Sunday, January 19, 2014

Chow.

I have written contradictory things about Song's apology in the last week, I know. I KNOW. "Damn her, undamn her, re-damn her." "It is up to the Chinese people, I have no "brief" here any more." Both of those things are true but the first are expressions of my personal opinion(s) and I should have resisted. I have been on this so long, in so much depth...What was I going to say, "I have no opinion?" Oh yeah, right. At any rate, I succumbed to temptation, again. I did not tell Chow my opinion, so his response was not a product of "coaching" (I do not think Chow is susceptible to coaching from any one :) ).

I have also written this week both publicly here and privately in emails that regardless of what one may think of Song's guilt or innocence, regardless whether her apology is accepted, it is a marvelous thing that it has occurred at all. That's what Chow says also. The Chinese people, victims and perpetrators, are doing this, not the Center, not a real legal system. They have not been permitted to examine the evidence and decide publicly, if informally, guilt and innocence. They have not had to search their consciences concerning punishment and reconciliation. They have not been permitted even to study the Cultural Revolution. They are deciding their HISTORY for the first time under the communists.

It is remarkable for me to read Chow's words "truth and reconciliation." I have related this anecdote previously so pardon the repetition but it is too relevant here. In 2008 I had lunch with Professor Xu Weixin. "What could be done?" That, essentially, was the lunch topic. "Trials?" I suggested. Without looking up from his lunch, Professor Xu replied, "No, we can't do that." I suggested something else, I do not remember what. Another no-look "No." "How about a 'Truth and Reconciliation Commission' like they had in South Africa?" Without looking up, Professor Xu pointed his left index finger in the air, nodded once and said "That we could do." I think there's a little truth and reconciliation going on here in China, has been for the past few years. Chow is correct that they need the truth first, and the whole truth. Song provided little detail on Bian's murder. And, what about other acts of violence? I know of just one other, a non-murder. But my God, there are reports of so many more. In "Remembrance," hapless Feng-whatever stated that an internet search turned up 7-8 MURDERS claimed to be Song's. Even with the whole truth, there are likely limits to the reconciliation. I mean, the women of the Manson family--Jeez, similar in some ways to Song--have apologized repeatedly and confessed in detail, they still are denied parole. Whatever the Chinese people decide, but if they decide against reconciliation in Manson Family-like cases, that would certainly be reasonable...My God, that Manson Family analogy, I have never thought of that before. IDIOT...Anyway, Chow. What a guy. Love that man.
There's a guy walking with his head down that I don't have to get off Tumblr. And in Beijing, too.
Depressing to write that last post but then I opened up gmail and saw this, an email from my Red Guard friend Zhou Jineng. I've known Zhou for going on eight years now. He was one of the first Chinese to email me. "Chow" as he is known on Weibo, had posted something about me which is how Greg had gotten in touch with me. So I wrote to Chow. He speaks and understands no English and I speak and understand no Chinese so I asked Greg if he would translate my email to him. Besides a standard friendly greeting I asked Chow what he thought of Song Binbin's apology. Chow had apologized movingly in Red Art for violence he had committed during the Cultural Revolution. I honestly did not know what Chow would think about Song's apology. Here is Zhou's email, which touched me greatly. I will let it stand alone and then write a follow-up post. 



Hi Ben!

I am very glad to hear from you. Just as you know that the apology from Song Binbin has caused a great repercussion in China. My personal view is that her apology is positive in some degree. Regardless her sincere awakening or from of some pressure, apology is always worthy of recognition. Moreover, since she apologized for the Cultural Revolution, this event brought it into the public spotlight, and broke through the authority’s blockade in discussion the topic of Cultural Revolution, that is what I like to see.

However, the personal apology is not equal to the national apology. Rulers always try to cover up the truth in the history,so that under the real situation to distort history , justice is too difficult to be realized. As famous Chinese historian Mr. Zhang Lifan said: “No truth, no reconciliation. The prerequisite of the reconciliation is the truth. ” Right now I am not so optimistic about China's future, because of the ravages of Leviathan, China is becoming Sodom. And that is what I am worrying about.

Dear Benjamin, we are so grateful to your concerning about Chinese people and pursuing righteousness over the years. In my posts about you, many people are expressing their respect to you.

I do believe that the justice can pierce the haze, and the sunshine will be onto our land one day.

