Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Seeking the Soul of America: The Tucson Massacre.

Well. Certainly a fine example of homo sapiens Americanus at top, huh?  Note the look of keen intelligence on the face. Note the bats in the belfry.


Let me branch off here a little bit, even before the trunk is developed. I cannot help thinking about the massacre partly as a professional. I am a juris doctor not a medical doctor with a speciality in psychiatry, but I do not think one need be a shrink (perhaps it "helps" to be a lawyer) to come to an instant idea for a defense for Bats: insanity. (Oh, you have a better one?  Like "reasonable doubt?"  Mis-id, peut-etre? Go into dentistry.)


Americans are going through a familiar cycle of reactions today and have since mid-day Saturday.  First, there's shock. "Oh my God! No!"


Why should there be shock if it's a "familiar cycle?"


Then there's grief.


If human beings are, as I believe, a combination, pretty much in equal parts, of emotion and intellect, it is emotion that predominates in our species reaction to a massacre, whether it's a more familiar occurrence, as in America, or a less familiar one, as in other societies. As a homo sapiens, and one of the Americanus variety, I shared these two emotions, as I think is manifest in the writing in these pages since Saturday. I have a particular fondness for children and first the knowledge that a nine-year old child had been among the victims of our fellow citizen Mr. Bats-in-the-belfry, and then seeing little Christina Green's photograph, well, friends, countrymen, non-countrymen, enemies, as the part of Jim Croce's song Operator went, "Can't read the number that you just gave me...Something in my eyes, it happens every time..."


And then, to complete the cycle, of emotional reactions, there's retribution: "SOMEBODY'S GONNA PAY FOR THIS!"


And somebody probably will. Probably Bats, but...


So what does this say, if anything, about the Soul of America, or of my Seeking same, as I have so grandly titled this. Quite a lot, I think.


Let us quickly dispense with some familiar bromides: Yes, the massacre says America is an "edgy" society in which those who come by bats in their belfries naturally have a particularly difficult time "adjusting" to American life. America demands self-reliance more than most other societies. The phrase "pull yourself up by your own bootstraps" is itself a bromide, quintessentially American, used frequently in all kinds of contexts by Americans, and is particularly challenging for those who struggle with even tying their bootstraps. Secondly, the edge to American society is often followed by violence. I say not "caused by,” but "followed by."


What other mind-numbing banalities can we dispatch with? Oh, too many guns, too many nuts on the streets. That's all the banalities I can think of right now.


Shock-Grief-Retribution. Is this cycle any different, in kind or degree, from that in, oh, to just pick a country at random, China?


It is.


Would Chinese not be shocked if this massacre happened in China?  They would. 


Would Chinese not feel grief?  That too.


Would there not be retribution?  Oooh, doggy.


The difference is that retribution, a natural emotional response tied to survival, is meaningfully mediated by the intellect in America. Bats will not be subject to a "struggle session" today, as he would have if he had committed a political (the massacre is deemed a politically-motivated crime so far) "crime" in China during the Cultural Revolution. He was not summarily executed, though for some Americans, and for this one when the worser angels of his soul get his ear, the heavens would not have darkened if that had resulted, as the heavans did not when Lee Harvey Oswald was summarily executed in 1963. 


No, Bats will not be struggled, he will not be summarily executed, he will be fed and clothed and housed, and perhaps medicated, courtesy of the American taxpayers, who will also provide him with a legal defense to his crimes.  He will be presumed innocent in the court of law funded by these same taxpayers, who will also pay the salaries of the judge, prosecutors, and perhaps defense attorneys who will conduct the trial. 


Another branch here. I believe Jared Loughner guilty of this massacre. I believe that with as much certainty as I believe in the presumption of innocence. Those last two sentences need explanation. As we defense attorneys are fond of saying when questioning prospective jurors, "When you're driving on the highway and you see a police officer leading a guy in handcuffs to the back of his patrol car, do you think, 'There is an innocent man?' " The answer to that is obviously no, we don't think that. We think the shackled fellow-citizen is guilty--of what we don't know, but guilty of something. The point is the presumption of innocence is an artificial legal construct that has applicability in one, and only one, setting--the courtroom. 


Americans put up with this sometimes exasperating trial business because too, in my opinion, they value human life highly, and because we value retribution not as much, and not as much as some other societies. Americans don't exact retribution on a citizen accused unless that Devil has been proved guilty beyond a reasonable doubt in one of the afore-mentioned American courtrooms. All of this is to allow "cooler heads to prevail," to allow America as a society to think about what it is doing, before it punishes someone, that is it is to prevent struggle sessions and summary executions.

It is indeed curious. Americans put up with, hell they fight for, what they call "the right to bear arms."  That is, they fight for the right of Bats to walk into a meeting with an elected official with a loaded firearm. And when a massacre happens it's "Guns don't kill people, people kill people."  That's not a rationale that has proved persuasive in foreign hutongs, but it's part of Americans' freedoms and they take those very seriously too. In the same way, Americans put up with the mentally ill walking around the streets because they are reluctant to take away their freedoms also (Americans could do better than that). 


