zhou Dianxun (1876-1929), one of the two brothers, was one of the forerunners in this “family of educators”, as the authority today puts it. He was a handsome young man distinguished with extremely bright eyes. As a child he was often teased,”you may hold a contest with the lantern to race that who is brighter; and you will surely win, for your eyes are so bright that can blow it out.”
Before reaching twenty, he was pointed a leader in charge of administration at Yuping School in 1885. From 1904 he began to engage in charity works, while teaching at a middle school (since 1908).
13 years after his success with examination at the provincial level, he passed it at the highest level in the Forbidden City. As a first class candidate he was appointed a position of section chief in the Board of Civil Office, one of the Six Boards whose tradition can be traced back to the Han Dynasty (206 BC-220 AD).
Although he was not particularly late-developed, his real success came a bit too late. One year after his appointment, the Emperor was overthrown by the Revolution in 1911. The two-thousand- year history of the Six Boards came to an end; they were, so to speak, reorganized into ministries, and hundreds of thousands revolutionaries were waiting for the positions in them. Although enlightenment minded, he himself was more a classic scholar than modern and he could hardly compete with the students coming back from Europe, America, and Japan. Perhaps he also kept in mind the traditional moral principle that a gentleman does not serve two regimes; when the Emperor was gone, he could not work for the next, no matter the title changed into President, Chairman, or General Commissar. So he quit his position and went back to his hometown Amoy, picked up his career as a teacher, and went on till the end of his day.
At home, there were a wife, two concubines, and four children from three mothers waiting for him. The wife was his second. The first one was from a well-off background and married him with two servant girls as parts of her dowager. One of the servant girls became concubine when turned fifteen. In 1900, she gave birth to a son, my grandfather, Zhou Shouxi (Youmo, 1900-80). In the same year, the wife also gave birth to a daughter, and died shortly afterwards.
As there were more granduncles and grandaunts on their way, I have to give an explanation of the Chinese seniority system. There were two ways of seniority of siblings: the major and the minor, and both numbered boys and girls separately. The minor was closer to the modern way, i.e., to number the children from the same father in success of their birth, though boys and girls were numbered separately. The major would put all the brothers’ children together to number them in success of their birth. The Zhou family used the major. My great grandfather was Nr.5 among his brothers, who already had 9 sons and 7 daughters, so his eldest son and daughter were numbered 10 and 8 respectively.
My great grandmother took care of the wife’s daughter, my Nr.8 grandaunt as her own, and gave birth to a second son in 1906, my Nr.14 granduncle, Zhou Shoukai (Youyan, 1906-70). As a well behaved mother of two sons, she might have a hazy hope deep in her heart: one day she would become the wife. To her great disappointment, my great grandfather married a young lady from nice family, and she was passed off.
She fell seriously ill. On her deathbed, she called my grandfather in, and took a little bag from beneath pillow. There were several hundred copper coins in the bag. She handed the bag to my grandfather, saying, “This is my private saving, and I don’t have much to give you. Take good care of your brother. He is so young and will become motherless.” “Yes, mom,” my grandfather said, with tears in his eyes, “I’ll surely take good care of my little brother.”
The young woman died, left two boys of eight and two, and the copper coins become their funds. She was twenty-seven or twenty-eight. Nobody knew her precise age. She had a name, though. Her name was Xiang, meaning fragrance, my great grandmother.
II.
My great grandfather perhaps made a right decision, after all. He married a lady, instead of raising a former servant girl, my (biological) great grandmother to the status of wife. His second wife was as elegant as her name, Qiongyao, meaning a kind of jade. This way of indicating jade was an allusion from The Book of Songs, the oldest surviving collection of poems, attributed to Confucius’ selection and complement. Qionyao gave birth to a boy who did not survive his infancy, and never had any child ever since. However, she was regarded the Mother of my grandfather and granduncles and grandaunts, the grandmother of my father’s generation, as well as the great grandmother of mine.
From contemporary point of view, it was a violation of mother’s rights from the concubines’ part, but tradition had its balance. The deprivation of mother’s right was made up with equal right of children, regardless their biological mothers’ status. In contrast the European tradition of primogeniture, the Chinese one was that every (male) child was entitled to an equal share of inheritance. This balance derived, in part at least, from the wife’s monopoly of mother’s rights.
Viewing from the up growth of my grandfather and his siblings, the Mother must have been a wise woman. If their beautiful calligraphy, literature cultivation could attributed to their father, their warm kindness, the will to help, and so on, were definitely from their Mother. As the Harvard Professor Tu Wei-ming once said, in classic China, it was the mother, who was in charge of carrying on the moral tradition.
My grandfather was a brilliant student at school, and did every subject well. When he was about to graduate, an American teacher offered him the opportunity to study at the University of Chicago. He hurried home in excitement to tell his father this great news, expecting appreciation. To his disappointment, his father showed no sign of happiness. “I have no money to support such a project,” my great grandfather said.
“There is no need for money,” my grandfather said, still in hope, “my teacher will apply for a scholarship, and everything will be paid when it’s done.”
“True enough,” my great grandfather said, “but in that case you will not be able to make money for several years. You will soon turn twenty, and you have to take responsibility for your younger brothers and sisters.”
Everyone could see this urgency: the family kept growing. Besides my (biological) great grandmother, my great grandfather had two concubines, who gave birth to my granduncles Nr. 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 and grandaunts Nr. 11, 12, 13, plus grandaunt Nr. 8 from the first wife, my grandfather (Nr.10) and his brother (Nr. 14), eleven in all!
“Yes, dad,” my grandfather said. He was an obedient young man. The oldest son in China had far more responsibilities, no privilege.
So my grandfather gave up any hope of higher education, and started working after finishing schooling.
Probably because of his earlier experience, my grandfather was somehow reluctant to support his children’s interests outside school. He turned down, in turn, the request of my father for buying radio parts, of my aunt for piano class, and my uncle for singing class. (They later became engineer, economic historian, and biologist respectively.) “I promise you, all of you, to support your university education,” he said, “that’s good enough. Don’t ask for too much.”
To be fair to my grandfather, his sacrifice was not a little one. He was a brilliant student; he could become a distinguished scholar, as several brothers did. Every granduncle or grandaunt I met said to me among first things, “Your grandpa sacrificed himself for us younger brothers and sisters’ sake.” This sacrifice meant more after 1949.
As for his work itself, my grandfather did well. As mentioned above Amoy was an old trade port with a long tradition of migration, both in and out, and people remained at home had countless connections with outside world, mostly southeastern Asia. My grandfather found jobs with ease in Indonesia and the Philippines at banks owned by ethnic Chinese.
My great grandfather’s economic burden was soon released, but not solely thanks to the money made by my grandfather.