Best regards

Your friend Zhou



I first read Richard Rorty in late 1998. I immediately felt a bond with him: American, reasonable, moderate, modest, witty, wise, fair, generous-spirited, "good," a marvelous, unpretentious writer, he was a little of what I was and a lot of what I wished I was. He became one of my "heroes." I read Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature and Truth and Progress and felt all of those things toward him. But Pragmatism's money shot disturbed me and disturbs me still. For the Lincoln thing I re-read parts of Mirror and Truth, and this morning, needing further break from Song Binbin, "Dewey between Hegel and Darwin," a chapter in Truth. 

"the true...is only the expedient in the way of our thinking, just as the right is only the expedient in our way of behaving," quoting James, approvingly.

"beliefs useful for some purposes and beliefs useful for others," Rorty's words, summarizing Dewey, approvingly.

"truth is what works," Dewey.

"For all descriptions of experience, nature, and their relation to one another will be evaluated simply (Rorty's emphasis) in terms of expediency--of suitability for accomplishing the purpose at hand," Rorty's words.

"to get Hegel to stop talking about human communities as expressions of something greater than themselves..."

I knew those words, I read them previously, I used some of those words of James and Dewey in the Lincoln posts. Of course, of course, my hero recognizes where this leads: Pragmatism "doesn't tell you what purposes to have; its ethics is situational at best." But didn't I read in Wikipedia or somewhere that Rorty was a "neo-pragmatist?" Maybe when he reflected upon the situational ethics that this was leading to he went in a slightly different, neo, direction. No, he doesn't, or no he didn't:

"I said earlier that the most Dewey can claim is that truth as what works is the theory of truth it now pays ("Pays:" Rorty's word.) us to have. It pays us to believe this because we have seen the unfortunate results of believing otherwise--...Similarly, the theory that, as Dewey said, 'growth itself is the only moral end' is the moral theory it now pays us to have, for we have seen the unfortunate results of trying to divinize and eternalize a given social practice or form of individual life. [Here, Rorty footnotes to the following: "The doctrine that evil is just out-of-date good is as central to Dewey as it was to Hegel."]  In both epistemology and moral philosophy, in short, we have seen the unfortunate results of trying to think of normative terms like 'true' or 'good' or 'right'..."

"[T]he particular charge of philosophy is to make sure that...continued use of the normative language employed in the social and moral strifes of an earlier day does not make it harder to cope with contemporary problems." 

"...pragmatism,...a doctrine of the relativity of normative judgments to purposes served..."

I remember one of the things I admired about Rorty was that he had heroes, he was modest enough and generous-spirited enough to admit he had people he admired and put on a pedestal. And I remember reading these books thinking "How can Rorty have heroes?" Pragmatism is anti-hero, anti-pedestal. He did have heroes. I have heroes. My big brother and Richard Rorty are two of them. I need heroes, I know that there is something better than me out there, that there are people who instantiate those somethings better than I do, and I need to believe in them, to have faith, which is belief beyond evidence.
And now the news from France: President Francois Hollande ("Frankie Dutch") has contracted "Benjamin Harris Disease" a condition that causes the pants to fall down at moments when, decidedly, the pants should remain firmly clasped around the loins. It has been revealed that President Hollande experienced that-there thing with a Vavavavoom, "Julie Gayet."

President Hollande is being squeezed thereby on account of he already had a squeeze, Valerie Trierweiller, who, although they were not, like, "married," is, like, the First Lady of France. Lady Trierweiller was hospitalized as a result of all this conjugal bliss, whether from hysteria or one too many sedatives, the undersigned male sexist pig is not clear. For reasons about which the undersigned is also fuzzy, the French Republic has been thrown into a tizzy about this-here, tons of horse-shit being deposited at the foot of the steps of Parliament by a citizen-saboteur. 




And so, yeah, that is the news from France. 

Saturday, January 18, 2014

Hey.

































"Virtual sunrise," Beijing. Smog.



Friday, January 17, 2014

I am so, like, done with this day right now. This week. I am going to drink whiskey and look at pornography.
State Council Information Office: Because online public sentiment is complicated, all websites must cool down the story “’s Daughter Apologizes.” First, remove the article from homepages. Interactive platforms must not pomote related topics. (January 13, 2014)
Today, "Song Binbin" and "宋彬彬" became blocked terms on Weibo. Evidently, they did not "cool down" sufficiently for PLIP.*
*Psst-Hey, don't cool down...If you don't want to...Whatever you decide, I back you...Cuz, I have no brief here any longer. 

