Sunday, January 27, 2008
Drawing Lines
of a kneeling, bare-shouldered beauty applying fire-
engine red lipstick. Her lips are slightly parted and
her wide-open green eyes look directly at the camera
with a caught-in-the-act expression.
On page 49 of this two-page ad is a knees-to navel
shot of a blue-jeaned man wearing a distressed leather
belt whose concave metal buckle gauzely reflects the
face of the woman. The camera angle is centered
directly on the man's crotch. The woman is so close
that her brown hair touches the man from navel
to knees. Her red lips are inches away from the man's
jeans zipper.
The ad served its purpose, I stopped leafing and
paused on it. The photos are such close-ups that
it takes a split-second to sink in. I laughed, it was
so direct.
The ad was not for lipstick, nor for men's jeans, but
for Belvedere vodka. I laughed again. I have written
here previously of the the ever-diminishing line between
fashion and sex photography. I like both a lot but am
jarred when I see the latter so prominent in the former.
If I'm reading a fashion magazine it is not for sexual
stimulation. When I'm looking at porn I'm not interested
in what the women are wearing, or could be wearing.
There, I'm looking for crotch shots.
In Washington I attended the Annie Liebovitz exhibition
at the Corcoran Gallery. She is a good photographer
and her work often appears in Vogue. At the entrance to
the exhibition, at the top of a staircase, was a full-length,
full-color nude of Cindy Crawford from her super-model
days. My girlfriend thought that she was stunningly
beautiful. I did too, but not in the same way I think an
Ansel Adams photo beautiful (there was an Adams
exhibition at the Corcoran too). The photo of Crawford
was sexually stimulating. I was too embarrassed to
look at it closely, as one would a piece of "art."
At least the subject matter of the Crawford photo was
beautiful. Not so of the--many--nude photographs of
a near-death Susan Sontag in the Liebovitz exhibit. I
didn't enjoy the Liebovitz exhibit at all.
This morning I was again leafing, through the January
28 issue of The New Yorker. The "Talk of the Town"
article is on the romance and impending marriage of
French president Nicolas Sarkozy and Italian actress/
bombshell Carla Bruni. France, of course, has always
had very...tolerant...attitudes toward sex and infidelity,
even among its political leaders. The Sarkozy-Bruni
affair however has not played well. Part, because
Bruni is tacky, and the French are not tolerant of the
tacky. The New Yorker article is written by Adam
Gopnik and it is so well-written that it deserves to be
quoted directly:
"The Italian model and singer, who has been
around several blocks, many of them touristique,
in her career--Mick Jagger and Donald Trump
have both been mentioned--took up with the new
President last fall, and was photographed with
him at Disneyland Paris and Luxor, among other
places."
Donald Trump and Disneyland Paris. Those are
two strikes of tackiness right there, and the French
smell a rat, the rat of infuriating American tackiness,
in the whole thing. The French press,
"has struggled, with subtle semiotic hints, to place
[the affair] linguistically in the right geography:
L'Express, in its cover story on the pair, called
Sarkozy 'Le President "People" (with the word
'people' in English, so that nobody would miss the
point)..."
In a reversal that further exasperates the French, the
American press has covered the story as one typically
French. "Zey are a funny race," is how Gopnik sums
up the American reaction.
The lines between Fashion and Art (sophisticated) and
pornography (tacky) are blurred, but real, and at the
intersection is Sex (enjoyed, celebrated, but sometimes
tacky). Each of us draws these lines in different places,
and where we draw them depends on our attitudes
towards sex. I enjoy porn but only in private; it's
like going to the bathroom. Both involve natural,
inescapable bodily needs, but I close the door when
doing both because I am embarrassed by both. When
I'm in the mood I don't see anything tacky about porn;
I feel only the incredible sexual high of seeing the
women. But when I see a porn when I'm not in the
mood I see only its tackiness, and turn away.
Having sex has always, of course, thrilled me, but
also depressed me. "Third base is best," I read a
woman write recently. "The best sex organ is
the mind," someone else has written. Imagining
sex with a woman who has caught my eye is
breathtakingly exciting. Getting aroused by
the sight of desirable women several times a
day becomes tedious for me and distracting.
I've got other things that I want to do and my
sex drive interferes. Then there's shame again.