Thus Americans will never—never, never, never—fail to be shocked by massacres and to grieve for the loss of individual human life, no matter how drearily familiar massacres become. And Americans tolerate that messy trial thing, and extend the freedom of movement to the mentally ill, and to those already convicted of crimes (they could do better on that also), because, in my view, of the same reverence for human life and for the freedoms that they hold “self-evident,” and God-given. Americans will give up a species-wide, survival-fueled, emotional desire for retribution of an undeniably guilty murderer, for that, for those, for the intellectual...pause...to contemplate before punishing, as a society, an individual member of that society.

Americans owe, or can extend blame for, this reverence for life and justice, for justice is what it is, to their Judeo-Christian religious heritage which predominates in their lives, both private and civic, and animates their law.


And lest one, whether American or otherwise, thinks a trial for Bats will just be some charade, some foregone conclusion forestalled, let me recall the mind back to that day in March, 1981 when the President of the United States was shot by another who had bats in his belfry, and wounded two others. That Devil, John Hinckley, was found NOT GUILTY by reason of insanity of those crimes, which he manifestly committed. Citizen Hinckley was committed to an insane asylum for a period of time but is now allowed to go home for visits with his mommy. And he's allowed to get his driver license back.


Justice, Pilgrim. Justice. That's one difference between America and China. It is one of the better angels of our soul. 

Sunday, January 09, 2011

Murders in Tucson, Arizona

                                                                      

Above, a photograph, represented to be that of Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords, being wheeled away from the scene of her grave wounding.  The news reporting on this shooting has been horrendous. This photo first appeared, to me, in the Indian newspaper, The Hindu, but the identity of the woman on the stretcher was not revealed, although it appeared likely to be Rep. Giffords. The same photo now appears in The New York Times with the identifying information.

Rep. Giffords physicians are quoted as saying that she has been responsive to commands when they have taken her out of her induced coma for assessment. That is near-miraculous, and wonderful news, if true.

Murders in Tucson, Arizona


In memoriam, Christina Taylor Greene, 9 years old, murdered.

Murders in Tucson, Arizona

This morning Rep. Giffords remains alive, thank God, and the names of those murdered have been revealed. In addition to Judge Roll they are:

Gabe Zimmerman, who worked for Congresswoman Giffords. He was 30 years old and engaged to be married.  A full life ahead of him, gone.

Dorwin Stoddard, 76 years old, murdered while trying to shield his wife from harm.

Dorothy Morris, 76 years old.

Phyllis Scheck, 79 years old.

Christina Greene, 9 years old, born on September 11, 2001, just elected to the student council at her school. Little Christina, a point of light born on the darkest day in American history, now taken from us also.

Saturday, January 08, 2011

Shooting in Tucson, Arizona.

                                                                          

Sheriff Clarence Dupnik should be commended for this official statement today, speaking for his department.  The situation in Tucson is so very unclear right now, but Sheriff Dupnik's remarks are wise and true whether the shooting does turn out to be politically motivated, as universally reported so far, or not:

"The anger, the hatred, the bigotry that goes on in this country is getting to be outrageous."

Shooting in Tucson, Arizona.

                                                                         


The New York Times, CNN and Reuters are all now reporting that Congresswoman Giffords, above, is alive, thank God, Reuters using the wording "clinging to life,"  the Times quoting her surgeon as saying he was "very optimistic" of her recovery. The Reuters report below was from earlier in the day and cited National Public Radio for the information that Congresswoman Giffords was dead. The number of wounded is widely varied.

Seven Murdered in Tucson, Arizona.

                                                                        

Just within the last few minutes the death toll has gone from five, to six, and now seven in the shooting in Tucson, Arizona earlier today. Reuters is reporting that Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords has died. At almost the same instant CNN was saying that she was expected to survive. A federal judge, John Roll, above, and a nine year old child were also among the dead. The reports are that Congresswoman Giffords was the target. My God.

New York City, December 2008.

                                                                    


                                                   Blue;                      -eared
"The hair was          The eyes were            AlyRose apear-            on stage at NYU!"
                  Red;

She wore black; I wore the uniquely vacuous facial expression of the male of my species in desirous longing. And she was a dancer for godssake—No, not that kind of dancer you capitalist roader, sexist, capital P, capital I, capital G—but still there’s a litheness of body, a flexibility of the limbs that threw me into paroxysms of desire and produced unwanted thoughts of ideologically perverse acts.

Then she spoke.

“I’m sure you’re wondering what this American girl can possibly say about China that would be interesting.”

I SWEAR ON MAO ZEDONG’S MAUSOLEUM SHE SAID THAT.

Ms. Rose studied dance in China and teaches contemporary Chinese dance at the Tisch School of the Arts. According to my notes she explained that, by contrast with the decadent Western variety, Chinese dance has “little focus on romantic love, it’s replaced by love for Mao.” My notes reflect that the audience laughed at this and that Aly followed up by saying, “Well, that’s okay. You can get more done.”

Romantic-love-replaced-by love-for-Mao-but-that’s-okay-you-can-get-more-done.

Oh well. Another crush bites the dust.

On the same theme, later in her talk, “Romantic love a no-no.”

A “no-no?”  Are we twelve?

By this point I was wondering what this American girl could possibly say about China that would be interesting.