She is! FUCK. You cannot fake that. That's a cry face. That is touching to look at. Difficult to look at, actually.  I'll be goddamned. Undamn her. FUCK me. Friends and enemies, we gotta call a spade a spade, that is sincere. Fuck ME. I commend her. She is trying. She is in pain and she knows the pain she has caused. It is often said that an apology does more good to one who apologizes than to those to whom the apology is made. But...but, what else can people do? We cannot erase the past, undo the harm, bring the dead back. Sometimes, it does help those who we have harmed. Sometimes, it doesn't. In this instance it did not. Mr. Wang rejected her apology. Whatever he says, I back him. Re-damn her.  I have no brief in this matter any longer. She is gone from my country. It is a purely internal Chinese affair once again. Mr. Wang and the Chinese people are handling these matters just fine. I wrote that to Greg last night. They are the ones who are responsible for these apologies, not the Party, not foreigners. They have done it and they should be proud. ALL of them, that INCLUDES those apologizing. Whatever the consensus reaction of the Chinese people is to each of these apologies, I back them. That's a real cry face there, though.  I commend her. SHIT! And the Chinese people.
Wait a minute, let's see something here. The last image at the bottom of the last post, is she crying? I'm going to find that one again and put it on the header so it's bigger.

Why has Song Binbin mishandled her public statements? In all three settings, Morning Sun, Remembrance, and this week, she appeared in very controlled settings, even with her face blacked-out in Morning Sun. The way that Feng-whatever-her-name-is moderated Remembrance was a farce. Song came out worse for Morning Sun and Remembrance than she was before (This week's may be too soon to tell, but the early returns are not good.). I have not seen video, if video exists, of this week's, so I cannot gauge her sincerity but again, very controlled setting: at the school, media alerted, bows to the bust of Bian click-click-click, reads prepared text, the "meat" of which is identical to what she said in Remembrance.

I've thought about reasons for this. One may be that Song is just a cold human being who has a tin-ear for public relations and who has committed too many acts of violence than she could ever apologize for. Next on the Song Apology Tour: Wuhan! This may be the preferred theory. She's smart but dumb in the way smart people can be dumb, lacking common sense; she doesn't realize how she comes across. And doesn't learn from her mistakes! But, I wonder if there is also some cultural thing going on here that I am not picking up on. I have read the writing of highly-educated Chinese, or those of Chinese descent, that are not coherent, Tocqueville in China is the one that immediately comes to mind. They have the form of coherence, Tocqueville ended as it began, a technique that is taught, but not the substance of coherence. In between beginning paragraph and ending paragraph in Tocqueville were a a lot of squiqqly lines that went nowhere. And the author of Tocqueville is a Stanford (as I recall)-trained lawyer! Weili Ye's opus, The Death of Bian Zhongyun (Sorry,The Death of Bing Zhongyun) exhibits another characteristic I've seen before: talking all around a point but never addressing it directly. Ye was a student at the school at the time, interviewed Song and Liu for Bing, says "I believe it is possible to identify the initiators of that day's event" and then doesn't! Including end notes Bing is 37 pages long of sound and fury, signifying nothing. When I read the English translation of Remembrance, I remember sitting in front of my computer, shaking my head and saying to myself, "Chinese do not argue well" (which was the first thing I posted). Not Song does not argue well; my thought was "Chinese do not argue well" because it wasn't just Song in Remembrance, it was a roundtable discussion with, among others, Weili Ye, it was Bing, it was Tocqueville, it was Feng. Feng was awful, just awful in Remembrance. She did Song no favors. Remembrance was so bad it could have been a Saturday Night Live parody.




So, cultural explanations: (1) I've read that there is more rote memorization in Chinese schools than in America today. (Fifty years ago we memorized too.) (2) Not as much critical thinking in the schools. What's safe to criticize? I've read that Premier Wen Jiabao has said "Chinese need to think more critically, more imaginatively, to keep our economy growing," which is true. I have read that American educators are being invited to observe Wen's new "critical thinking" classes. I have read that Wen's new critical thinking classes would also work well on Saturday Night Live. (3) China doesn't have a political system or a legal system like in America so I would highly suspect that the forensic arts are not a big part of the curriculum. (I think at one point I wondered, "Are there any debating societies in China?" and then found out there were!)