I feel puerile, I feel guilty at reacting to a woman,
often a colleague or friend, so one-dimensionally.
Having sex (on the few occasions I have) with
a woman my mind has lusted after, has usually
been anti-climactic, both figuratively and literally (I
usually don't climax). Having the woman's body
has seldom been as good as imagining her body.
For many people, wonderful though sex can be,
it can become dull quickly. My girlfriend, a
(young, beautiful, blond) marathon runner,
summed up this conundrum with this priceless
statement to a married friend of ours, about sex
with her ex-husband (and undoubtedly me
too):
"Sex for me is like running a marathon. I dread it
happening, enjoy it when I'm in it, and never
want to do it again after it's over."
I, and, as my girlfriend's statement indicates,
others, struggle with where to draw these lines.
Drawing these lines is the ambitious work of the
(American) painter John Currin. Calvin Tomkins
writes about Currin and his angst in the same issue
of The New Yorker as does Gopnik on Sarkozy-Bruni.
For some time now, Currin has used pornographic
images taken from Internet sites as the subject matter
for his paintings. He does not seem to know clearly
why he does this. He says that he was motivated by
the furor of Muslim reaction to the Danish cartoons
of Mohammad last year, of the shock of the Western
world's reaction to that reaction, but particularly by
The New York Times refusal to reprint the cartoons
and its defense of Muslim defensiveness. So using
pornographic images as subjects for his painting
became an act of defiance. The reader is not alone
if he fails to see the exact connection. Tomkins, a
Currin admirer, writes,
"When I asked how [the cartoon controversy]
tied into his making pornographic paintings,
Currin talked about low birth rates in Europe,
and people having sex without having babies,
and pornography as a kind of elegy to liberal
culture, at which point I lost the thread."
I don't get the sense that this is yet another shallow
artist attempting profundity where there is none, of
muddying the waters to make them look deep. Currin
is struggling to understand what he does and what
motivates him. He's unclear because drawing the lines
between art and pornography is so difficult, and
because the difficulty has to do with his attitudes
toward sex.
Currin experiences the guilt over the women in his
pornographic paintings and other equally prosaic
emotions. He has painted his wife's face into other
traditional portraiture. Tomkins, for one, seems eager
to see Rachel in some porno paintings with her "wide-
set hazel eyes, pearly skin, heart-shaped face...long
bare legs." Easy for Tomkins to say about someone
else's wife, but Currin won't do it. "At one point,
I thought of using Rachel's face there, but I decided
against it. The humiliation of the narrative is not
something I want to put her face into." Like one
who enjoys viewing porn, Currin feels guilty about
the women, but also embarrassment at his own
pleasure, "I'll keep myself as the only person
humiliated by this painting."
Currin experiences the difficulties in drawing lines
in every way. He is mesmerized by Woman:
"He sees women as different beings, some kind
of embodiment of creativity, of life and beauty,
all these strange emotions," says Rachel. "The
male-female issue is a constant battle for John
and me." Rachel has never experienced the
unnerving sensation of seeing a beautiful girl
or woman, and being stopped in one's tracks.
It's a guy thing, Rachel you wouldn't understand.
It is not only a constant battle between Currin
and his wife, it's a constant battle within Currin.
That is what he is trying to work out in his art.
Like many modern women, Rachel Feinstein asked
John Currin out on a date first. Like many modern
men in that position, Currin refused. "He was sort of
taken aback." For Currin, this disconcerting reversal
of traditional male-female roles reoccurred when they
finally did go out.
"I went to see him in his studio first. He had placed
two chairs so we could look at his paintings, but I
turned mine around so it was facing his. 'I'm not
interested in the paintings,' I said, 'I'm interested
in you.' " So how to think of Woman, or women,
if you're a guy today? Currin won't paint his
wife's face into one of his porno paintings, but
maybe his wife wants him to, but won't say
because she feels guilty.
The couple struggle over whether to hang one of
his porno paintings in their apartment. They have
two young boys. "What's that?," their three-year old
asked. "That's a vagina," said Rachel. "Ewww," said
boy.
Currin is mortified at what his parents reaction will
be to the paintings. "Is it really bad?," Currin's mother
asked Rachel. When told the painting showed pene-
tration Currin's mother responded, "Oh, good grief."