I have two memories of Ms. Rose besides those recorded in my notes.  One is that despite romantic love being a no-no in her life’s work she nonetheless punctuated her remarks with some dance…moves, if that’s the right term, and it probably isn’t, which seemed to me to be consciously sensuous in intent, and which did in fact produce that result in at least one member of the audience of the male persuasion. 

The second is that she also punctuated her remarks with Chinese, and this was clearly conscious (It is like when I sprinkle my English with Spanish: too “show-offy.”). There were at least two other native Chinese speakers on this panel, Li Onesto and Bai Di, neither of whom said a word in Chinese.
One of the things I had not remembered but that is in my notes is that Ms. Rose said near the end of her presentation that Chinese dance “presented a united front of the Han and minority peoples in adoration of Mao.”

I have just begun to write about the soul of China. There is no doubt that unity and related concepts are very important parts of the Chinese soul. China is also 92% ethnic Han. That is a very big number. By comparison the dominant ethnicity in America is “non-Hispanic white,” at (from memory) about 60%. To what extent is Chinese unity, Chinese survival—the soul of China—ethnic survival?

Friday, January 07, 2011

New York City, December 2008.





"Mary Lou, Mary Lou, pretty, pretty, pretty, pretty Mary Lou,Uh-uh Mary, da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da, my Mary Lou-ooh-ooh, ooh, ooh-ooh-ooh-ooh..."


Oh right, Peggy Sue.

Looks like Mary Lou, or at least Mary Lou's biz card, has not seen a lot of action in the Revolution for awhile. Or, maybe the printer made a mistake--God, a couple of mistakes--which would have Unleashed the Fury of Mary Lou! Hope they gave her a discount.

Point of personal privilege here however: I do not think that "Mary Lou's" can "Unleash Fury."  As might be said in Social Text the juxtaposition of "Mary Lou" and "Unleash Fury" creates "cognitive dissonance." A more martial name--say Yaowu--is needed. Yaowu Greenberg: such it will henceforth be.

She was actually a very nice person, not a panelist, just a comrade-ette helping out at the conference.

I had a lot of fun that weekend.

Thursday, January 06, 2011

New York City, December 2008.













It is rare that an endangered species is photographed in the wild.  Above is one such endangered species, an American Maoist. A radio tracking device encircles his left ring finger. This individual example of the species is known as "Raymond Lotta" to wildlife specialists devoted to observing and documenting the species.  "Ray" as he is affectionately known is depicted doing what he does in the wild, talking.  Ray talks a lot.  A lotta lot.   

Ray was at the zoo at NYU in December, 2008. He was one of the panelists, along with hosiery magnate Andrew Ross. I will never forget Ray's opening act.      

It is cold in New York City in December. And of course I got lost going from hotel to NYU zoo. And I was cold. There is nothing more comforting when one is cold than when one comes in from the cold, and into a nice, warm auditorium and sit in a nice, comfy chair. It is so comfy it is snooze-inducing. And I was warm and comfy and, well, my head drooped a bit and my eyelids got a little heavy.

Then Ray was introduced.  "THIS IS A VICIOUS, ANTI-COMMUNIST HATCHET JOB!,"  he screamed, and he really did scream, as he walked to the podium. He was holding up a copy of Jung Chang and Jon Halliday's seminal Mao: The Untold Story.  I was proximate to never-never land when Ray did this and momentarily forgot that I was proximate to never-never land at a Maoist convention. Personally being fond of vicious, anti-communist hatchet jobs I was half-way out of my seat and in mid-clap when I came to my senses, or rather my surroundings came to my senses.(1) I adjusted my trousers or something and cleared my throat and sat back down as naturally as I could.


1. When I got back home I emailed Ms. Chang and Mr. Halliday and told them that I had been at a conference where their work had received the greatest tribute I could imagine and then I related this story.

Top: Ray's business-is-for-capitalist-roaders card.

Wednesday, January 05, 2011

New York City, December 2008.

                                                                    

The handsome chap at top who appears to fancy hosiery is "Andrew Ross." He is a professor in the Department of Social and Cultural Analysis at the New York University and is not unknown to the undersigned.

In 1996 Andrew was part of something which Wikipedia terms the "editorial collective" of a magazine called Social Text. It was in that baleful year that Andrew first came to the attention of those beyond the captive collective of his NYU students and the tiny but "very bright" pageviewership of the worthy Social Text aforementioned, that is it was in 1996 that Andrew became something of a household name in America.

What brought Andrew into the hearthstones of millions...well maybe not millions but thousands, lots of thousands...of Americans was "The Sokal Affair."  What might that be. The Sokal Affair, sometimes called the Sokal Hoax, takes its name from a colleague of Andrew's, then and now, at NYU, Alan Sokal.  Professor Sokal was, then and now, resident in the Physics department.  Then and now colleagues in Departments of Physics and Departments of Social and Cultural Analysis are sometimes less than collegial. That was the case in the Sokal Affair. Professor Sokal, having read a "critical mass," in physics terms, of the learned writing in Social Text came to the opinion that the editorial collective of Social Text had tweety-birds flying around in their heads.  To prove the existence of this aviary Professor Sokal submitted an essay with the fetching title, Transgressing the Boundaries: Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity. 