Now, a reverse cultural explanation: What would any red-blooded American-in-a-tight-spot like Song Binbin do--book an interview with Barbara Walters; appear on Letterman; go to Red Fox News or some other friendly TV network. To humanize yourself: "I've made mistakes in my marriage;" "I've made mistakes with a butcher knife in my hand." If you're sincere, that stuff can work. Hell, even if you're not sincere sometimes it works: Nixon and his Checkers speech. Is that just an American thing? We're schmaltzy, sentimental fools, we fall for that crap all the time. I don't think so: My Red Guard friend Zhou Jineng became the star of Red Art because he so movingly confessed to beating people. I don't know much about the other notable Red Guard confessors of the last few years but my sense is they helped themselves by confessing or apologizing. Song has not. Song has never done what Zhou did: appear in his own kitchen, dressed in a tee-shirt and just emptying his soul to Hu Jie. Song has not gone to whoever China's Barbara Walters is if there is one--Maybe Hu!--she has never spoken without a script, as Zhou did, never appeared without her handlers. She has only appeared in these carefully-controlled "events." Maybe these are so unsatisfying and seem so sterile because Song isn't engaged, she doesn't interact with people, she makes statements, she is not questioned, she is just allowed to make statements. Why wasn't

Mr. Wang present this week? Why didn't she apologize to him? Interact with him? She can't do that. It isn't in the script.



DAMN you. God DAMN you!
The preceding post is a perfect example of the stereotyped differences between Russia and China. Putin is, among other things, a buffoon, like Yeltsin was a buffoon. I know of no Chinese buffoons. Russians are vodka-besotted, crude, comparatively simple-minded; Chinese are not known as drunks, are not crude, and are brilliant--stereotypically. Russians are funny in their dumbness. Chinese...are not funny, not the dumb ones not the smart ones. It is inconceivable that any leader of China--and homosexuality is illegal in China--would make the dumb-funny statement that Putin made. I've played this game before: Quick, name a Chinese comedian. I can't name a Russian comedian either but I know there are more of them! I cannot take Russia as seriously as I do China. If somehow I had gone to Russia in 2006 instead of China, there is no way I would have come back and become as involved with Russia as I have with China. 
And now the news from Russia. Gay rights activist Vladimir Putin offered this reassuring message to all gay people attending the Sochi Olympics:

“One can feel calm and at ease." “Just leave kids alone, please.”

Straight people, of course, do not have to leave kids alone.

Rejected.


Obama's NSA "Overhaul." I co-opt the language and tone of Mr. Wang Jinyao's rejection of Song Binbin's apology. And the imagery of Obama's favorite sport.

Thursday, January 16, 2014

There were four, and only four, search keywords today:

song binbin, 5
bian zhongyun, 2
binbin song mit, 1
song bin bin, 1

This week the top two were:

song binbin, 15
bian zhongyun, 12

Oh, man! I could hang out...Heck, I could live there.
Lovely sunrise up there, no? Yeah well, it's too cold out to be looking at water, it's outta here.
Guess which post just got a hit?
"Susan Sontag in Artforum," 2005. Both she and Arthur Danto are dead now.


(Tumblr wisdom)...Wow.  I must say, as a "line," as a proposition, that would be pretty compelling. Dissolves the "mind-body" problem. Among people I know, that could work. 
There is an ad on here now with breasts. 
Are those real schools? I mean, c'mon, how many of them even have a football team, huh? MIT? What's their nickname, the frigging Fighting Bytes? Leipzig? Don't make me laugh. Haifa! Oh yeah, lot of offensive linemen who are Jewish. Syracuse, Stanford, I'll give you those. To me the most impressive name on that list is 'Bama! ROLL TYDE!

Holy Molio, tons of scholars here recently. This is since January 9. Including from the 'Tute!, Songie's
other alma mater. Man, I bet they're proud.




















From Greg, Red Royalty celebrates Mao Zedong's birthday this past December 25. Song, second from right. Seldom looks festive. Doesn't do festive well. "Be martial!" Does that well.

The Three-Day Blow.


The sun is out? The skies are clearing. Ah, a new day!

What just happened? Hurricane Song.

The wind was noticeable on Monday, and I noted it. But I never checked the "instruments," never googled Song; hardly read the New York Times anymore, didn't check the Times. Check the news frequently but this was too "niche" to make the top stories immediately. Monday night, late. In bed, in my boxers and a t-shirt. One last news check and, unusually, an email check. My new China friend was the first to inform me, at 2:58 am of the 13th but the first one I saw, emails being displayed most recent to most remote, was from Dr. Ruth at 12:09 pm.

"did you see this?!!??!" (subject heading)

There was a link.

I saw what it was about.

BH-JR.

"Holy fucking Christ."

I called Carmen at 11:24 pm.