Both mother and father attended the Gagosian
gallery's opening of their son's work. Tomkins
writes, "Anita steered a quick course around the
room, avoiding the worst examples. Jim headed
for the gallery's terrace..."
The commonness of these feelings do not
render common Currin's attempt to deal
with them. Commonness is another word
for universal and Currin is struggling with
that universal, and if that is not a worthy
goal for an artist then nothing is. This is
Public Occurrences.
Wednesday, January 23, 2008
True Crime Stories: Confident Murderer
You killed one person, got away with it, and
then killed again. You are probably going to
get away with this murder too. You know that,
I know that, and you know that I know that.
You were cocky in court today. If you are
acquitted, don't bother killing witnesses as
you have in the past. I have kept you in jail
for almost five years. Come after me, punk.
You think murdering a drug dealer and getting
away with it shows how smart you are. Kill a
prosecutor and try to get away with that. Come
after me. I will even keep the dome light on in
my car when I drive home at night to give you a
better shot. You know who I am, I am Benjamin
Harris.
Tuesday, January 15, 2008
Islam in its Own Words: The Koran, Part One-Unbelievers
"This book is not to be doubted."
This establishment of infallibility is then followed, all on the first page, by these statements against unbelievers.
"As for the unbelievers...grievous punishment awaits them."
"There is a sickness in their hearts which God has aggravated: they shall be sternly punished for the lies they tell."
"And when they are told: 'believe as others believe,' they reply: 'are we to believe as fools believe?' It is they who are the fools, if they but knew it!"
"When they meet the faithful, they declare: 'we, too, are believers.' But when alone with their devils they say to them: 'we follow none but you: we were only mocking. ' God will mock them..."
On practically every page that follows in the entire book is similar castigation of everything and everything that is non-Muslim:
"Give us victory over the unbelievers." 3:148
"Believers, if you yield to the infidels they will drag you back to unbelief and you will return headlong to perdition." 3:148
"They follow nothing but idle fancies and preach nothing but falsehoods." 6:110
"Who is more wicked than the man who invents a falsehood about god or denies his revelations?" 7:34
"Their prayers at the sacred house are nothing but whistling and clapping of hands. 'Taste then the scourge, because you disbelieved.' " 8:31
"The basest creatures in the sight of God are the faithless who will not believe..." 8:51
"God and his apostle are under no obligation to the idolaters." 9:1
"How can you trust them? If they prevail against you, they will respect neither agreements nor ties of kindred. They flatter you with their tongues, but their hearts reject you. most of them are evil-doers." 9:6
"Believers, know that the idolaters are unclean." 9:27
"Be they men or women, the hypocritesare all alike. They enjoin what is evil, forbid what is just, and tighten their fists." 9:64
"Have you not seen those who repay the grace of God with unbelief...in hell shall they burn." 14:29
"The day will surely come when those who disbelieve will wish that they were Muslims." 14:3
(first published here May 14, 2003)
Sunday, January 13, 2008
True Crime Stories: 90% Boredom, 10% Horror
blood- stained, naked man carrying something in
his hand,walking alongside I-70, in broad day-
light. Reasonable suspicion established, the officer
pulled over and stopped the man. As the officer
opened his driver's door, the man threw a
severed human head at him and into his police
cruiser.
Later, the man's headless girlfriend was
discovered in their apartment, wearing a tee-shirt
with the lettering, "Sticks and Stones may break
my bones but Whips and Chains excite me."
The man was adjudged legally insane. The
officer went on temporary leave and received
psychiatric counseling. This is Public
Occurrences
American Civil War Anecdotes
GET SHOT!"
-A Union 6th Corps captain to an insouciant civilian who kept exposing his head to get a look at the action at Fort Stevens, July 12, 1864. The captain was Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., later Justice of the United States Supreme Court. The unrecognized target of his injunction was Holmes' commander-in-chief, Abraham Lincoln. (James G. Randall and Richard N. Current, Lincoln the President: Last Full Measure, cited in McPherson, Battle Cry of Freedom.)
Friday, January 11, 2008
Fatigue Makes Cowards of Us All

"Stonewall" Jackson repeatedly out-thought, out-
maneuvered, and out-generaled the Union army
in the Shenandoah Valley Campaign. Jackson's
performance there is still studied in military
colleges.