Wednesday, April 08, 2009

China's Great Wall of Silence: Beijing, November 2008

Open Magazine of Hong Kong will be publishing the series of articles written under the above heading in its May issue. I thank the editors of Open. The publication is due entirely to the efforts of Youqin Wang, Rongfen Wang, and Bei Su Nei. All three took it upon themselves to translate the articles into Chinese. Youqin and Rongfen successfully lobbied the editors of Open for publication. Bei Su Nei, who I did not know previously, read the articles on duping. net and took it upon herself to aid in the translation.

I have written here previously of Youqin and Rongfen. They are, and have been all of their lives, giants in the struggle for China's history. It is embarrassing to me that such as they have helped me. I think it was Newton who paid tribute to his Youqin and Rongfen by saying that he stood on the shoulders of giants. I cannot think of how to express my gratitude in original terms and so adopt his.


Saturday, April 04, 2009

A Million Drops of Blood: "Our Days in Red Terror," by Ye Weiyou

My Paternal Grandparents

My paternal grandfather Ye Chong-Zhi (alternative name Ye Wenqiao),with his ancestors in Anhui Province (the mid-south of China),lived in the late Qing Dynasty (1644-1908,the last feudal dynasty in China), having experienced two tiles of emperor's reign: Guangxu and Xuantong. Grandpa came from a 4-line of officials, the highest being like a state governor of the U.S.Fearing the terrible persecution (chopping head) even to those who just sympathized with the reformists in imperial court,Grandfather found an excuse and quit his official position:head of the Public Security Bureau of Hebei Province.Soon he started to run industries with a position in his two banks, chairman of the board.

Grandfather married three women. His first parent-arranged bound-foot wife #1 grandmother Cang was of equal socioeconomic status with her hometown in Jinan, the capital of Shangdong Province. While flying a kite, Cang had an abortion and became barren ever since. In feudal society of China a doctrine was among the three unfilial things having no offspring is number one. A young girl Liu came from a poor family in Henan Province. After a severe flood, Liu was sold to a rich family in Tianjin as a maid (Tianjin is a port city near Beijing). The lady in the rich family happened to be my great-grandmother's friend. #1 grandmother Cang often accompanied my great-grandma to the lady's for mahjong(a game of Chinese origin played with tiles resembling dominoes)One day, while playing the game, Great-grandma found Liu there and asked about her background. The adoptive mother told everything true about the girl except her age: she was then 14 but was said 16.Great-grandmother often saw her there and came to like the girl. Then she decided to buy Liu for my grandfather as a concubine to continue the family tree.

#2 Grandma Liu soon was pregnant but did not show any sign in a month. Soon, on a business trip in Henan Province, Grandpa got to know a pretty Beijing Opera actress Chen who played a male's role in the opera. After hearing about Chen's poor life experience, Grandpa sympathized and fell in love with her. Having made sure that Chen was selling just her singing not body, Grandpa decided to marry Chen as a second concubine but dared not bring her home for the poor social status--actresses, particularly poor ones, were just above prostitutes. Fortunately, a month after living together, hen conceived a child and this made Grandpa very happy and bold enough to write home immediately.

Great-grandma agreed to accept Chen and allowed his son to bring her home at once though by then Liu also proved in a family.#3 Grandma Chen was about two years older than Liu.Interesting enough, the two women's first five kids were born in the same year and of the same sex with their first baby being both female. Thus the two humble-origin women produced for the family 14 offspring in all, each of them had five boys and two girls. The ten boys and four girls were ranked by sex in two groups. Chen was my grandma, #3 grandmother.
#2 Grandmother Liu's first girl was a couple of months older than my grandmother’s first girl. She was adopted by Cang and became the family's treasure. When she died at the age of three, Great-grandmother attempted a suicide by striking her head to the wall! The two concubines’ second child were both boys.#1 uncle was Liu's while #2 uncle was my grandmother Chen's. Her first daughter, my poor #2 Aunt was disdained by great-grandmother as she suspected the girl's blood lineage

As the 2nd boy in Ye ancestors' families tended to live short, when 2# uncle reached the age of 6 or 7,he was rearranged to number 8 after the newly born #7 Uncle. Unfortunately, the reranked boy (#2 uncle) couldn’t avoid an early death either. He died at the age 7---another grief storm in the family...My father, ranked #3,is Chen's second boy, and #6,#7 and #9 (originally ranked 8) were all her sons. My grandma’s first daughter, my poor #2 Aunt died young as a result of being bullied by her husband, a landlord's son. He forced her to watch while making love with a maid. Grandma’s second daughter my #3 aunt died of stroke in 1980.Her husband was not good either: taking opium. All Liu's children died except her youngest girl, my #5 Aunt, 87 years old, in Shanghai. Her kind husband, a famous translator lived to see Mao's death, predicting a great change in China. Concubines' children in a feudal Chinese family had to call their own mother aunt, while call their father's first wife mother. The same unfair rule in my grandfather's family.