BH-JR, JR-BH, BH-JR...

Internet.

JR-BH, BH-JR...Twenty times in total.

BH-Dr. Weimin Mo, WM-BH...Twelve times.

Greg, my new China friend, eight times.

Emails to Dr. Youqin Wang, Zhou Jineng.

Writing, writing, writing, 14 posts total.

400-500 extra clicks.

Back to normal.


Wednesday, January 15, 2014

Hey...Ad here right now, last 15-30 mins:

Why Men Fall in Love
9 Powerful Words You Can
Say That Remind Him Why He
Needs You.

I should like to establish a baseline assumption as a precondition to consideration of what those 9 words might be. The precondition is the ad is aimed at women not men. Okay? Agreed?

Sex. Oh, don't get all huffy on me now, every FRIGGING straight guy who sees this would say the same thing. But that would be the same for gay guys.

Good sex. A little redundant...Leave me alone.

I can't, man, I'm too tired, I can't complete this.

Song Binbin would not be one of them. Or two of them.

Why did I start this?  I'm going to sleep, with NO thoughts of love, or sex, or Song Binbin. I hope.
Hey Goils and Boils, check this out:

WASHINGTON — The Air Force said on Wednesday that 34 officers responsible for launching the nation’s nuclear missiles had been suspended, and their security clearances revoked, for cheating on monthly proficiency tests that assess their knowledge of how to operate the warheads.

Pretty funny, huh? Yeah...pretty funny. 
Oh, "nation" there? That's the "American" nation. 
Hey, have a great evening, huh? If you're going to sleep, don't let the bed bugs bite, K?
The Dangerfield-Sinatra joke illustrates some important legal principles raised in Song's apology. The first is the law of principals (which I have explained to Songie before): If two or more people participate in an act together, performing different roles, both intending the result, each is responsible for the actions of the other. So it is no defense to Sinatra if he didn't participate in the beating because he procured the thugs to do the beating. Song acknowledges "responsibility" for Bian's death as a result of the violence of which she personally witnessed part. She says vaguely that she had some kind of responsibility to "protect" Bian and the other teachers who were beaten. What she is referring to is this: Violence had been going on in the schools for months. Bian was "struggled," i.e. beaten, in June. She, Bian, wrote a letter of protest to the Party. The Party, not knowing WHAT the hell Mao wanted, sent in work teams to all the schools to moderate things. Then, Mao ordered the work teams and their moderating influence OUT. Mao wanted MORE violence. This is what Song is referring to later about not wanting to repeat the mistakes of the work teams. The violence was to continue and to INCREASE. When the work teams left the nascent Red Guards took control of the schools and of the new curriculum, violence.  Song was the leader in her school, Liu Jing the...vice-leader. Violence had to be approved: Only the leaders could "yaowu," be violent, or less commonly, others who were approved by the leaders could yaowu. So, Song was, as she says here, "responsible," practically, morally, and under Anglo-American precepts, legally, for the August 5 beating of Bian. Which resulted in Bian's death:

Second Important Legal Principle: You are responsible for the foreseeable consequences of your illegality.  So, if Dangerfield had died from the beating, even after Sinatra stopped it, sucks to be Sinatra. Sucks to be Song, too. Bian was beaten for hours. Song saw part of it, personally. It didn't look "too serious" to Song. She doesn't get to make that call. It is sometimes alleged that Bian had a pre-existing condition, high blood pressure or something:

Third Important Legal Principle: The "Egg-shell skull victim." I punch a guy once, he falls over, hits his head, dies of a fractured skull. Unbeknownst to me he had an unusually thin skull, susceptible to fracture. Sucks to be me. I'm "responsible" for his death.

"In conclusion:" Song is guilty on this statement alone.

Benjamin Harris on Song Binbin,The Apology, Translation.

Reactions? Well, thank you, I don't mind if I do. This section here:

…I was one of the student representatives in charge when the (government-sent) work team came to our school.  Only one week after the work team was asked to leave campus did the August 5 Incident take place in which Principal Bian was violently killed. Liu Jin and I went to the sports ground two times in an effort to stop the violence. When we saw the excitement-watching students were beginning to leave, believing nothing serious was going to happen, we left, too. Therefore, I am responsible for the unfortunate death of Principal Bian. 

That section there reminds me of the Rodney Dangerfield-Frank Sinatra joke:

"Yeah, yeah, Frank's a good guy, saved my life once. Yeah, two guys were beating me up, Frank came over, said to them, 'Arright, that's enough.'"