Shenandoah "created an aura of invincibility"(1)
around Jackson and his troops, and General Robert
E. Lee aimed to capitalize on that aura immediately.
He intended to surprise Union troops in the area of
the Chickahominy River "and he knew whom he
wanted to lead the attack: Jackson." (2)
Lee's plan called for coordinated action by his
generals. Jackson was to attack early in the
morning of June 26. Early morning came and
went and even at noon Jackson was
nowhere to be found. Finally, in late afternoon
General A.P. Hill acted for Jackson, and took
tremendous casualties. "Jackson's three
divisions were only a few miles to the north,
but their commander made no effort to hasten to
Hill's aid." (3)
Lee planned another coordinated attack the next
day "but once more Jackson was slow getting to
position and lethargic in attacking." Again, A.P.
Hill's troops had to step into the breach.
On June 29, Lee planned an assault on paranoid
Union General George B. McClellan's flank, but
"yet again--Jackson's slowness frustrated Lee's
efforts." (4) Lee had ordered Jackson to cross a river
and attack McClellan "but Jackson dawdled all day
rebuilding a bridge instead of fording the river." (5)
"Next day another of Lee's complicated plans for...
an assault...near the village of Glendale came to
grief." (6) Only General James B. Longstreet--and
A.P. Hill--were able to get their troops moving.
Not Jackson. When Union soldiers prevented his
men from completing a bridge over a river "Jackson
lay down and took A NAP." (7) "Seemingly in a trance,
[Jackson] did nothing while Longstreet's and Hill's
men bled and died two miles to the south." (8)
Jackson, of course, has been savaged by historians for
all of this, which occurred during what has become
known as "The Seven Days Battles," but what was the
cause of this strange behavior? Jackson was one of
the most audacious, battle-hungry generals in the
Civil War. He is rightly celebrated as one of military
history's great generals.
James McPherson, from whose book Battle Cry of
Freedom all of the above quotes come, believes
in this prosaic explanation: Stonewall was tired.
McPherson writes that Jackson generally
"seemed to need more than an average amount
of sleep" (9) and had gotten much less than
his required allotment during the Shenandoah
Valley Campaign.
We often discount that great people are first, people.
They have the same needs as we all do. Robert E. Lee
said that "under ordinary circumstances the Federal
Army should have been destroyed" during "The
Seven Days Battles." It wasn't, because Stonewall
Jackson needed his rest. This is Public Occurrences.
1. Battle Cry of Freedom. James McPherson, p.460.
2.Ibid, 464.
3. Ibid, 465-466.
4.Ibid, 468.
5. Ibid, 468.
6. Ibid, 469.
7. Ibid, 469. Emphasis added.
8.Ibid, 469.
9. Ibid, 466.
Thursday, January 10, 2008
China's Great Wall of Silence: Letters from China
date: Jan 9, 2008 6:33 PM
subject: thanks
mailed-by xu3331@hotmail.com
Hi Mr. Harris, thanks for your hard working on China's
culture revelotion. Xu
.....
The emails that I receive on this subject
mean a great deal to me.
-Benjamin Harris, J.D.
Wednesday, January 09, 2008
China's Great Wall of Silence: A Letter from China
Entitled A Few Words from the Heart, below are
excerpts:
Mr. Harris:
I got your response and I read it again and again;
so you are a prosecutor...
Belated justice, if achieved at all by political means
as per nature of government in China,can't really
compensate I guess the emotional anguish and suf-
fering of yesteryears...Yes, I am proud to take a
stand on this matter because the hollowing experience
did help to form an important part of my life's journey.
Actually, I think the reach of what we are talking
about is very deep and universal indeed.
...
I shy from communication [because] the fear of real
terror in the environment, in the world around me is
still real - or real in my head, fully qualifying the
existence of terror struck so deeply so many years
ago by a government that seemed mad.
Feel free to email: publocc@gmail.com
Tuesday, January 08, 2008
American Civil War Anecdotes
their guns under water! What sort of critters
be they, anyhow?"