Now I, Benjamin Harris, don't know what the hell that title means. Neither did Professor Sokal as it turned out because, you see, Trespassing...Transgressing...The Transsexual Transformation..., I say the article was a hoax.  Professor Sokal made the whole thing up, muddying the waters in order to make them look deep. Of course, Andrew didn't know what the hell the article was about either--but he and the editorial collective published it anyway as a serious social text in Social Text and Andrew got all splashed with mud. Abandoning for the moment the polite prose in which readers are accustomed to reading the learned articles here in Public Occurrences and adopting the lingua franca of the great unwashed but un-muddied, it was all bull shit, and a shit storm of derision descended on Andrew's head. And to provide happy transformation from last sentence to this it was in the journal Lingua Franca where Professor Sokal revealed that he had made Andrew Ross his bitch.

Then in December 2008--or the 20th century fin de siecle as it might be called in Social Text--the undersigned had the privilege of traveling to New York City, home of the New York University cleverly enough, to attend this:




Please forward widely
 REDISCOVERING CHINA'S
CULTURAL
 REVOLUTION:
Art and Politics, Lived Experience, Legacies of Liberation
A Weekend Symposium at Revolution Books and New York University 
December 12-14, 2008 

A Maoist convention. How could I resist?


The first day I remember there was an unfortunate transgression of the boundaries of the auditorium sound system's capabilities which caused a delay but more memorably a transformation in the blood pressure of the Master of Ceremonies, one "Andrew Zee," owner of Revolution Books, sponsor of all this erudition, which transformation transgressed healthy blood pressure levels. "Andy," as he was called by his comrades was much discomposed by this malfunction and before I had fully realized its seriousness I had made bold to mount the stage with my own tape recorder so that I could perpetuate in perpetuity the goings-on. A comrade, seeing that my intrusion might push Andy "over the edge," somewhat severely advised me to dismount the stage. Which I did.

I repositioned myself in a seat among my unwashed brethren and sistren (sistren?) in the auditorium.  And I glanced through the program. I read through the list and resumes of the panelists and saw:




Andrew Ross-- Professor of American Studies, Chair of Department of Social and Cultural Analysis, New York University; author of Low Pay, High Profile: The Global Push for Fair Labor; articles on China include "Mao Zedong's Impact on Cultural Politics in the West."

Andrew Ross, Andrew Ross, who the hell is Andrew Ross. I know that name from somewhere...Steve Ross, no...wait a minute...I got on my cellphone. I googled. Then I giggled.


It's been over two years now and I don't have my notes with me as I write this so I cannot be certain but I am pretty sure that Ross was not the first speaker. I had taken an aisle seat. Seats, whether in auditoriums (auditoria?), theaters, airplanes, or like that are designed for people of average leg length and I, like the residents of Lake Woebegone, am "above average" in this regard, if in no other. This data on my physical...dimensionality... is provided solely for the purpose of elucidating something of my physiognomy for it happened that the aisle seat I chose was cheek-by-jowl with the lighting system for the stage which I had just been unceremoniously booted from. I'm pretty sure that Ross was not the first speaker because of course there were breaks during the day and my memory is that it was during a break that a comrade asked me to assist the smooth-flowing of the erudition by manning these stage lights.

In his insouciance, the comrade had made an unfortunate choice in me.

All I had to do, the comrade explained, to make sure it wasn't "over my head," was flick the light switch when the lights needed to be turned on, and then flick it the other way ("That's 'off,'" he articulated helpfully) when the recorded portion of the erudition was done and questions were taken from the audience. It was after this instruction and now burdened with this task, that I keenly listened as Andrew took the mic.

I can report that although the sound system was repaired in fairly short order there remained a persistent problem the remainder of the day with the lights, which flicked on and off at the wrong times, causing momentary distraction on stage and momentary consternation on Andy Zee's face. I reveal for the first time here that the cause of this annoying malfunction was definitely "human error."  I can further report that Ross, so stage-disciplined, or so wrapped up in the sound of his own voice, was completely unfazed. I think I could have set off my fart machine with the volume on high and Ross would never have noticed.

The only thing I remember now (no notes) is his conclusion:  "Let's bury neo-liberalism once and for all. And make sure we don't bury it in a shallow grave."  At which point the audience broke into loud applause, the lights strobed inexplicably, and the members of the audience made up of ladies who wear sensible shoes squealed with their first orgasms.(1)

(1) I anticipate one or two readers may be thinking, "Why now?"  "Why are you writing about this now?"  Alas, my to-do list is a long one and I never got around to it.  Today however I got on Arts & Letters Daily and there was a blurb that began, "Alan Sokal's 1996 hoax," and that's all the reason there is.  Gonna miss you, Denis.

Tuesday, January 04, 2011

Seeking the Soul

                                                                


I think that one day you will publish your book on China’s Great Wall of Silence and the book will be a great one.

...

Dear Ben, 
I just read some of your exchanges with Ye Weili on Public Occurrences, you do amazing work.

The above are from two eminent scholars, the first from one who I have long corresponded with, the second who just completed a major book I had read and to whom I had sent my congratulations and appreciation.  That was the extent of our contact until yesterday.