Song Binbin's Apology, Translation.

Okay, out of order, first the rejection, now what was rejected, but beggars can't be choosers. This is not Songie's whole statement, it is the "meat" of the apology, translated by Dr. Mo.

…I was one of the student representatives in charge when the (government-sent) work team came to our school.  Only one week after the work team was asked to leave campus did the August 5 Incident took place in which Principal Bian was violently killed. Liu Jing and I went to the sports ground two times in an effort to stop the violence. When we saw the excitement-watching students were beginning to leave, believing nothing serious was going to happen, we left, too. Therefore, I am responsible for the unfortunate death of Principal Bian. At that time, what concerned me the most was the fact that the work team had left campus because of the mistake they made (of not following Mao) and we, of course, made similar mistake while working together with the team. We were worried that someone would accuse us again of opposing the effort to attack the Black Gang (class enemy), so we didn't and were in fact unable to make a strong effort to prevent to violent struggle against Principal Bian and other school leaders.

Secondly, we had little common sense of the Constitution and lacked the consciousness of law, and didn't know citizens had the Constitutional right to personal protect and the irreplaceable right to personal life.
The collective ignorance about human rights and life eventually caused the tragedy of Principal Bian's death.

Please allow me here to express my ever-lasting condolences and apology. And my deep apology to school leaders Hu Zhitao, Liu Ziping, Mei shumin, Wang Yubin and their families for not protecting them then. That was a pain and regret of my life.
...
Over the past forty or so years, there have been two different Song Binbins, namely, the Song Binbin you teachers and fellow students know and understand and Song Yaowu who has become the symbol of violence of the Cultural Revolution. I'd like to take this opportunity to say to the teachers who know me that I was never involved in the early years of the Cultural Revolution in any violent activities such as searching people's houses, beating up people, or harming any teachers and students.

...

Song Binbin's Apology Rejected.

Mr. Wang Jinyao, Bian Zhongyun's widower (who the undersigned interviewed (for three days) in 2008)), has issued the following statement. This is from China Digital Times, via Dr. Weimin Mo, who I thank for the translation as it forestalls me committing terrorist acts against Google Translate.


Song Binbin’s Apology Rejected by Bian Zhongyun’s Husband
“Without Truth, No Reconciliation”

Song Binbin’s apology was rejected by 93-year-old Wang Jingrao, Bian’s husband. Over the past decades, he has been accusing Song Binbin and some others of their attempt to cover up their role in the death of Bian, which occurred on August 5, 1966.
Bian’s husband said Song and some others have never directly apologized to him. He only got the news about the apology through media. Wang was quoted saying, “She is an evil person because of all the things she did. She and some others were supported by Mao Zedong, who was the source of all the crimes. He committed so many atrocities. It by no means was a personal matter… the whole Communist Party and Mao should be held responsible.”
Seven years ago, the glamorous anniversary celebration of the school failed to muffle Bian’s husband’s outcry and condemnation of the murderers. Wang, upon hearing that the school selected Song Binbin to be included in the list of school’s celebrity alumnus, issued a declaration of three points which was widely read on internet but never mentioned in official media:
First, On August 5, 1966, the Red Guards of the then Girls’ School of Beijing Normal University tortured, in broad daylight, Comrade Bian Zhongyun to death. Those merciless murderers beat up Bian with clubs of sharp nails, whipped her with military belts with a heavy metal buckle attached, and kicked her with military boots, for hours. The whole process was unspeakably brutal. The current school authorities, regardless of unmistaken opposition from people who knew the truth, insisted such honor of “celebrity alumnus be converted to Song Binbin. For that reason, I must protest strongly.
Second, the current school authorities have openly violated the conclusion made by the Central Committee of Chines Communist Party on the Cultural Revolution by bragging Song’s activities and the 8/18 Incident as glorious achievements. That seriously hurts victims of the Cultural Revolution and their families a second time. That blasphemes the history. The kind of outrageous behaviors are dangerous signals for openly inviting the Cultural Revolution to come back. It should have alerted the party and the people nationwide.
Third, I demand that the school authorities reasonably handle the issue by revoking the honorable title of celebrity alumnus and report how they handled the issue to all alumni at home and abroad as well as to the faculty and students currently in school. They also must organize a serious discussion among faculty/staff and students on campus, especially the young students, on the decision the Central Committee of CPC made on the Cultural Revolution so that the young students clearly understand the humongous disasters the Cultural Revolution has cause our nation and people.