With her low position in the family, my grandma was sort of discriminated. Her brother was not allowed to talk with her inside the house but just at the gate, so her father never came. And her children were also treated less well than #2 grandmother Liu's. My grandma tried to tolerate all this but occasionally vented her grievances on Father and asked him to take her out of the family after he graduated from Yanjing University (the predecessor of today's Beijing University, a missionary school run by the last American ambassador before 1950) Father had great pity on his mother and, while tapping her legs to relieve her pain, he once again promised to make her dream come true.

Family Ye was then very famous in Hebei Province, especially in the city of Tianjin, for their achievements in industries and great generosity to their servants, friends and particularly the poor around. At the peak of the family, there were about forty servants in the large house including wet nurses for each grandchild’s birth. Grandpa never demanded any receipt for a loan. Whenever there was a natural disaster, he and his mother/our great-grandma would give out grain and relief fund to the needed. Grandpa died quickly of stroke at the age of 58 as a result of his carriage accident. Then Father was still in Tianjin Nankai High School, one of the very few top missionary schools in China. About a month after Grandpa’s death, my father received admission notice from both Yanjing and Qinghua University(in comparison to Oxford and Cambridge in Britain)Yangjing admitted Father due to recommendation by his high school for his excellence in his studies while Qinghua admitted him after an examination. When Grandpa’s safe was unlocked after his death, instead of a great fortune they supposed to find, there were quite a few receipts since he never pressed for repayment of debts. No wonder Grandpa Ye Wen-qiao was known as philanthropist in Tianjin. Since early childhood all the boys had been imbued by Grandparents with the spirit of self-achievement: never rely on family properties. And Grandpa encouraged them to study natural sciences, thinking only this could save China.

While paying great attention to his sons' education, Grandpa didn't let his daughters go to school as he believed in another feudal doctrine: having little talent and learning is a female's virtue. So except #5 Aunt, the youngest girl in the family, all the other four girls had little literacy as Grandpa just let the half-illiterate sewing women servants teach them. In Grandpa's eyes, it was good enough for a woman to be able to write a simple letter reporting her safety to her husband when she got married. A female in a feudal eastern society was always dependent: obeying her father before marriage, then her husband and finally her oldest son after her husband died. When living with my #3 Aunt in the same Chinese house (a compound with houses around a courtyard), my mother often taught her Chinese characters.

After Grandfather's sudden death in 1920s, with limited wealth, the family began to decline, which made Father, his full brothers and two half brothers, #1 and #5 uncles, work even harder at school with a determination to have a good future for themselves and for their disaster-ridden nation. Number Three Aunt, my Grandma Chen's second daughter, fell ill with TB, which was almost incurable in those years. One day, when combing hair for that favorite girl, Grandma prayed to deity with the words to a crow in a tree Oh, god, let me catch the disease and save my daughter. If you hear me, please make the crow cry three times. At this, she heard the crow wa,wa,wa. Coincidentally, Grandma soon caught TB and got worse and worse while my #3 Aunt fully recovered. In the momentary recovery of consciousness just before death, Grandma struggled
to kneel on her bed and asked the supreme lady Cang what she was allowed to wear after death. Number One
Grandma Cang, with some mercy, said that she could wear red skirt since she made some contribution to the family by having produced and brought up both girls and boys. Red skirt in the old days of feudal China was a symbol of a first wife, not a concubine. Hearing this, Grandmother was touched to tears and said with a faint smile: Thank you, Madame and left the world sort of satisfied.

My father grieved so much over his mother's death that he, in order to invite her soul return,
according to a superstitious saying, fasted three days with his eyes closed and his mind deeply meditating. But nothing happened. That painful trying in vain may have reinforced his atheism. My poor grandmother didn't live to see Father's graduation and failed to wait for the day: being taken out of the house of humiliation and staying with her favorite son in another place.#1 Grandmother Cang died second of I don't know what disease.#2 Grandmother Liu was shocked to death in 1966,the start of the Cultural Revolution, by the Red Guards who rooted her apartment and forced her to kneel in front of the household building, shouting with angry and insulting words...Except #2 Uncle who died too young, none of our grandmother Chen's other four sons,Father,#6,#7 and #9 uncles, failed to live up to her expectations--winning honour for her when they grew up. All of them, though having suffered in different way with the nation's lot, have done pretty well either in social or in natural sciences, and all have a long and respected life. My father and #6 Uncle died in 2004 and 2005 after several years of hemiplegia.#7 & #9 Uncles are still alive today though the latter,#9 Uncle also caught the disease of hemiplegia two years ago, in 2006.

A Million Drops of Blood; Individual Chinese Histories Under Mao : Poem by Ye Weiyou


Introduction


Maoist China produced an ocean of blood. That ocean is comprised of a million drops of blood, each with a name and a face. If Maoist China and its successor regimes have their way that ocean will remain anonymous. But there are those, like Youqin Wang, Xu Weixin, and Hu Jie, who will give name to each of those million drops of blood.