None of us, even those of us who are Crabby Hermits by our nature, enjoy work (and work it is) that by its nature, must be done alone and obscured from the outside, especially work so dark and serious. We do it because we think the subject important and because we think we must try. That provides satisfaction and we Crabby Hermits are content. A compliment to one's work though produces more than satisfaction, it produces happiness, and there is little of that when one is shrouded in blackness. And so my thanks to the two scholars who extended me these kindnesses.

Monday, January 03, 2011

In Memoriam, Denis Dutton

                                                                          

Denis Dutton's death came as a complete surprise, and judging by some other online reactions, to others as well.Even since last night at 9:08 pm or whenever it was I first posted I have not had the chance to read his obituaries and get more information. I know this much: Mr. Dutton personally wrote each of those blurbs that appear on Arts & Letters Daily. Every single one of them. That is a remarkable feat itself.

And every single time I got on the A&L site there was something else that was interesting. Last night it was Mr. Dutton's blurb, "Does America have a national character?," which sounded pretty close to the idea of a "soul" that has been occupying me. The first thing I noticed that was amiss when I got on the site was the header in all black type instead of the usual red. Then I saw the link to the obituaries. Awful.

Like so many websites, A&L reflected one person's taste, judgment, style. Arts & Letters Daily was Denis Dutton.

Sunday, January 02, 2011

In Memoriam, Denis Dutton

My goodness gracious Denis Dutton died on December 28 of cancer. I had no idea.
Mr. Dutton was co-founder of Arts & Letters Daily, one of the finest websites in the world and much cited here. He was also a professor of philosophy at the University of Canterbury.
R.I.P.

This is Public Occurrences

These are the posts with the most "pageviews" according to Google stats since May* 2010:

1. China's Great Wall of Silence: The Anthropology of the Cultural Revolution, Sept. 19, 2009: 2,077.

2. Seeking the Soul: The Devil and Lebron James, July 9, 2010: 861.

3. China's Great Wall of Silence: The Anthropology of the Cultural Revolution. Liu Shaoqi, Sept. 30, 2009: 406.

4. The Joy of America: Citizenship, July 4, 2010: 208.

5. What a Wonderful World: Susan Boyle, May 15, 2009: 106.

6. The 133rd Pennsylvania Volunteers Regiment at Fredericksburg, June 3, 2008: 104.

7. China's Great Wall of Silence: "The Cultural Revolution as a Series of Coups," by Chang Mu, September 24, 2010: 69.

8. Red Legacy in China, March 19, 2010: 64.

9. Susan Sontag in Artforum, March 2, 2005: 60

The Sept. 19 "Anthropology" has had more pageviews (Google, why couldn't you just say "readers?" Why a "pageview?" Because one reader may click on it more than once?  Big deal. Do you think one reader has gone click, click, click, click, click 2,077 times?  Don't be dumb.)  than the remaining eight posts combined (Google, why a "top 9?"  Who ever heard of a "top 9?")?  That's astonishing, I don't know why. The other "Anthropology" and "Red Legacy" (#8 (out of nine???)) are both on Liu Shaoqi. He was the president so that makes a little more sense.

"Lebron James" #2. Makes sense. The American pop culture. If I wrote a post on orgasms, "Anthropology" would not be #1 (I don't think).

Good to see Mr. Chang Mu's article is being read. And hey Chinese censors, guess where it's being read?  Guess which country is #5 in countries of readers? Ha-ha-ha-ha-ha.

"Susan Sontag" from almost six years ago, wow (Google, what do you think, Susan Sontag's clicked on that 60 times?  She was dead when I wrote that.).

*Make that July.

Saturday, January 01, 2011

The Soul of China

The soul of China is survival.

I use the following definition of soul:

"The immaterial essence, animating principle, or actuating cause."

The soul is mutable.


The Great Wall of China is one piece of evidence, and symbol of, soul as survival. It was built to keep the foreign out.

The peasants are the large majority of the Chinese population. The land that the Chinese peasants work is hard. Their lives have been about survival on that land.

I do not believe that the soul of America is survival. The majority of Americans are not peasants.  When the majority of Americans lived off the land the land was more abundant than the land for Chinese. 

Survival may be considered an "instinct" or a value. If an instinct I hold that China does not have a value or set of values that is as important in explaining Chinese behavior as is the survival instinct. If a value I hold that it is the preeminent value in a Chinese hierarchy of values. I do not believe that survival in either sense has the same prominence for Americans or Europeans. I believe that there is a set of values that is more important to how Americans and Europeans behave and why they behave as they do.

Survival is defensive and inward-looking. I find China so.

America's soul is more assertive and outward-reaching.Chinese have not been as exploring a people as Europeans or Americans nor as conquering a people as Europeans.

Chinese are less religious than are Europeans and especially Americans. The religions of Europe and America are transcendent, dominantly Christian. I believe that Judaism and especially Christianity provide the set of values that constitute the souls of Europe and especially America. I attribute exploration and conquest in significant part to the effect of Christianity also.

Confucianism historically has been the most important provider of a set of values in China. Confucianism is not a religion, either transcendent or immanent.(1) It's obligations and responsibilities were guidance to emperor and subject alike to aide the emperor's survival.

I believe that of the fundamental human emotions (2) fear is more prominent throughout Chinese history than in European or American and is directly related to the soul of China, survival.

