The chaotic endgame of the American withdrawal has undercut some of the most fundamental premises of President Biden’s presidency.
For most of the last week, in the fires of the worst foreign policy crisis of his young administration, the president who won the White House on a promise of competence and compassion has had trouble demonstrating much of either.
The chaos in Kabul and his own conflicting messages have left President Biden struggling to assert command over world events and seemingly more intent on washing his hands of Afghanistan than expressing concern over the humanitarian tragedy unfolding on the ground.
Mr. Biden’s team argues that it will not matter in the long run because Americans agree with his decision to pull out after 20 years of war and do not care what happens in Afghanistan as long as their fellow citizens are extracted safely.
...
But the tumultuous endgame of Mr. Biden’s withdrawal has nonetheless undercut some of the most fundamental premises of Mr. Biden’s presidency — that unlike his erratic, self-absorbed predecessor, he brought foreign policy seasoning, adults-in-the-room judgment and a surfeit of empathy to the Oval Office.
“I just had the feeling that he was so wrapped up in the decision itself that he forgot the basics of implementation,” said Leon E. Panetta, the former defense secretary who served alongside Mr. Biden in President Barack Obama’s administration. “The American people may be with you on the decision, but if they see chaos, they’re going to be very concerned that the president doesn’t have his act together.”
Secretary Panetta's wording sounds the most accurate to me: Biden "forgot." He "doesn’t have his act together.” So, the concern is beyond incompetence and lack of empathy. Panetta's wording goes to Biden's mental capacity. I have written on both of the president's speeches that it was as if he was not perceiving reality correctly. They both had Iraqi foreign minister surreality to them.
David Axelrod, a former strategist for Mr. Obama, said he had no doubt that most Americans agreed with Mr. Biden that it was time to wrap up the Afghanistan operation. “The way it’s ending, at least thus far, is more problematical,” he said, “and cuts against some of his core perceived strengths: competence, mastery of foreign policy, supreme empathy. It’s as if his eagerness to end the war overran the planning and execution.”
Mr. Biden...on Friday...asserted that the evacuation operation had “made significant progress”
Faulted earlier in the week for not consulting with allies, Mr. Biden made a point of noting that he had now called the leaders of Britain, Germany and France.
That's another one. He "forgot" to call Boris and Angela and Emmanuel.
Mocked for spending time at Camp David, where he had gone for summer break, while Afghanistan fell to the Taliban, Mr. Biden delayed plans to fly Friday afternoon to his home in Wilmington, Del., until Saturday.
And that's the "not in touch with reality" one.
Mr. Panetta said Mr. Biden seemed to have realized that he had mishandled the message, at least, and needed to make adjustments. “I just had a sense that he was back on his feet today as opposed to earlier in the week,” he said.
Maybe I'm...Didn't Panetta just say... I most assuredly did NOT have a sense that he was all person-woman-man-camera-tv today. I had the sense his staff told him, "You have to call Johnson and Merkel and Macron, YOU FUCKING DOTARD!" I had the feeling (because it was like reported this way) that he returned from Camp David only after his staff urged him to return, implored him to return, and finally told him "You must". So to me, those two decisions did not occur to him.
Was Leon interviewed by the Times before it was revealed that Secretary Austin had told Congress that Americans had been beaten by the Taliban?
Something odd to me that he had Harris and Blinken with him today, no? Why? We're supposed to go, "Ooh, he's got Kamala and Tony backing him up"? If you put a photo lineup together of a person, Kamala Harris, Antony Blinken, a camera and a tv, and asked them who the man in the mask was they would have no fucking idea.
Beyond repeating that “the buck stops with me,” [which he did in his first speech also] however, Mr. Biden conceded no mistakes of his own and again deflected the harsh reviews by focusing on his desire to end the war rather than directly addressing what many consider the botched execution of that decision.
As he has all week, Mr. Biden made assertions seemingly at odds with reality.
BINGO! There you go.