-One Confederate soldier to another, as Union troops swam across the Chattahoochee River. During their swim the Union soldiers realized that they could load their waterproof metal cartridges underwater, then pop up, empty the water out of their carbines and fire. (A. Hoehling, ed. Last Train from Atlanta cited in James McPherson, Battle Cry of Freedom.)
Friday, January 04, 2008
China's Great Wall of Silence: Song Yaowu Plays Hard to Get.

About three weeks ago, I called you twice at your U.S. phone
number, and both times you had your phone connected to
your fax machine. PROBABLY OUT WITH ANOTHER MAN!
Today, after I got home from work, FOR PROSECUTING
CRIMINALS FOR MURDER, I noticed that I had two missed
calls from you. My heart skipped a beat. Then, about forty-
five minutes later you called again. With quavering voice,
I answered, "Benjamin Harris." You didn't hang
up immediately, because you were unsure what to do, but
after about two seconds, I heard, "click." I called you back but,
coquettishly, you had put your phone on fax mode again.
Song, don't you see, it's inevitable? We were meant to be.
Jilted suitors everywhere feel my pain and, like all of them
who are successful, I will never give up.
Love,
Ben
Wednesday, January 02, 2008
China's Great Wall of Silence: Song Yaowu and Liu Jin Back Together Again!

Ahh, the warmth of the holiday season.
These party girls include Song Yaowu
(second from left), and Liu Jin (third
from left). That dynamic duo were
lead singers of that red-hot chick band
of 1966, The Red Guards!
Song and Liu made their first hit in an
impromtu afternoon jam session at
their all-girls school on August 5. They
left their audience screaming and crying.
One witness to their performance, Bian
Zhongyun, even died of high blood pres-
sure brought on by the excitement! That
night Song and Liu got to meet the
deputy mayor of all of Beijing in person
to tell him first-hand of the day's events.
The next morning Liu crooned over the
school loudspeaker so movingly that her
audience was left dumbstruck.
But the highlight for the band came less than
two weeks later. Their first public concert was
held on August 18 in Tienanmen Square. Over
one million fans gathered. It was China's equiv-
alent of Woodstock.
Mao Zedong, the astute politician, seized the
opportunity to capitalize on the popularity
of the group. Just before dawn, The Big
Bopper appeared at the concert. Mounting
the gates of Tienanmen, Mao endorsed The
Red Guards new music. Mao and Song even
performed a duet together!
That photo of them, representing China's
past and future, became one of the iconic
photos in Chinese rock-and-roll history.
Mao went on to become a favorite of the
artistic avant guard, such as Andy Warhol.
As for Song, she proved to be no one-hit
wonder! She took her act to the countryside,
before eventually escaping fame to the U.S.
and settling down to become wife, mother,
and geology Ph.D. From rock star to rock
scientist!
But who can forget those halcyon days of
the summer of '66, when The Red Guards lit
up all of China? A few years ago, Song Yaowu
appeared in a feel-good film of that time,
Morning Sun, by friend and rock historian,
Carma Hinton. Ever modest, Song would
not allow herself to be pictured in
Morning Sun. We here at People's
Occurrences, however, are proud to
show Song and Liu again to their
adoring fans.
We love you Song and Liu!
To join the official Song & Liu fan club,
email us at publocc@gmail.com
Tuesday, January 01, 2008
Afghanistan, Albania, Algeria, Angola, Argentina, Aruba, Australia, Austria, Azerbaijan, Bahamas, Bahrain, Bangladesh, Barbados, Belgium, Belize, Benin, Bermuda, Bolivia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Botswana, Brazil, Bulgaria, Burkina Faso.
Canada, Chile, China (Communist), China (Free), Colombia, Costa Rica, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Dominica, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, Egypt, El Salvador, England, Eritrea, Estonia, Ethiopia, The Headquarters of the European Union.
Finland, France, Georgia, Germany, Ghana, Greece, Grenada, Guam, Guatemala, Haiti, Honduras, Hong Kong, Hungary, Iceland, India, Indonesia, Iran, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Ivory Coast, Jamaica, Japan, Jordan, Kazakhstan, Kenya, Kuwait.