This series presents the stories of some of those million drops, of those who are gone, and those who survived to tell their own stories.


-BH


MOURNING OF BROTHER YE WEI-ZUO


( I )


Is it a nightmare?
Far from a nightmare.
Brother is still swimming there
In the big lake he loves
Having no fatigue and fear.
He's swimming in every style
Without any danger.

Is it a nightmare?
By no means a nightmare.
Brother is flying high over there.
The righteous man is saved by the Lord
Having been baptized in the lake water.
He is staying with kind angels
Under God's care.

Is it a nightmare?
Not in the least a nightmare.
Brother is speaking to me in the air:
“Please stop grieving and smile,
For I am so happy in Paradise here.
You'll come and join me someday
In the near future"



( II )


It is like a dream,but not a dream,
Down my cheeks warm tears stream.
The good grief is sure to pass clean,
On Brother's salvation I will beam.

For my nation and my faith I'll fight,
By working hard from morning till night.
When I have some time to relax,
Reminiscing Brotherly love brings me delight.

Saturday, February 21, 2009

China's Great Wall of Silence: Beijing, November 2008. Part XI

A person’s mentality is of central importance in the criminal law. It is important as applied to victims, witnesses, and perpetrators. Many rape cases turn on the mentality of the victim: did she consent to sex? A witness’s credibility is undermined if (s)he has a bias (a mental state) toward one side or the other.

For this reason the characterizations of mentality made by those who I interviewed in Beijing, and of others in books and articles, have been of particular significance because the Great Wall of Silence concerns a crime, the murder of Bian Zhongyun.

As important as it is as applied to victims and witnesses, the mentality of the perpetrator is the fulcrum of criminal responsibility under law. Previous articles have examined the mentality of the victim and witnesses in Teacher Bian’s murder. This article examines the mentality of the perpetrators, which is called mens rea, from the Latin.

A particular mens rea can vitiate culpability entirely. For example, a toddler who picks up his father’s gun and shoots a playmate is not held criminally responsible. There is an irrebuttable legal presumption that one so young does not know the nature and consequences of his actions.

The mens rea is also what differentiates degrees of seriousness of the same crime. The mens rea for First-degree murder is “premeditation.” If premeditation is not proved then a lesser degree of unlawful homicide, with a different mens rea, may exist, but the mens rea for the crime charged must be proven before a person can be convicted of that crime. However, as the example of the toddler above was meant to illustrate, the mental capacity of the perpetrator to commit any crime is sometimes in question.

Mr. Wang said that Chinese under Mao had a “slavish mentality.” Others have used the same, or similar, terminology. Dr. Li Zhisui described Zhou Enlai as Mao’s “slave” (1) and “dog” (2). Jung Chang has written that Chinese were “programmed” by Mao. (3) An “obedient” mentality and a “please” mentality are terms that others and I have thought about. “Crazy,” and “insane” are terms that have been used to describe the general mentality during the Cultural Revolution and of individuals, such as Mao. (4)

Ma Jisen’s characterizations were particularly intriguing because the words she used have specific meaning in criminal law:

[Mao’s various purges and campaigns] had carried with them the reversal of what many believed to be right or wrong. (5)
Thus all those taking part in the work [against the “May 16 Clique”] must give up any inclination to think for themselves and restrict themselves to obeying the leadership. (6)
From the very start of the Cultural Revolution, ideas of right and wrong were turned upside down (7)

Right and wrong during Mao's time was totally distorted. (8)

Mao's idea of right and wrong was different from that of the universal value and common sense. (9)

During the CR, all the right and wrong were messed up. (10)

You may say these persons, Red Guards, rebels, or other revolutionaries, didn't know what they did was wrong. On the contrary, they thought and were thought by some others to be doing revolutionary deeds. They were not torturing human being, but class enemy. (11)

People were educated to be kind to people of revolutionary classes, while be ruthless to class enemies. (12)

The Gang [of Four], like Mao himself, might not kill or torture anyone by their own hands, but they were the sources of the crime by their ideas, speeches, orders...(13)
Before proceeding further, it is critical to note two things: One, these characterizations are those of “normal” people (i.e. non-lawyers) in normal intercourse, i.e. general conversation or non-legal books. Second, these characterizations are general: they are of the Chinese people, not of a particular individual. Criminal law, whether international or national, applies to individuals. Jiang Qing was on trial in 1980, not the Chinese people. It was her mental state (“just following orders”) that was at issue, not that of Chinese. Adolph Eichmann was on trial in 1962, not the German people. It was Eichmann’s mental state (“just following orders”) that was at issue, not the mentality of Germans.

This is not a criminal trial but an article on an historic event that was a crime and which historic event is being examined from the perspective of the criminal law. The specific mental characteristics of an individual Red Guard cannot be presented as they would in an actual trial. For this article, characterizations like those above, and those below, will be used to construct a generic mens rea of “Red Guard.”

The characterizations above implicate two legal defenses only one of which, that below, applies to murder:

Red Guard is not guilty if she can prove by clear and convincing evidence that:
1. She had a mental infirmity, disease, or defect, and
2. Because of this condition:
A. She did not know what she was doing or its consequences, or
B. She did not know that it was wrong.


Even if Red Guard believed that what she was doing was morally right she is still guilty if she knew that what she was doing violated societal standards or was against the law.

All persons are presumed to know what they are doing and its consequences and all are presumed to know right from wrong. Red Guard must prove by clear and convincing evidence that she did not know what she was doing or its consequences or did not know that it was wrong.
Unrestrained passion or ungovernable temper is not a defense under law, even though the normal judgment of the person is overcome by passion or temper.