1. The analytical distinction between transcendent and immanent religions and its importance is due Roberto Mangabeira Unger, Law in Modern Society. Free Press (1977).
2. See for example, http://changingminds.org/explanations/emotions/basic%20emotions.htm.

to be continued.

Friday, December 31, 2010

I have been getting more spam from China recently that has snuck under Google's spam filter. Yesterday I got the following:


我是中国普通的中国人,我知道宋要武(也就是那个宋彬彬)是不是她还在美国呢?      不过我想她可能还在吧。我想也许她不能也不可能回来。         卞仲耘的事可能她忘记的。
 我希望你能交流


No, I have no idea what the hell it says but I thought, "Another goddamn discount cigarette offer."  Something, a lull in the day or whatever, made me Google Translate it rather than do a no-look pass to trash:


"I am a Chinese general of the Chinese people, I know to Wu Song (that is, the Song Binbin) is not she still in the United States? But I think she might still be right. I thought maybe she could not and can not come back. Bian could she forget something.
I hope you can exchange."


"HOLY SHIT!  Song...Bian...and from a Chinese GENERAL!"


I sent the email to a Chinese-American friend and asked her to verify.  This is the translation of the translation:


"I am an ordinary Chinese. I would like to know if Song Binbin is still in the States. I think that she may be still in the States. Perhaps, she cannot or is not allowed to return to China. Probably, she has forgotten Bian Zhongyun.

I hope that I can exchange ideas with you."



In other words, "general"=ordinary, not "GENERAL."


Swine Google Translate.


And the writer didn't leave a name, so it may still be spam. 


Happy New Year world, and especially to friends...and enemies. It is a wonderful world.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V1bFr2SWP1I

Miss you, Iz.

Thursday, December 23, 2010

I rolled out of bed this morning and somnambulated over to the bagel shop. Bruce, the owner, looked at me as I walked in and immediately called to Mercy, "A dark cafe con leche, please." (pause)  "The kind we use to wake up the dead."

Sunday, December 19, 2010

Seeking the Soul

And he will be a wild man; his hand will be against every man, and every man's hand against him; and he shall dwell in the presence of all his brethren.

I live in a neighborhood called "Little Israel."  I am a frequent patron of the local bagel shop and the owner has become a friend. He is a good man, and thoughtful, and when he speaks I listen; sometimes I ask questions. He talked to me the other day about friendship.  He said his dad had told him to always find the good in others and that once that good was found everyone could be a friend.

It is good to have friends, and I believe that there is good in everyone...but it's a matter of weighing.  There are other things in us all besides good. In some of us those other things outweigh the good.  In that case they must become enemies. It is good to have enemies.

Monday, December 13, 2010

"We Are Coming Father Abraham, Three Hundred Thousand More."

                                                                       


It's been an entire year since this series was begun. 


Because "Public Occurrences" is non-interactive, i.e. with no comments sections, readers have to email.  The effect of that over eight years has been to create readers who are contributors.  That has greatly improved  "Publocc."  It has also been a source of happiness for me personally. I have "met" a lot of people and they have become friends. 


Last year at just about this time I received two emails of the kind described, pretty much back to back, I think one the day after the other. Some readers may remember the song "We Rise With Our Dreams," last profiled here on December 11, 2009. One of the emails I received concerned that song and it resulted in an email kind of interview with the singer, John Jarvis. 


Then I received another email. It concerned the Battle of Fredericksburg.  It provided links to a trove of documents that had just been put online.  And I began to write what I envisioned to be a roman a clef on the battle.  I only got three posts into it before other matters, principally China, occupied me.  I have had Fredericksburg on my mental "to-do" list for a year and have not publicly thanked the reader, for reasons relating to the structure of the series as I envisioned it. However, it's been a year. 


It was just about now, at this time of day, on December 13, 1862 that General Andrew A. Humphreys led his fatal charge across that barren field.  It was the last charge the Union armies were to make in the battle. Some of Humphreys' men survived the rain of balls in the field and began to ascend the rise toward Marye's Heights. 


I would like to extend belated, apologetic thanks to reader Steve Shipe for forwarding the link to the documents that he did last year. And I remember the one condition that Steve put on my public thanks to him, to credit the transcribers at usg.archives who did the work to make this information available online. Thank you.