Lao, Latvia, Lebanon, Libya, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Macau, Macedonia, Maldives, Malawi, Malaysia, Mali, Malta, Mauritius, Mexico, Moldova, Mongolia, Morocco, Myanmar, Namibia, Nepal, Netherlands, Netherlands Antilles, New Zealand, Nicaragua, Nigeria, Norway, Oman.
Pakistan, Palestine (separate country per Sitemeter (NOT per Publocc)), Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Portugal, Puerto Rico, Qatar, Romania, Russia, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saudi Arabia, Scotland, Senegal, Serbia and Montenegro, Seychelles, Sierra Leone, Singapore.
Slovakia, Slovenia, South Africa, South Korea, Spain, Sri Lanka, Sudan, Swaziland, Sweden, Switzerland, Syria, Tanzania, Thailand, Trinidad and Tobago, Tunisia, Turkey, Uganda, Ukraine, United Arab Emirates, United States, Uruguay, Venezuela, Vietnam, Virgin Islands (British), Yemen, Zambia.
This is a photograph of Dr. Lisa Randall from the August, 2007 issue of Vogue. She is one of the most accomplished scientists in the world. She is also the author of the acclaimed book Warped Passages: Unraveling the Mysteries of the Universe's Hidden Dimensions.
Saturday, December 29, 2007
Friday, December 28, 2007
The Bhutto Assassination
MANUFACTURER IDENTIFIED.
"Investigators with our Product Safety Bureau have
identified the factory that produced the defective
sun roof that killed Mrs. Bhutto as "Al Qaeda Sun
Sun Roof Manufacturing, Inc." and have closed
it indefinitely. I congratulate those involved in
so swiftly bringing this investigation to a
conclusion," said the Pakistani President.
The Bhutto Assassination
ROOF RECALL
"We must restore confidence in the safety of Pakistini
sun roofs," said the President.
Thursday, December 27, 2007
The Bhutto Assassination, America, Pakistan, and The Clash
Pakistan in its continuous subcontinent feud with
India. Our countries have remained cordial ever
since. In the "war on terrorism" President Musharaff
was one of the most outspoken (if somewhat panicked)
in the world, certainly in the Islamic world, in
condemning the attacks. He pledged help to the
Bush administration, and has delivered some.
The old bromide that politics makes strange bed-
fellows applies here, of course. India is the world's
largest democracy; Pakistan has had far more coups
than free elections. India is a stable country;
Pakistan has gone through more leaders than
Lincoln went through generals. Finally of course,
Pakistan is Islamic and India is Hindu and our Clash
is with Islam.
Bedfellow Bush has snuggled up to bedfellow
Musharraf, to the detriment of both countries, and to
our side in the Clash. He has done all that he can to
protect Musharraf against surges of Islamist violence
and assassination attempts. On the bedfellows theory
that would seem to be a good thing, but it's not. The
Musharraf regime is about to fall, that will be one of
the results of the assassination of Benazir Bhutto
today, and in it's place will be...who knows in Pakistan,
but eventually, probably later rather than sooner, an
Islamist government. And this one will have the bomb.
That's a very bad thing. Pakistan developed and test-
launched its bomb under President Musharraf, and
with President Bush looking on, or looking the other
way.
The most vital threat that America faces in the Clash is
an Islamic bomb in the wrong hands. That is closer to
happening today than it was yesterday.
The bed-fellows approach has produced this result.
The U.S. never should have permitted Pakistan to
develop its atomic capability. This day was foreseeable.
In the Clash, instead of the bedfellows theory that
delays the inevitable, this page has proposed an
opposite theory, of encouraging the inevitable.
We have called it "constructive provocation" and,
applied in the context here, the U.S. would have, if
necessary, bombed the Pakistani nuclear facilities out
of existence. That would have brought down the
Musharraf regime. Constructive provocateurs would
say, better sooner than later, better by our action than
the improvised reaction that the bedfellows theory
produces, better that we fight the Clash at a time of
our choosing rather than the enemy's. Whatever one
thinks of theories, we should have prevented the
Pakistani nuclear capability by all means necessary.
Long before President Bush, America should have
gotten out of bed with Pakistan. Pakistan shares none
of America's values. The bedfellows approach shunts
that consideration aside--for defensible reasons--for
geopolitical expediency. But there's the rub. The
bedfellows theory is supposed to be temporary and,
given the "strange" relationships it produces, it is
critical that each relationship so produced be
constantly reevaluated.