1. Dr. Li Zhisui. The Private Life of Chairman Mao. 2582. Ibid. 470.3. Jung Chang. Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China. 6334. A good reference work of the scholarly literature on a “Chinese mentality” is Guo Wu’s “Injured Self-Image: Rethinking the Critique of Chinese National Character as an Intellectual Discourse,” in The Chinese Historical Review, 14, no. 2, (Fall 2007): 266.
5. Ma Jisen. The Cultural Revolution in the Foreign Ministry of China (hereinafter “Foreign Ministry”). p.166. Ibid. 2727. Ibid. 4058. Ma Jisen. Personal communication with author.
9. Ibid.10. Ibid.11. Ibid.12. Ibid.13. Ibid.

Thursday, January 29, 2009

China's Great Wall of Silence: Beijing, November 2008. Part X

Mr. Wang’s family had vigorously objected to him meeting with me at all. “Do not let him get involved in your personal dispute!” was what I was told they had said to him. At one point, after I had made my airline reservations, they had succeeded in getting him to cancel the meeting. Now on the afternoon of the 28th I was meeting with him for the third time. Ye Weiyou again was our translator.


Mr. Wang told me that the call the previous night was from one of the Red Guard students at the school at the time. He said that the caller told him the last name of one of the girls who had participated in the beating. Mr. Wang told me that he had suspected this girl and tried to confirm the identity by her first name, but the caller denied that the girl was the one Mr. Wang had suspected.


Mr. Wang had brought some photographs with him to show me. The photographs had been taken a few years ago when he had hosted Weili Ye and Liu Jin in his apartment. As I looked at the photographs I asked Mr. Wang why they had wanted to meet with him, but what I really wanted to know was why he would want to meet with them.


Liu Jin had been one of the leaders of the Red Guards who had murdered Mr. Wang’s wife, one of those who had presented Mr. Wang with the “official” document on Bian’s “death.” She was the one who had informed the students the next day over the loud speaker,


“Bian Zhongyun is dead. That’s it. There’s no reason to talk about it.”


In the conversation that followed Mr. Wang said, “In China, human relationships are more important than human life.”

As foreign as that was to this foreigner personally, I told Mr. Wang that I understood the sentiment. I was thinking of something similar that I had heard a number of times in my job.


A lot of murders are committed in families or among friends. The victim, the perpetrator, and the witnesses all know each other and are close. When the murder occurs, they call the police of course. But after their loved one or friend has been in jail for a while awaiting trial, the mentality develops, “So-and-so is gone, we can’t bring him back. We have to look after the living now.” That is what I had thought about when I told Mr. Wang that I understood his statement.


When I got back to the States I pondered Mr. Wang’s statement further. He was not related to Weili or Liu. I found it utterly implausible that they had become friends over the years. And Mr. Wang had not used the word “friends,” that was my interpretation of what he meant. He had used the word “relationships.”


I tried to fit every variety of “human relationships” that I could think of into his statement but still couldn’t make sense of it.


Finally, I went back to the source. What Mr. Wang had meant was that “common Chinese” know that they have to keep up good relations with the privileged classes, or at least not offend them. He also felt that this mentality was why witnesses to Bian’s murder would not come forward.


It was the “slavish mentality” again, and the “please mentality” variant in the third meeting and Mr. Wang’s wish to provide me with information that he knew I wanted.


This was my last meeting with him and in the back of my mind I still wondered if he had something important to tell me. Perhaps he hadn’t told me in the first meeting because he was nervous or afraid, and then afterwards regretted it and asked for the second meeting, and the cycle then repeated itself. So I decided to ask an open-ended question with a wistful beginning.


“Mr. Wang this is the last time that I will ever see you. You and I aren’t getting any younger. Is there anything else that you want to tell me?” Ms. Ye translated.


“Benjamin, do you think that I am going to die soon?”


We all laughed. I asked the question different ways a couple of more times but he didn’t tell me anything more. So we just chatted as friends. He said that he wanted the two of us to write a book together. I was touched but I couldn’t help but think that maybe in part this was what he and everyone else had in mind when they asked me, “Why are you doing this?” Because I wanted to write a book, or make a movie, become famous, make money. I told him I’d be happy to.


Mr. Wang saw us to the door. We shook hands, and I embraced him. This is the last time that I will see this extraordinary man, I thought to myself. We were on the fourth floor of a walkup. I took my leave of him and walked down the first flight of stairs. I stepped onto the third floor landing.


“Benjamin.” I turned around and looked up at him. He was smiling just as broadly as he was the first day I met him in Ms. Ma’s apartment.


“Benjamin, see you again.”

Monday, January 19, 2009

China's Great Wall of Silence: Beijing, November 2008. Part IX

The next day, November 28, was my last full day in Beijing. I had no meetings scheduled, but hoped to acquire one, with Song Binbin. That night Ye Weiyou called again. Mr. Wang wanted to meet with me again. I enjoyed spending time with Mr. Wang immensely and always learned something. We arranged to meet in the afternoon, after my attempted rendezvous with Song.

I went incognito. Before leaving on the trip, I had gone to a costume shop in Washington and picked out a disguise: a fake mustache, big round black-rimmed glasses, a fedora, and a cane to hobble about on. I wore my hair un-gelled to further alter my appearance. I certainly had succeeded in that, but instead of the distinguished, older, enfeebled, gentleman I had envisioned invoking a moment's sympathy in Song and giving me my opening, I looked like a guy who had gone to a costume shop.