I




In the summer of that year the man heeded the president's call for a second wave of volunteers to save the country from the rebellion. His was the 133rd regiment-sized* group of men from his state to volunteer.
The man left his farm and his wife and child. The parting of husband and wife may have been sorrowful, or it may not have been. Many of her gender have a fondness in the loins for men in uniform and she must have for she later gave birth to a boy who could not possibly have been fathered by the man and who was probably the issue of one of the many other young men coming and going and marching and looking heroic and virile that summer.
The man, Nathan Bracken, mustered in on August 15 as part of Company F.** And almost immediately he was bucking authority.
On August 23 he (and fifty-eight others) signed a letter addressed to their Company's Second Lieutenant assuring him that they did not “bear any disrespectful feeling,”
“But knowing your incapability of discharging the duties required of you…we [declare] our unanimous wish that you will resign your office, so as to enable us to place a competent person to teach us the duties which we [have].”
The Second Lieutenant stayed. And Nathan didn’t give up.
Three days later he and some of the men sent a second petition, this time to the Colonel of the regiment who, they wrote, they knew “to be a gentlemanly officer who will deal justice to the privates under your command.”
The privates, stating their willingness “to serve our country, and die in its behalf if such requirements will be asked of us,” prayed the Colonel remove the offending Lieutenant because, “...before we enter upon the field of battle, we want to be efficient in the knowledge of drill…in the manual of arms,” which efficiency does indeed seem reasonable to expect if privates are to serve their country, and to avoid, if possible, dying in its behalf. The privates, “Hoping to hear from you soon,” closed their letter to the Colonel.
The privates’ hopes to hear from their Colonel soon were met, for three days after hearing from him they sent a third petition, on August 26. The men were then encamped in Washington, D.C. For many ever since, and perhaps then, the proximity to power of residence, however briefly and whether encampment or residence is the technical term for it, in the capital of the New Republic has proved an intoxicating experience. Perhaps thus fortified the privates bypassed several intervening links in the chain of command and directed their third petition to their state’s Governor. Writing that they were “compelled much against our will, to trouble the highest authority that a soldier [ed note: they had been "soldiers" for eleven days.] can appeal to,” the soldiers got right to the point:
“We have a Second Lieutenant, whom we are anxious to see removed.”
“We wish to have officers who are able to instruct us in the present drill, but our Second Lieutenant cannot do this.” Intuitively grasping the strategy, essential to success of all privates appealing to highest authorities, that it is wise to always propose a solution to a stated problem, the petitioners proposed that Lt. Francis Flannagin be replaced (by petitioners’ election, not highest authority’s selection) with “a man who is thoroughly acquainted in the knowledge of drill.”
“Such a one,” they proposed helpfully, “is to be found serving as a private in our company, Richard M. Jones.”
Although petitioners’ own vetting of Private Jones was good enough for them they indirectly acknowledged the uncommon Leap in rank that they were proposing and pointed out that Jones had been “commissioned, by your honor, in April 1861, as a Lieutenant” and “served with credit to the regiment and himself, for three months.”
It must be said that this summary of Private Jones’ resume surely proved unhelpful to petitioners’ cause for it alerted Highest Authority Curtin that he had once before appointed Jones a Lieutenant, in which position Such-A-One lasted only three months, and whose subsequent fall down several rungs to private went unexplained by petitioners.
At this point the innate forensic and literary abilities of the men appear to have been exhausted; they were, after all, only farm boys for the most part. Alternatively it could be that it was not proximity to power that proved intoxicating. The soldiers could have attempted to augment nature’s gifts with essence of rye or like substance and as they neared completion of their third formal letter in nine days the affects of the latter became deleterious to the former. However it was, after this point the cogency of the appeal worsened beyond reason:
“His [Jones’] business affairs m (sic) from enlisting in the three years service but when he found a (sic) country in actual need of all able body (sic) men, he, unhesitatingly came forth…”
Highest Authority could have been forgiven if he had put the letter aside and opened some other mail at this juncture for it seems doubtful that the press of business should have kept Richard from enlisting earlier in a contest that threatened the existence of the country in which he was doing that business; or that Richard had ever possessed the skills—or any skills whatsoever—to succeed in commerce seeing as how they had not prevented him from falling from Lieutenant to Private in three months time; or for doubting whether Richard, and his champions, were “able mind men” whatever the condition of their bodies. The unhappy sentence above concludes with the men repeating themselves, that it is their great, good fortune that their deliverer from inefficiency in the knowledge of drill in the manual of arms--just such a one--“is now to be found in our midst.”
Lieutenant Flannigan stayed. Richard remained a private. And Nathan Bracken became a Sergeant (elected, not selected). Together they and the other members of Company F of the 133rd Regiment Volunteers continued their march south, to war.
*1,000 men.
**100 men.

to be continued.

Friday, December 10, 2010

By the time I got out of law school I had moved from a small, rural town (which doesn't exist by that name anymore (which in case I haven't mentioned previously greatly annoys me)) to three cities--all clustered in the northeast of the US&A. By the end of that "odyssey" I was Done. I could have ended up in Timbuktu, I wasn't moving again.

A Chinese-American who I have corresponded with frequently in the last few years is retiring from her profession. I emailed her my congratulations and commented that she had lived such an eventful, fascinating life. Her response is below.

We American "natives" don't have lives like this. However, our fellow citizens who CHOSE to be here have these incredible stories.  In my own family, my mother's people came from England in the 19th century (they were coal miners from the northeast around Newcastle upon Tyne, came to the New World for a better life...and moved to the northeast of the US&A where they became coal miners (which decision-making greatly annoys me since there's a genetic component to it)). As was typical at the time, the man came first, got settled, and then sent for the rest.  His wife and children (one was born on the ship) arrived and had something like the following MapQuest directions: " Go to Timbuktu, western Pennsylvania."  That first night they made it as far as Lancaster or someplace in southeast Pennsylvania. She and her children had no money to stay anywhere and so a family took them in for the night.  Eventually they made their way to Paradise upon Susquehanna. "Honey, how was the trip?"  But even that was a Sunday drive compared to what my friend experienced:

"You are so right. Sometimes, I look back my life: being born to Buddhist parents, being educated in a Baptist school, forced to be an atheist, sent to labor camp, becoming American by choice, being re-baptized as a Christian, disgusted by the tele-evangelists, turning out to be an indedpendent thinker... Whatever has happened to me, I believe honesty and sincere, I believe in human conscience, and I believe in science, so finally I have found my own religion. Maybe that is what you have been searching for in the Chinese soul. At least I believe that is my spiritual life. I will lose sleep if I know I have wronged people. I am ready to face God, be He whatever kind, with a clear conscience. I'll enjoy my retired life. I will write something to praise good people and expose bad ones.
I am an American and think like an American. I wish Chinese are doing well and will do what I can to push in that direction. However, I did some research on the differences in culture. I like one definition of culture: "culture is a web which people have knitted for themselves to hang on." If they as a whole are sluggish to change, there is nothing you can do about it. How many Chinese who have physically moved to this country but insist living in China in their mind? For that reason I am against exporting democracy like the Iraq War.
Friend, I respect Americans like you for opening your heart to people of other cultures.

Monday, December 06, 2010

WikiLeaks

                                                                            

WikiLeaks is the most important website on the internet. It's the most important website that's ever existed.  It will win a Nobel Peace Prize one day. http://wikileaks.ch/

Sunday, December 05, 2010

Seeking the Soul

The story of the Circassian chief is recounted in two major works on Abraham Lincoln, Team of Rivals by Doris Kearns Goodwin, pp.747-8, and Lincoln’s Melancholy by Joshua Wolf Shenk, p. xiii, from which the account posted earlier is taken nearly verbatim.

It is that it is the Circassian chief’s story--and not Leo Tolstoy’s--that gives the story its power, that knowledge of Lincoln had reached such a remote corner of the world.  But this was Tolstoy’s take on Lincoln:

“This little incident proves how largely the name of Lincoln is worshipped throughout the world and how legendary his personality has become.  Now, why was Lincoln so great that he overshadows all other national heroes?  He really was not a great general like Napoleon or Washington; he was not such a skilful statesman as Gladstone or Frederick the Great; but his supremacy expresses itself altogether in his peculiar moral power and in the greatness of his character…Lincoln was a humanitarian as broad as the world.” (Goodwin, 748)

How did America produce an Abraham Lincoln?  Why has China never? 

Seeking the Soul

                                                            

"His name was Lincoln and the country in which he lived is called America."

Saturday, December 04, 2010

Seeking the Soul

A year before he died, Leo Tolstoy told the following story:

“Once while travelling in the Caucasus, I happened to be the guest of a Caucasian chief of the Circassians, who, living far away from civilized life in the mountains, had but a fragmentary and childish comprehension of the world and its history.  The fingers of civilization had never reached him nor his tribe, and all life beyond his native valleys were a dark mystery.”

Tolstoy told them of the industries and inventions of the outside world.  When he turned to the subject of warriors and generals and statesmen, the chief said, “Wait a moment, I want my neighbors and my sons to listen to you.”

“He soon returned, Tolstoy said, “with a score of wild looking riders and those sons of the wilderness sat around me on the floor and gazed at me as if hungering for knowledge.  I spoke at first of our Czars and of their victories; then I spoke of the greatest military leaders.  My talk seemed to impress them deeply.  The story of Napoleon was so interesting to them that I had to tell them every detail, as, for instance, how his hands looked, how tall he was, who made his guns and pistols and the color of his horse.  It was very difficult to satisfy them and to meet their point of view, but I did my best.” 

When Tolstoy finished, the chief lifted his hand.  “But you have not told us a syllable about the greatest general and greatest ruler of the world,” he said gravely.  “We want to know something about him.  He was a hero.  He spoke with a voice of thunder; he laughed like the sunrise and his deeds were as strong as the rock and as sweet as the fragrance of roses.  The angels appeared to his mother and predicted that the son whom she would conceive would become the greatest the stars had ever seen.  He was so great that he even forgave the crimes of his greatest enemies and shook brotherly hands with those who had plotted against his life." 

Friday, December 03, 2010



Above is Megan a painting by Weimin Mo.  Below is the Mona Lisa by Leonardo da Vinci.

                                                        

Compare the eyes, the "windows to the soul," in the two paintings.  I would recognize Megan if I saw her on the street.  I would not recognize Lisa del Giocondo.

It is often said that artists have a "sixth sense," that they can see what we cannot.  The Impressionists abstracted slightly away from the realism of the Renaissance.  That is apparent to us now but at the time it was not a slight change. It was a radical departure.  We can see now that we did begin, in the 19th century, to experience--see-- the world the way that Monet, et al showed us: The world had sped up as the Industrial Age began, it became a blur of light and shadow and outlines and shapes, and that's the way that the Impressionists painted it:

                                             Monet, St. Lazare

                                         Seurat, Sunday Afternoon on the Island of the Grand-Jatte.

                                          Pissaro

                                                     Degas, The Absinthe Drinker.

Shunned in their own time, the Impressionists have now become the most popular artists in the world.

Weimin Mo paints in the style of the Impressionists but with spectacular verisimilitude. He has a sixth sense for his portrait models' souls.  It's all about the eyes: the models', and Mr. Mo's.

                                                    Weimin Mo, Elyssa.