It has been the long-standing view here* that Pakistan
has not been a net plus for America in the Clash.
Rather, we have consistently argued that Pakistan and
Saudi Arabia are our greatest enemies. Shortly after
9/11 The New York Times Magazine did a story on
President Musharraf's madrasahs, the Pakistani schools
that inculcate Pakistani children in Islamist hatred.
As does our other major "friend" in the Islamic world,
Saudi Arabia, the madrasahs were one way for President
Musharraf to buy off Islamist threats to him personally,
and to his regime. The result for America however is a
new generation in Pakistanis--and Saudis--who, when
they come of age, will act out their school lessons with
the violence and hate that they were taught.
Additionally, U.S. intelligence indicates that Osama
bin Laden is alive and well. In Pakistan. In that "lawless"
tribal area in the mountainous border region it shares
with Afghanistan. Reportedly, we had a bead on bin
Laden in that area of Pakistan at one point, but
Secretary Rumsfeld called off military action for fear
of destabilizing our "friend." Acting under a theory of
"constructive provocation," obviously the U.S. would
have gone in and gotten bin Laden.
President Musharraf's fiat does not extend over a large
geographic area of his country; he does not rule the
hearts and minds of a large segment of his people;
he hasn't been able to produce bin Laden; our
ability to capture bin Laden ourselves has been
thwarted by concern for our bedfellow; and he
is teaching his youngsters to make jihad on us.
Another old bromide comes to mind, with friends like this...
* Our Friends in Pakistan, May 29, 2002.
Wednesday, December 19, 2007
China's Great Wall of Silence: China's "Eichmann's Defense" Law
At his trial in Israel in 1961 Adolph Eichmann defended himself
as someone who "never did anything great or small,
without obtaining in advance express instructions from Adolf
Hitler or any of my superiors."
At her trial in China in 1981 Jiang Jing defended herself in the
same way, "I was Chairman Mao's dog. He told me who to bite
and I bit them."
Israel convicted Eichmann and China convicted Jiang but
Israel is a nation of laws and applies them indiscriminately;
China is a nation of orders which it issues at its whim.
"Following orders" is not a defense recognized in a society
ruled by laws; it is a defense in a society ruled by orders.
It is for this reason that those responsible for the murder of
Bian Zhongyun and of 3,000,000 others during the Cultural
Revolution go unpunished. When it wants to, as in the case of
the Gang of Four, China issues orders holding people
accountable. When it doesn't want to, it issues no such orders.
Wang Jinyao, Bian's husband, has found this out over the
years. Wang has tirelessly sought justice for his wife's murder.
Pausing here for a moment we note another distinction.
"Memorializing" and "justice" both are important, noble
concepts. There are two parties to a murder, the victim and the
murderer. Memorializing focuses exclusively on the victim:
when we lay wreaths on the graves of our loved ones we do so
regardless of whether they died by murder, accident, in
war, or by natural causes. Justice focuses on both victim and
murderer. When Wang Jinyao went to his country's authorities
it was not to memorialize Bian; he has done that in his
apartment since 1966. Wang sought justice, he wanted those
responsible for his wife's murder to be held accountable in
some way.
When Wang sought justice he was cited a Chinese "law" that
codified Adolph Eichmann's defense. Wang was told that since
Bian's murder had occurred in the midst of a "mass movement"
the requisite criminal intent could not be imputed to any
individual. Without criminal intent there is no crime. Without a
crime there is no criminal. Therefore, no one was responsible
for Bian's death. Such was the Chinese government's order.
Justice is not revenge, the two, like orders and laws and
memorializing and justice, are often conflated. Justice is the
product of the shared values of a society, those values are
embodied in its laws and a society's fairness, that is, its
legitimacy, depends on the enforcement of those laws, that is,
those values. Wang Jinyao received no justice from his country
for his wife's murder because, you see, his country has no
justice to give. This is Public Occurrences.
Tuesday, December 18, 2007
Poetry Lives, American Culture Lives
Credit, not for the first time, to Arts and Letters Daily at www.aldaily.com.
Monday, December 10, 2007
China's Great Wall of Silence: The Struggle for History. Photo #1 Again