My un-gelled hair was too long for the fedora and curled beneath the rim. The glasses were unnaturally big. The mustache glue gave a little every time I moved my facial muscles. I was afraid it was going to drop and hang from one end in the manner of a character in a slap-stick comedy.

Song's office was in Beijing, my hotel was in Beijing, so with no thought whatsoever to the distance between the two I hopped into a cab. The distance was great. It was about 9 am, morning rush hour. We crawled along the highways, the minutes passed, and the meter kept running, and I had to go to the bathroom. Nervous perspiration beaded on my forehead and upper lip, loosening the mustache glue. We kept driving. The cab driver got lost. Twice. And had to stop to ask for directions. "Tibet, Next Exit," the thought flashed through my mind. Did I have enough yuan to get from wherever I ended up and back to the hotel?

At 11 am, two hours after I had left the hotel, I finally alighted that cab in front of Song Binbin's building with a stiff back, a thin wallet, a mustache of uncertain adhesion, and a full bladder.

I went into a nearby restaurant to use the facilities. The restaurant was not quite open but the hostess showed me to a table. I ordered a pot of green tea. And went to the men's room.

I returned to my table and began drinking the tea. The steam was having a deleterious effect on the mustache glue so I took out Ma Lisen's book and read while the tea cooled.

As I was reading, the manager called out something in a loud voice. The staff came scurrying. They gathered round and the manager addressed them, giving them some sort of instructions it was clear. At one point the staff responded in unison. I looked and caught the eye of one young staff member who looked away sheepishly. I remembered seeing the same thing once at the hotel. A little later there was a second response in unison.

The staff didn't sit while the manager addressed them, they stood. They stood, not exactly in military formation, but in an orderliness and with body language that was "regimental."

It seemed to me (I don't know for certain because I do not understand Chinese) that the meeting was part inspirational and that the unified response was group affirmance of the ideal expounded, something like,

Manager: "THE CUSTOMER IS ALWAYS RIGHT!"
Staff: "THE CUSTOMER IS ALWAYS RIGHT!"

The purpose of the meeting was not, I am quite sure, limited to informing staff of the daily specials. To an American observer the regimented nature of these sessions was unusual (American manager: "THE CUSTOMER IS ALWAYS RIGHT!" American staff: "ONLY WHEN HE'S A BIG TIPPER!"), and I think the staff member whose eye I had caught knew that I thought it was unusual.

I finished my tea, paid the check, and went to the men's room for one last mustache adjustment.

Song's building was just around the corner, the omnipresent manned guard station at the entrance. Emboldened by the experience that Carmen and I had with the guards at Bian's school, I confidently walked up to the guard in my clown outfit and showed him the piece of paper with the address. He pointed to the building entrance.

The doors were the standard double-glass and entered into the linoleum-tiled elevator waiting area. There were two elevators with standard metal doors. It was a standard building in every respect.

The elevators delivered me directly to the waiting area of Song's office. It had the look of a front, not a real office. There was no one in the waiting area and no one behind the drab linoleum desk when I first entered. Within moments a receptionist came from around the corner. I showed her my Public Occurrences business card and told her that I was here to see Song Binbin. She picked up the phone.

"No, Song's not going to come walking around the corner, is she? It can't be this easy," I thought to myself. The receptionist spoke into the phone, there was brief conversation, and then she gave the phone to me. A young man identified himself as Ms. Song's Assistant in the pleasant voice appropriate to Assistants.

I identified myself and explained that I was there to interview Song for Public Occurrences. He said that she was not in. I asked him where she was. I asked in a tone of slight annoyance that I thought he would find authentic for an American in the situation. He replied, in the tone of solicitous concern that I had expected, that he would call her.

He picked up another phone and tried to reach Song. After several seconds He got back on the phone with me and said that she was not answering. "Where is she, I have an appointment to interview her?" "I'm sorry, Mr. Harris, she may be at her apartment in downtown Beijing. I will give you her cell phone number."

"No, he's not going to give me her cell phone number," I thought, but he did. He asked me if I had an appointment with her and, stupidly, I said that I did, for 11:00am. Song then called back. "That is her now, Mr. Harris, one moment please."

Assistant: "...(unintelligible Chinese)...Benjamin Harris..."

Song: "Benjamin who?" (gleaned from context)

Assistant: "Harris...(unintelligible Chinese)"

Song: "What does he want?"(gleaned from context)

Assistant: "He says he has an appointment with you." (gleaned from context)

Song: "I don't have an appointment with anyone at 11."

Assistant: "Mr. Harris, she says she didn't have an appointment with you."

Me: (in appropriately annoyed tone of American but realizing I had blundered in claiming that I had an appointment). "I emailed her from the States and set up this time for the interview with her," continuing my blunder.

The assistant and Song spoke.

Assistant: "She says that she had no appointment with you Mr. Harris. She is currently at the hospital with her mother."

Me: (seeing a way out of my blunder on the appointment). "Well, if she's at the hospital with her mother I can understand how she could have forgotten about the appointment. That's understandable. If it is all right I will leave my business card here at the front desk and we can reschedule."

Assistant: "Yes sir, please do. What was it that you wanted to interview her about, Mr. Harris?"

Me: "I'm doing a story on the Girls Middle School that she attended. It is one of the best schools in China, as I am sure you are aware. The school has named Song a distinguished alumnus and I wanted to interview her about one of her teachers, Bian Zhongyun."

Assistant: "What was the name again, Mr. Harris?"

Me: "BIAN ZHONGYUN." (authoritative tone).

Assistant and Song then talked.