His description of a smoother evacuation contrasted with the continuing confusion at the Kabul airport,
He made it seem like Southwest was in charge, somebody said.
where flights were halted for hours on Friday until they resumed late in the day. His claim that there was “no question of our credibility” with NATO allies belied the deep frustration in European capitals. And while Mr. Biden hailed the “degree of precision” of the operation, he could not say how many Americans were still in danger.
He has this reality in his head that is not the reality in the real world.
Those comments came after other suspect statements earlier in the week. A month after he said it was “highly unlikely” the Taliban would take over Afghanistan and there was “no circumstance” that would lead to a chaotic, Saigon-like exit, Mr. Biden told George Stephanopoulos of ABC News this week that chaos was in fact always inevitable. While multiple reports indicated that military leaders argued to keep a small force in Afghanistan rather than pull out entirely, Mr. Biden insisted that “no one said that to me that I can recall.”
He doesn't recall.
At points, the president has evinced little sense of the human toll as the Taliban swept back to power. Asked about pictures of fleeing Afghans packed into planes and some even falling to their death after trying to sneak aboard, Mr. Biden interrupted. “That was four days ago, five days ago,” he said, when in fact it was two days earlier and hardly made less horrific by the passage of a couple of sunsets.
When your mind starts to go, your emotional response often gets blunted, too.--I think that that is correct statement.
Mr. Biden instead has pointed the finger d, [sic, "at"] the now-deposed Afghan government, the vanishing Afghan security forces and even Afghan civilians who he said resisted being evacuated earlier. He has avoided blaming the Taliban, presumably to avoid antagonizing them while executing the evacuation.
...
The Biden team’s cold political calculation is that the outrage expressed by the Washington political class and the ghastly images shown by the national news media will have little lasting effect on Americans who will soon forget the messy departure but remember that the president got the United States out of a failed war.
Americans have now been beaten. The president could not guarantee that all Americans would make it out alive. If some Americans are repatriated in wooden boxes, the American people will jump at any alternative, even Trump.
They may be right. By Friday, newspapers in places like Phoenix, Fresno, Jacksonville, Minneapolis and Providence had no stories about Afghanistan on their front pages. Americans historically have not voted much on foreign policy unless it directly involved Americans, which is why Mr. Biden’s main priority has been to get his own citizens out without casualties or a hostage situation.
I’ll be a sonofabitch. You know, that’s the way it is with my adult children, too. I was wiped out by this week and went over to visit my son yesterday afternoon. He was playing Rocket League, same as always. On Thursday, I was on my phone feverishly reading the news when I got a text message that my daughter had a new vlog up.
“Biden thinks he gets away with this as long as there are no Americans that are killed on the ground, which is a big if because a lot of things could go wrong,” said Ian Bremmer, president of the Eurasia Group, a geopolitical risk firm. “But I happen to agree with him. I think that’s right.” At the same time, he added, “I’m amazed at how he’s mishandled this with the allies.”
The political danger for Mr. Biden may be that the chaotic exit provides fodder for a broader Republican argument that he is not up to the job and has left the United States humiliated on the world stage.
Forget the last clause of that sentence. Republicans cannot capitalize on "competence" for reasons previously stated. But "not up to the job"--That's too vague. Trump was "not up to the job." If Republicans can make this into a mental capacity issue...but they've got Trump there, too. I don't know, mental capacity is more dangerous than competence.
Some of those who have criticized Mr. Biden nonetheless said the final verdict was yet to be written. It will hinge, they said, on whether he can ensure the safety not just of Americans trying to leave the country but also the Afghans who worked with the United States over the past two decades, even if it takes longer than Mr. Biden’s Aug. 31 deadline.
“The president still has a lot of agency over how this will be perceived and the impact on our reputation for compassion and competence,” said Representative Tom Malinowski, a Democrat from New Jersey. “It all depends on whether he’s willing to do what it takes and to allow our military to do what it’s capable of doing to rescue everybody we can without regard to any artificial deadline.”