Assistant: "Ms. Song will not talk to you about that Mr. Harris."

Me: "Why?"

Assistant: "She does not wish to speak to you, Mr. Harris."

I gave the receptionist my business card and left, satisfied, that I had at least made Song Binbin know that I knew where she was and wouldn't give up investigating Bian's murder.

Friday, January 16, 2009

China's Great Wall of Silence. Beijing, November 2008. Part VIII

I asked Mr. Gao what he thought when he heard that Mao had died.

“An era ended."

In context I understood Mr. Gao to mean that madness and violence was finally over. Others have expressed similar views. Ms. Ma told me that “the root cause [of the violence] lay with Mao’s CR ideas and policy,” and she and others saw the beginning of a new, bright era,

The disaster of the CR taught the Chinese people the importance of universal values like human rights, democracy, freedom and equality.

We took Kitty back to Renmin with us in our cab. Her boyfriend at university had come from the countryside and had grown up very poor. She was very proud of how far he had come.

I asked her what she thought of China’s future. “I am very proud of my country,” she said in her soft voice. She then spoke at length and with great knowledge of the inequality between city and countryside, of how workers come from the countryside, do the same work as city dwellers, but are paid less by the government. The discrimination against country folk is well-known and of ancient practice in China. I asked her why she thought her government would do that. Her response indicated that the communist government of China had adopted a tactic of exploitative capitalists. “People in the country are so poor, and the wages that the government does pay are so much greater than what they can make in the country, that the government can get away with paying them less.”

One of the most memorable exchanges I had with anyone in Beijing occurred with Kitty in that cab. I asked her what the Chinese people thought of the election of Barack Obama as president. Kitty was sitting to my left. There was a brief pause and then she turned and looked at me with her big eyes and said, “It is a miracle.”

She said that it had been inconceivable to Chinese that a black man could ever be elected president given America’s history of slavery and racial discrimination. She told me that Chinese students are taught in middle school to memorize Martin Luther King, Jr.’s “I have a dream” speech.

Kitty had made me proud of my own country.

The night of the 26th was when Ye Youyi called me to say that Mr. Wang wanted to meet again because he “has something to tell you.”

Carmen was right, there was no naming of names, but I learned more about whey there was no naming of names. I think I also learned much more.

The venue for the second interview of Mr. Wang had to be changed because of a logistical snafu. The surreal alternative setting was the waiting area of a Bally’s fitness center. Tape-recording this session was hampered by the pump-you-up background music so I took notes as a backup.

After my first interview with Mr. Wang I made it a point to ask others for their thoughts on individual responsibility. I asked indirect and open-ended questions to guard against being told what people thought I wanted to hear. Mr. Wang and I were talking about Mao’s responsibility for the Cultural Revolution violence and the effect on individual Chinese. He said to me that Chinese have a “slavish mentality." I started at the phrase because I had read others using similar phraseology. (1) I had once begun to write an article on it, my formulation was "slave's mentality." Mr. Wang also said that he thought that the slavish mentality was changing.

I do not think that Mr. Wang spoke literally, that all Chinese have a slavish mentality. We speak more simplistically than we really mean.

Human beings are complex things. Societies are more complex. The earliest of our species recognized the utility of simplifying the complex in order to understand. We continue to utilize the tool of simplification but most of us realize that its powerful attraction can pull us far off the path of understanding and onto that of misunderstanding.

Simplifying and simplistic both have the same root.

But neither imprecise speech nor the pitfalls of simplification should deter us from using a construct that truly does contribute to understanding.

Maoist China had characteristics of a slave state. Literal slavery did exist. Mao’s regime may have been the most totalitarian regime in human history. The extraordinary oppressiveness and the constant attempts at thought control help to explain how one could walk to the gallows without protest, or watch one’s wife walk to her death without intervening.

However, simplifying Maoist China by calling it a slave state is simplistic. The control of the master over the slave is more personal, the danger of disobedience more immediate; the slave has even less freedom, and no opportunity for advancement out of his position.

There was a subtle but significant distinction between the two formulations of the idea. My word was “slave;” Mr. Wang’s was “slavish,” “slave-like.” His was much better.

The effects of oppression are not uniform. A victim (Bian) is affected one way, the loved one of a victim (Mr. Wang) another. Perpetrators (Red Guards), uninvolved witnesses to violence, the state, and the general populace are all affected differently.

The first time that I went to Beijing in 2006 I was astonished at how western the city looked and how western was the behavior of the residents. Deng Xiaoping had said “To be rich is glorious,” and by God Beijingers sure seemed fully committed to the glory of getting rich.

How could this be in a country that had been arch-communist under Mao, where even Russian communism was considered “revisionist?” How could people so suddenly and completely shift from hatred of capitalists to being uber capitalists? Because the leading authority figure in the country had said so. A “slavish mentality” produces obedience. This, I suggest, helps explain the abrupt one hundred eighty degree turn.

A key corollary follows: If Mao was obeyed because he was the leading authority figure in the country and Deng was obeyed because he was the leading authority figure in the country then Beijingers were communists then and are capitalists now out of obedience, not out of commitment to the ideals of communism or the benefits of capitalism.

Ye Youyi once said to me with disappointment and disapproval, “Chinese don’t think for themselves, Ben.”

Where there is oppression one would also expect to find passivity and passive-aggressiveness. An author has made the observation that Chinese are neither confrontational nor argumentative. I would offer up the behavior of urban motorists as an excellent index of aggression among a people.

New York City taxi cab drivers will cut you off, honk their horns obnoxiously to get you to move (when there’s no place for you to move), and will get out of their cars and scream at you if you want to argue. “Road rage” is well known among ordinary drivers in the U.S. Many people have been murdered for the offense of cutting another driver off in traffic.

Beijing taxi drivers are as aggressive as their Manhattan brethren. However, they rarely honk their horns. I have thought on many occasions that a collision with another vehicle or a pedestrian was imminent but the Beijing drivers seem to have some secret Chinese anti-collision device planted somewhere. If there is such a device it is not connected to the ocular nerves however. They don’t look at each other, classic body language of the passive. Drivers don’t look at other drivers or pedestrians and pedestrians don’t look at drivers. But somehow, and often at the last possible opportunity, doom is averted. And the result of these near misses is never road rage.

Chinese have a reputation for being polite and my experience is consistent with that. I have communicated with a good number of Chinese in the Great Wall of Silence project. No one has ever been argumentative. All of this would seem to be good: no road rage, no traffic accidents, no arguments.

However there are downsides. I read somewhere that one has to be careful when interviewing Chinese people because they are so conditioned to say whatever they think their interviewer wants to hear. Agreement negates confrontation, which precludes punishment. Agreement of this kind requires no thought.

I would suggest a “please mentality” as the term to apply to those conditioned by oppression to agree or please. I think that Mr. Wang said he wanted to tell me something because he knew that it would please me.

During the American civil rights movement northern white volunteers went into the Deep South to register African-Americans to vote. The former slaves or descendants of slaves would unfailingly accept the registration forms enthusiastically and promise to fill them out and mail them in. Civil rights workers were therefore astonished when few new eligible voters showed up on the registration rolls. The oppression of Jim Crow conditioned them to avoid anything that could lead to a confrontation with white people. They followed up on the avoidance with the passive-aggressive behavior of not registering to vote to avoid confrontation with Southern whites.

Wouldn't a please mentality also be consistent with the Chinese government's actions vis a vis the Beijing Olympics? The government badly wanted the imprimatur of world approval that conferring the games on Beijing symbolized. They remade the city, bull-dozed the hutongs and replaced them with modern buildings. They had artifically reduced air pollution by shutting down factories and restricting the driving of ordinary Beijingers. They instructed Beijingers to smile, not expectorate, and taught them this amount of English (while smiling): "Welcome to Beijing."

The Chinese government did all of this to please, to please the International Olympic Committee, and foreign visitors.

These are all gross generalizations. One can not talk or write seriously about a Chinese mentality. However, I would suggest that there is a sense in which one can seriously talk or write about an American mentality; or an English, Japanese, French, or Indian mentality because those societies freely choose their leaders. The results of an election are at least a meaningfuly snapshot of the mentality of a society. A span of elections over a century or more does, I suggest, enable meaningful generalization about the mentality of a people, their hopes, values, ideals, and taboos.

Chinese don't have the freedom to choose the kind of government that they want. If they ever get that freedom the choice that they make, and its chances for permanent success, will require political freedom of thought. Chinese don't have that freedom either. What will that free election show the hopes, values, ideals, and taboos of Chinese to be?

In the second interview with Mr. Wang I saw that there is still fear. I had been concerned about using the Bally’s waiting area for the interview as soon as we sat down. Here were two Chinese people talking to two foreigners, the foreign man in the suit asking all the questions and the foreign woman holding a microphone. However I didn’t voice my concern since Mr. Wang and Ye Youyi, or interpreter, had chosen the site. Still, I paid attention to other people in our vicinity.

Mr. Wang spoke freely at first. People walked by but didn’t seem to pay us any mind. After about an hour a man sat down in our vicinity. He was to my right but directly in Mr. Wang’s line of vision. I turned to check him out. Mr. Wang paused and with squinted eyes looked carefully at the man. We continued to talk for a little while but Mr. Wang was no longer at ease and we finished up and left.

Fear produces false agreement. Fear also produces silence. One would expect false agreement and silence to be most pronounced in people of Mr. Wang’s generation, who lived through all of the brutality of Mao. The Great Wall of Silence surrounding the murder of Bian Zhongyun is a consequence in part of present fear and residual fear from the past.

There is also evidence to support the second part of Mr. Wang’s statement that the slavish mentality is changing. There was no evidence of a slavish mentality in the protests of Spring 1989. Those were bold, courageous, and widespread in participation and public support. The protesters of 1989 had the mentality of those willing to rebel against oppression, just as their forefathers had in 1644, 1911, and 1949. The June 4 massacre showed that Deng Xiaoping's regime still had a "slavish mentality," that is the mentality of the slave's master. The problems that the current regime has had in the countryside demonstrate that some Chinese still have the will to rebel.

However, there seems insufficient evidence for Ma Lisen’s positive assessment of the change. China is free only in the economic realm. Precisely the values that Ms. Ma mentioned--human rights, democracy, freedom, equality--are those that are still missing. China remains a civic communist state.

Human rights is a misnomer in a sense. A people have to demand them. Human rights cannot be gained by pleasing those who deny them.

(1) This and the other footnotes in the next post on this subject are in no way intended to be comprehensive. Dr. Li Zhisui, in The Private Life of Chairman Mao, uses it in a variety of contexts, as it is used in this post also: On the general public: " 'The people' were nothing but a vast multitude of faceless, helpless slaves [to the C.C.P.]" (355); On Zhou Enlai: "Suddenly, I realized that Zhou Enlai was Mao's slave..." (258);” 'We shouldn't do everything according to the books, slavishly copying every word,' “quoting Mao.”He traced the party's slave mentality to China's Confucian past." (234)